• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Neuter My Jett ?

Jett

Member
:help:I swore I would not consider this, even though Im not breeding him and I signed a limited registration because I have this thing that a Male masculine dog should not be without his buddies, I guess it's aesthetics!!!

Well, Im concerned with his power, he is so strong, and he is still a pup, he won't be a year old until November, but I worry about him being mean etc. and I know they are supposedly calmer afterward, following the neutering, so with that said...

Can a male Doberman be in tact, and trained to be obedient without being bred?
 
Well, of course they can! There are thousands of well trained, intact male dogs out there in the world. But neutering does not automaticly give you a non aggressive dog! It shure helps without the frustration of the hormones, but even the guys with the "empty bags" can be the most vicious in the neighbourhood if he is not trained right around other dogs from the start.
Training and a clear leadership is the ultimate key to succeed, with any dog. You can't lack out of training just because he is neutered.

I would say it is always the best thing to do is to spay and neuter dogs that are not in a planned breeding program. Just imagine the some 2 million strays and homeless dogs that are euthanized in America each year because of the over population as a result of unplanned breeding.
 
Well, of course they can! There are thousands of well trained, intact male dogs out there in the world. But neutering does not automaticly give you a non aggressive dog! It shure helps without the frustration of the hormones, but even the guys with the "empty bags" can be the most vicious in the neighbourhood if he is not trained right around other dogs from the start.
Training and a clear leadership is the ultimate key to succeed, with any dog. You can't lack out of training just because he is neutered.

I would say it is always the best thing to do is to spay and neuter dogs that are not in a planned breeding program. Just imagine the some 2 million strays and homeless dogs that are euthanized in America each year because of the over population as a result of unplanned breeding.
Well, thank you ..he does need more training, he isn't aggressive or mean, but he is already getting to that point where he is trying to mount my friends female spayed lab, he had an over night stay because Im going to Boston in Aug. and will be gone for 4 days so they are practicing getting used to one another . He will be a yr. old in November, and my friends had mentioned that they had a dog growing up that her father refused to fix and he was mean and pent up. I don't want that for Jett, and everyone keeps telling me that it will help but Im not really sure yet how I feel about it, but also don't want him frustrated because breeding him is not what I had intended.
 
I had Hunter neutered because I was not going to breed him and it
sure did not stop him from being a MAN he was very strong too.
It really helped though and didn't do the riding thing so I guess
it is all up to the owners choice. I think it made him even more
VELCRO and LOVING.:love:
 
:help:I swore I would not consider this, even though Im not breeding him and I signed a limited registration because I have this thing that a Male masculine dog should not be without his buddies, I guess it's aesthetics!!!

:lmao: That's funny! Especially coming from a woman! :blush: But seriously, this is a pretty personal choice that some people take to heart! I totally agree with Linda above. IMHO I believe that if you are not breeding or showing, but just a Pet Person, all animals should be spayed/neutered. I don't think the average person with a pet can possibly watch their dogs 24/7 to avoid an accidental breeding. And why would they want to? A fixed animal makes a great pet and relieves the mind (on both human and pet) so you concentrate on more important things. :)

Sometimes it's not just IF to spay/neuter, but WHEN. I think they are both important and again, everyone has their own thoughts on it.

Being intact OR neutered isn't what makes a dog "mean" , but neutering will sometimes help end frustration in a male dog that may be perceived as 'mean'. Your pup is young and you have a lot of socializing and training to do yet. You still have lots of time to form his personality. Be a Pack Leader. :D
 
my friends had mentioned that they had a dog growing up that her father refused to fix and he was mean and pent up. I don't want that for Jett, and everyone keeps telling me that it will help but Im not really sure yet how I feel about it, but also don't want him frustrated because breeding him is not what I had intended.
Cesar Millan has always addressed this and I firmly believe it too. Leaving a male intact is almost mean in itself unless you are allowing him to breed. It's a normal natural thing to want to breed if an animal is intact.
 
The behaviors your describing are simply dominance displays. He is an adolescent, like a teen boy. He is not aggressive or humping for sexual pleasure.
As for neutering, honestly it does nothing to change these behaviors. That is a myth and will not change for you, what you need to address with training.
 
I'd suggest neutering him since he is not to be bred. You will have many more opportunities to have fun with your boy if he is neutered. Being off-leash is not a good idea with an intact male, so if you don't have access to large fenced areas it will be hard to run and play with Jett.
 
Ya, I know it's so silly and stupid. LOL!!!! but I am honest, and that is the reason. I wanted him to keep his masculine look, !!! If he were a Beagle or something like that I would have neutered him by now. LOL...Boxers, Dane's Dobermans, to me they are that proud Strong looking breed, so...Sigh~!!!!:rolleyes: Appearance isn't most important with regards to this topic and all of you have very good valid comments, they are all true, I know that Titan my male boxer still did all the things that an intact male does, and he was nuetered it was just not as bad.

Jett will want to get out especially if he smells a female in heat and I certainly don't want to face losing him to being hit by a car, etc. So decision is made, I just wanted run it past the board, but I had really made my mind up before I posted...just had to ask that one question about aggression if it had much to do with it. Thank you everyone, calling the Vet next wk.

Maria :)
 
Ya, I know it's so silly and stupid. LOL!!!! but I am honest, and that is the reason. I wanted him to keep his masculine look, !!! If he were a Beagle or something like that I would have neutered him by now. LOL...Boxers, Dane's Dobermans, to me they are that proud Strong looking breed, so...Sigh~!!!!:rolleyes: Appearance isn't most important with regards to this topic and all of you have very good valid comments, they are all true, I know that Titan my male boxer still did all the things that an intact male does, and he was nuetered it was just not as bad.

Jett will want to get out especially if he smells a female in heat and I certainly don't want to face losing him to being hit by a car, etc. So decision is made, I just wanted run it past the board, but I had really made my mind up before I posted...just had to ask that one question about aggression if it had much to do with it. Thank you everyone, calling the Vet next wk.

Maria :)

:congrats: Jet will be joining the majority of pet doberboys here. My guy made it to 16 months when he started some anti-social behaviour toward other dogs. It was either the snip or less socialization for Hans.
 
:congrats: Jet will be joining the majority of pet doberboys here. My guy made it to 16 months when he started some anti-social behaviour toward other dogs. It was either the snip or less socialization for Hans.
Ya, and how fun can that be not to play with other Dogs? He loves to play! Plus I want to get another sometime down the road, so can't have two males with Testies. Whew, that would not be a good combo:eek:
 
I don't think you'll regret your decision and I can personally say that I did regret not neutering our GSP since he was so easily distracted. Even though we live way out in the country, if a dog way down the road came in heat he was just crazy.

If you really do like the intact appearance, there is the Neuticles option, even though they're not cheap. http://www.neuticles.com/sizing.php ;)

One of the things I was worried about was them not lifting their leg after being neutered, but I found out after the fact that a very high percentage of neutered males still lift them just like an intact male. Boris started lifting his leg 2 months "after" being neutered.
 
Ya I considered that once with Titan to get the fakey's. LoL..but not gonna be that vain. I think it will be good for him too, my biggest thing is him running off, id be devastated . He doesn't lift his leg yet, he 8 months. old. When does that usually start??? The leg lifting??
 
So is it inappropriate to discuss Breeders here? I am going to get another down the road, and Im not getting another from where I got Jett! I love him to death, think he is beautiful, but Im still not quite sure about them.
 
When does that usually start??? The leg lifting??
I think Boris was 9 or 10 months when he started, but it varies from dog to dog.

So is it inappropriate to discuss Breeders here? I am going to get another down the road, and Im not getting another from where I got Jett! I love him to death, think he is beautiful, but Im still not quite sure about them.
Go ahead and post up a question in the breeder section and you should get plenty of ideas there. Congrats on starting to think about another one! :)
 
The leg lifting thing definitely seems to vary from male to male and even some females! Hans started fairly early with the leg lifting at around 5 or 6 months, but that doesn't make him manly at all. He's the biggest girly man you'd ever want to meet.
 
Ok, but can names be mentioned in there? Like the lines? or What Breeder he comes from?
Sure, go ahead and post it up. We can't allow direct bashing, but people can give the pros and cons.
 
The leg lifting thing definitely seems to vary from male to male and even some females! Hans started fairly early with the leg lifting at around 5 or 6 months, but that doesn't make him manly at all. He's the biggest girly man you'd ever want to meet.
Ha ha ha...girly man?? Too funny, Jett is a big giant baby face!!!! He is so "stuck on you" when Im in bed, he comes to my side and wants so bad to lay with mommy, but I have not allowed him to sleep in my bed for a few months now...when he was smaller yes, but I like my space and allow him for a special treat. He lays his head on my chest and just stares at me, like CMON MOM PLEASE??? LET ME UP!!!
 

Back
Top