Need advise please

I think given all the input she has received that she is going to be just fine and if anything that puppy might keep her on her toes for a bit but Dobies are famously smart and intuitive. Once a kennel, routine, some training techniques are added she will toe the line and learn boundaries. I too, have privately mocked some of the training techniques and openly questioned practices at some of the stores...but then I do not blindly accept anything as one form fits all. Each animal is different and I had one Doberman (20 yrs ago) that hit stupid come 11 months and fully realized he was bigger than me and took me on quite a run...dragged me half a block 7 months pregnant after a blasted stray cat. He received a remote trainer and threaded choke for xmas and quickly learned just because your faster, bigger and stronger than Mom does not mean Mom puts up with your bull. He was the best damn pal I could ever ask for and I thoroughly enjoy his guff. It was thanks to a "superstore" that I found training manuals, books, and obedience classes. I have since modified practices for different breeds and continued on in this journey. I wish there had been computer options back then :cool:. FYI I took his nuts too and boy did his attitude change lol :eek:
 
It builds a sense of extended community which also helps the ASPCA, local shelters, and designer breeds.

Who the heck wants to help the ASPCA - another veiled AR group that is out to get our rights to own dogs? NEVER in my lifetime.

It has been my experience from clients that both training programs of the stores and behavorists are pretty useless. It seems they have a lot of book learning to get their certification but have not actually worked with that many dogs. They try to fit a dog into a pigeon hole and dogs have a mind of their own- it is us who must be able to read the dog and act accordingly and that is not written in any book. Part is developed instinct from dealing with a wide variety of dogs. It is like a doctor who gets out of school but can't practice til he apprentices with another doctor or hospital. Book learning will not get you there.

Plus just because I bought a book from a store does not mean they did any training.

I recommend them to people for socialization but the training is just not going to get them very far with a dominant breed. For the little foo foo dogs it is fine but ifyou have a real dog you need real help with people who work with these dogs. How many times have you heard Cesar say the "trainer" or the "behavorist" said put them down???? too many to count because they have no real dog understanding but they have book knowledge. I have said it before the dogs don't READ the books.
 
[RI]http://www.canine-chat.com/content/images/stories/34683_116752515039845_116751395039957_96147_7624470_s.jpg[/RI]

All I meant was that with additional knowledge encourages interests to develop. It is very easy for a young owner to become overwhelmed and discouraged. What I meant by helping out the local shelters and ASPCA was that there would be one less abandoned and abused animal for their organizations to claim. Personally, I enjoy reading about different perspectives and look forward to my magazines and books about the breeds I favor. Sometimes I don't wanna talk to people and probably why I prefer my animals' companionship. I agree with you that not all the programming is one fits all and yes, you have to be able to read the animal you are dealing with and become in tune with their behavioral characteristics. I do however encourage them to go regardless because socialization is vital and "training" is a life long adventure which takes constant research and field time. A Doberman is never finished and needs that mental stimulation to be emotionally sound correct?
 
Honestly, I would seriously consider returning the female pup to the breeder. Those behaviors in a pup of her age could be signs of pretty serious temperament issues. Not only that, but having two pups close in age is not recommended. Almost all the time you end up with pups that have littermate syndrome (whether littermates or not) and it's not a good situation. Especially since you've never had a Doberman I really, really don't think this is in the dogs' best interest, or yours. You'd be better off with the one pup who seems to have a stable temperament.

I have a girl that has some pretty serious temperament issues, and I got her at about that age. At that age they are past the critical age for socializing and many behaviors will be much harder to minimize, despite training. I will tell you that managing my girl to give her a good quality of life can be very difficult, and it's very expensive and emotionally exhausting. If I could go back in time to my past self, I would not have gotten her. It doesn't mean I don't love her more than almost anything, but I would never choose to go through this experience again.
 

Back
Top