Need advise please

Hi everyone as you know I just joined most because I love the breed but also for advise. Although I loved dobermans all my life I have never owned one. With my career and kids I just didn't have the time.my own personal feelings is your dog is like your child they need attention medical care and so on. Now I finally got my dobermans and I'm in love. because. I don't have experience please chime in not sure what's normal or not.

I have had my boy since he was a baby 10 weeks. He is so mellow Mr kool cat not clingy but every now and then he comes lays his head on mommas lap. He don't growl or have any bad habits at all he is perfect. He is 4 months old.
I brought my female home 2 days ago she is 5 months old. A little skittish however she just came home. One thing I notice right away she does not like to share. When eating if you go near her food she becomes very angry and begins to growl. Although I have toys and huge bones everywhere anytime my boy starts to enjoy a bone she snatches it from him. Even though there is bones all over for them.

Last nigh they both came up by me and I was petting them both she became so aggressive she started to attack my boy . Her teeth and body language was so scary so they both started going at it. Remember one is 4 months one is 5 months. They got into it so bad I tried pulling them apart and she snapped at me. I jumped over the back of the couch ran turned on all the light and grabbed the leash. By then one ran one way the other the other way. Then when I approach her the ears where down she was crouching like she was afraid of me. I grabbed her mussle and said no bad girl and gave her a lecture. Is this normal if so what is the best thing to do.

Today they both are acting normal she gets like that around food and me she is 5 months and I just got her. She comes from a breeder and was outside on a farm with other dogs

Thank you
 
OUCH - that is not good behavior for any puppy at 5 months. You could be headed for some serious problems if you don't get a handle on it now. First BOTH need to be enrolled in obedience classes. Both need to go places separate from each other for socialization.

They need to be crated when they get bones and they should be a special treat not laying all over the place. Dogs are not humans and sharing is not necessarily one of their strong suits.

I would definitely talk to the females breeder - I am betting she has never trained a dog or shown a dog and has no clue how to help you or she would have told you about this behavior upfront. A puppy should not be acting that way regardless - she has temperament issues that can get out of hand very quickly. This is not an internet fix. Find a good trainer now or for the safety of all.
 
Like Susan said thats not good for a five month old pup, sounds like she has had no rules or boundaries set for her to follow, I think you have taken on a bit too much having two pups together it is so difficult to raise and train both of them at the same time most breeders would not have let you have a second pup when you already have one so young, especially as they are your first Dobes, but at five months I would not expect any aggression from them although they will always want the same bone if there were a hundred bones, you do really need some excellent advice and help with a good trainer.
 
Your female is resource guarding fairly aggressively at a young age. I third professional training ASAP for this. If you allow it to continue you will have a serious issue on your hands. The longer they are allowed to act like this, the worse they get. This behavior from your female can negatively affect your male as well.

Like D4E said, you need to remove all the high value items from off the floor and only give them when they can be supervised. I strongly advise crating your dogs when they can't be watched, or when you're not home.

I advise a professional behaviorist as well. Plus, you should enroll them in obedience classes right away.

This is a serious issue you don't want to allow to escalate.
 
All dogs will squabble at some point in a community household. Never ever try to put yourself in the middle of a dog fight or pull on their collar. That is a good way to get bit in my experience. I create big scary noise, yell stamp my feet to provide enough distraction to separate. Unless the animal has been in blood bath dog fights, rarely is it to the point of injury (just dominance and hurt feelings). I agree with Archer, prized resources belong in the kennel and not laying around and there should be enough for two. If she is asserting herself as the dominant this early...she has had no boundaries, socially excluded, and likely to only received physical punishments. I am a big fan of positive psychology and using rewards. I like to push back mentally; enforce community rules/behavior and use time outs. I know no one likes the term alpha but when my animals hear that tone dropped in my voice, every one of them go to the down position. So my question is do either one of them know what the commands sit, down, stay and come are yet?
 
I'm guessing if she lived outside until you got her she has had no training or socialization and that's most likely why she's afraid and is lashing out because of fear. I totally agree that they need some training asap and I would keep them separate for feeding and special treats, etc.

If you just got her it's going to take a while for you to build the trust, but hang in there and be persistent and she'll get it. Let us know how it goes. :)
 
Just a note I would not bet my training on Pet Smart - I serously doubt that any of their trainers could handle what you are seeing. What you described is not something to take lightly especially by a new dog owner who has never had a dominant breed before.

I agree 2 puppies at the same time was not a good idea - unless you are experienced at training and what is required to raise two at the same time.

I would put the female on a leash where you can get to her for safety sake. Being attacked will not help you male develop confidence either.
 
Until you get a handle on this, you should be doing crate and rotate, or some variation thereof. While I do understand that this is not something that is happening all the time, until you know absolutely everything that is causing the problems (and therefore can prevent it 100%), you should do everything you can to minimize them, which means keeping them separate from each other. Yes, it sucks not letting them be near each other or giving them attention at the same time, but I guarantee you it'll suck a whole lot more if you have to take a trip to the emergency room/vet or one (or both) of them is scarred for life because of this behavior.

Keep a drag line on the female. This way, if she starts showing any sort of undesirable behavior, you can step on the leash or use it to gently guide her away from whatever is antagonizing her. Read the book Mine! (Amazon.com: Mine! A Practical Guide to Resource Guarding in Dogs eBook: Jean Donaldson: Kindle Store), which is a guide on dogs and resource guarding. Start playing the "trade" game with her, which is where you give her something good in return for something she has. Don't just take it from her, but rather hand her the other item. She should just drop the thing she has to take the item you're giving. It won't help you with her going after her fur-brother, but it will keep her from snapping at you if you have to take something away from her. There's also this video that shows a little bit what you can do with her kibble and food dish:
View: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xDeAKj2etMs
.

Another thing, don't scold her for things like this, especially after the fact. If she growls at your or makes any aggressive move towards you, respect her and back away. It is absolutely normal for you to want to punish her for it, but doing so does not teach her to not be aggressive. Instead, it teaches her to not giving warning signs. A dog that is punished for warning signs is a dog that "suddenly snaps" with "no warning" and the family says they had no idea. You want her to growl if she's feeling uncomfortable because it's a much better reaction than just giving you a hard bite. If she growls, back away, and over time she will become more relaxed because she knows that she will be given space if she feels threatened.

She was cowering from you because she sensed that you were angry with her, but by the time you scolded her, she has no idea what she had done wrong. You have 3-5 seconds to react to a dog (and what it's doing) or the moment is lost.

You really need to consult a veterinary behaviorist. Most of the time, this kind of aggression, while I don't want to say isn't a big deal, is manageable and possibly very fixable. The problem is that your dog is five months old and should only be displaying puppy behaviors -- definitely not serious resource guarding, etc. Worst case scenario, your dog either has something wrong with her genetically or has some other health problem causing her behavior, and that's something that usually only gets worse with time. Obviously, I'm not saying this is definitely the case with our dog, but I'm saying it to illustrate why it's very important to get professional help immediately. You'll want to go to a veterinary behaviorist, as opposed to anyone calling themselves a behaviorist, because this is the only class that is certified and regulated. Find a Board Certified Veterinary Behaviorist « ACVB

Until you find a behaviorist, you need to find a trainer you can work with both the dogs separately. I absolutely agree that a Petsmart trainer or similar is not going to be able to help you, but you also need to find a trainer who is positive only. I'm not saying that you should train your dogs without correction only but rather that until you consult a behaviorist, corrections that are the wrong kind or given at the wrong time will only make your problem worse -- and you will have no way of knowing whether a trainer who uses corrections is doing damage to your dog or not until the damage is already done because you're not experienced enough. So until you consult with the behaviorist, use a positive only trainer -- even if they're not doing it right, they can't really damage your dog any further the way bad corrections can. After you work with the behaviorist, you can change trainers if you want to.
 
If she growls at your or makes any aggressive move towards you, respect her and back away.
I disagree with this approach. I would never back away and respect a dog that growls at me. While I would never move forward at that point either, I could never condone their behavior by backing away. I would stand my ground similar to Cesar and make them back away. They should respect ME.

Although I loved dobermans all my life I have never owned one.

Taking on two young Dobermans when you've never owned one is a huge challenge. I have to agree with what others are saying with putting away high value treats/bones and using a crate. You will have to give both of them some individual attention and be a Pack Leader. It's much the same as your children. I'm sure there are times when you spend quality time with them individually. It's important to develop a rapport with both. Getting into some obedience training will be a big help too.
 
I never back away either but I rarely have to man handle my dogs. I would have tossed their sassy butts in the clink (kennel) for a couple hours and ignored them. Time outs do wonders for temperamental furry children. I really wish people would stop bashing the Petsmart & Petco training programs. It does wonders for preliminary education for new families and novices, something is better than nothing. It really warms my heart to see people come together...these are just average simple folk. It builds a sense of extended community which also helps the ASPCA, local shelters, and designer breeds. You have no idea how many people have no idea how to housebreak, teach simple manners, socialize much less live in a community household with their furry babies. Next, I am going to hear I shouldn't take crocheting lessons from Michaels because that grandma doesn't know her needle size and yarn quality, sarcasm.:wub:
.
 
Morning thank you all love love anything that's is positive I'm all for. I also like to try anything at least once. I'm great flu for all the great advise but one thing I'm learning with my puppies is quality time does wonders. Believe it or not I been spending allot of time with them over the weekend. I'm happy to say she has stopped her aggressive protecting her food or toys. All I did was have her on a leash and everytime my male went to grab a toy or eat when she would lunge or growl I pulled her back with the leash held her mussle and told her no along with praise. In just two days she has stopped. They are now even eating out of the same bowl. Hiring a trainer does help it forces us to spend time with our puppies. But I forced myself to spend quality time and a whole lot of patients and they are behaving. They are so smart they catch on so fast. It's all about putting the time in and having patients. I love my puppies.
 
if she starts showing any sort of undesirable behavior, you can step on the leash or use it to gently guide her away from whatever is antagonizing her.

This might work for a weak dog but again the word gently shows hesistancy to the dog. The correction should be swift and firm to help snap their attention away from what they are doing. If you let these dogs walk on you they then later become very serious red zone cases because they did not learn as a puppy how to behave around other people, dogs or you.

respect her and back away. It is absolutely normal for you to want to punish her for it, but doing so does not teach her to not be aggressive.

I have said it numerous times before - if you back away you show weakness and dogs do not respect weakness. Usually the problem is with this kind of behavior the owner becomes afraid and backing up is a sign of giving in which means she becomes top dog and then the real problem begins. You must stand tall and walk right into her and back her up to show that are the one who sets the rules and hands out the discipline. Backing away sets you both up for failure. The loser always turns tail and runs. That is not the image you need to display.

To be showing these signs at this young an age means that you are already headed for trouble. This needs to be met head on. I agree it is a fine line as you don't want to appear angry or aggressive yourself as that can only accelerate and make the situation worse. But a FIRM calm direct approach will show the dog that you have the confidence to know what is right and that you have the confidence to follow through.

Again - I strongly recommend you find a good trainer preferrably a Schutzhund trainer as they know how to handle these types of situations safely for all. In some cases it take double handling to get control safely. do a web serach for Nothing in life is free training it will also help
 
Many of you said take away bones and toys they should earn it. However they both are constant wanting to chew on something. Leaving the bones and toys out helps in this way every time they grab a flip flop or end table I push there bone or toy towards them. I have had corleone for 4 months and her 5 days. As of yet neither one of them have destroyed anything but there toys or bones. My house is not puppy proof I have decorative pillows on the floor and other things they can destroy. I'm not saying they haven't tried but when they do I quickly push there bone in there direction. Because I have had corleone longer he goes right to his bone. BIGG ANG runs up to the end table grabs stuff off and runs. I quickly jump up and hand her the bone. My daughter puppy sat yesterday and said mom they are a handful yes I told her but it forces me to get up after them.
 
OUCH!!! All I can say is you might want to rethink the decorative pillows on the floor thing - Never turn your back or those pillows are destined for the trash!!! Wishing you lightening speed and eyes in the back of your head.
 
. Time outs do wonders for temperamental furry children.
I never believed that a 'time out' works for dogs. When children have a time out, it's usually with much conversation about what they did wrong and WHY they are now in a time out. You can't do that with a dog. They don't understand conversation.

First off, 'tossing them in the kennel' as punishment is, in my opinion, not something I want to do. I want the crate to be a good place, not a punishment place. Second, put in there for a time out is useless (again, my opinion) They do not sit in there thinking about what they did wrong, and why they are in there and that they will not do that again. It may give you a good feeling but they don't really understand what's happening.

After I've corrected the dog my way (verbally), I may decide to crate them just to give me some time to do something without having to watch them and maybe give them some quiet time, but I wouldn't associate it with the punishment. It would be long after the fact so the dog is not connecting the dots, so to speak. :)

I really wish people would stop bashing the Petsmart & Petco training programs. It does wonders for preliminary education for new families and novices, something is better than nothing. It really warms my heart to see people come together...these are just average simple folk. It builds a sense of extended community which also helps the ASPCA, local shelters, and designer breeds. You have no idea how many people have no idea how to housebreak, teach simple manners, socialize much less live in a community household with their furry babies.
I've never been to a Petsmart/Petco training program but I have to agree 'something is better than nothing'. I'm sure it is all very basic but I would think that all the points you mentioned make for some good bonding and training. Like you say, there are a ton of people who do not even know those basic points. It may be a good starting point for a novice and a way to bond with your dog and other folks with the same interest and with a young pup or even a calm older dog.

Going there with a dog that may already have a larger problem is another issue. Even without ever going there, I wonder if they are equipped to handle a 'problem dog'. They seem very basic, which, again, can be very helpful to the right person/dog. I wouldn't totally boo hoo it, but I'd be careful if I had a dog that I thought had some serious issues.
 
"tIme outs" do work, especially in a community household. I give warnings, offer praise for good behavior and if the dog continues the offensive behavior they get sent to their room. I use this when there are snapping squabbles. This also allows for tempers to cool (mainly mine) and for the other that are being dominated to relax and get some love/attention. I also have found that this works on cats and dogs alike, it also inadvertently reinforces that I am the alpha and they got separated from the pack for being a brat. When I bring them back in and work with them, that also is time spent re-enforcing community expectations and rules. My point is that we are all talking about the same thing. We are teaching the animal respect, rules, and expectations all while trying to create a loving and stimulating environment in which they can mature in "good & well mannered dogs."

I get peevish over the box store cracks because not only do I use them for supplies, dog friendly social outings, but also that sense of extended community. This is the first time I have had the opportunity to join a forum of this nature and my breeders have never bothered to check on their offspring (sad, because I did). I have seen a lot of hallaballo about how the AKC and other registries should expand involvement to maintain interest in the breeds, have community shows to encourage locals, etc. All great ideas but as of right here and now, Petco, PetsMart, local Vets, and the local shelter are the communities only hands on source for information. Some people need hands on works and to be shown how.

*** This puppy is only 5 months old? Hardly a problem dog yet and yes, the trainers there can handle it. If she was a year and half, I might give my number and groan internally because the issues are almost always easily resolved in the home. I listed not only the box stores but also trainers in the area...most will make a home visit as well.
 
Many of you said take away bones and toys they should earn it. However they both are constant wanting to chew on something. Leaving the bones and toys out helps in this way every time they grab a flip flop or end table I push there bone or toy towards them. I have had corleone for 4 months and her 5 days. As of yet neither one of them have destroyed anything but there toys or bones. My house is not puppy proof I have decorative pillows on the floor and other things they can destroy. I'm not saying they haven't tried but when they do I quickly push there bone in there direction. Because I have had corleone longer he goes right to his bone. BIGG ANG runs up to the end table grabs stuff off and runs. I quickly jump up and hand her the bone. My daughter puppy sat yesterday and said mom they are a handful yes I told her but it forces me to get up after them.

My house is not puppy proofed either. The bones are the only thing I watch carefully because of dog squabbles. I have a wooden table and shelf set that I brought back from Panama... a Doberman, a Boxer, 23 Shitzus, a Retriever and finally my Baby Dobie are growing up with the same furniture...the couch is the only thing that has changed. They have their own blankets, toys, pillows/beds/kennels, food bowls. I have yet to loose anything beyond a bag of chips and silk flower arrangements (storm hated those). It sounds as though BIGG ANG is bored and looking for attention if she is snagging stuff off the table. Reinforce rules and in a couple of months this will all be behind you...I promise. sounds like you are committing to training your pups and you will do good things, have faith in yourself.
 
This might work for a weak dog but again the word gently shows hesitancy to the dog. The correction should be swift and firm to help snap their attention away from what they are doing. If you let these dogs walk on you they then later become very serious red zone cases because they did not learn as a puppy how to behave around other people, dogs or you.

Perhaps I should work on my wording then... I said "gently" because in the heat of the moment, people (especially those that are inexperienced) can forget themselves. My point was that she shouldn't be wrenching on the dog.

I disagree with this approach. I would never back away and respect a dog that growls at me. While I would never move forward at that point either, I could never condone their behavior by backing away. I would stand my ground similar to Cesar and make them back away. They should respect ME.

I have said it numerous times before - if you back away you show weakness and dogs do not respect weakness. Usually the problem is with this kind of behavior the owner becomes afraid and backing up is a sign of giving in which means she becomes top dog and then the real problem begins. You must stand tall and walk right into her and back her up to show that are the one who sets the rules and hands out the discipline. Backing away sets you both up for failure. The loser always turns tail and runs. That is not the image you need to display.

In most cases, I do agree with you. However, in this specific situation, we're talking to someone who has very little experience with dogs and the dog in question has already snapped at her. While you and I know the point to where we can push a dog without there being consequences (ie, an escalation in behavior or a bite), based on what the OP is saying, I don't feel she has that kind of experience or knowledge. So rather than risk an altercation or worsening of behavior, I think it would be best to wait until she can consult with a professional before trying to handle it.

I really wish people would stop bashing the Petsmart & Petco training programs. It does wonders for preliminary education for new families and novices, something is better than nothing. It really warms my heart to see people come together...these are just average simple folk. It builds a sense of extended community which also helps the ASPCA, local shelters, and designer breeds. You have no idea how many people have no idea how to housebreak, teach simple manners, socialize much less live in a community household with their furry babies. Next, I am going to hear I shouldn't take crocheting lessons from Michaels because that grandma doesn't know her needle size and yarn quality, sarcasm.:wub:

I get peevish over the box store cracks because not only do I use them for supplies, dog friendly social outings, but also that sense of extended community. This is the first time I have had the opportunity to join a forum of this nature and my breeders have never bothered to check on their offspring (sad, because I did). I have seen a lot of hallaballo about how the AKC and other registries should expand involvement to maintain interest in the breeds, have community shows to encourage locals, etc. All great ideas but as of right here and now, Petco, PetsMart, local Vets, and the local shelter are the communities only hands on source for information. Some people need hands on works and to be shown how.

*** This puppy is only 5 months old? Hardly a problem dog yet and yes, the trainers there can handle it. If she was a year and half, I might give my number and groan internally because the issues are almost always easily resolved in the home. I listed not only the box stores but also trainers in the area...most will make a home visit as well.

I have nothing against the big box stores. The problem is that the training course required for their trainers to become "certified" trainers is beyond subpar. Their head trainer is made head trainer not because of skill but rather based on how many sales are made. It has absolutely nothing to do with their actual ability. I've known some absolutely wonderful Petsmart trainers... who after spending a short time at Petsmart realized they could better serve their community by opening their own training school or going to work for the local training club. People who go to Petsmart, etc., aren't looking for anything beyond basic obedience and as a result, the trainers rarely have the ability to handle anything beyond that. If they could, they would have their own school or work for someone else because the pay just isn't good enough for them to stick around, the rules really impede your ability to actually help someone, and if you're in it for the dogs and not the money, you'll be stuck on the bottom rung forever.

There is absolutely nothing wrong with going to a big box store for basic puppy classes, or even some of their not so basic classes. In fact, I'll most likely be taking my new puppy to classes at the local Petco because there aren't a lot of other options for puppy socialization around here. But I know enough about training to know that the "trainer" there telling me to harshly correct my four month old puppy, to put a headcollar on my doberman, that treats don't work, or to alpha roll my dog when he's just being insecure is complete bull. This person, the OP, clearly does not have that experience, and while if she were simply asking for basic training advise I might tell her to go there, she has a dog with a problem and not enough experience to know if what the big box trainer is suggesting is going to make her problems worse or not.

As of right now, a five month old puppy is not a huge problem in and of itself. The problem is that the dog is five months old and showing these problems. At five months old, it is still a baby and should be acting like a baby. Babies don't aggressively guard things or attack other dogs. They should only be concerned with eating, playing, and pooping. If a baby is doing these things, it is almost always a sign of big problems to come, especially if care is not taken to get control of it quickly.

I'm sorry if I'm coming across strongly in this; it's just that I've seen more than one dog's life ended by something like this. If the handler had just gotten help in the beginning, when the dog was a puppy and just showing these signs, those dogs would still be alive -- and I know that there are so many more out there in the same situation. But it sounds like the OP's situation is already improving, which for that I am very glad.
 

Back
Top