• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Stop Barking Collars, Do They Work? Has Anyone Tried One Of These?

Jazzycan

Notable member
Yep the old he won't stop barking thingy..:confused:
We have all heard the stories and the stress a barking dog can cause.. :pullhair:


What I would love to know if any of you have tried these different dog collars etc.. and if they really work... I have posted links so you know what I mean..

The Citronella spray collar
http://www.amazon.ca/Collar-Citronella-Spray-Anti-Bark-collar/dp/B00AM05U9O/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1392986831&sr=8-1&keywords=citronella+dog+collar

The Static Shock collar
http://www.amazon.ca/Esky-Training-Effective-Labrador-Retriever/dp/B00D6AYNC2/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1392987060&sr=8-1&keywords=anti+bark+shock+collar

The Vibration Bark Control Collar
http://www.canadianbarkcontrol.com/vibration-bark-control-collar.htm

The Dog Silencer pro
http://www.canadianbarkcontrol.com/ds_pro.htm#page=Main-Tab

(This last one can also control your neighbours dogs) or so they say...hehehe:devil:
 
I have the citronella spray collar but the refill I use is a non scented spray. It works very well.

I only use it in the very early hours of the morning or late at night for my neighbors sake. Lots of squirrels and children boarding school buses and he can get kind of barky then.

He is collar smart so he knows when I put it on what it is.

I tried the ultrasonic yard bird house (for the neighbors dogs lol) and for Luca but it didn't work for anyone.

I use an ecollar for my emergency back up recall when off leash so I chose not to use the shock bark control as he is trained to recall if nicked and that would send a mixed signal.
 
Hi Jess
Wow, that's hard to say but a lot sounds good..:)
About an hour in all of training by me. Basic rules, and then hubby adds some also.
Exercise I'd say two hours or so in and out of the house, maybe more, depending on the day and the weather.
Oh forgot to mention I need it for nightime.
 
That should be enough, really. Especially if the exercise is vigorous. What exactly is the issue? With a bit more detail we may be able to give you some better alternatives.
 
Believe me we've tried them all...... during the day now he is pretty good and listens to us..
Its during the night if he hears hubby get up (his idol) well its yap yap yap.. he does it for awhile until he realizes its futile and gives up but then our sleep is cut in half.. driving us nuts, I can make it up as I'm retired but hubby works and needs his sleep...
If he hears hubby snore he is quiet as a mouse but hubby gets up a lot..you know..lol....
 
Believe me we've tried them all...... during the day now he is pretty good and listens to us..
Its during the night if he hears hubby get up (his idol) well its yap yap yap.. he does it for awhile until he realizes its futile and gives up but then our sleep is cut in half.. driving us nuts, I can make it up as I'm retired but hubby works and needs his sleep...
If he hears hubby snore he is quiet as a mouse but hubby gets up a lot..you know..lol....
Is his crate in your room? Can it be placed elsewhere? Is it covered?
 
No he has his own room and yes he is in a crate. No it's not covered cuz its dark in there.. should we? Cover it I mean? Thanks a lot Jess..
Oh btw.. the only place left is the basement.. and he is scared to go down there the lil chicken ...hahaha
 
No he has his own room and yes he is in a crate. No it's not covered cuz its dark in there.. should we? Cover it I mean? Thanks a lot Jess..
Oh btw.. the only place left is the basement.. and he is scared to go down there the lil chicken ...hahaha
I cover ours to help encourage them to sleep and not be bothered by the goings on in the rest of the house. His barking, does it sound like he's scared, defensive, or just wants to be included in the activity? What do you do when he barks?
 
Watching this thread:cool:

Mr. Barky McBarksalot is starting to try my nerves.And it doesn't matter how much exercise he gets.
 
I want to know too....we have started back up again on crate barking. I can't always run back upstairs with my bad knees and there is no where downstairs for a crate.
 
How much training? What do you do when he barks? Do you offer him an alternative action?
Tell him "NO"!
Sometimes a flick to the rump when his hearing is blocked by being a boy...or he didn't hear the no because he's so loud.
He barks when he's excited,barks at the neighbors dogs barking,barks at Daisy to play,bark bark bark!!!

Define training.We work on the basics,and when he's focused he's great.Lose the focus and he needs a physical touch,and just a touch.Not a pop on the rump,just a slight touch anywhere.
I try to go over the basics daily,maybe 15-20 minutes.After that amount if time he loses that focus.
We do off lead walks to burn off the energy,ranging from 1.5-3 miles.Usually mid morning to avoid the heat,and avoid afternoons.That's when the hills are most active with other dogs,joggers and dirt bikes.
He's just a 1.6 year old puppy.
I believe the early age of neutering has something to do with it.
 
Gel, in your case I'm more apt to believe it is a matter of not being used to the place yet. He still hasn't figured out all of what is normal or not so everything brings an alert. We're going through this right now with Riv. She is still adjusting to the country life so things like the horses up the hill put her on high alert. When this happens I correct her verbally and try to engage her in something else. The strategy is very similar to trying to get her to ignore the cat. Make it clear the actions are not okay but then provide an alternative action like playing fetch or just plain coming inside. It is a long term process but I believe it will succeed. It can also vary by dog, though. Spock is in the same environment but only alerts to like 1/4th of what she alerts to. Could be age, could be experience, could just be his personality. I asked about the training to evaluate three things 1) his level of mental exhaustion 2) the level of control you have over him and 3) the level of bond/trust he should have in you. A well trained and bonded dog should have the trust in you that when you call them off something it means either the situation isn't what they thought or you've otherwise got it under control and it isn't their problem anymore.
 
I should have added I usually grab a toy and throw it.He likes to retrieve.
Another aspect I'm seriously considering is his food.
Pro-Plan Sport
Lots! of energy.
I tend to not correct the barking when they are out in the yard doing their gladiator dance and chasing each other around.
He can out run her,they both know it.He can not however maneuver like her and it frustrates the crap out of him:D
 
Gel, in your case I'm more apt to believe it is a matter of not being used to the place yet. He still hasn't figured out all of what is normal or not so everything brings an alert. We're going through this right now with Riv. She is still adjusting to the country life so things like the horses up the hill put her on high alert. When this happens I correct her verbally and try to engage her in something else. The strategy is very similar to trying to get her to ignore the cat. Make it clear the actions are not okay but then provide an alternative action like playing fetch or just plain coming inside. It is a long term process but I believe it will succeed. It can also vary by dog, though. Spock is in the same environment but only alerts to like 1/4th of what she alerts to. Could be age, could be experience, could just be his personality. I asked about the training to evaluate three things 1) his level of mental exhaustion 2) the level of control you have over him and 3) the level of bond/trust he should have in you. A well trained and bonded dog should have the trust in you that when you call them off something it means either the situation isn't what they thought or you've otherwise got it under control and it isn't their problem anymore.
This does make a lot if sense,so thank you.
His bonding process is coming along.He's become more affectionate with all of us.
In the case of going to the fence to bark at the little dogs on the other side,he's barking as he heads that way.
If I can give him the no before he gets to the fence he usually will stop and come.If he gets to the fence first I have to show that I will come get him if he doesn't recall.He hasn't made me go all the way to him,he knows I will though and stops.Then he comes wagging the banana tail and turns on the face.View attachment 30939This "don't you love me?" face.
 
We used one for Boris because he would just work himself up with the non-stop barking when company came over. With that he was able to be quiet long enough to realize that the company was okay and not going to hurt him. He had issues with trust since he wasn't socialized properly by his breeder.

We have the Petmate static collar but never use it anymore with the current dogs we have.
 
I should have added I usually grab a toy and throw it.He likes to retrieve.
Another aspect I'm seriously considering is his food.
Pro-Plan Sport
Lots! of energy.
I tend to not correct the barking when they are out in the yard doing their gladiator dance and chasing each other around.
He can out run her,they both know it.He can not however maneuver like her and it frustrates the crap out of him:D
That is Tasha and Boris he is bigger, faster on the long run but she is much quicker and agile than he is. She cuts like a cowdog does he trips on his feet when he tries to stay with her lol
 
Last night Kato barked, I was up as I am a night-owl and hubby had gotten up too.. well we did nothing at all, it lasted a whole 20 minutes then quiet. Even after hearing Tony's voice he was quiet.. hmmmmmmmm something to this.. ignore?! Maybe eh? Tonight he barked about 5 minutes then it stopped.. omg I think he gets it. Thing is we always yelled at him to stop, be quiet.. etc... sometimes Tony would let him out to pee..(that was a ploy) he gots out often enough all day and before bed. But this total ignore without a word... I like it.. gonna get a collar of some sort as back up though just in case..
So please everyone if you have successfully used one of the above.. let us know k? :ty:
 

Back
Top