• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Where's the rattle?

CalamitysHuckleberry

Notable member
I'm having two issues with Huckleberry that I would love to have some insight and/or advice on.

Huck is a "soft" red boy, 11 months old on the 19th. We got him at 8 weeks and we allowed Calamity to "discipline" him in most things that involved dog to dog socialization. Big mistake there!

We understand, agree and have always allowed both he and Calamity to growl at one another when there was disapproval. She was a bit of a resource guarder but we worked through that. For the most part they have worked it out.

*we do not feed them together and we keep them separated with high value treats, like raw bones or kongs*

It has always bothered me for some reason when Huckleberry would "guard" something. I didn't figure it out until tonight.

I had come in late from shopping and dinner was already made and sitting on the stove (Helman's parm chicken is really good, BTW).

As I'm putting items away, Huck all if a sudden turns into this -
nevazatu.jpg


And goes after Calamity, I'm assuming over the food on the stove since he can practically place his nose on the counters from standing position. He has never done this behavior before; they beg together, get treats together. He bullies sometimes and tries to take her treat, but never like this.

But the big thing that was missing was the growl and now that I think of it when he started guarding a "special" toy, he would strike without a growl then too. That's why it bothered me so much but I couldn't put my finger on it.

This is very concerning to me. Like a rattlesnake without the "rattle". I know we didn't "shame" his growl away. Where did it go and can we get it back?
He still growls when he is playing, but not when he is serious.

Second issue - we have been controlled by our dogs long enough. They both have been feeding off each other and are exhibiting some behaviors that are unacceptable. NILF once again is being introduced as well as a lead at times.

On high volume people and traffic days/nights - i.e. airplane patterns, snow plows, school busses, certain "partying" holidays, Calamity's barking in out of control. Her sudden burst throughout the house chasing who knows what has to end. Also both of them are going outside barking at shadows and won't come inside when called. This is often occurring late at night and it is too cold and icy to be outside trying to get them to be quiet and to come back in.

That being said they need to go back on a leash/ling lead in order to wrangle in this behavior. BUT Huck won't stop grabbing Calamity's collar. No matter what we have tried and he also does it in other dogs. I know we could resort to a spiked collar but that's not something I really like and doesn't solve the problem with other dogs. Here is a poorly shot video of his overpower ness of her and the danger of it.

View: http://youtu.be/ORMxNPx3EKM


I had just soaked her collar in bitter apple five mins prior!

Any suggestions or questions would be greatly appreciated!
 
They won't make a sound when they are dead serious about taking a bite. You may have noticed, no sound and ears pinned back, just before the aggressive behavior. You should not let either of them get away with resource guarding. NILF is one way to cure it so it's good that you have started that program.

If you are talking about putting a leather collar with spikes on it, very bad idea. Huck may bite on it, get poked by a spike and that would make things worse by increasing Hucks aggression.

If they aren't behaving outside then they need to lose the privilege of being off leash.

I'm sure there are others who can chime in here and give you some good advice.
 
On the guarding of the stove and contents,we have a strict no dogs on the kitchen policy.You need to have one too.
On the going outside and not coming back,close off the dog door.Restricted to indoors it's easier to correct their will to go "on guard" actions.
Please take note I am no expert,but I know what works here in my house.Daisy doesn't normally just run outside to bark,if she does I listen to see if those lil asshole dogs on the other side of the fence are going off.If they are,I just call her in,she comes.She does because she knows if she doesn't I'm going to come get her,often looking like that green guy you posted a pic of.;)

If those lil dogs aren't going off,something is up.Then I'm going to see what,because like I said she doesn't do that....unless there's something ( or someone)there.
Also keep in mind she's 4,not a youngster,so she has a good idea what noises are neighbor and what noises need attention.
 
They won't make a sound when they are dead serious about taking a bite. You may have noticed, no sound and ears pinned back, just before the aggressive behavior. You should not let either of them get away with resource guarding. NILF is one way to cure it so it's good that you have started that program.

If you are talking about putting a leather collar with spikes on it, very bad idea. Huck may bite on it, get poked by a spike and that would make things worse by increasing Hucks aggression.

If they aren't behaving outside then they need to lose the privilege of being off leash.

I'm sure there are others who can chime in here and give you some good advice.

I agree with the NILF and the leash outside. But Calamity needs something on while inside too. We can't stop her erratic behavior without physically grabbing her so to speak. Keeping her on a lead in order to stop this has worked out great. But I need a collar on her to do this. Her being without one isn't teaching him anything.

She doesn't focus or re-focus like most dogs. You have to break her focus to then quiet her or calm her. Often times you have to physically grab her to redirect her to watch you and listen to direction. It's hard to explain.

I might have a video somewhere, I will look.

Worse part with Huck, he has never shown any signs of aggression over anything. Other dogs come after him, he runs away screaming, it's almost embarrassing.
 
I agree with the NILF and the leash outside. But Calamity needs something on while inside too. We can't stop her erratic behavior without physically grabbing her so to speak. Keeping her on a lead in order to stop this has worked out great. But I need a collar on her to do this. Her being without one isn't teaching him anything.

She doesn't focus or re-focus like most dogs. You have to break her focus to then quiet her or calm her. Often times you have to physically grab her to redirect her to watch you and listen to direction. It's hard to explain.

.
I think I get it.
She's a youngster,yes?
Get a collar on her,so you can grab her if needed.What I found and have read is consistency consistency consistency.
Give the command,if there's no reaction,you react and move her where you want her to be.Repeat.
If it takes two times in 5 minutes or 10 times in two minutes,be consistent.Dont say it if you're not ready to back it up.Eventually they get it,don't forget to give a positive note or treat when you correct.
Usually (9 out of 10 times) I just have to say "come" for instance,and she's on her way.
 
This is her "normal" self, she is 10x more hyper than he(Huck) is. She is the white one and is two, he is of course the red one. This is just prior to the next video

View: http://youtu.be/_COVmplbrJY


This is her reacting to a plane. This is outside. She does this inside....inside the car, inside the house, inside a store....at all hours of the night. Sometimes are worse than others. I think the flight pattern chases so some nights it goes on and on...she also does this at buses, trains, helicopters, birds and who knows what else. They can also just be on TV.

Ohh our house is only 800 square feet so you can only image what a PITA this is.

View: http://youtu.be/ilVt6klEjy0


Huck also feels the need to discipline her now too when she does this (I image because we don't, until now). It's a fight just waiting to happen.
 
Hmm. The first two (which are the same) is her hyperness! She is older than him.

The two last videos (which are the same) is her chasing planes. She also does this to trains, busses, large sounding trucks, birds. It's done inside the yard, car, and house. The sound can come from real life or TV and she reacts this way. She has ran into things doing this. Somedays are worse. We can now usually figure out when it's going to be a bad night. That's when I want to put her on a lead. Also know everyday it will be this when school lets out or when there is a snow emergency.

I would like for her to have a collar on at all times because of this.

(Dunno why I typed this in the post above and it didn't appear, hmmm)
 
On the guarding of the stove and contents,we have a strict no dogs on the kitchen policy.You need to have one too.
On the going outside and not coming back,close off the dog door.Restricted to indoors it's easier to correct their will to go "on guard" actions.
Please take note I am no expert,but I know what works here in my house.Daisy doesn't normally just run outside to bark,if she does I listen to see if those lil asshole dogs on the other side of the fence are going off.If they are,I just call her in,she comes.She does because she knows if she doesn't I'm going to come get her,often looking like that green guy you posted a pic of.;)

If those lil dogs aren't going off,something is up.Then I'm going to see what,because like I said she doesn't do that....unless there's something ( or someone)there.
Also keep in mind she's 4,not a youngster,so she has a good idea what noises are neighbor and what noises need attention.

Yea, we have lax on the kitchen thing. Now we know not to do that again.

The outside barking is now a habit, it's that annoying bark for him. Not the "drunk neighbor staggering down the ally way at 3 AM" bark (which is a retired cop and happens WAY too often, BTW). He barks as soon as he hits the backdoor not even looking up.
Calamity is looking up, barking at the planes in the sky. They both need a little "hulk" to be busted on them, I mean that in the nicest terms.

But I sure want to know what happened to his growl!
 
Yea, we have lax on the kitchen thing. Now we know not to do that again.

The outside barking is now a habit, it's that annoying bark for him. Not the "drunk neighbor staggering down the ally way at 3 AM" bark (which is a retired cop and happens WAY too often, BTW). He barks as soon as he hits the backdoor not even looking up.
Calamity is looking up, barking at the planes in the sky. They both need a little "hulk" to be busted on them, I mean that in the nicest terms.

But I sure want to know what happened to his growl!
For that (his growl) I have no answer.Lets hope one of the more experienced folks here will chime in.
Pitts

Or someone?
 
Discipline discipline discipline! Regardless the negative behavior barking food aggression toy hog it is about aggression and demanding his/her own way and there is only one way, your way! Everything they have is a privilege so start taking it away. I have two about this age and we are daily learning how to treat each other, My dogs eat together, they sit and wait for me to release them to their food and then they eat their own. They are not allowed to argue over food, toys or James and myself. If they fight over a toy it goes in the timeout box for at least a week, if they fight over food they get to sit and watch the other one eat until they are through before the other one gets to eat. We have had many leash days where any movement was controlled by me. They get invited into the house after they have sat and then I release one at a time to come in. They have separate sleeping areas and when I say night night they head to their crate. It takes time, I sit with them while they eat, I can now allow them to run and play without my constant supervision but one argument and hey are in trouble and have to come in and think about it for a while on their dog mats. I raised 5 kids three were like triplets so I have a blackbelt in teaching and discipline young energetic minds. They have to first know and trust your their mama but when they do, they better mind me or else and I don't tolerate rude behavior even from my dogs. If your not gonna growl then your not playing so you need a attitude adjustment. They are very smart if they get a sharp hush and they don't stop then put them in the sit mode and tell them to hush, if they keep it up make them ly down if they keep it up put them in time out away from the thing they were barking at. If you do it every time it will take no time and he will get that barking equals timeout. I have a nice timeout place in the corner. No one goes there unless they are in trouble. I don't use their kennels for punishment, it's their house and I want them to love it so I made them a timeout bed - they hate it :(
 
Discipline discipline discipline! Regardless the negative behavior barking food aggression toy hog it is about aggression and demanding his/her own way and there is only one way, your way! Everything they have is a privilege so start taking it away. I have two about this age and we are daily learning how to treat each other, My dogs eat together, they sit and wait for me to release them to their food and then they eat their own. They are not allowed to argue over food, toys or James and myself. If they fight over a toy it goes in the timeout box for at least a week, if they fight over food they get to sit and watch the other one eat until they are through before the other one gets to eat. We have had many leash days where any movement was controlled by me. They get invited into the house after they have sat and then I release one at a time to come in. They have separate sleeping areas and when I say night night they head to their crate. It takes time, I sit with them while they eat, I can now allow them to run and play without my constant supervision but one argument and hey are in trouble and have to come in and think about it for a while on their dog mats. I raised 5 kids three were like triplets so I have a blackbelt in teaching and discipline young energetic minds. They have to first know and trust your their mama but when they do, they better mind me or else and I don't tolerate rude behavior even from my dogs. If your not gonna growl then your not playing so you need a attitude adjustment. They are very smart if they get a sharp hush and they don't stop then put them in the sit mode and tell them to hush, if they keep it up make them ly down if they keep it up put them in time out away from the thing they were barking at. If you do it every time it will take no time and he will get that barking equals timeout. I have a nice timeout place in the corner. No one goes there unless they are in trouble. I don't use their kennels for punishment, it's their house and I want them to love it so I made them a timeout bed - they hate it :(

Got it! Thanks!

But I still need to add a collar and find a growl, lol.
 
Hopefully Huck will grow out of that collar grabbing and shaking. From what I saw in the video he was just playing like a pup. Have you considered using a slip lead on Calamity? They go on just as fast if not faster than clipping a regular leash to a d-ring.
 
The collar is actually a major concern. People have had dogs die from getting their jaws caught in another dog's collar and died in the panic of trying to separate or the dog wearing the collar would choke. Sorry to make it so blunt but you need to understand the risks. Dogs need to run and have fun. In a small house it is not at all surprising that they don't get much chance to stretch their legs and run like Dobes really need to. That is why outside Calamity has the zoomies like that. How much training do you do daily? I ask because part of the problem could be pent up energy and lack of control. The playing together is part of a multi-dog household but you need to be in control enough to stop it at any point. Ours wrestle and get really into it but the moment we feel it is getting too serious all we have to do is yell "hey" or some other quick loud noise to break it up and they know that means enough is enough. That is because we train and exercise them as much as possible and they know we are the ultimate say in anything.
As far as the warning missing, that is hard to determine at this point. One possibility is that you accidentally trained it out of him. If you ever corrected him for just growling without making it clear that it was the overall behavior that was the real problem what you were doing was teaching him that growling was not okay.
 
I have kind of a similar situation with a Giant Schnauzer named Pepper that I keep off and on along with my Dobie girl Pippi, and I have a thread that I opened on it a few weeks ago here:

Doberman Chat Forum: Talk About Doberman Pinschers

Pepper's mom hadn't really trained her well, so she didn't have very good manners when she 1st came into my house. Because they're both big girls at 85 lbs (Pippi) and around 110 lbs (Pepper), I was concerned about bloodshed and fighting. While neither one is resource aggressive towards humans, they definitely knocked heads when competing between each other for food. Here's how I avoided fighting and issues:
  1. I make them sit before getting any food or treats.
  2. I feed them both right next to each other, at almost exactly the same time - Pepper gets her food 1st because she gets twice as much as Pippi and ate slower and incompletely at first (she doesn't anymore - the 1st feeding after Pepper left food, Pippi came right behind her and snatched it all, and Pepper watched and learned quickly!)
  3. As soon as Pippi is done (she's always done first) I have her come away from the food bowls. Since I always give them their vitamins which they love right after, Pippi comes away immediately and sits and waits politely for her 'fish balls' which are fish oil capsules in a pill pocket.
  4. Whenever I give them treats, I always given them both one at the same time. I watch to make sure Pippi doesn't try to dip in on Pepper's treats, since Pepper eats more slowly than Pippi. Pepper is learning to hurry up and to never leave bits behind or Pippi will get them!
  5. I never EVER leave one single food resource out - I did that once with a bone that I accidentally dropped, and they both went for it and tangled viciously over it.
I don't want Pepper to be dominant with Pippi when she's with us, so I treat them equally and don't let Pepper dominate over Pippi (or me) which is her instinct to do probably because she's so big. She's adjusted well to that discipline, and it's great to have her around. I don't ever have either of them on collars in the house - that's asking for trouble I think. Pippi has gotten caught on the strangest things on both her flat and prong collars, and with Pepper being a longer-haired dog, I could see her getting tangled in Pippi's collar which would be a nightmare!

I definitely am consistent and immediate with discipline ad obedience though - I don't allow any fighting or bad manners in the house and Pepper knows that she doesn't get what she wants until she obeys.

Pippi barks appropriately to sounds from neighbors, but Pepper does a continuous wolf howl whenever she hears neighbors in close proximity, and construction noises as well (we've got a lot of new construction right across the street). I've had to use an extended arm duster to stop her - she seems to hate being touched on the rear by it, so when I just pick it up and show it to her she stops her howling. It's a fine line because I want her to alert, but to do so appropriately, and to stop howling on command. It's a work in progress like a lot of things with her.

Overall it sounds like you need to establish new rules of obedience in your household. They should 'work' for every reward they get - whether it's food or going out to the bathroom. Having them sit before eating or going out helps a lot with establishing order. As for food aggression, you need to be consistent with stopping any food aggressive behaviors - that should be an absolute no-no that gets them a 'time out' away from the food and from the pack when they demonstrate food aggression. In the short term you will need to watch them closely around food, and catch any misbehavior as it happens.
Good luck - I feel your pain!
 
Hopefully Huck will grow out of that collar grabbing and shaking. From what I saw in the video he was just playing like a pup. Have you considered using a slip lead on Calamity? They go on just as fast if not faster than clipping a regular leash to a d-ring.

That's a great idea on the slip lead. I used part of the suggestion:) I can't use the slip lead because she needs a long line to go out on. So I have that hooked up to a paracord choker I made to send her out on, it's quick on and off.

Thanks!
 
The collar is actually a major concern. People have had dogs die from getting their jaws caught in another dog's collar and died in the panic of trying to separate or the dog wearing the collar would choke. Sorry to make it so blunt but you need to understand the risks. Dogs need to run and have fun. In a small house it is not at all surprising that they don't get much chance to stretch their legs and run like Dobes really need to. That is why outside Calamity has the zoomies like that. How much training do you do daily? I ask because part of the problem could be pent up energy and lack of control. The playing together is part of a multi-dog household but you need to be in control enough to stop it at any point. Ours wrestle and get really into it but the moment we feel it is getting too serious all we have to do is yell "hey" or some other quick loud noise to break it up and they know that means enough is enough. That is because we train and exercise them as much as possible and they know we are the ultimate say in anything.
As far as the warning missing, that is hard to determine at this point. One possibility is that you accidentally trained it out of him. If you ever corrected him for just growling without making it clear that it was the overall behavior that was the real problem what you were doing was teaching him that growling was not okay.
There is no doubt in my mind that he came within seconds of killing her with her collar. I had just taken a shower and noticed it was TOO quiet. I found her dragging him in circles with her to tongue hanging out of her mouth and he "attached" to her martingale collar. He had gotten the choke part of the collar caught on his tooth. She would pull tightening it up. When I got them released she practically collapsed.

We weren't aware of his collar obsession prior to this. It almost seems to be when it started was with this situation. He was about 6 months old. She hasn't worn a collar in the house since other that the other night when that video was made.

They get exercised as much as weather permits. If not physical then we do mental in the house. Sometimes they are stuck with each other for days and we can tell they are getting on each others nerves, so we separate them and spend some one on one time.
Could they be exercised more? Absolutely, and it's a great observation. We have made a conscious effort the last several days of increasing their activity level and that has helped.

We will be working with a new trainer on the 6th. We have 6 lessons scheduled for now. We will let y'all know how that goes.
 
Quee, we are doing all the NILIF stuff. We are also going to work one on one with a new train or starting the 6th.

Thanks for your advice, it's very helpful!
 

Back
Top