When were your Dobermans finally allowed off-leash outside?

**Completely out of curiosity.** I scroll through pictures of dobies on here and 95% of them are off leash when outdoors and get to roam free. At what age did you decide that they were able to handle it? Apollo is 10 months and has never ever been off leash outside before. One time he ran out the house and I had to chase him down because he was running away to someone else's backyard. I'm afraid if I ever let him outside without a leash on, he'll run away and leave me forever haha. It seems so natural and easy for other dogs to be outside without a leash but I'm not sure if Apollo would stay or run away and I would need to chase him down again. How do you know if they're ready?
 
Do you have any all enclosed baseball fields or anything like that in your area? Or can you get to a dog park at odd/off hrs when you know there won't be anyone there?
Our current trainer is big on emergency recall and recall in general so we've been working on it from the beginning.
Have you done recall training with him before like on a long lead? How does he respond?
 
Last edited:
I did it with my X's GSD in stages slowly lol. First I worked on Recall in the house Id call her to me from the basement from the bedroom and when she was great with that we took it to the field beside us that was "Fenced" by trees and I used a long line and worked on recall and then I let her loose there and again worked on recall. When she could do it there consistently I took her to the fenced dog park and I worked on recall there with tons of distractions. Then you get to this point where you know its highly highly unlikely they would ignore a recall and you know you can trust them. I had my big day with her on a trail, I found that the natural course they will take is predictable and if the worse happened and my instincts were somehow wrong I would at least have a clue where to look. I have not been wrong but I try to take every precaution. My X got her when she was 6 months old it took 6 months of training before I had that feeling of surety that she would not ignore my recall. That said I have had dogs like my pittie for example that I wouldn't have ever trusted like her, he spent to much time as a stray before we rescued him. My Weim I had it took 3 months. Every dog is different and I was different to as to how much time and dedication to the "cause" I was able to put in. Sorry to be vague but there are many variables.
 
I should add that since Shadow is in her doberteens (she's 9 mo) she has not been 100% with recall. This probably started last month right before she went into heat.
Oh .. she knows what I'm asking but she's just being an ass and doesn't want to listen. I'm conditioning her to the ecollar now and plan on starting to train with it next month.
 
I won't let our dogs off leash if they're not in a fence or until their recall is 110%, as stated. We did start the e-collar training after they were a year old and once we're confidant with that, they will get some freedom. We have a lot of land and one of the first things they were taught is that a certain point down the driveway is off limits, so most of the time they don't wear the e-collars anymore either, aside from a few reminders or if we go to places like the lake. I still keep a leash in my back pocket so it's handy though.

Our RIP boy Boris had a 99% recall, but that one time was all it took for him to bolt out to the road and get hit by a car so I won't take chances again.
 
Lots of variables to consider. What are your local laws?

Mine are never allowed off leash unless the area is fenced. But we also have both state and city leash laws. So I just don't feel like risking a ticket. If I did find a place that I considered letting them off leash, it would be with an e-collar as back up. (Do they make water proof e-collars?!) But only if I had worked on off leash training a lot more than I currently do. But I also live in town, on a main road. If I had acreage, I'd probably be a bit different. My moms two dogs have free roam of her 5 acres. She's never used leashes or e-collars. Her dogs just know their boundaries but they've been raised since tiny pups that way and they both have amazing recall (don't ask me how, because dog trainer my mom is not and they never went through any official training or obedience), they can be after a rabbit or other critter, in a dead run and they are still %110. My lab has zero recall if he's after something, so I don't think I'd ever trust him off leash. even at the lake where we could get away with it, he has a long lead tied to one of us on at all times. That's really about the only place we go where I would even consider letting them off leash.
 
Where I live there are lots of big open fields, far from traffic. I have always started all my puppies off leash from the time they are little. We take them for walks off leash along with some of the older dogs who know to come when called and they get treats every time they come running. We have a fairly big lake with a trail around it that is off-leash and lots of people walks their dogs there and we take ours too. Have never had a problem as everybody keeps their dogs under control and puts them on leash when they meet another dog. I do have Kris trained with the e-collar as she is not 100% reliable without it but seldom use more than the tone.
 
His recall needs to be absolutely solid. Pretty much the #1 command a dog should know. You don't have to have him off leash to teach that. :) I'd work on that a ton for the next year. Start with different pieces of recall training. Saying his name and getting eye contact, treat. Saying his name from a few feet away while simultaneously reeling him in with leash, treat when he turns into you. Do the same as before but further away. etc etc until you work your way up from being on a short leash, to a long leash, to dragging a long leash, to off leash.

I would highly recommend having an ecollar for backup even when his recall is solid...you just don't use it but have it on. Dogs aren't robots and can ignore that command 1 time...having the ecollar to maybe snap them out of it 1 time and avoiding a risky situation is worth putting it on every time for me. Make sure you find a trainer to show you how to use one properly. Timing, patience, and understanding is everything for ecollar training.
 
8 years and still don't allow off leash without the e-collar. Hans' recall is quite good, but the e-collar is a that one thing that can prevent a major disaster.
 
Recall must be solid as stated above. Dog must be well trained and mature so you are probably looking at 2-3 years old minimum. We don't let our dogs off leash but we have strict leash laws. I train off leash training even as puppies but it is at our training field and it is a fenced in 40 acre private dog park.
 
Great idea for a thread.

With my first Dobe, I feel like it was the longest. He was maybe around 2 yrs. give or take. I remember teaching him recall and he was unreliable if he saw an animal. Well that is pretty common isn't it? I used the throw-chain method with him, which is a mean-sounding technique but is legitimate and safe if done properly.

Next I got a working-line Dobe and it was easier.

Same with my current working-line Dobe. Seems they are (well in my fairly limited experience) maybe more prone to want to stay close. I want to say "Daddy's boy."

Current boy, Oji, is the most extraordinary example yet. We did not have a fence-in yard (actually it was poorly fenced and he could have easily escaped). So I'd take him out back on-leash to potty for the first several weeks, but began to have him off-leash. Then I even let him off-leash some in the unfenced front yard. This, at maybe 6 months.

I really like how things have gone this time around, and I will try for it again next time. One of the keys is trying to make it not abnormal – trying to make being off-leash natural and no big deal. The more foreign being off-leash is, the more likely they are to bolt. If they get too far from you, call them excitedly, getting their attention, and then start running away from them. Make coming to you fun and rewarding for them. The more successful exposure you have, the more success you will have going forward.

There was one time that he bolted out of the backyard and I had the e-collar on him. I have to admit that I messed up and zapped him for it. He was not trained well enough on the collar for that. It made him want to run away from me. Fortunately, it just isn't in him to really run away so he just went across the street and when I came close to him he eventually just stayed still so I could get ahold of him. This could be much different when dealing with a dog that is really prone to running away.

So today I am able to have Oji off leash surprisingly a lot. I still can almost not believe it, given how very difficult he has been to train in so many ways. Now, if he caught sight of another animal I do feel that he would run after it.

This brings up the other side of the equation: You need to train them to react to your negative commands as well – in other words, if you shout angrily for him to stop he needs to hopefully heed that. You just need him to stop running in response to your negative-sounding command. After that, don't angrily call him to you. Either make a 180° turn in your demeanor and start happily calling him to you as you move away from him, or just calmly walk to him and get ahold of him. The risk with that last approach is that a lot of dogs will wait until you get almost to them then they'll play keep-away.

Of course you never want to chase your dog. It's very unlikely that you'll be able to catch them and it just encourages them to run from you. It can be a fun activity for them, this keep away business.
 
Too many factors. If you live in a rural area, if you have a fenced in area, if you are able to keep up with him exploring compared to a city with no fenced in yard and a street only a few feet away.
Regardless you want to work on recall but how much freedom you give him is subjective.
 
I guess if you live VERY RURAL this is a possibility, but to me there are too many variables with your dog being off leash. You CANNOT EVER GUARANTEE your dogs recall...they maybe be 100%...until they AREN'T. That's when disaster happens. :(
 
The Dingo is only off leash at the dog park and in fenced in yards. We make an exception when we go to my parents house but they live in the country and have 4 other dogs that have learned not to leave their backyard. Those dogs are enough to keep her interested with no desire to stray. We've started the e-collar training and her recall is generally very strong so I would like to find some remote places to practice with the e-collar at some point. That being said:

My friends boyfriend has a dog that he likes to have off leash and she was telling me about a time when the dog started chasing a squirrel, didn't recall and impaled herself with a stick - a great example of leash laws being for the dogs safety (she's fine, now).

There was a lady walking her dog outside the fence of the dog park without a leash the other day. That really irritated me. Inside the park; fine. Outside the park; no reason for it. People think that just because their dog isn't aggressive, that dogs walking around on leashes aren't, either. Their is a Schnauzer in our neighborhood who just is not dog friendly for whatever reason. We always wave when we walk by by we recognize that he needs his space. If a 'friendly' off leash dog ever got near him, I fear it would not end well. Most people forget that leash laws aren't only for their dogs, but for other dogs, too.

Some dogs just cannot be off leash and I don't think their lives are any worse for it, as long as they get their physical and mental exercise. As others have said, even if off leash ins't practical, you should still work on having solid recall just in case.
 
I find this super interesting. I've never walked neegan to potty him... If we go somewhere certainly he's on a lead. He jumped out of the car once at my ex's shop. So funny, he took a quick lap around the car said "I don't know where the F I am" and came right to me.

At home he's always off lead. I've raised dogs the other way and found that when they're used to always being confined in some way that they really test their freedom more when it happens. Congo and Neegan never leave the property, but they no longer go out together. They stick around and come running when I call and honestly we've never really "worked" on it. It's just "mom yelling means I can suggle on the sofa, be right in momma" and that's it.
 
I've raised dogs the other way and found that when they're used to always being confined in some way that they really test their freedom more when it happens
This can certainly be true. I think it depends on the dog. Some dogs seem to think 'I'm free and I'm getting as far away from that lead as I can' others seem to feel lost since they're used to being so close to their owner they feel uncomfortable being too far away.
 
This can certainly be true. I think it depends on the dog. Some dogs seem to think 'I'm free and I'm getting as far away from that lead as I can' others seem to feel lost since they're used to being so close to their owner they feel uncomfortable being too far away.


I agree. And I think I would feel differently if I lived on under 20 acres... I mean he's not above seeing something and giving chase, I can get him back though before he's off property. He's also outside alone quite a bit but when I call him he's usually right around the house because he's at the door in under a minute.
 

Back
Top