• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Should I spay-neuter my European Doberman?

strykerdobe

Hot Topics Subscriber
I know the title is misleading. This should be followed for most dogs and cats.


Should I spay-neuter my european doberman? Doberman Blog

Should I spay-neuter my European Doberman?

should-i-spay-neuter-my-european-doberman.jpg



I occasionally receive a question from my USA readers – should I spay-neuter my European Doberman? This question is specific to the US, because in Europe intact dogs are the norm.

1. The reason behind mass spay/neuter campaign in the US.
You won’t see abandoned dogs running in packs on the streets in the US. This is due to a network of shelters, veterinarians, and volunteers that work with lost and surrendered dogs. But catching and re-homing dogs is only one side of the problem. If dogs breed uncontrollably it becomes a vicious cycle.

US Humane Society was formed somewhere in mid 1950s aiming to resolve animal welfare issues. Spaying and neutering was a quick and easy solution to control unwanted pet population. But how do you make this a long-term solution? You change public perception of the problem.

US is great at influencing public decision and judgement. It has been done many times in the US history. We know that lobbyist were able to push tobacco products to the public and have doctors promote cigarettes to their patients as “it’s good for your lungs”. We know that high-fructose corn syrup is widely used in food because it is subsidized by USDA (department of Agriculture), despite the fact it is the reason why US population is heavily affected with diabetes. And the list goes on.

So when you wonder “should I spay-neuter my European doberman” you need to understand the truth about it.

2. The importance of sex hormones.
Spaying and neutering would be absolutely appropriate thing to do, if severe health consequences wouldn’t be ignored or lied about. There are so many articles out there promoting the false benefits of spaying/neutering as if nature created sex hormones by mistake.

Sex hormones develop later in life (during puberty) in humans and in dogs. Of course dogs are not humans, but the purpose and function of the most of the organs are the same. And like in humans, hormones in dogs travel through the blood stream and carry messages between organs and cells. Hormones are secreted by glands in the endocrine system to help the body stay balanced and function optimally. In humans, the loss of sex hormones is associated with aging. We know that in aging humans replacing lost sex hormones restores feelings of well-being, reverse muscle and bone loss along with other functions that are associated with aging.

Below is a video posted by a well-known veterinarian in the US (and perhaps worldwide). This video explains her personal discovery of the affects of spaying/neutering dogs and health issues associated with it. If you ask yourself a question “should I spay-neuter my european doberman”, you must watch this video.


I have 2 adopted pets and both suffer from health issues directly connected to neutering. What are the odds? Well, perhaps spaying/neutering health issues are more common than we think.

Endocrine issues are among most common. A spayed/neutered dog is more likely to develop hypothyroidism. And this is what happened to my adopted Chihuahua-terrier mix. He was a young dog when we adopted him. Very energetic, happy, playful, adventurous, with silky white coat. A couple of years later he developed hypothyroidism. His skin was covered with bacterial infections and pimples, his coat became dull and hard and dirty-looking, he was always grumpy. He is on prescribed medication twice a day for life. And even though his lab test results show “normal” thyroid levels he never fully bounced back. He has unpredictable mood swings, hairless tail, and constant shedding. And it is required by law to do an annual thyroid test, otherwise the vet can’t prescribe the medication. Which is an unnecessary expense.

hypothyroidism-in-dogs.jpg


Another common issue is connected to urinary tract functions. Research has shown that females with ovaries live longer than spayed females. Neutered males have greater risk of prostate cancer and bladder cells carcinoma. And spayed/neutered pets have a greater risk of urinary incontinence.

From my experience I also want to add there is a risk of a surgical mistake. My second adopted pet is an outdoor (barn) cat. He also was neutered at a young age by the shelter veterinarian. Turns out he was damaged during the surgery and can no longer control his bladder. He “spills” urine whenever he sits or sleeps. The condition is irreversible. He is on 2 expensive medications twice a day that help him empty his bladder. We have to spray our yard regularly to eliminate the odor, and the cat has to wear a diaper every time he wants our company.

damaging-effects-of-neutering.jpg


Hip and elbow issues are also very common. If you watched the video above, you’ve learned that sex hormones also contribute to proper formation of joint tissues. Tore ligaments is a common problem and that is what happened to my nextdoor neighbor’s Labrador puppy. He was neutered at a very early age and by the time he was 1 year old he tore the ligament on his knee and needed a surgery.

Obesity in pets is another common problem associated with early spaying and neutering.

3. Healthy dobermans are rare.
Dobermans have very fragile health due to genetic issues (read more about Doberman genetic diseases). About 70% of dobermans are affected with a deadly DCM gene and should not be bred. Deliberately exposing this breed for more health risks, especially while it’s not necessary, will more likely increase your expenses in medical care. And in case it turns out your dog is free from breed specific genetic diseases at the mature age – it would be a great and needed contribution to the doberman population to breed such a dog. Also, there are very little well bred and genetically healthy European Dobermans in the US and Canada. So, if your dog is healthy – he/she might be in demand by reputable breeders.

4. Are you responsible for your dog?
If you are reading this blog – you are doing research. And very likely, you will invest the time and the money to import a dog from Europe. The fact that you are willing to learn and take the time to obtain the knowledge already differentiates you from people who impulsively buy a puppy on the internet and more likely be irresponsible.

Most of the dogs you will meet in the parks and on the streets are already spayed and neutered. Chances of your dog coming across an intact female is very low. Not to mention the female has to be in heat and during fertile period.

Responsible dog owners train and exercise their dogs, and don’t leave them unattended. If you want to be among responsible dog owners – join a local Schutzhund/IPO club or AKC club. Most dogs at the AKC clubs are intact, and ALL dogs at Schutzhund/IPO clubs are intact. Spaying or neutering does not substitute for owner’s laziness and dog’s lack of exercise or training. If you need help controlling your European Doberman’s high energy try engaging your dog in training and games (read my article Outdoor games to play with your dog).

If you wonder will your intact dog be able to play with spayed/neutered dogs. The answer is “absolutely yes”. If your dog is friendly and meets another friendly dog they are more likely to play. Dogs don’t discriminate against being fixed or not. The only advise I have for owners with intact males is that a neutered male dog doesn’t smell like a male to an intact dog. Your intact dog will consider most of the neutered dogs as females. It doesn’t mean he will mount them (it’s a bad behavior that owners should correct). A proper intact “gentlemen” dog will lick and sniff female dogs more intensely than he would a male dog. And if it’s a neutered male – he won’t like such attention and might growl. Your dog most likely will ignore the growl because he thinks it’s a feisty female and she is acknowledging him. In such cases – take your dog away before the situation escalates.

5. Myths about spaying/neutering.
Neutering/spaying WILL NOT:

  • make your dog calm,
  • stop him from humping other dogs;
  • eliminate aggression.
European Dobermans have high energy level and great temperament. If you want a calmer dog – European Doberman is not for you. They are very confident with people and other dogs and more likely to be friendly with friendly strangers.

Humping is a bad habit that should be corrected. I’ve seen neutered dogs trying to hump puppies or owner’s leg. It’s bad manners.

If your dog is aggressive – it’s most likely behavioral. Find out the reasons behind the aggression and work with your dog (and perhaps a trainer) to correct it.

Spayed/neutered dogs don’t loose their natural protective instincts. Same as hunting dogs don’t stop chasing wild life, and retrievers don’t stop retrieving – neutered or not. However, spayed/neutered dogs considered unfit to do police work and related competitive sports. If your dog has a talent for competitive sport and you find it interesting – keep your dog intact.

6. If you must do it.
Do it after your dog is fully developed. If possible, find a vet, who can perform sterilization procedure instead of spaying/neutering. This will keep the hormones, but makes your dog unable to conceive (like vasectomy in men).

Resources:
Neutering health risks.
Neutering-spaying effects.
The unspoken truth about spaying and neutering.

Help us spread the word! Share:
 
I realize this is a rather controversial topic in the USA. Lots of the big TV Vets advocate spaying/neutering. If you've seen "Dr. Jeff - Rocky Mountain Vet" on Animal Planet, he's like the disciple for Spaying/Neutering... All animals that pass through his clinic will get spayed/neutered if they aren't already. I don't know how he gets away with that but...

Personally, I would not be in favor of neutering a male unless there was an acute and immediate medical need for it. That is, not as a "preventive maintenance" measure, but a fix for a problem. This, especially, if I have a pure bread animal that might be a breeder candidate. All of the dobies I had as a kid were never neutered, and we had none of the difficulties normally associated with *not* neutering a male. Now, as I understand it, there are circumstances where it might be better from a "preventive maintenance" perspective to spay a female, but not until after the first few menstrual cycles. I'm not sure. I've only had males to raise.

I get why the TV docs are spay/neuter advocates... to keep the feral populations down. I'm not totally convinced that it's needed for health maintenance when there's nothing wrong with the animal., save for those potential conditions in females. I'm sure others with better knowledge than I will chime in...
 
I have never had one of my male Dobermans neutered. Never had any problems. Then again, they've each lived only to about 8 yrs. so I don't know if any problems would have come up later on.

I can tell you they've had no joint issues. I don't know if that would be true if they had been early-neuterd.
 
You won’t see abandoned dogs running in packs on the streets in the US

They lost credibility right here, even though I agree with their stance.

There most definitely are packs of wild dogs living in many US cities. Particularly, the larger and poorer cities. Detroit was in the news a few years back for just this reason. Now, the estimates in the news were ridiculous (50k stray dogs running loose in Detroit proper.) But none the less, the city does have a real problem with feral dog packs. I know Cincinnati area did at one point as well, a friend's dad was amongst a group sent out to dispatch the feral dogs down there (this was a great many years ago and the dogs had become flat out dangerous).


Neighbors living in fear over stray dogs on Detroit's east side

Wild Dogs of Detroit | National Review
 
They lost credibility right here, even though I agree with their stance.

There most definitely are packs of wild dogs living in many US cities. Particularly, the larger and poorer cities. Detroit was in the news a few years back for just this reason. Now, the estimates in the news were ridiculous (50k stray dogs running loose in Detroit proper.) But none the less, the city does have a real problem with feral dog packs. I know Cincinnati area did at one point as well, a friend's dad was amongst a group sent out to dispatch the feral dogs down there (this was a great many years ago and the dogs had become flat out dangerous).


Neighbors living in fear over stray dogs on Detroit's east side

Wild Dogs of Detroit | National Review
I know that it was not long before we moved to Cincinnasty that there was a Pit Bull ban in place.
 
I know that it was not long before we moved to Cincinnasty that there was a Pit Bull ban in place.

The ferals were just mutts. Non-descript mutts. Same with Detroit. Sure, a lot look like some sort of bully mix, but they're what I call 'Detroit street mutts' or 'Detroit special'' if they're of the exceptionally crazy variety. Rogue park is another bad spot for strays and ferals. Some of these dogs were born on the streets. They're impossible to trap. They're smart and not even a tiny bit pet quality. Breed is totally irrelevant at that point. Just like feral cats, they unfortunately can usually not be rehabbed to the point of being pets.

Despite all of that - i stillI think responsible ownership should be the answer, not sterilization. These animals are not the cause of responsible owners.

But I have an issue with people who write articles and don't even bother to check their facts. Saying there are no packs of wild dogs in the US is a bold faced lie. And i sincerely doubt Detroit and cinci are the only places with this problem. It's not even a secret. We have whole groups of volunteeers that dedicate their time to feeding the ferals.
 
The ferals were just mutts. Non-descript mutts. Same with Detroit. Sure, a lot look like some sort of bully mix, but they're what I call 'Detroit street mutts' or 'Detroit special'' if they're of the exceptionally crazy variety. Rogue park is another bad spot for strays and ferals. Some of these dogs were born on the streets. They're impossible to trap. They're smart and not even a tiny bit pet quality. Breed is totally irrelevant at that point. Just like feral cats, they unfortunately can usually not be rehabbed to the point of being pets.

Despite all of that - i stillI think responsible ownership should be the answer, not sterilization. These animals are not the cause of responsible owners.

But I have an issue with people who write articles and don't even bother to check their facts. Saying there are no packs of wild dogs in the US is a bold faced lie. And i sincerely doubt Detroit and cinci are the only places with this problem. It's not even a secret. We have whole groups of volunteeers that dedicate their time to feeding the ferals.
We have wild dogs in KC, Kansas too. They look more like GSD lab mixes.
My opinion is that there are more irresponsible pet owners than responsible ones and that is why vets push for it. I agree if people aren’t going to be responsible they should get their dog fixed. Hell most people aren’t even responsible enough to train their damn dogs let alone pay enough attention to keep them from an unwanted mixed pregnancy.
 
We no longer have a feral dog problem in the St Louis area. We did a few years back and it got pretty ugly. Who knows if this is true or not, but the problem was explained to the general public and tons of rescues popped up everywhere. The explanation was that gang members in North St. Louis wanted a bad ass dog. Enter the Pit Bull. Gang leaders would get one and put a spike collar on and not bother to train or socialize. In fact do everything the wrong way so the dogs became more than the owner could handle. Their answer was to just dump them on the streets. It wasn't long before there were 100's of dogs running the streets of N. St. Louis. In some areas it was so bad people (mostly kids playing in the street) were being attacked. A few kids were actually killed. Shelters were full of pit bulls that no one wanted so eventually they just caught them and put them down. Somehow they got the problem under control. What is left is you are evil if you own a purebred dog, especially a bully breed, and a hero if you have a rescue.
 
I think it's laughable when people say their favourite breed of dog is a rescue. Gimme a break... that's not breed, it's an action. People still sell pets on craigslist, they just call it a "rehoming" or "adoption" fee. We have pet stores in Colorado and one contributes thousands of dollars to our vet clinic each month with parvo puppies.
I think adopting and rescuing is great, don't get me wrong. Most dogs I had growing up were adoptions and rescues or the product of accidental litters. We looked into several puppy adoptions here before purchasing Nero but the pup we wanted seemed to fall through. I'm happy to have a purebred. I know the genetic issues I am dealing with.
But he's neutered for several reasons all of which were my decision. I understand the risks of neutering but also the risks of him being intact. We weighed our pros and cons. Each owner should do so. However I do not believe that majority of dog owners are responsible. Working in a vet clinic you see too many that are terrified, overweight, on more meds than a grandma, etc... I'm not saying these people dont love their dogs, they certainly do as we are not a cheap clinic. But money does not = responsible owner.

Edit:
On a side note it is not responsible to own a pet when you cant afford a vet visit. We had a mastiff lab cross come in. The old man screamed at me because the vets refused to see his dog without at least the basic exam cost. He only had $34 to his name and wasn't even the owner. The owners refused to cough up the rest. Everyone thinks I'm upset that he yelled at me... no I'm upset that 3 vets refused to see an obviously limping dog for the want of $30 and mad at myself for not offering to pay it. Had he not been screaming at me I would have offered but he was told to leave before I could. Im still upset about it.
 
We have a ton of rescues in Detroit. One even got millions in donations after news stations started talking about the problem.

To date - jack all has been done about the actual problem. Why? Because there's no nice solution. Feral dogs can't just be loved on and turned into family pets. Dealing with just the strays and abuse/neglect cases eats up resources. One of the links I posted is pretty recent. The only *true* solution is to unfortunately kill the ferals. People have tried trapping them. They're too smart. We're talking dogs that date back many generations to living on the streets. It's not a "new" problem. But of course, no one wants to go in and kill them. I get it. But when they're putting humans in danger, something drastic needs to be done. Every single year we hear I don't even know how many local stories about people being killed or seriously injured by loose dogs. Some ferals, some owned.

But education can go a LONG way. A lot of these people truly just don't know any better. They don't know that chaining their dog outside 24/7 is not appropriate. They're doing what they've always seen done. When/if people come in and actually work WITH them, great changes tend to happen.

By all means, if the owners aren't responsible enough to own intact animals, they should spay and neuter. But let's be realistic, the vast majority of "unplanned" litters are anything but. More often than not it is someone who thinks they can make a quick buck and very intentionally got opposite sexes to do just that. It's not an "accident" when you go out and buy both a male and a female, don't get either fixed, never separate them and then have puppies. Which is what we most commonly see around here. It's also not an "accident" when you allow your intact, in heat female to run loose - yes, i actually had a neighbor that did this. She'd open the front door and just let the dog run the neighborhood. But these dogs rarely, if ever, see a vet. So there are degrees of responsible ownership. Some can be educated. Others just shouldn't own so much as a pet rock. It can be hard to decipher the difference.
 

Back
Top