My Doberman is restricted in my new apartment!!!

Well the way I see that's between you and your wife. What I'm talking about here is different. We're talking abuse of a privilege of owning a dog that can help it's owner. That abuse could lead to having that privilege taken away. No doubt @AresMyDobie would look at things differently if it was. Let's say the next flight she took and Ares couldn't be there to help her.....just sayin'
First off it’s not an abuse of privilege since the animal is not consider and actual service animal but apparently that part isn’t being understood. The ESA can’t go into freaking Disneyland for hell sake. Second of all don’t talk about me as if I’m not here honestly I just find you to be extremely critical and a know it all. Oh when I can’t take my well behaved dog on an airplane then I’ll understand? Lol ok. Well not everyone has your type of funds to afford the things you do. No offense but it’s rude to just be like oh well should have thought to get a different breed.
ESA has nothing to do with the service animal industry other then protect the dog from being rejected to live somewhere, don’t see what the issue is. Besides do you know if this person needs one and didn’t know about it ? No.
 
First off it’s not an abuse of privilege since the animal is not consider and actual service animal but apparently that part isn’t being understood. The ESA can’t go into freaking Disneyland for hell sake. Second of all don’t talk about me as if I’m not here honestly I just find you to be extremely critical and a know it all. Oh when I can’t take my well behaved dog on an airplane then I’ll understand? Lol ok. Well not everyone has your type of funds to afford the things you do. No offense but it’s rude to just be like oh well should have thought to get a different breed.
ESA has nothing to do with the service animal industry other then protect the dog from being rejected to live somewhere, don’t see what the issue is. Besides do you know if this person needs one and didn’t know about it ? No.
Moderator reminder: Please remember to not call people out publicly and keep any personal matter you have with a member private through PMs. It is a policy on this forum to remain respectful towards one another. This being said, if you continue having issues with any member privately, please contact a moderator for assistance. Thanks :)
 
On a side note, a CGC is helpful. It can and does get you a discount on your home owners insurance, albeit not through all companies. It can also be a requirement or prerequisite for many SD training organizations. Belmont and Archer had to have their CGC for therapy work. It, however does not guarantee anything. It is simply a title to have to show that training has been put into he dog to ensure it is a proper citizen and can exist in public sans issues. It is still a respected title. Let’s not bash it for that but honor the time and work that goes into training for it. It is a title that some people work hard for and working with your dog to train and build a bond is never a bad thing.

As far as this thread goes, if the dog is NOT truly used for a SD or ESD it is not appropriate to say that it is for housing purposes. It is best (and safer) for both the dogs and owner to find other housing. I also advise to everyone to research rules and regulations of their city and housing to make sure that a Doberman is an accepted breed prior to bringing one home. Many cities, complexes and even HOAs have Dobermans on their list of restricted breeds. Since the OP is already in the situation they are in, it is best for them to seek housing elsewhere where a Doberman is accepted.
 
Many Doctors are refusing to write letters stating you need your dog as an ESD due to the dogs not being stable or trained and then going out and biting a person or another dog while on a plane or in a restaurant or other venues.

They are afraid of being sued when that happens.
I read not long ago about an ESD attacking a trained Service Dog causing considerable damage to the SD handler and dog resulting in extensive medical bills.
Any dog that is going to be in a public place where other animals and people are, needs to be trained. CGC teaches your dog to focus on you, ignore distractions including other dogs and generally be well behaved.

I think it should be required in order to obtain an ESD certificate/letter.
I also think these online Dr. letters for SD and ESD should be eliminated as they are nothing more than a fake registry that will eventually lead to making it difficult for legitimate SD to accompany their handlers.
It has been abused by many people and makes it much more difficult for disabled individuals to lead as normal a life as possible.

Seems it’s much simpler to just train your dog to be a good, obedient sidekick in public.
 
"In the U.S., people with emotional or mental disabilities can be exempted from certain federal housing and travel rules if they own an emotional support animal. To receive that exemption, they must meet the federal definition of disabled, and they must present a letter from a certified healthcare provider, stating that the animal provides emotional support that alleviates one or more of the symptoms or effects of the disability.[2]

Additionally the FHAA, in section 3602(h) defines handicap, with respect to a person, as:

  1. a physical or mental impairment which substantially limits one or more of such person's major life activities;
  2. a record of having such an impairment; or
  3. being regarded as having such an impairment.[24]
The term "major life activities" has been interpreted broadly to include those "activities that are of central importance to daily life," such as "seeing, hearing, walking, breathing, performing manual tasks, caring for one's self, learning, speaking, and reproducing.

Landlords are entitled to ask for supporting materials which document the need for an emotional support animal.[23] Mere emotional distress that would result from having to give up an animal because of a "no pets" policy will not qualify under federal law. Instead, there must be a link, or a nexus, between the animal and the disability.[19] The nexus between the animal and the disability is analyzed under the third element of an FHAA housing discrimination case, known as the necessity requirement, and requires that the accommodation will affirmatively enhance a disabled tenant's quality of life by ameliorating the effects of the disability.[26] So long as the requested accommodation does not constitute an undue financial or administrative burden for the landlord, or fundamentally alter the nature of the housing, the landlord must provide the accommodation."

Your rights to have an ESA in a place with a strict no pet policy, is a privilege and shouldn't be abused. Just because they are not trained doesn't mean they aren't performing a service for someone with mental health that doesn't need specific tasks done. Lying is never a good way to go about things, especially when it puts others rights at risk. You also risk losing your home and animal.
 
Right after I took this picture in the park on Sunday, a woman asked if he is a German Shorthair Pointer. Really!

People know so little about dogs, you might get away claiming he's a Beauceron. Which is a partial truth because one of the breeds that went into Dobies is the Beauceron.

View attachment 108987
This is a great post.:)
Since my boy Rocky has natural mud flap ears I could probably get away with claiming he’s a Black and Tan coon hound. :whistle:


I wonder?
Given today’s social/political climate.
Could one simply say yes. He’s a Doberman. But he identifies as a black lab. So you have to accept him. :scratch::cool::bag:
 
Landlords are entitled to ask for supporting materials which document the need for an emotional support animal.[23] Mere emotional distress that would result from having to give up an animal because of a "no pets" policy will not qualify under federal law. I
And perhaps there’s the angle someone will take some day who has the pockets to fight it.


It’s not that there is a no pets policy.
Pets are allowed. Except x, y,z, f, o, etc.

Basic discrimination based on breed.
I’ll stop there as I feel a political rant brewing :rofl:
 
I let them know that pets are also family and will like to cancel and get a refund.

Thats what I would do!
Good for you!

As someone who owns rental properties here is my insight and advise.

With all due respect to those who advocate fudging the facts or tell what they may consider to be "white lies" is actually really bad advise with serious consequences that they are not taking into consideration.


Never misrepresent your dogs breed or try to represent it as a ESA or SD.
Besides being against the law and dishonest. It is a disservice to folks who genuinely need and have a SD or ESA.

Lying on a rental application is fraud and grounds for eviction & surrendering any and all deposits you have paid.
It is one of the best ways I can think of to get you and your dog evicted and lose your security deposit in the process.
Oh and on top of being homeless and out your deposit you will be responsible for all of the attorney fees, court cost and any other expenses incurred by the property owner to evict you. And yes the eviction and its costs will be on your credit report for the next 7 years..

Trying to find a place to rent with a Doberman is hard enough.
Dobermans and their owners have enough misconceptions and reputation issues to over come as it is. Adding being perceived as liars or dishonest helps no one or the breed.

I can assure you trying to find a place to rent after being evicted and with a Doberman will make it even harder if not damn near impossible. Then add in the financial burden & stress of losing your security deposit on top of everything.
Well I hope you get the picture & it is not a situation that you and your dog want to be in.

After being evicted you will find that the only places & people that will rent to you are probably not places you want to live or people you want rent from (Slum lords renting way over priced substandard housing) Renting places you do not want live in (Dumps in high crime areas) and renting to people you don't want as neighbors (Convicted felons, sex offenders drug dealers etc) Hey they have to live some where too right?

You may find that you will absolutely need your doberman to keep you and your belonging safe and just to sleep at night.

So hopefully now you understand why lying or misrepresenting anything on rental application or agreement is a really bad idea and not in your best interest.
MR
 
Just came on here to ask if anyone else have been through this? I’m nervous that many other apartments will not take in my puppy. It’s is such BULLS**** that dobermans are restricted. I let them know that pets are also family and will like to cancel and get a refund.
If your dog isn't altered or cropped I would reclassify him as a Weimaraner mix (since technically that's what a Doberman is)

My girl is a fawn dobe but I call her a weimaraner mix and all her paperwork says she is a weimaraner mix because I knew I would be breed restricted if she was classified as a Doberman.

Yana compared to a weimaraner.
Her fawn color helps but if any dobe is unaltered/cropped dog breed novices won't recognize the dog as a Doberman.
 

Attachments

  • 00000_hK9hPtUXrxu_0lM0t2_1200x900.webp
    00000_hK9hPtUXrxu_0lM0t2_1200x900.webp
    109.1 KB · Views: 3
  • Screenshot_20230830_224016_Firefox.webp
    Screenshot_20230830_224016_Firefox.webp
    224.2 KB · Views: 3

Back
Top