any tool used correctly is worth it. Any tool used incorrectly is a disaster and will not deliver the intended results.
So if you are considering one then I would check with a trainer first and see what they suggest. The e collar is not the fix all but is is awesome with certain issues when used correctly.
Ingrid, I just read about that DVD last night and am going to purchase it...thank you!I use an e-collar with Hans and Ladybug. Ladybug was difficult to train recall with since she was 2 1/2 years old when I adopted her, very independent, and because she knew she could just give me the finger and just keep running. LOL
My collar of choice is the Dogtra. They don't make the model number I have, but the one I have is the same as the 1900 NCP. I'm totally satisfied with the collar and the remote. The adjustability of stim level is very accurate, and the button lay-out is easy to use.
While we are on the subject of e-collars, I highly recommend the DVD "Remote Collar Training for Pet Owners" http://leerburg.com/318.htm The DVD lays out a complete course of recall training that may not even end in the use of an e-collar depending on the dog.
Rits, I've been doing pretty much the exact thing you suggested in Callie's training minus the e-collar and there times she just (as Ingrid puts it "Gives me the finger") and ignores the recall and sometimes it takes several minutes for her to acknowledge me. (Her game of course)I use an e-collar with just Java as she knew her recall but would blow it off every now and then and I couldn't afford that. I drilled the recall into her head first before ever approaching the ecollar. Just remember, they have to understand the command first before using the collar and just because you have the collar doesn't mean you are ready to let them be offleash with one.
I'm not a pro by any means but I did a lot of reading up on different approaches and this is how I did it. I had to put the ecollar on, but it was off, and have her on a long line. Would let her run around and whenever her attention was away from me, I'd call her...lots of praise. If she hesitated, it was followed by a leash pop. I did that for a good solid 2-3 weeks to reinforce the recall, then stepped up to having the ecollar actually on. Called her when her attention wasn't on me (you do this because you don't want them associating looking at you as bad) and if she blew me off, leash pop while at the same time a stim. I always have the stim as low as she'll notice it...look for an ear flick or slight head tilt. I did this for another week (I'm still holding onto the long line) then I moved up to letting her drag the long line. It took a good month+ of solid reinforcing so she absolutely knew what "come" meant before I ever trusted her off leash with just the collar. Now I can call her without ever having to correct her, she comes running a million miles per hour towards me and looks up at me so happy waiting for her treat. If she does blow me off (very rare) I use the paging button on the remote which just sends a vibration like a cell phone feels when it's on vibrate. I always keep yummy treats on me so they know that I am awesome, haha.
With all that said, I would personally try everything first before going that route with Callie. I would never use an ecollar on a dog under 12 months if even 18months. She is still young and there are so many other methods to try before reaching for the ecollar.
Edit: forgot to say, I use the Dogtra 7100H. It has a feature called surestim and the remote will vibrate whenever you apply a button so you know that the collar and remote are making a correction. It's great in the cold cause sometimes your hands are numb or when you are wearing gloves you can actually feel that you are hitting the button. This feature can be turned on or off.
I've read online of many like you had to go through a course to be able to even purchase the collar. An extra measure to help guarantee that the abuse doesn't happen.I think e-collars can be awesome training tools if YOU take the time to be trained properly on their use. I took seven training classes with a professional trainer. Actually it was a purchase requirement from the dealer. They would not have sold me the collar without seeing a trainer first. As Rits mentioned, my dog was already trained and needed a reinforcement for the recall. I have seen e-collars give new life and freedom to deaf dogs (vibrate button becomes their name) and enable handicapped handlers to train very large strong dogs from their wheelchairs. However, as with any tool they can become a crutch or create serious problems when not used correctly.
I have a Dogtra collar that is over ten years old and it still works like new. I will have to get a Tritronics collar down the road though... My current trainer prefers them over all other brands. Do not buy any of the collars from a pet store. They aren't reliable and the batteries aren't rechargeable.
any tool used correctly is worth it. Any tool used incorrectly is a disaster and will not deliver the intended results.
So if you are considering one then I would check with a trainer first and see what they suggest. The e collar is not the fix all but is is awesome with certain issues when used correctly.
I agree with both of you....the collar must be understood by me first before I can even think of introducing it to Callie and she must also know the commands first.I second this. I use the TriTronics Sportster and strongly recommend you take lessons from a knowledgeable trainer before using. There's things that aren't in the manual that a trainer will tell you or demonstrate.
The dog MUST understand what is being asked of him for the e-collar to be of any use. Otherwise, you'll screw up your dog.
Also, get a quality e-collar, not something you'll find in a pet shop.
......
......and more 
Thank you Jess. Callie does do the blow you off thing every once in a while and then when she sees or hears a reaction from me the GAME is on. Catch me if you can type of thing and like you I can't have her unknowingly putting herself in harms way.We worked on reinforcing recall with the e-collar on Spock. At the nice big park he would sometimes get so focused on playing or other dogs that he either wouldn't hear us or would flat out blow us off. We used it at first on a very low shock to reinforce the command given. Now all we need is the beeping sound and he'll come running. We have used it to break him of habits he would only do when we weren't nearby like digging and his bad bad habit of jumping out of the car and running down the driveway ignoring our calls. We couldn't have him running into traffic so we used it on a slightly higher setting to get the point across quickly. We have not used it on River and will not until she is much older, if at all. We learned a lot of what not to do with Spock that is helping our training of River.
Forgot to add we use the PetSafe Big Dog Remote Trainer: http://www.petco.com/product/109430/PetSafe-Big-Dog-Remote-Trainer.aspx
Thank you very much for the offer...that is extremely nice of you. I think I'll take your advise and purchase it for the quick reference from time to time.Earl, I would loan you the video if you like. PM me if you want to borrow it, but I found it was good to own for easy reference.