• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Stop Barking Collars, Do They Work? Has Anyone Tried One Of These?

Last night Kato barked, I was up as I am a night-owl and hubby had gotten up too.. well we did nothing at all, it lasted a whole 20 minutes then quiet. Even after hearing Tony's voice he was quiet.. hmmmmmmmm something to this.. ignore?! Maybe eh? Tonight he barked about 5 minutes then it stopped.. omg I think he gets it. Thing is we always yelled at him to stop, be quiet.. etc... sometimes Tony would let him out to pee..(that was a ploy) he gots out often enough all day and before bed. But this total ignore without a word... I like it.. gonna get a collar of some sort as back up though just in case..
So please everyone if you have successfully used one of the above.. let us know k? :ty:
Yes! Sometimes yelling can just encourage the behavior. It is kind of like "well they're upset, obviously I should be upset, too." This only gets worse if you cave to them. Once a dog is at least 6 months old they should be able to make it through a normal night without needing to go outside. There are exceptions, of course, but certainly not all the time. Think like Caesar Millan, no talk, no touch, no eye contact until they calm down. Yelling only works if they understand that means you've got the situation under control and don't need their warning anymore.
 
Yes! Sometimes yelling can just encourage the behavior. It is kind of like "well they're upset, obviously I should be upset, too." This only gets worse if you cave to them. Once a dog is at least 6 months old they should be able to make it through a normal night without needing to go outside. There are exceptions, of course, but certainly not all the time. Think like Caesar Millan, no talk, no touch, no eye contact until they calm down. Yelling only works if they understand that means you've got the situation under control and don't need their warning anymore.
Thanks, makes sense to me!!! :)
 
Back to the question at hand...

I use a Dogtra no-bark. It delivers one corrective stimulus and takes 13 seconds in between to charge. This is so if they cry from surprise (not pain mind you) it won't keep stimming them. I use it for Silence any time he's left alone in the car. Vex is just crying it out at this point. But a low stim bark collar will be in his future I'm sure as well.
 
To add...

This is not to say I recommend you using one without exhausting the other options as well. The spray doesn't work for my dogs for ex. So make sure IF you do go the collar route it will be the best correction for YOUR dog.
 
Sometimes yelling can just encourage the behavior. It is kind of like "well they're upset, obviously I should be upset, too."
I was just reading an article about this in Cesars Way magazine.

A small quote:
Stay calm.
If your dogs barking is aggravating you, it's easy to snap, and your irritation will show. But all this will do is make your dog bark more, because she will pick up on your anxiety and mirror it. To successfully correct your dog you must first make sure you are calm. Try some breathing exercises to put yourself in a relaxed state before you address your dog.
 
Okay, I think my issue is related to this post so I didn't want to start a new one. Gambit has started barking as soon as he hits the porch steps every single time he goes outside. The vast majority of the time, there's nothing even there. There's nothing new going on in the neighborhood (ie: construction). There's nothing new in our yard. As far as I know, unless there's something dogs pick up on that I can't, his environment is completely unchanged. The amount of exercise they've had seems to be irrelevant. Time of day seems to be irrelevant. He gets himself so hyped up barking at nothing that he sometimes forgets why he's out there in the first place and doesn't use the bathroom! Sometimes we can give him a firm "No" and he'll quiet down to muffled barks but sometimes we may as well not be there at all.

I don't want to discourage him from barking in the event there's actually something there that he does need to alert us about but I'm wondering if there's something I can do that will teach him it's not okay to bark like a maniac every time he steps out the door.

My mom believes that he's "at that age" where he's discovering his "manly" bark and wants to hear it, lol!
 
Okay, I think my issue is related to this post so I didn't want to start a new one. Gambit has started barking as soon as he hits the porch steps every single time he goes outside. The vast majority of the time, there's nothing even there. There's nothing new going on in the neighborhood (ie: construction). There's nothing new in our yard. As far as I know, unless there's something dogs pick up on that I can't, his environment is completely unchanged. The amount of exercise they've had seems to be irrelevant. Time of day seems to be irrelevant. He gets himself so hyped up barking at nothing that he sometimes forgets why he's out there in the first place and doesn't use the bathroom! Sometimes we can give him a firm "No" and he'll quiet down to muffled barks but sometimes we may as well not be there at all.

I don't want to discourage him from barking in the event there's actually something there that he does need to alert us about but I'm wondering if there's something I can do that will teach him it's not okay to bark like a maniac every time he steps out the door.

My mom believes that he's "at that age" where he's discovering his "manly" bark and wants to hear it, lol!
Seems like Kato is starting this also.. He never used to bark when going outside, he was so quiet it stunned the dogs next door even into silence.. Now whether he is there alone without distraction and nomatter what time of day it is.. it is non stop barking.. also he is now starting his 3 am barking even if he does not hear anyone. (he had stopped this a whie back) but he is now doing this again and it is driving me insane, my nerves are frayed and I'm at my wits end.. I've tried everything, now I really don't know what to do.. the only thing left is the citronella collar and that is expensive, considering everything I've already paid for him, so I dunno, hubby is getting upset which upsets us all... I need HELP... FAST...should I dish out more money for a collar ..???? :(
 
I have started a new routine with Luca as he is now old enough to start settling into it. We do down stays in the morning (when it is hardest for him) right after breakfast. It is also a good way to help control bloat rather than letting him run and roll around like a fool. If he whines for attention or to get up from the down stay he is zapped by his lovely new remote collar. Later through the day there is plenty of exercise, play, and training going on. In the evening after dinner there is some more training and another down stay. I plan to try out the remote collar in his crate tonight and see if it stops the barking. We are only on level 1-2 out of 8. I like the remote function of the collar because I KNOW when he is getting shocked. My friend has used a bark collar on her dobe before and because he spins and bangs around in his crate a bit the collar is shocking him for the noise that is making and I don't like that. Also we have a problem with whining for attention or to not do something I have asked of him. The collars (shock, vibrate, or spray) that are automatic do not deliver a punishment for this. But I CAN with this collar. I am hoping that it makes training and car rides more enjoyable.
 
I have considered a remote collar too but I don't want to start then too young and I know it's something that you have to know how to use correctly. Would it work in our situation? Maybe he starts barking, we tell him no, but then if he continues then use the remote just to let him know that no means no. I'm worried that a citronella one may spray our other dogs when he barks and I definitely don't want to use a bark collar for similar reasons that you mention, Caloni
 
I have used the PetSafe Bark collars on my dogs and have found they work great. One my Shih Tzu x Maltese used to do the same thing as your dog, walk out the door and start barking before she even looked around. I used the collar on her for quite a while and barely use it now. I also used one on Kris when she insisted on barking at my horse. These collars allow them to bark and only work if they keep barking so they can still give a couple of barks. She is smart enough to know when the collar is on, not to keep barking as they start out with a mild shock and it keeps upping if they keep barking.

I did manage to get my remote collar working but what I am using it for is if she gets too rough on my little dogs. I tell her to leave it and if she persists I give her a beep warning and if she still persists I will give her a shock. So far as long as she has the collar on, she leaves them alone even though I have never shocked her with it yet. Too smart for her own good.
 
I have considered a remote collar too but I don't want to start then too young and I know it's something that you have to know how to use correctly. Would it work in our situation? Maybe he starts barking, we tell him no, but then if he continues then use the remote just to let him know that no means no. I'm worried that a citronella one may spray our other dogs when he barks and I definitely don't want to use a bark collar for similar reasons that you mention, Caloni
I would use the remote collar. Stopping unwanted behaviors at the youngest age you can is the most desirable. I would use the bark collar and use it only for the barking in the crate. I think that saying no, then later shocking them may send an inconsistent message to the dog, but I also don't know your dog so that is just my opinion. Try it and see what you think. If it doesn't work out, return it. I would not use a bark collar that is automatic or a spray collar in a house with more than one dog.
 
I would use the remote collar....

Luckily, we don't have the crate barking problem. They hardly bark in the house at all pray.webp They don't even bark when the pizza or delivery guy comes to the door! So, it's just the run outside and bark for no reason issue. He's also started digging so maybe I could kill two birds with one stone with the remote collar?


Cariboo Country I had someone tell me that you couldn't use bark or remote collars on long haired dogs. It was someone who has little to no experience with them and i never looked it up to confirm or deny even though it made no sense to me. I'm guessing it's safe to say that your shih tzu/maltese probably wasn't a short haired dog, lol!

I've had several forum members say that they use the remote collar for recall. Has anyone used the remote collar to tell the dog to do something (ie come) AND not do something (ie stop barking)?
 
The bark collars work off vibration of the dogs throat when they bark so it does not affect any other dogs. With the longer coated dogs you just get a little longer prongs on them and they work fine. I would never use one of those ultra-sonic type things as it affects all the dogs when one barks and the spray type collars leave the scent on them long after they stop barking. With a dog's sensitive nose, I think it is worse than a small shock.
 
I was just reading an article about this in Cesars Way magazine.

A small quote:
Stay calm.
If your dogs barking is aggravating you, it's easy to snap, and your irritation will show. But all this will do is make your dog bark more, because she will pick up on your anxiety and mirror it. To successfully correct your dog you must first make sure you are calm. Try some breathing exercises to put yourself in a relaxed state before you address your dog.
Lol,this might be much easier said than done.
When I've corrected and stayed calm 20 times in 9 minutes,my "calm" is flat exhausted away.
Seems like Kato is starting this also.. He never used to bark when going outside, he was so quiet it stunned the dogs next door even into silence.. Now whether he is there alone without distraction and nomatter what time of day it is.. it is non stop barking.. also he is now starting his 3 am barking even if he does not hear anyone. (he had stopped this a whie back) but he is now doing this again and it is driving me insane, my nerves are frayed and I'm at my wits end.. I've tried everything, now I really don't know what to do.. the only thing left is the citronella collar and that is expensive, considering everything I've already paid for him, so I dunno, hubby is getting upset which upsets us all... I need HELP... FAST...should I dish out more money for a collar ..???? :(
+2,now barking on the way out.
It is usually a reaction to the little dogs barking,but after a while it just has to be their scent being blown in by the wind,he's barking.
 
Any shock collars is out of the question cuz 1. We tried it once as my friend had one for her dog and he just got used to it and it never bothered him... he is one tough cookie.. 2. It is now illegal in Quebec to use them any longer which is why I thought citronelle..
Anyhow he is destroying everything now.. We just got him a walking halter which Tony said he loved and Kato walked really well with it. So tonight when Tony got home he took him for a long walk before supper then we put Kato in his crate while we ate our supper..(omg he chewed through the new halter) Tony had forgotten to remove it.. He has chewed through tons of toys, quite a few beds, blankets, collars rips off his dog tags etc..etc..I get to feel sorry for him and buy him more, but now I really can't afford to keep paying for things he destroys, we just got a house and have to do a lot of modifications for me, so money is out of the question... He gets plenty of attention, excercise and training.. so I don't know what is going on with him.. I really am becomming angry and counting to 10 and staying calm went out the window ages ago... He never sees me upset so I don't know.. maybe he is jealous of the cat.. that is one thing I hadn't thought of till now.. But he sees her every day and we never play favourites.. oh heck I dunno and here I am venting.. sorry guys..
 
Any shock collars is out of the question cuz 1. We tried it once as my friend had one for her dog and he just got used to it and it never bothered him... he is one tough cookie.. 2. It is now illegal in Quebec to use them any longer which is why I thought citronelle..
Anyhow he is destroying everything now.. We just got him a walking halter which Tony said he loved and Kato walked really well with it. So tonight when Tony got home he took him for a long walk before supper then we put Kato in his crate while we ate our supper..(omg he chewed through the new halter) Tony had forgotten to remove it.. He has chewed through tons of toys, quite a few beds, blankets, collars rips off his dog tags etc..etc..I get to feel sorry for him and buy him more, but now I really can't afford to keep paying for things he destroys, we just got a house and have to do a lot of modifications for me, so money is out of the question... He gets plenty of attention, excercise and training.. so I don't know what is going on with him.. I really am becomming angry and counting to 10 and staying calm went out the window ages ago... He never sees me upset so I don't know.. maybe he is jealous of the cat.. that is one thing I hadn't thought of till now.. But he sees her every day and we never play favourites.. oh heck I dunno and here I am venting.. sorry guys..
I agree with Jan,it's a phase.Rocky is right with yours.Destroying beds and toys,and makes a mess doing it.
I keep my sanity by telling myself it could be worse,he's only destroying "dog stuff".He's left the furniture alone and none of our things.He would have a serious "going to meet Jesus" moment if he were to start in on the wood furniture here.
Some has been in the family for decades and decades.When Daisy was a youngster we had a dining room table that was from the late 1800s.That was my biggest worry,that table and my departed mother in-laws coffee and end tables.She never touched either.
For what it's worth,we don't even crate here.They have free roam while we're gone.

For some new cheap toy ideas,the cheaper they are the more the dogs like them.A mesquite stick for chewing,an empty water bottle,a dish towel tied in a couple of knots,a shop towel for tuggy,you get the idea?Be creative.
 

Back
Top