• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Need relaxation/settling advice

Gman88

Hot Topics Subscriber
Hello all! I need some advice on how to get my guy to relax or settle. He's so glued to me and the prospect of going outside that he can never relax. He literally follows me around and paces..... for hours.... when he does actually lay down if I move he gets back up wagging his tail and gets back to within finger distance.

While sounding like hes a normal velcro dog, I feel it's often too excessive. On occasion I have seen him work himself up to nervousness (shivering) on a few occasions when my family and I are watching TV and he doesnt get attention from me. He doesnt seek this attention from my wife or child.

He exudes the highest level of this during feedings. Hes not out of control in the sense of aggressiveness, nippy, or not taking commands.
I make him work for his food, but hes so excited he executes the commands looking like a dog on crack.....

I dont want this to manifest into something worse.

So far I've tried the following -

1. Adding a more strict routine (same time of the day on the dot for meals, outside, training etc etc.).

2. Reward training for laying on his bed, relaxing (calmly laying comfortably).

3. Giving him a toy/chew treat for relaxing..

On a normal day he gets two training sessions for 40 min, and either a 2 mile rollerblade or 3 mile walk.

I feel like hes using my attention to settle himself but I dont know how to fix it.


Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
 
How old is he again?

Luckily the worst we endured when our Dobe was a puppy was she would get on the couch and be CRAAAZY trying to play. I'd kick her off and ignore her for a minute or two (a lifetime for a dog) and then invite her back up. If she was calm, she was allowed to stay, if she wasn't, she got kicked back off. Her reward for being calm was getting attention from and snuggling with us. Same goes when they're on the bed (before bedtime or in the morning after potty time).
 
How old is he? Have you tried some mind stimulating activities? Sounds like you already give him a good amount of physical exercise. Some relaxing music, perhaps. I would kind of go about it like I do with my kids with trying to get them to occupy themselves so I can have a moments peace. Good luck!
 
Sounds like he has anxiety of some sorts. Everything you have tried is good. The routine, exercise, rewarding when he is calm, providing chews- all seems right. What kind of mental games does he get?
 
@Doberman Gang yes he is kennel trained. His kennel is in my home office and he goes in there for about an hour a day when I'm doing work (voluntarily with the door open). He usually spends another hour in there after his evening feed as my tiny rescue dog is a slow eater and Bruno is so food motivated.

Should I incorporate a longer kennel period to his daily routine? If you think yes when would be the best time and how long?
 
@Dnetmd @Lizbeli @LifeofRubie he's 2 years and 6 months old. As far as mental games, during his training we do "body language" exercises and his reward is fetching the ball. I either stare at him or give him a hand gesture wanting a certain behavior out of him. When he gets it he gets a ball launched (his favorite).
 
@Lizbeli he definitely has anxiety in my opinion, it's just that the anxiety is so random. It has gotten a lot better from the time I rescued him but this behavior has been really hard for me to get a handle on.

For example, when he has just been outside for 20 min and comes back inside, then sees a squirrel in the backyard. He'll bark asking to go outside. I'll tell him no and he'll go right to dropping on the floor and wrapping his whole mouth around his flank. I feel this behavior is a normal reaction to an excitement inducer like a squirrel because he is so prey driven.

An example that bewilders me is when I'm petting him while watching tv and stop. He'll stare at me with ears lowered and tail wagging. Then he'll whine and i'll firmly say "no". He then paces around the coffee table for up to an hour (i've timed this before) then will come back to me and whine again. I'll give him another no and tell him to go lay down... he then goes to his bed, lays there and stares at me and if I even move my arm more than two inches, he jumps up and runs up to me wagging his tail wanting to be pet again. If I still don't pet him he'll wag his tail until his whole body is shaking.... I'll finally pet him and then he sits, almost closes his eyes and seems fully relaxed... It's the weirdest thing... I just feel that he needs to learn how to "shut off" on his own somehow but I've never dealt with this before.....
 
He seems pretty intense. I have never dealt with high anxiety dogs before in person. Higher energy yes- but its different. And you are giving him a decent amount of exercise imo anyways.

Im not sure what to recommend. I know people have been trying CBD oil for anxiety but I personally wouldn’t do this unless I felt I have tried everything else. I would ask myself if there seems to be any triggers to his anxiety and work from there.
 
Crack dog, oh yes. We had issues with this largely when he was under 1 year old and I think it was partly how we handled him. First time Dobering is no joke!

Teaching them to settle is a tough one. Short of crating Kaiser, he wouldn’t really rest. He would snooze. Definitely start with that.

Sounds like you also have a bed, that will help. Anytime he is laying down and relaxed, say something to mark it. Problem here is that he will probably get up in response haha but keep at it. Try giving him something to settle WITH initially so you can keep his interest in staying put and reshaping the current behaviour - use a blanket, bully stick, or Kong because you need something that occupies his time.

While he is settling for a few minutes, approach him and praise, give light touch snuggles as an additional reward for continuing to stay put. They love a soft light voice so if you tend to be louder or deeper voiced, be conscious of that.

If he whines for more, don’t reward it. Something similar was happening with my hb. He would go casual about being nudged at the elbow while at the dinner table. He would tell him he didn’t want it and push him away with his hands. Using hands is praise. Talking to the dog is attention. Speaking a whole sentence to the dog instead of a command he knows was also wrong. He would look at the dog thereby validating him. Sometimes he would give in and play with the dog, this is all inconsistency and it was reinforcing the bad behaviour. Yet he never continued nudging me the same way because I never gave in, I held my elbow tight to my body and ignored him. It’s often easier to see what you’re doing to encourage the behaviour so get your wife to video it so you can see yourself interacting with him.

It may well be anxiety, I don’t know, but the whining in particular sounds like boredom to me. When Kaiser isn’t mentally worn out, he will get up in a split second if anyone even moves, he’ll whine to go outside even if he was just out there. The body language training sounds like a good idea but I bet it’s not enough. They get used to repetitive things, so you need to change it up.
 
He then paces around the coffee table for up to an hour (i've timed this before) then will come back to me and whine again.
It sounds like you are doing so much right, but this sentence here is suggestive of what Kaiser just said: consistency. You said NO, but didn't ask/tell him what you DID want, and if he paced one time around the coffee table that would have been my que to say no again and add go lay down. And then enforce it. To let him pace for an hour is taxing on both of you. He's unhappy and you're unhappy. Go lay down could mean be at your feet leaning on you while you watch tv or if he preferred he could go to his kennel - a general command, but his choice of where, but go.lay.down.now.somewhere. Same at the dinner table. It shouldn't be up to you & yours to have to use elbows and avert eyes while eating. Sometimes I think a "needy" dog (not an insult, just the only term I could think of) really just wants a strong leader! They want to know rules so they know what is ok and what isn't. If you let him pace for an hour and don't make him stop, perhaps he thinks it's pleasing you so on and on it goes. It actually makes them feel more secure understanding what pleases you, if that makes sense. Rules bring much peace to pack animals as they are craving order. And you probably already know, the kennel is his safe place, not to be used as punishment. Keep us posted on your progress and let us know what works!
 
I like what Ravenbird wrote above. I don't know, given the amount of exercise you give him, why he would be the way he is. An anxiety problem does come to mind.

Dobermans, I've found and have read, tend to be overall relaxed in the house. They are ready at a second's notice to go outside for activity and will often pester you for such; but one quality I love about Dobermans is their chill-out inside the house.

I'd say keep up the good work of being consistent in your handling of him and providing him exercise and stimulation. I think a safe, calm place for him to settle and be relaxed would be very helpful. This may be a crate. It may be a dog bed. You would have to insist on his compliance with the command to go to his "place" and remain there. Start with short durations and build up. Don't forget to release him from the command to assume his place. This will be a job for him, which may be just the ticket. It will also provide him relaxation and the sense of security and satisfaction that comes from structure, pack order and consistency.
 
Crack dog, oh yes. We had issues with this largely when he was under 1 year old and I think it was partly how we handled him. First time Dobering is no joke!

Teaching them to settle is a tough one. Short of crating Kaiser, he wouldn’t really rest. He would snooze. Definitely start with that.

Sounds like you also have a bed, that will help. Anytime he is laying down and relaxed, say something to mark it. Problem here is that he will probably get up in response haha but keep at it. Try giving him something to settle WITH initially so you can keep his interest in staying put and reshaping the current behaviour - use a blanket, bully stick, or Kong because you need something that occupies his time.

While he is settling for a few minutes, approach him and praise, give light touch snuggles as an additional reward for continuing to stay put. They love a soft light voice so if you tend to be louder or deeper voiced, be conscious of that.

If he whines for more, don’t reward it. Something similar was happening with my hb. He would go casual about being nudged at the elbow while at the dinner table. He would tell him he didn’t want it and push him away with his hands. Using hands is praise. Talking to the dog is attention. Speaking a whole sentence to the dog instead of a command he knows was also wrong. He would look at the dog thereby validating him. Sometimes he would give in and play with the dog, this is all inconsistency and it was reinforcing the bad behaviour. Yet he never continued nudging me the same way because I never gave in, I held my elbow tight to my body and ignored him. It’s often easier to see what you’re doing to encourage the behaviour so get your wife to video it so you can see yourself interacting with him.

It may well be anxiety, I don’t know, but the whining in particular sounds like boredom to me. When Kaiser isn’t mentally worn out, he will get up in a split second if anyone even moves, he’ll whine to go outside even if he was just out there. The body language training sounds like a good idea but I bet it’s not enough. They get used to repetitive things, so you need to change it up.

I think you're on to something with more mental training for sure..... Thank you for simplifying the hands for praise and order of communications, I've been monitoring since reading your post (sorry for the long delay in responding) and I have since found a few areas I polished up.
 
It sounds like you are doing so much right, but this sentence here is suggestive of what Kaiser just said: consistency. You said NO, but didn't ask/tell him what you DID want, and if he paced one time around the coffee table that would have been my que to say no again and add go lay down. And then enforce it. To let him pace for an hour is taxing on both of you. He's unhappy and you're unhappy. Go lay down could mean be at your feet leaning on you while you watch tv or if he preferred he could go to his kennel - a general command, but his choice of where, but go.lay.down.now.somewhere. Same at the dinner table. It shouldn't be up to you & yours to have to use elbows and avert eyes while eating. Sometimes I think a "needy" dog (not an insult, just the only term I could think of) really just wants a strong leader! They want to know rules so they know what is ok and what isn't. If you let him pace for an hour and don't make him stop, perhaps he thinks it's pleasing you so on and on it goes. It actually makes them feel more secure understanding what pleases you, if that makes sense. Rules bring much peace to pack animals as they are craving order. And you probably already know, the kennel is his safe place, not to be used as punishment. Keep us posted on your progress and let us know what works!
 
I agree raven, I should have clarified a few things too; when he paces i will tell him "no" then give him a "go lay down" command. I have spot trained him so I'll point when I say the command and he'll lay down where I'm pointing.

The coffee table hour as I call it was an experiment for me to see how long he would go for and what he would do if i ignored him and didnt give him a command..... he laid down in his bed when he finally stopped and took a nap.

I think you're spot on with giving him "the rules" so he knows what he can and cant do but I feel like I've been very responsible in my training with showing him the rules and I also feel like he definitely understands them and abides by them.... that's what's so frustrating for me. That's why I also feel like I'm failing him somewhere else. Since the post I've taken the advice from everyone and implemented some changes.... update coming....
 
UPDATE - First off I appreciate all the support on this. I read the advice and this was what I've implemented so far.....

The next three days I didnt do anything different and just monitored our routine and his behavior during every activity we did for the day.

My big take aways were that I am verbally communicaing too much and petting him way too much when not giving commands or training. (I cant help it.... i love the guy!) I feel like Im being way too over affectionate with him and hes becoming dependent on it so when I dont give him attention, it's like an anxiety trigger for him.

What I've implemented - I've redefined (mostly for myself) the communication tools with him. I've reserved touch only when he does something correct and kept communication short.

I've reduced the amount of exercise I give him and I've increased mental activities... I've started playing hide and find with his toys, incorporated mental games with cups and treats, etc etc. The mental sessions are 3 times a day for 20- 30 min or so, they follow short obedience reinforcement...

RESULTS - So far I feel like hes making strides in the right direction. It's obviously too soon to see night and day differences but hes napping on his own more frequently and longer. He still paces and flank sucks but not as frequently or as intensely. I'm hoping to build this up in the next month or so....

I appreciate all of the advice and help!!!!

P.S. sorry for my sleep face lololol:tearsofjoy:
 

Attachments

  • 20190526_221350.webp
    20190526_221350.webp
    137.9 KB · Views: 8
  • 20190601_221700.webp
    20190601_221700.webp
    88.8 KB · Views: 9
This is great news! I really like how you are researching this and making changes to your daily life to make sure your fur baby is happy and healthy. Dealing with anxiety must be difficult, but I’m sure with time you will find a schedule that he does better on and a balance between physical and mental exercise.

And I know what you mean about giving too much attention! Its impossible to deny them sometimes XD little stinkers
 
Sorry, I missed this thread the first time around.

Looks like you’re implementing some great changes. As far as exercise...Yes, there is such a thing as too much exercise. It’s all about watching them carefully for any signs and not pushing it. Read his behaviour and his response to the exercise you provide, and react accordingly to his needs.

By being in control of when attention is given/earned, you are learning not to humanise him. He instinctively need rules that he must follow, and limits to what he’s allowed to do. For the relationship to succeed, you must become his pack leader.
Remember, only award affection when he’s in a calm and submissive state. If done at the wrong times, i.e...skittish, shy, hyper behaviour...you’ll be making his state of mind more intense. You are in fact telling him it’s ok to feel that way. You think you are comforting him when actual fact he’s seeing you as being weak.

Gosh, I hope that all made sense. I do wish you both the very best going forwardTrust me, he’ll respect you more for being his leader rather than his follower.

Keep us updated on his progress :)
 
So happy to see the update - you are wise to try to observe the situation, isolate the problem, then find a solution. Thanks for explaining the hour pacing. Many times things get misunderstood on the forums simply because we can't see the whole picture. I'll bet you see much more progress and we'd love to be updated on all the things that work! And what @Viemarangelrock said:

he’ll respect you more for being his leader rather than his follower.
 

Back
Top