• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Sleeping In the Crate?

Nick

Notable member
Linus sleeps on my bed, or has been since I got him. I was told that by having him on my bed, he see's me on the same level as him. So I was told to crate him when I go to bed, so he can sleep in his and crate and I sleep on my bed. If I don't crate him, he'll jump on my bed when I fall asleep and I won't wake up.

We all know how long he spends in his crate now because of my work schedule. So should I crate him when I go to bed or not? I need help :(

I do have someone come over and let him and foster outback for an hour while they take their dogs on a walk. So they have SOME relief time.
 
Well ya know what I think ;mine sleep with me it's not going to make him feel anything but loved it's a great bonding time as far as I'm concerned but it's personal taste too Nick..It would seem that he spends more than enough time in his crate for sure;)WOOF!!! I vote let him sleep with ya!!:eekwtf:
 
You don't think that by him sleeping in my bed with me that he thinks he's just as much alpha as I am?
 
I have 11 beds/crates in my house for three dogs and two of them sleep with me and Joe gets in bed with us in the morning. I love it. Sometimes when I am watching a movie, it's me, Joe, Charley and Taylor on the sofa. My dogs get away with way too much but when it comes down to it they absolutely have no doubt who alpha is. I think it's just fine for your dog to sleep and cuddle with you.
 
He's supposed to be sleeping anyways, so I think sleeping in the crate is totally different than just being in the crate. I don't think it would hurt since he's supposed to be sleeping. Mine don't sleep in a crate, but that's because they know the bed is strictly off limits. We took the cushion off of one of those papasan chairs, so they have plenty of comfy bed of their own. :)
 
All my dogs slept with me. One would squirm down to the bottom of my sleeping bag. I never had a problem with my dogs challenging me and they have no doubts at all who's the boss.

I recall you got new dogs, and my trainer always advises treating every new dog, no matter what their age, like an 8 week old puppy until they settle in and learn the house rules. Therefore crating is an option in the beginning, and that's what I'm still doing with Anna, who I got a month ago.

I have an observation that some trainers seem to be on a mission to convince people that they shouldn't sleep with their dogs. One person in my town, who deals with house pets, and has never put a title or any kind of certification on a dog, tells me fairly often that I shouldn't sleep with my dogs. I really wonder about his obsession with the topic.

My opinion is that Linus already spends a lot of time in the crate and dogs need companionship. If he behaves himself in bed (no chewing, etc), I think it would be very good for him to spend time with you while you're sleeping.
 
The new one acts even better than Linus!

Neither chews on anything while we're asleep. But I'm obviously missing something because I'm having issues with him listening to me :( Which is a real pain in the ass. I'm going to try having him in his crate a week or two while we're sleeping. If he has an issue with it, o well. He has to sleep and so do I. He also has to listen. Thanks for the input guys :)
 
I understand you dont want him in his crate anymore than he is now... but i'll tell u what nick, Zeus started out in a crate, few weeks into it, I took it away. That alone created problems. I pulled it back out and those problems disapeard. Dont ask me about the technicalitys cause I aint a clue... as you know Im no expert but yno Linus is still only 11 months aswell? I reacon a crate will help ALOT :)
 
I'd say it depends on his behavior. Any dog who isn't 100% sure about his place in the pack (or family:) ) shouldn't sleep in the owner's bed. When people at the dog park talk about their dog's behavior problems, the 1st question I'm asking is always ''where does your dog sleep?'' and most of the time they answer ''my bed''. Just a thought :paw:
 
I'm trying to ween him off the crate while I'm at work. And crate him at night. I think starting tonight I'll crate him. Today is his first day out of the crate while I'm at work.
 
I'm trying to ween him off the crate while I'm at work. And crate him at night. I think starting tonight I'll crate him. Today is his first day out of the crate while I'm at work.

Good luck! Hope everything is spared for your sake. :D
 
Sad to admit this but zuko has slept with me since day 2 of getting him. If anything I think it has made our bond stronger. Why crate him when you sleep as well, especially if he's in the crate while you are work. Everyone in this forum can say that most of the time all their dobes want to do is be as close to them as possible. Alpha is a mentality almost like an aurora that you give off...its not shown by denying your dog, its shown by being firm and confident yet gentle and loving. IMO ;) and that mentality has always worked for me. good luck
 
Nick, there are pros and cons to everything, there are
pros and cons to them sleeping with us. I have always
always allowed my dogs to sleep with me and that includes
125lb euro German Shepherd never have I had a problem
with the Alpha thing. To me I love it, it's cozy even if you
do end up with a little space and share your pillow. I will
always do it and I won't have any ISSUES. Plus I dare
somebody to walk in my bedroom at night when we
are all snuggled in comfy and cozy...........NOT IN THIS
LIFETIME ANYWAY.

 
PSHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!! I dont know who told you that, but I can tell you for sure that it doesnt decide who is Alpha or not... I can let all 5 of my dogs sleep with me and they still know who is alpha... I DONT let the italians sleep with me... because then I dont sleep! LOL, or I do but I wake up with a sore back. But Fate always sleeps with me, Karma usually will sleep in her bed but sometimes will jump up with us for whatever reason. She is a PITA cuz she buries herself under the blanket and usually pulls it away.

You just need to decide if you want to let them or not. Fate is a cuddle bug and "I" dont mind that, if she is in the way, I will move her or tell her to get out of the way. Whatever you decide you need to stick with, the flipflopping is what makes you look weak.
 
PSHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!! I dont know who told you that, but I can tell you for sure that it doesnt decide who is Alpha or not... I can let all 5 of my dogs sleep with me and they still know who is alpha... I DONT let the italians sleep with me... because then I dont sleep! LOL, or I do but I wake up with a sore back. But Fate always sleeps with me, Karma usually will sleep in her bed but sometimes will jump up with us for whatever reason. She is a PITA cuz she buries herself under the blanket and usually pulls it away.

You just need to decide if you want to let them or not. Fate is a cuddle bug and "I" dont mind that, if she is in the way, I will move her or tell her to get out of the way. Whatever you decide you need to stick with, the flipflopping is what makes you look weak.
AMEN
 
Our dogs have always slept with us, but I do have rules. They are not allowed to lay on us, play or roughhouse, or get their head above ours when we're laying down, which can be signs of dominance. Della must be like Fate and curls up in a little ball, or spoons behind us and she's just plain cuddly. Boris was the same, except a much bigger version and could pretty much keep me warm from shoulder to toe when he stretched out. :)
 
But I'm obviously missing something because I'm having issues with him listening to me

I had an hour long drive last night to and from my club, and your problem came to mind. My dogs occasionally play dominance games with me. Sometimes it's an outright challenge, but it most often takes the form of ignoring me when I give a command. (They'll stare out into space without looking at me). If I sense I have a dominance issue, I put them through a mini boot camp until they get their head on right. I'll go through a drill where I stand in front of them and they sit, stand, down, go to heel position, pivot in heel position several times (right and left 90 degree pivots), I go back in front of them and repeat. The commands follow quickly and I don't allow them to dawdle and give an instant correction if the command isn't performed smartly. Dogs hate this drill, but I make them do it to perfection. They don't test me for a while after doing this.
 
I had an hour long drive last night to and from my club, and your problem came to mind. My dogs occasionally play dominance games with me. Sometimes it's an outright challenge, but it most often takes the form of ignoring me when I give a command. (They'll stare out into space without looking at me). If I sense I have a dominance issue, I put them through a mini boot camp until they get their head on right. I'll go through a drill where I stand in front of them and they sit, stand, down, go to heel position, pivot in heel position several times (right and left 90 degree pivots), I go back in front of them and repeat. The commands follow quickly and I don't allow them to dawdle and give an instant correction if the command isn't performed smartly. Dogs hate this drill, but I make them do it to perfection. They don't test me for a while after doing this.
This is a good idea! I like it! I will have to do this!

Today is a very exceptional day! He's listening! Every word I've given him except once.. woohoo!!
 

Back
Top