• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Raw diet cost efficient? Need help :-(

My dogs have had dry skin, dull coats, and are constantly scratching or biting. This has been going on for a good while now. I treated my yard for fleas, wash bedding weekly, have used bombs, and bathe the dogs and condition their coats. Its been a bad summer for fleas and I am trying to see if they have a flea allergy or if indeed it's the food causing the skin irritations.

I just switched from Purina Pro Plan to Holistic Select grain/gluten free Salmon. It has no poultry, wheat, soy, or corn in it as well.

I also stopped giving them Cocosoya in their food after reading Soy can mess with the thyroid function. Soybean oil was the top ingredient in that liquid fat supplement.

Curious to see if feeding 10 dogs raw or home cooked would be cost efficient. I want to do what's best for them in regards to nutrition, but stay within my budget. The Holistic Select is a highly rated commercial food and so far they seem to like it. But it costs double my previous budget feeding Pro Plan.


They do offer a breeder program. Buy 8 get 1 free. The store offers a program too, where you buy 10 bags, they give you one free. Thats basically counting the same bag 2x.

This new Holistic Select is $60+ per 24lb bag. I normally went through 8-12 35lb bags of Purina Pro Plan each month. Obviously with the new dog food being smaller bags, I will end up using more bags monthly. Pro Plan with coupons and breeder checks were about $30 a bag.

Could anyone who is already feeding raw or home cooked to multiple dogs help me to calculate feeding 10 dogs ??? to see if it is worth making the switch to a raw diet or homemade.


I am trying to keep everything as natural or organic as possible. I do not use chemical flea treatments directly on the dogs. (frontline or advantix etc) I found a recipe online for a citronella essential oil flea repellent and I get the therapeutic grade citronella from an aromatherapy distributor. It is mixed with baby or mink oil and sprayed on the dogs.

I limit vaccines as well since that is known to cause problems.


Thanks in advance for any suggestions.
 
I spend $250 CAN on 2 dogs monthly. I don't think raw feeding will work for you unless you are ready to spend approx. $1000 a month :scratch:

Maybe you should bathe your dogs and wash their beddings less frequently? Shampoo/conditioner and detergent may cause skin problems
 
I found myself spending 400-1000 every month to do it right.

Not cost efficient here in the US, but well worth it.
 
We don't have fleas, never seen them. Have you tried coconut oil? We use a humidafer in the winter which puts moisture in the air.

Ten dogs? Wow, all Dobermans? You must have a big house and yard
 
I spend $250 CAN on 2 dogs monthly. I don't think raw feeding will work for you unless you are ready to spend approx. $1000 a month :scratch:

Maybe you should bathe your dogs and wash their beddings less frequently? Shampoo/conditioner and detergent may cause skin problems
I dont bathe them too often. I have rinsed them off in the summer months and not used products on them to drown fleas. Wow, $1000 a month is steep. Yikes. Thanks for that info!
 
I found myself spending 400-1000 every month to do it right.

Not cost efficient here in the US, but well worth it.
Wow, holy crap! Yeah, that is really steep for me. What exactly do you use each month? Can you give me an idea? Maybe if I could do 1/2 the holistic select and do the other in raw?
 
We don't have fleas, never seen them. Have you tried coconut oil? We use a humidafer in the winter which puts moisture in the air.

Ten dogs? Wow, all Dobermans? You must have a big house and yard
I used to have a 2400 sq ft home on 3 acres before I split from my husband. I have a 1200 sq foot rancher now on 15 acres. Mostly wooded. We never had any problems with fleas until we moved here. I live in a valley with a creek that runs through the property and the land lays wet all the time after hard rains. We actually just had about 1 acre of trees taken down so we get more sunlight to dry things up faster and hopefully lessen the bugs.

I have my dogs on the lower level in a large room in my walk-in basement. I dont have a kennel building. I do have 4 chain linked fence areas and 2 custom made kennels to keep dogs separate during the day. I have supplies and materials to make 2 more fenced areas, but I havent had the energy to fool with it lately.

I rotate the dogs on the main level everyday so they have time to be with mommy. I dont work outside the home, so I am with them all day. A couple will sleep on the couch at night, usually have 1 sleeping with my daughter, and have 1 in bed with me at night. Rest are downstairs in their room sleeping in their Perla beds or crates. I have a system going to rotate them. It's harder when it rains, because they hate going out to pee.

We were using Cocosoya from TSC from the equine dept. It is 98% fatty acid, but after doing some reading about low thyroid, I learned soy causes the thyroid to function properly. The cocosoya had more soybean oil than cocount oil in it, so we stopped using it. I do have a humidifier and I use it in the winter months, because of our wood stove and I always have a pot of water on the woodstove.

My guys and girls are fed 2x a day. I usually give them a small rawhide chip at bedtime and was giving them each a large milkbone. I have stopped the milkbones in the event of grain allergies. We are basically starting over fresh so that I can slowly introduce back and hopefully identify the allergen.

Yes, all my dogs are dobes except 1. She is a 10 yr old miniature pinscher/ pomeranian mix. Looks like a fox with a curly tail. LOL. She's the boss lady of the bunch.

I found a website that sells coconut oil in bulk. I need to go back and check out their prices w/ shipping. The dry skin etc, has to be either environmental issues like pollen or their food. 7 out of my 9 dobes have itchy skin, flakes, and minor hair loss. Or could be flea allergies.

My vet said that the fleas were terrible this year. I have treated my yard, bombed the house, I wash their bedding w/ laundry soap w/ no perfumes or dyes, and I either rinse the dogs with water every 2 weeks or actually bathe them in a citrus shampoo that I got from Cherrybrook. I condition them afterwards with an AvoDerm conditioner or baby oil.

Been very frustrating, because I feel bad watching them scratch and carry on.
 
For fleas I now use
  1. Diatomaceous Earth Food Grade Benefits:Gallon Jars to 50 pound ...
    www.earthworkshealth.com/How-Diatomaceous-Earth-Works.php‎e
    Benefits of Diatomaceous Earth-Food Grade: Diatomaceous earth is a powdery mineral that is comprised mostly of silica, containing a variety of other trace ...
It is all natural and I just sprinkle in the bedding and on the dogs. On the months they are off heartwormer I use the diatomaceous earth in their food for control.

I know several who have had to stop feeding raw - Paint is one of them. Raw food carries bacteria and not all Dobermans tolerate it well. He had a terrible smell, his teeth had to be cleaned due to bad breath and he had to go on antibiotics which is why vets and the AVMA are out against raw feeding. So while it did not seem to bother Helio Drake came home in worse condition. When she switched him back to kibble and got his teeth cleaned and antibiotics he went back to normal.

I know many believe raw is the holy grail but our dogs are domesticated and not wild so do not have the same digestive system of a wolf. JMHO I do kibble. Occasionally they get a raw chicken thigh and leg - but then I realized NO WONDER they love my chickens!!!
 
For fleas I now use
  1. Diatomaceous Earth Food Grade Benefits:Gallon Jars to 50 pound ...
    www.earthworkshealth.com/How-Diatomaceous-Earth-Works.php‎e
    Benefits of Diatomaceous Earth-Food Grade: Diatomaceous earth is a powdery mineral that is comprised mostly of silica, containing a variety of other trace ...
It is all natural and I just sprinkle in the bedding and on the dogs. On the months they are off heartwormer I use the diatomaceous earth in their food for control.

I know several who have had to stop feeding raw - Paint is one of them. Raw food carries bacteria and not all Dobermans tolerate it well. He had a terrible smell, his teeth had to be cleaned due to bad breath and he had to go on antibiotics which is why vets and the AVMA are out against raw feeding. So while it did not seem to bother Helio Drake came home in worse condition. When she switched him back to kibble and got his teeth cleaned and antibiotics he went back to normal.

I know many believe raw is the holy grail but our dogs are domesticated and not wild so do not have the same digestive system of a wolf. JMHO I do kibble. Occasionally they get a raw chicken thigh and leg - but then I realized NO WONDER they love my chickens!!!

Understood. I figured I would check out all my options. I know it is going to take time to see results, if indeed it is ingredients in the dog food causing the problem. They seem to like this new Holistic Select dog food, which around here is part of the battle.
 
For fleas I now use
  1. Diatomaceous Earth Food Grade Benefits:Gallon Jars to 50 pound ...
    www.earthworkshealth.com/How-Diatomaceous-Earth-Works.php‎e
    Benefits of Diatomaceous Earth-Food Grade: Diatomaceous earth is a powdery mineral that is comprised mostly of silica, containing a variety of other trace ...
It is all natural and I just sprinkle in the bedding and on the dogs. On the months they are off heartwormer I use the diatomaceous earth in their food for control.

I know several who have had to stop feeding raw - Paint is one of them. Raw food carries bacteria and not all Dobermans tolerate it well. He had a terrible smell, his teeth had to be cleaned due to bad breath and he had to go on antibiotics which is why vets and the AVMA are out against raw feeding. So while it did not seem to bother Helio Drake came home in worse condition. When she switched him back to kibble and got his teeth cleaned and antibiotics he went back to normal.

I know many believe raw is the holy grail but our dogs are domesticated and not wild so do not have the same digestive system of a wolf. JMHO I do kibble. Occasionally they get a raw chicken thigh and leg - but then I realized NO WONDER they love my chickens!!!

LOL Susan! My dogs are domesticated and not wild and they are doing extremely well on raw. I have been feeding dogs raw for 4 (Gino) and 2.5 (Asha) years.
They have no bad breath or digestive problems. Actually I have never owned dogs with such a perfect digestion.
 
Different foods work for different dogs. We do raw for our healthy adults but our diet is a lot of wild game and heavy on wild Salmon so it wouldn't compare to something you would do. We also do quality kibble for our very young/old, fosters or sick dogs. Good care and food for one dog is not cheap and 10 will only be 10 times the cost. GIGO definitely applies to anything we or our dogs ingest.

Give the new food (and anything else you try) time to work before adding anything else so you can evaluate effectiveness. Definitely a good thing to stop the junky milkbone type treats.

I would also verify where your rawhide treats come from. I don't find it safe to use any kind of treat not made in the USA or at least not made by a well known company. Too many problems and many don't result in recalls unless it's a big company. Even with well known problems it's very hard for US authorities to trace the problem source if the product is from small sourced generic manufacturers in different countries.

There are also some great shampoo and conditioner recipes that might work well for your dogs that would probably save some $$$ on the shampoos. You can always add a drop or 2 of essential oils it keep it citrus. We wash when needed. Every 2 weeks like clockwork might be stripping a bit too much of the natural oils. We probably do it about that often in the summer with lots of swimming but definitely less in the winter. I also find it helpful to thin the shampoo so it's still effective but much easier to ensure I wash it out 100%.

I know some people like coconut oil but there is only anecdotal evidence to support the good claims and zero research has been done to show if there are any long term side effects. We add modest salmon oil if the diet isn't that heavy in salmon as our dog's diet is a bit seasonal. I know all about the middle chain fatty acids but it also adds significantly to the fat calories your dog takes in. If they are eating a quality balanced diet already, they shouldn't need a lot of additional fat.

I say it a lot but it really is important to make certain whatever supplements you use are well tested by an independent lab. Many really do not contain all that they claim and some have harmful fillers instead of the all pure stuff-regardless of what the label says. It has stopped me from being penny wise and pound foolish more than once.

There is also the very real possibility that some of the issues stem from genetics and not entirely environmental factors. Definitely something to clarify before having any more litters if you're breeding.

Good luck! It must be a very frustrating situation.
 

Back
Top