Raising a dog neutral puppy

Kbailey34

Notable member
My little guy Rajah is about 4.5 months old now. He's getting along very well with my female senior dog, Mirage. She corrects him now and again but they play well and he's been picking up on the boundaries she has set. He hasn't really met other dogs beyond her (only just finished his shots), but my brother was in town with his GSD (female, ~1yr old, spayed). We met at my parents house, a home we frequent every 2 weeks or so. When he saw her, he started barking nonstop! We decided to take them on a walk and he pretty much calmed down. We saw them the next day and he just ran after her barking at her tail. If she got agitated and moved toward him he would back up in a hurry but continue barking, until i grabbed his collar and made him sit by my side. He calmed down after a bit, but as I want to raise a more neutral dog, I was upset by their interaction.

Overall he seemed nervous and reactive, whereas I would obviously prefer confident and calm. My goal is for him to not take too much interest in other dogs, beyond dogs he actually knows like Mirage and eventually my brothers GSD. Any advice? I want to start taking him to more public and dog friendly places soon.
 
Seems your pup needs more exposure to being around other dogs.

I'm not sure which way you should go with this:

1) Let him play with a lot of other dogs, but at the same time, maybe have a high value treat you can break out and call him to you and give the treat (when there are no other dogs right there to compete for it, so there won't be a fight!!)

2) Don't let him interact with dogs other than those in your immediate circle. Always have him ignore them when you are on walks and never let him bark or growl at them.

I did something more like option 1 with my Oji here. I took him to dog parks (yes, beware this option) and let him interact and socialize with lots of dogs. Note that he already had a foundation of obedience and I mixed in some commands in the middle of the dog park sessions and I expected him to obey them strictly.

See, Oji was naturally a very very dog-reactive Dobe. He would look and sound vicious if he even saw one at a distance. I opted for the dog immersion concept.

I tell ya' though: He is obsessed with all other animals, and this in a very real way diminishes his capability of being an effective guard dog for our home and family. If he was protecting me on the street and a squirrel ran by he would probably abandon me. He barks like a maniac out the windows of the house if he sees any other animal – most explosively when he sees a dog. Thus, we cannot give him the roam of the house as we sleep. He must be contained in our bedroom and thus the rest of the house is unguarded.

So yeah. I'd LOVE to try with my next dog to get him to as much as possible IGNORE all other animals!

My only concern with this is: What happens if, having never interacted with other dogs, the inevitable happens one day and a dog runs up to him or he gets loose and encounters a dog? Will he be so unfamiliar and scared that he would cower and possibly get attacked?
 
Seems your pup needs more exposure to being around other dogs.

I'm not sure which way you should go with this:

1) Let him play with a lot of other dogs, but at the same time, maybe have a high value treat you can break out and call him to you and give the treat (when there are no other dogs right there to compete for it, so there won't be a fight!!)

2) Don't let him interact with dogs other than those in your immediate circle. Always have him ignore them when you are on walks and never let him bark or growl at them.

I did something more like option 1 with my Oji here. I took him to dog parks (yes, beware this option) and let him interact and socialize with lots of dogs. Note that he already had a foundation of obedience and I mixed in some commands in the middle of the dog park sessions and I expected him to obey them strictly.

See, Oji was naturally a very very dog-reactive Dobe. He would look and sound vicious if he even saw one at a distance. I opted for the dog immersion concept.

I tell ya' though: He is obsessed with all other animals, and this in a very real way diminishes his capability of being an effective guard dog for our home and family. If he was protecting me on the street and a squirrel ran by he would probably abandon me. He barks like a maniac out the windows of the house if he sees any other animal – most explosively when he sees a dog. Thus, we cannot give him the roam of the house as we sleep. He must be contained in our bedroom and thus the rest of the house is unguarded.

So yeah. I'd LOVE to try with my next dog to get him to as much as possible IGNORE all other animals!

My only concern with this is: What happens if, having never interacted with other dogs, the inevitable happens one day and a dog runs up to him or he gets loose and encounters a dog? Will he be so unfamiliar and scared that he would cower and possibly get attacked?


I think I like option 2 better. I just have to get him out more. I don't like walking him around my neighborhood because we've seen too many dogs out in their yards with no supervision and no leashes! So he hasnt really even seen too many dogs since we moved ...

Yeah its a delicate balance. I dont think he should have no interaction, but limited for sure. Maybe he just needs to build his confidence?

Lol Oji sounds like a riot. Rajah likes to bark at anything that walks by the house too, thankfully he hasnt learned to look out of windows so he only notices things if the front door is open, as we also have a storm door, he likes to look outside through
..
 
My 5 month old girl loves dogs she doesn’t bark at them but loves to play. When we are on a walk I don’t let her interact with other dogs when I see a dog coming I get her attention (I do a short leash so she is always right by my side) I call her name and give her treats (just her regular food we use that for training) and when she tries to look away back at the dog I tell her to leave it and keep walking getting her attention back on me. She also goes to doggy daycare 2/3 times a month she does pack walks and plays with all kinds of dogs I think it’s a great way to get them socialized and learn appropriate behaviors with other dogs, because she is so used to other dogs she doesn’t go crazy when she sees new ones (my opinion).
 
I think with dominant breeds like this it can be hard to raise a dog that is completely non reactive. Definitely takes time.

My boy is fine with dogs if he is off leash. There was actually one time a loose dog ran towards us and chased Jasper to play and Jasper just kept looking at me and was trying to avoid the other dog. He could have cared less. I can call him to my side easily.

However, while on leash he can be reactive. Walk by other leashed dogs and he is fine. Pulls a little but nothing serious. I never voluntarily let him meet other dogs while on leash. But if a loose dog approaches us while he is leashed, he gets a bit dominant and tries to get on top of them. His hair goes up and there is just too much energy. I almost rather unhook his leash but at this point he is already worked up and I am afraid the high energy levels could lead to a fight. And of course our dobermans would be the ones to blame.


I believe teaching your dog to focus on you is the first step regardless of the type of reactivity. I will admit though, sometimes I wonder if it is just generally easier with other breeds such as goldens and labs. Maybe they are more social and less suspicious of other dogs. Idk.
 
If I were doing it all over again with a new puppy, I'd have no dog interactions unless it was the dogs of friends and family. Strangers and their strange dogs present too many unknowns. I'd also not introduce him to people - a dog that ignores others will be more focused on you which is ultimately what you want and need from a strong breed like this.
 
If I were doing it all over again with a new puppy, I'd have no dog interactions unless it was the dogs of friends and family. Strangers and their strange dogs present too many unknowns. I'd also not introduce him to people - a dog that ignores others will be more focused on you which is ultimately what you want and need from a strong breed like this.
That's what i was going for originally, but after his reaction to meeting a family dog he hadn't met yet, I'm no longer sure it's the best option. Idk if I should stick to my guns or change it up ... he's also met plenty of people but they've all been family or friends. He's gotten rubs at football games and stuff like that, but after sitting still for a pet I always praise and give him treats so his focus doesn't leave me for long. He doesn't usually try to come up to strangers, but is friendly when approached.
 
My 5 month old girl loves dogs she doesn’t bark at them but loves to play. When we are on a walk I don’t let her interact with other dogs when I see a dog coming I get her attention (I do a short leash so she is always right by my side) I call her name and give her treats (just her regular food we use that for training) and when she tries to look away back at the dog I tell her to leave it and keep walking getting her attention back on me. She also goes to doggy daycare 2/3 times a month she does pack walks and plays with all kinds of dogs I think it’s a great way to get them socialized and learn appropriate behaviors with other dogs, because she is so used to other dogs she doesn’t go crazy when she sees new ones (my opinion).
I think with dominant breeds like this it can be hard to raise a dog that is completely non reactive. Definitely takes time.

My boy is fine with dogs if he is off leash. There was actually one time a loose dog ran towards us and chased Jasper to play and Jasper just kept looking at me and was trying to avoid the other dog. He could have cared less. I can call him to my side easily.

However, while on leash he can be reactive. Walk by other leashed dogs and he is fine. Pulls a little but nothing serious. I never voluntarily let him meet other dogs while on leash. But if a loose dog approaches us while he is leashed, he gets a bit dominant and tries to get on top of them. His hair goes up and there is just too much energy. I almost rather unhook his leash but at this point he is already worked up and I am afraid the high energy levels could lead to a fight. And of course our dobermans would be the ones to blame.


I believe teaching your dog to focus on you is the first step regardless of the type of reactivity. I will admit though, sometimes I wonder if it is just generally easier with other breeds such as goldens and labs. Maybe they are more social and less suspicious of other dogs. Idk.

I think you're right. You can't go wrong with treats and lots of praise when he's presenting the correct behavior.

I just want him to learn to keep a cool head in any situation. Because you're right, we and our dogs will be blamed first. I got lucky with Mirage who is an American Bully, shes never been reactive and is so quick back off from a behavior if I ask. Don't know how she got to be that way though lol, otherwise I'd just repeat
 
My 5 month old girl loves dogs she doesn’t bark at them but loves to play. When we are on a walk I don’t let her interact with other dogs when I see a dog coming I get her attention (I do a short leash so she is always right by my side) I call her name and give her treats (just her regular food we use that for training) and when she tries to look away back at the dog I tell her to leave it and keep walking getting her attention back on me. She also goes to doggy daycare 2/3 times a month she does pack walks and plays with all kinds of dogs I think it’s a great way to get them socialized and learn appropriate behaviors with other dogs, because she is so used to other dogs she doesn’t go crazy when she sees new ones (my opinion).

I would do some controlled socialization. Our trainer offered special classes just for young dogs so the trainer could step in if necessary.

Thanks, I'll look to see if I can find anything similar in my area, but I would just worry that he would start to find other dogs too interesting. I only want him to have interest in people and dogs that I have a relationship with. I love the idea of structured class and this would be my choice if I cant get it under control on my own.
 
If I were doing it all over again with a new puppy, I'd have no dog interactions unless it was the dogs of friends and family. Strangers and their strange dogs present too many unknowns. I'd also not introduce him to people - a dog that ignores others will be more focused on you which is ultimately what you want and need from a strong breed like this.
Just be prepared for people to get offended that you don't let them pet your dog and (my favorite) tell them your dog's name. You could put a vest on him that says "in training" or you wear a t-shirt that says the same.
 
a dog that ignores others will be more focused on you which is ultimately what you want and need from a strong breed like this.
THIS. It's the bottom line for a good neutral dog. I'm learning as I go, and I did figure out that my Asha is way more reactive when we are being still than when moving. @Kbailey34 like your meeting with the GSD, at the house it was not so good, then you went walking and it got better. Same when I go to a public park (NOT dog park) If we sit around, those approaching, dog or no dog, she wants to growl or bark. If we are training & moving, screaming kids, dogs & people don't get her attention because she's listening to me. This focus on me didn't happen overnight believe me, we still have our moments of disconnect. I would take walks with the GSD with no play since that dog is extended family, but all other dogs and strangers I would ignore and distract Rajah to you with a toy or command like sit (as he learns commands) & reward for attention on you.
 
Obedience training. People think socialization means "my dog needs to party with other dogs". Not true. Socialization means being able to walk your dog, or go out maybe to the vet, a park, walk through a crowd and not have your dog react negatively. A strong foundation, through training, will be the most effective way to have a dog that is non-reactive. Once your dog has that foundation and no longer reacts, they may or may not want to actually inter act with another dog. Some dogs want to play with every dog they see, others just want to be friendly not playful, and others want just to ignore other dogs in favor of being with their owners! Solid training really allows you to decide how far you want to go in relation to letting your dog inter act with other dogs and people. :)
 
THIS. It's the bottom line for a good neutral dog. I'm learning as I go, and I did figure out that my Asha is way more reactive when we are being still than when moving. @Kbailey34 like your meeting with the GSD, at the house it was not so good, then you went walking and it got better. Same when I go to a public park (NOT dog park) If we sit around, those approaching, dog or no dog, she wants to growl or bark. If we are training & moving, screaming kids, dogs & people don't get her attention because she's listening to me. This focus on me didn't happen overnight believe me, we still have our moments of disconnect. I would take walks with the GSD with no play since that dog is extended family, but all other dogs and strangers I would ignore and distract Rajah to you with a toy or command like sit (as he learns commands) & reward for attention on you.
How old is Asha and do you let passing dogs sniff and introduce themselves. Do you allow people to pet her?
 
How old is Asha and do you let passing dogs sniff and introduce themselves. Do you allow people to pet her?
She just turned 1 year old. I would never ever let a passing dog sniff my dog. Ever. All my puppy/dog classes did not allow dogs to physically contact each other. No sniffing, no playing. Classes are for owners to train their dogs, not teaching dogs to play with dogs. I took her to Star Puppy and Canine Good Citizen and now we are doing AKC Obedience. When she was about 4 - 6 months old I'd take her to the local feed store and she would growl or bark at anyone who stared at her. Same with dogs. If they went about their business she was fine. I let some people pet her because I wasn't sure how to deal with it, and it definitely helped, but now that she's older I just tell her no if she starts growling. If someone wants to pet her now I just say "no, we're training right now". I didn't get to expose her public life nearly like I'd planned - so many places closed because of COVID19 and some events were canceled that I was going to take her so she could have a some travel/motel/patio dining-out experiences. But it all comes together as they grow up, just keep doing your part of being the best thing in your puppy's life.
 

Back
Top