When were your Dobermans finally allowed off-leash outside?

This can certainly be true. I think it depends on the dog. Some dogs seem to think 'I'm free and I'm getting as far away from that lead as I can' others seem to feel lost since they're used to being so close to their owner they feel uncomfortable being too far away.
I think it surely depends on the dog. I often think of the Husky and its reputation for running off and not coming back. Our Husky had that tendency, but it was subdued somewhat in that she would have what I called "escapades" when off leash on hikes but would always come back to us. The escapades were no fun though, and usually made my wife cry. :( It really is a very crummy feeling not knowing if your dog has left for good, or if they have become injured or trapped by something. Scary stuff.
 
I agree. And I think I would feel differently if I lived on under 20 acres... I mean he's not above seeing something and giving chase, I can get him back though before he's off property. He's also outside alone quite a bit but when I call him he's usually right around the house because he's at the door in under a minute.
I was gonna say: Country living you've got there. Conversely, if Oji takes off (which thank God he's never really done) he is in someone else's yard in about one second. If someone sees a Doberman, or a scary dog for modern JQP who may not know what breed it is, on their property they are likely to really take issue with it and might call the cops.
 
On the other hand, my once best-friend had his GSD wind up with a bullet in him when he ran onto someone's property in a fairly rural area where he lived. Seems a couple young guys with their small-caliber rifles thought it would be fun. What was not so fun was when my friend beat the snot out of them like they richly deserved.
 
On the other hand, my once best-friend had his GSD wind up with a bullet in him when he ran onto someone's property in a fairly rural area where he lived. Seems a couple young guys with their small-caliber rifles thought it would be fun. What was not so fun was when my friend beat the snot out of them like they richly deserved.
My GSDs were runners. They kind of looked like coyote and I always worried they'd get shot. I rehomed the bitch because she was such a runner and it would make my ex so mad. Dog was better off in a better home. Regardless, yes you can shoot a dog out here if it's attacking your livestock. I had a beagle and a boxer show up and chase one of my colts until they cornered it. It was an older Colt, yearling maybe?, and I was about to shoot the dogs. Thankfully they ran off. Told one of my more gossiping neighbors and I guess word got around I was going to shoot their dogs because later they apologized and I didn't see the dog again.
 
Around here, there is a very real chance your dog will get shot unless it's a small breed. But we also have an insane amount of pit-type dogs and people/their pets getting attacked is more common than anyone likes to realize. So people tend to be jumpy around loose big dogs. As an owner, you are responsible for your dog and 9 times out of ten, the law will side with the shooter, atleast in MI. That alone is enough for me to just not risk it. Especially when I've had people ask me if my lab is a pit ....
 
Around here, there is a very real chance your dog will get shot unless it's a small breed. But we also have an insane amount of pit-type dogs and people/their pets getting attacked is more common than anyone likes to realize. So people tend to be jumpy around loose big dogs. As an owner, you are responsible for your dog and 9 times out of ten, the law will side with the shooter, atleast in MI. That alone is enough for me to just not risk it. Especially when I've had people ask me if my lab is a pit ....
I am all for gun owners' rights, but that type of behavior – shooting loose dogs – plays into the anti-gun stereotypes.
 
Yes and no. I live near farms. Loose dogs are a serious problem for farmers. I don't blame them for shooting dogs going after their live stock. And I don't blame people for shooting loose dogs that act aggressively. We've had way too many fatal dog attacks in the city and surrounding areas.

Personally, I'm going to try to scare a dog off first. But if that doesn't work? I'm not going to wait to get attacked or have my kids attacked either. There are leash laws for a reason. And I say that as someone who's dogs have gotten loose. I know full well that if they are loose, there is a very real chance they will be shot and it will be my fault for my dogs being loose in the first place. As such, I try my best to make sure it never happens and keep a very close eye on them when they are out.
 
Yes and no. I live near farms. Loose dogs are a serious problem for farmers. I don't blame them for shooting dogs going after their live stock. And I don't blame people for shooting loose dogs that act aggressively. We've had way too many fatal dog attacks in the city and surrounding areas.

Personally, I'm going to try to scare a dog off first. But if that doesn't work? I'm not going to wait to get attacked or have my kids attacked either. There are leash laws for a reason. And I say that as someone who's dogs have gotten loose. I know full well that if they are loose, there is a very real chance they will be shot and it will be my fault for my dogs being loose in the first place. As such, I try my best to make sure it never happens and keep a very close eye on them when they are out.


People don't realize the damage dogs can do. It isn't unheard of for a horse tobhave to be put down due to coyote attacks, dog attacks etc. And depending on the horse, the loss can be less than if the animal does make it because thennyoubhave extensive vet bills. However, when you're raising cokts and trying to get 5k+ for an animal it can't have scared up legs, can't have any evidence of trauma because it could mean lameness down the road.

Horse, cows, goats all are investments. If you're a big breeder raising 20k+ colts, imagine the damage a dog could do!!
 
People don't realize the damage dogs can do. It isn't unheard of for a horse tobhave to be put down due to coyote attacks, dog attacks etc. And depending on the horse, the loss can be less than if the animal does make it because thennyoubhave extensive vet bills. However, when you're raising cokts and trying to get 5k+ for an animal it can't have scared up legs, can't have any evidence of trauma because it could mean lameness down the road.

Horse, cows, goats all are investments. If you're a big breeder raising 20k+ colts, imagine the damage a dog could do!!
I wasn't disputing that dogs that do damage to livestock or legitimately threaten people should be subject to being shot.

The sentiment put forth was that around where the member lives in MI, a loose dog is at risk of being shot. That sounds like there are folks who are likely to shoot without just cause, which sounds like yahoos with guns yet who lack the brains to handle the responsibility.

It's worrisome to think that if my Doberman got loose he might be shot.
 
I wasn't disputing that dogs that do damage to livestock or legitimately threaten people should be subject to being shot.

The sentiment put forth was that around where the member lives in MI, a loose dog is at risk of being shot. That sounds like there are folks who are likely to shoot without just cause, which sounds like yahoos with guns yet who lack the brains to handle the responsibility.

It's worrisome to think that if my Doberman got loose he might be shot.

Yes it's scary. Here they also shoot if they see loose dogs. It has to do with them forming packs, and preventing stock from being damaged. Just because they aren't damaging them currently doesn't mean they won't later.

I don't know, it would really piss me off if someone shot my dog because he ran off one time or something, but people here see it like they see a dog getting hit on the road, it's the owners fault.
 
Kobi's rarely on a lead. My first dobe/lab never owned a collar or leash. I could cycle for miles and he'd trot alongside me. Stop and wait at pavements. He wouldn't move till he was given a que. He wouldn't batten an eye-lid at another dog, or cat, horse....nothing.

I live in a very rural village, deep down in the South West of the United Kingdom. When I'm walking along the pavement, doing the school run he's on a leash. Away from busy traffic, in a rural setting he's always off. I'm surrounded by a ton of farmers fields, which has helped. The farmers are friendly and as long as you pick up after your dog they are happy for your dog to run loose in their fields. How cool is that?

The Cornish born and breed individuals are soooo laid back, we're almost horizontal! Lol
 
The sentiment put forth was that around where the member lives in MI,
I'm 3 miles from Detroit and the cops in my town did just recently taz an "aggressive" dog off leash. I think this is a better alternative IMO. But in more Rural areas of Michigan I can understand farmers concerns with their livestock. In the city of Detroit they have had some fatal attacks by packs of dogs on people, the last one I remember was a 4 yr old child. With fatal results.

We've had way too many fatal dog attacks in the city and surrounding areas.
I am really surprised to hear you have such problems in your area, I have an Uncle that lives there, had no idea.
 
Yes it's scary. Here they also shoot if they see loose dogs. It has to do with them forming packs, and preventing stock from being damaged. Just because they aren't damaging them currently doesn't mean they won't later.

I don't know, it would really piss me off if someone shot my dog because he ran off one time or something, but people here see it like they see a dog getting hit on the road, it's the owners fault.
Well then I refer everyone back to my previous comment.
 
I am really surprised to hear you have such problems in your area, I have an Uncle that lives there, had no idea.

I meant in Detroit and the surrounding areas as a whole. Since the news covers a lot of dog attacks, the general fear of large, loose dogs travels even out here. Which I understand to some degree. As dog attacks are definitely not limited to just the city, many of the suburbs and more outlying regions have seen them as well. However, the issue is people who have zero concept of canine behaivor. What many see as aggression, is not. And fear makes people do strange things.

That said - I also live far enough out of the city that hunting occurs within a couple miles. Many hunters will shoot a dog running game. And it's legal.

Not saying it's right. But that's just reality. Odds are, the shooter will be protected by the law and the dog owner will be facing any number of charges and fines.


It would be awesome if people tased instead of shot, but the reality is you can open carry a gun in MI without a license. You can not carry a taser unless you have your CPL. Thus, not many people even own tasers.

I see both sides of it. As a dog owner, I'd be upset if my dog(s) got shot on the off chance they escaped. But knowing farmers, I also know how much damage one dog can do to the livestock they make a living off of and rely on to eat.
 

Back
Top