Best time for a second Dobie

Please don't jump down my throat for this. Obviously I am not in any position to get a second one for some time, i'm just kicking around ideas and trying to get some info.


When is the best time to get a second one? After some reading on here it seems like the best entertainment and companionship for a doberman is, another one.


Would it be better to get one sooner than later so they are around the same age? Males mature quicker than female dogs right? So would it be ok for her to be a year or more than get a male puppy?

As far as cost and time how big of a difference is it? Pretty much double? It seems like it wouldn't be a whole lot more, considering you already have to walk and play with one. Do most vets offer a discount for 2 at once or is that exactly the price of two? Obviously the food would be double.

The biggest thing for me is being tied down by a dog. And if i'm already going to be tied down for one, and a second one would be a great playmate/mate for her, what's the difference. If I have the money for extra food etc.



Another reason I ask is breeding. That's a really far thought and probably no reason for me to do it. But if I got good bloodwork no VWD etc perhaps? I have left her unfixed and don't know if and when I should get her spayed. I like having the option and its a permanent decision, but someone mentioned not doing it could cause possible health issues?
 
The best time to bring another Doberman into your house is when your current Doberman is around 2 years old. This allows time to have your dog trained to your standard and have them old enough to make sure there aren't any behavioral problems you need to deal with first before adding another.

The cost for me adding Aria nearly doubled my dog expense. Twice the food, twice the training, twice the vet bills and supplies. Adding a second means you have to be more financially prepared than you would ordinarily if a medical issue comes your way. If you are complaining about medical bills with yours now, a second one makes it worse. Most vets offer a 10-20% discount for more than 2 dogs who receive the same service.

I hope you don't think I am bashing you, it is not my intent, but breeding your current dog just to have another is not a reason to breed her. Much thought and careful planning goes into breeding and it should never be done for fun. Only dogs that offer something to the breed standard should be bred. Breeding is not for the faint hearted either. The health testing required to properly breed is expensive too and should not be taken lightly.

Adding a second strictly for company of your first is an a bad idea. Two Dobermans are MUCH harder than one. They might keep each other company, but it's possible they might not and then you have two dogs to separately meet the needs of. Twice the work. You are right in saying where if it works, it's great! My two adore each other, but much work was done in the beginning to ensure this. Most of it comes naturally though. Feeling like you are "tied down" by having one just tells me it's a bad idea to get another. It just ties you down more.

If you want to add a second, my advise is to seek out a reputable breeder who health tests for you (i agree very important). They can also help match you up with a puppy who would work well personality-wise with your current girl. I would get a male the second time as Dobies are prone to same sex aggression. If you do add a male, please spay your female. It would make it so much easier for you. Two intact opposite sex dogs are hard to raise. This is another reason you should wait until your girl is around 2 to add a puppy. You can have her spayed beforehand and still have the benefits of not spaying her early.

Again, I hope you don't think I am attacking you. Just sharing my honest opinion.
 
Last edited:
I agree that 2 is the optimal age since one is old enough to be of some guidance for the pup, but yet ready to play. We brought both of our 2nd pups home when the older one was 2 and it worked out perfectly. It does pretty much double your work and expense as well since they both need their one on one time so they don't become dependent on each other rather than you.

I also agree that finding a reputable breeder is the best since breeding your own is a huge dedication to time and health testing, not to mention titling them to show their conformation and how sound your lines are.

If you are thinking about it in the future, it doesn't hurt to start researching good breeders now and asking questions. Many reputable breeders have at least a year waiting list, so it takes time to find one you like and make the commitment.
 
You definitely do NOT want them around the same age. It is best to wait until your first dog is at least 18 or 19 months old before bringing home the second puppy. This gives you a chance to get the first one well trained, socialized, and bonded to you. You don't want two puppies or two teenagers at the same time, talk about two against one! Spock was 19 months old when we brought River home and I'm glad we waited. It is so tempting to bring them home earlier but it is definitely better to wait.

Males actually mature slower than females. Think about it, in the wild with wolves the male's only concern is breeding and retaining the right to breed, which can wait for years if necessary, the female has to mature faster to care for puppies, provide food, etc. We see this in the training world with females maturing much faster and able to handle more mentally intense training sooner than males. It is good that you already recognize the need for opposite genders. That's not to say that two males or two females absolutely can't get along, but the odds are against it.

Cost is almost double, double the food, double some toys, double the crates, double the vet costs, etc. I've never heard of a vet discounting for multiple pets, though some boarding places do if they're kept together. Time wise varies over the years. The youngest is going to take extra time when they first come home to potty train and get through the basic obedience stuff on their own so they can focus and bond with just you. Because of that, for the next year or so your time required will almost double because you'll have to train the puppy and reserve time for the older one. Some play and exercise time can, of course, be shared by both. But you definitely need to spend time with each one individually or you risk them bonding more to each other which can cause problems down the road.

I'm sure your girl is wonderful but to breed properly requires a ton of time in researching pedigrees and training your dog; money in health testing your bitch (there is SO much more than just clear bloodwork and vWD), paying stud fees, training/showing equipment and fee, and raising the pups; and effort in raising the pups, showing, and training properly. Another part of proper breeding is a life-time commitment to the pups. Are you prepared to house and re-home up to 15 puppies for the next possibly 13 years? A good breeder will take back a pup whose owner can no longer keep them and try to find them another permanent home. Some times that means the pup or adult dog will go back to the breeder for months at any age. We encourage doing it the proper way only because there are already so many Dobermans out there being improperly bred with bad conformation, poor temperament, and health issues and we want the best for our breed. As far as spaying, the research is still being conducted but so far shows that females are at a slightly greater risk of mammary cancer if they go through even one heat cycle. Plus, they are at risk for pyometra, false pregnancies, and real pregnancies every time they go into heat; not to mention the risk of ovarian cancer (obviously can't get that if they don't have ovaries!).

In the end the decision is yours, but I hope you'll take all of this into consideration.
 
Thanks a lot guys that pretty much solved everything. The more I think about breeding the more I realize it would be for selfish wrong reasons so I guess I'll get her spayed.

Good to hear 2 is a good age hat gives me plenty of time to figure it out and think about it. I was worried I was missing the correct time to introduce one. Thanks!
 
Thanks a lot guys that pretty much solved everything. The more I think about breeding the more I realize it would be for selfish wrong reasons so I guess I'll get her spayed.

Good to hear 2 is a good age hat gives me plenty of time to figure it out and think about it. I was worried I was missing the correct time to introduce one. Thanks!
Of course :) It's really the perfect amount of time to use to plan ahead.
 
I got my second when my oldest was 10 months old and its a mistake I wont make again any time soon. With them so close in age, it was difficult in training and attention and alot of other things. My hope is that I do not lose them one after another, and that I have time to introduce a new one once one of the two has passed before losing them both. Then it will be a good long time before the second one comes, at least 18 months. Of course, my two are 3 and 4 so I am hoping I have alot of time before I have to think about getting another!
 
I personally like them more like three years apart...I find that there's less "regression" in habits when the older dog is a bit older and more settled in their good behavior :D

For some reason, I also think expense can more than double, and I'm not sure why that is for me, but that's been the case whenever I have more than two. Two is definitely more fun, and it's my preference, but it's more than twice the work, and expense, at least at my house. I wouldn't have it any other way, though!
 

Back
Top