My 7 year old Dobie is showing sign of aggression

bbarbie2u

Active Member
I have a 7 year Old female spayed Doberman, 90 lbs. She’s very intimidating but has never really showed aggression until recently. My 6 year old granddaughter was sitting next to him on the couch and doing great. My granddaughter repositioned herself, and Cindy, my dog, turned around and growled and snapped at her only an inch from her face. I have eight grandkids who visit. She loves to be petted by them, but because of this one incident, I am scared to death because she was unprovoked. Should I lock her up when they visit, try a muzzle? I have to admit I’m not sure if she would even be good with so,some new in my house. She has no aggression towards me at all. Any suggestions please???
 
I have a 7 year Old female spayed Doberman, 90 lbs. She’s very intimidating but has never really showed aggression until recently. My 6 year old granddaughter was sitting next to him on the couch and doing great. My granddaughter repositioned herself, and Cindy, my dog, turned around and growled and snapped at her only an inch from her face. I have eight grandkids who visit. She loves to be petted by them, but because of this one incident, I am scared to death because she was unprovoked. Should I lock her up when they visit, try a muzzle? I have to admit I’m not sure if she would even be good with so,some new in my house. She has no aggression towards me at all. Any suggestions please???
I cant give you any help but just my experience. I had a almost 8 year old doberman who I always thought was amazing with my kids . She ignored them most days but if she did take food from them she did take it pretty gentle from them. But one time last year my daughter 5 year old walked out of the kitchen no food was around she was getting water and my girl nipped at her . It didn't break skin. So we watched her and nothing else happened until 6 months later she walked out of the kitchen again no food this time I was cooking and the dog attacked her and almost took her eye. She now has a scar on her eye brow and had a black eye for almost 3 weeks. Not to mention it was the night before her dance recital so that was a shit show. We then kept her away from the kids pretty much as much as we could which was very disheartening but she was living downstairs with our roommate downstairs until kids were gone to school or daycare or grandmas house or bed time then she was aloud upstairs again. She passed away about 4 months later and we found out she had a brain tumor and those signs of aggression which were so unusual for her to display towards the girls should of been a sign that something was going on. We unfortunately didn't know and just thought it was a doberman thing and she had a really bad seizure and didn't come out of it and passed :( we now have a puppy and I will say im more stressed with the puppy nipping at the kids then I ever felt with our older girl until her last year. Goodluck I hope someone has more help to give you
 
I cant give you any help but just my experience. I had a almost 8 year old doberman who I always thought was amazing with my kids . She ignored them most days but if she did take food from them she did take it pretty gentle from them. But one time last year my daughter 5 year old walked out of the kitchen no food was around she was getting water and my girl nipped at her . It didn't break skin. So we watched her and nothing else happened until 6 months later she walked out of the kitchen again no food this time I was cooking and the dog attacked her and almost took her eye. She now has a scar on her eye brow and had a black eye for almost 3 weeks. Not to mention it was the night before her dance recital so that was a shit show. We then kept her away from the kids pretty much as much as we could which was very disheartening but she was living downstairs with our roommate downstairs until kids were gone to school or daycare or grandmas house or bed time then she was aloud upstairs again. She passed away about 4 months later and we found out she had a brain tumor and those signs of aggression which were so unusual for her to display towards the girls should of been a sign that something was going on. We unfortunately didn't know and just thought it was a doberman thing and she had a really bad seizure and didn't come out of it and passed :( we now have a puppy and I will say im more stressed with the puppy nipping at the kids then I ever felt with our older girl until her last year. Goodluck I hope someone has more help to give you
 
Thank you for responding. Just that one time has freaked me out, but she is so for vaccines so I will mention to vet. I might look into some type of muzzle maybe. I’m afraid if I always put her up it might make her less use to people and worse??
 
Our girl unfortunately wasn't great with people she didn't see everyday. For the people she knew she would jump and lick and not leave them alone but for strangers she would growl so we always had to lock her up when strangers came over or just someone she didn't see much so I have no optio to help. We tried the muzzle but she was houdini and could get out of both of the muzzles we got. With the puppy we have decided we are going to bring her out as much as possible and make sure she learns to socialize better. Goodluck
 
Our girl unfortunately wasn't great with people she didn't see everyday. For the people she knew she would jump and lick and not leave them alone but for strangers she would growl so we always had to lock her up when strangers came over or just someone she didn't see much so I have no optio to help. We tried the muzzle but she was houdini and could get out of both of the muzzles we got. With the puppy we have decided we are going to bring her out as much as possible and make sure she learns to socialize better. Goodluck
 
Yeah dont go Google dog attacks cause it scared me completely. We had looked into giving out girl away after the major attack on our daughter we got lucky she didn't get her eye but we just loved her to much and the kids loved her. We have a 2 year old daughter as well and she always would get off the couch and go sit beside her in her bed on the ground and cuddle buthad to restrict that and she didn't understand and still just wanted to love her
 
I have a 7 year Old female spayed Doberman, 90 lbs. She’s very intimidating but has never really showed aggression until recently. My 6 year old granddaughter was sitting next to him on the couch and doing great. My granddaughter repositioned herself, and Cindy, my dog, turned around and growled and snapped at her only an inch from her face. I have eight grandkids who visit. She loves to be petted by them, but because of this one incident, I am scared to death because she was unprovoked. Should I lock her up when they visit, try a muzzle? I have to admit I’m not sure if she would even be good with so,some new in my house. She has no aggression towards me at all. Any suggestions please???

I think we are missing the most important aspect of this post;

What did you do immediately after the dog nipped at your loved one?

If you did nothing, then the dog thinks it got away with being the alpha in that scenario. If you did something then the dog hopefully understands that it is not the alpha.
 
I think we are missing the most important aspect of this post;

What did you do immediately after the dog nipped at your loved one?

If you did nothing, then the dog thinks it got away with being the alpha in that scenario. If you did something then the dog hopefully understands that it is not the alpha.
“
 
I took her by the collar and told her she was a bad, bad dog. She knows exactly what that means, then I put her in the kitchen that has a gate. Then of course comforted my granddaughter and checked her over. The snap was just an inch away from her face! I eventually let Cindy back in room and kept her close to me
 
Welcome back!

Well, I don't know that I have the solution for you. It's a scary thing. I think most dog and Doberman owners think they have it all under control and that they've trained their dogs well enough and their beloved dogs would never hurt a family member. In most cases, they're right. It's always a risk though, having a dog around children, and I hate that aspect of dog ownership.

One thing I suggest: Don't let your Dobe on the furniture. This puts your dog on an equal level in the pack with the humans in the family. Kids already have a disadvantage with their smaller size and less impressive presence.

I'll just give an example or two from Oji, or current male (who has never been on furniture):

We got him at 12 weeks from a reputable working breeder. I'm quite experienced in dog training and this is my third Doberman.

Our older daughter was 3 or 4 when we got Oji. No issues between them that I recall. Then, when Oji was about 5 years old, we became blessed with another child! We were, of course cautious and concerned in introducing our adult working Doberman to our little baby but he showed zero signs of aggression or roughness with her. Phew!

When our daughter was about 1 year old (she's now 19 months old) I saw her toddle up to Oji, who was laying and doing nothing, and he felt he had to get up and move (which I think is a good thing, as it shows deference to the child) but as he got up, he snapped at the air toward her. I take this to be simply irritation at having to get up when he didn't feel like it, and having to give up his spot that he had chosen. I rushed to him and with utmost sternness grabbed his scruff and shook it (my standard correction – that he has never seemed to be fazed by) and verbally condemned what had happened very sternly and angrily.

Some weeks later, the same basic thing happened, only this time Oji was laying in a comfy sunbeam on the floor. Our daughter toddled toward him and as he got up he snapped at her and his jaws went around her forearm but did not close. Thank God!! This, of course, was even more serious. I gave him basically the same correction. I don't know what more I can do aside from "Alpha Rolling" him which I had done a few times with my previous working Doberman which always ended in something perhaps just a little better than a stalemate. It saddens me a bit to remember Alpha Rolling my Dobe and it's always a bit amazing to think of doing this to a 90 lb. hard as a rock beast but in the heat of the moment he's goin' down and I ain't gonna' fail.

With Oji, I feel we wind up in a true stalemate if I do anything more than a scruff shake and yell his "no" command at him, because he will bare his teeth and threaten in a very real way to bite me. This sucks because I feel he actually wins those unfortunate confrontations as I am forced to back off my aggressiveness toward him and he knows he has caused me to stand down.

So it's scary. All I can do is just watch him as carefully as I can, and consistently as I can, and continue to pray.

Sorry if I've made this reply about me. I hope it may add some information for you.
 
Well, all of this is quite distressing. It's very difficult to have a dog you cannot trust around your children or grandchildren. It was my number one condition when I got my dogs. And both have been extremely good with kids. That said, I still am vigilant! I think it just goes with the territory that kids and dogs should still be watched together, no matter how good they are.

My two have never shown any aggression but I still warn my grandchildren not to put their face directly in the face of the dogs. Sometimes they want to hug them and get face-to-face with them. That kind of stuff makes me nervous. Sometimes I worry that the dogs will view it as being trapped or stared at LOL Kids can be overexcited, move quickly, and some dogs will snap when in fear.

Now that doesn't seem to case with @bbarbie2u To come out of the blue like that is a little bit bewildering. And after hearing @Doberman 1994 story, it makes one wonder. I don't know how you find a brain tumor without an x-ray or MRI and I don't know how invasive or expensive that can be for a 'just-in-case' situation. But it's an awfully sad story to be punishing or separating a dog for these actions when it's really a health issue. :( But who knows that? And just like you, I would want to protect my children or grandchildren but separating my dog all the time or Worse, getting rid of him, pains me. For one, I would never get rid of my dog. I would much rather be aware of the situation and change things. My animals are here for life. It's hard to do if there are children in your home all the time. But if it's just on a visit basis, maybe a muzzle? I can't really give a lot of advice on that because I've never been through it but I'm sure we all can sympathize. We all love our dogs! Maybe someone else can help with a few other suggestions. I wish you well!
 
I know that in the moment these events can seem like aggression. Because well, they sound like it. JMHO, but I think the term is way over used because we forget dogs can't talk. More often than not, it is just the dog saying "Get out of my face, I don't feel good!" or simply "I don't want you here right now"
I do think this warrants at minimum a talk with your Vet and a thyroid panel drawn.
 
I will add that after the stern corrections for snapping at little daughter I have followed with giving him a command. That helps to remind him that I am in charge, and his compliance is a sign that he is accepting this. It also gives me a chance to give him the "good" words for obeying.

I suppose a "similar" situation would be Oji bumping into our toddler and knocking her down or even not knocking her down. Of course, the reprimand he receives for this is less severe, and if it was a mild incursion the reprimand is mild. It seems like a grey area because he may not have intentionally done anything wrong, but I feel it a wise thing to go ahead and show my significant displeasure with him bumping her and especially knocking her down or into a wall or table or something. It's like: You mess with toddler, Alpha is going to be displeased with you and you don't want that.

This leads me to mention that as part of my vigilance, I quite often can be found quickly moving to a position where I can get a visual on dog and toddler. It's not convenient as I'm doing other things around the house, but it's necessary for me to closely monitor what they both are doing and to intervene if I see a potential situation unfolding.

It should be noted that when Oji sees me pop around a corner or stick my head around a door frame and give the eagle-eye but not say a word, he looks at me like "Am, I good here? Did I do something wrong?" I think that's an important indicator that it does matter to him what I think about his actions with regard to toddler.
 
Oi, tough situation.

I do agree that having her on the couch when there are children around is probably not a great idea, as hard of a habit as that is to break once the privilege has been granted.

We do not have children but we have nieces who visit. They have been drilled with "Leave the dogs alone." And if a dog does approach them, here is the correct way to pet them, when they leave the situation, that is their choice so don't chase them. My Dobe is muzzle trained and even though we want to feel sad for dogs wearing muzzles, it's actually a GREAT tool. My nieces now have their own puppy so I highly suspect their attitudes toward my dogs will be lax. Instead of putting my Dobe away when they come to visit, I can put her muzzle on to keep everyone at ease while I observe the nieces and their behavior and the comfort level of my dogs. If the girls are too much for her, she's also perfectly happy hanging out by herself with a peanut butter kong while jubilant children run amok.

It is very scary when a dog corrects a child as they would another dog but that is their language and I am a firm believer that dogs that feel like they CANNOT express themselves in certain situations default to much more over the top reactions when they literally cannot take anymore. When a dog growls and we silence them instead of listen to them, we are taking away their first level of communication. The next level may be an air snap. And the last level is a bite.

Listen to your dog and set them up for success. Talking to the vet about the change may also not be a bad idea as it can at times be an indicator of underlying issues, as others have said.

Keep in mind that 7 is starting to creep into senior age for a Dobe. She may be a point in her life where she doesn't appreciate the energy of children.
 
I will add that after the stern corrections for snapping at little daughter I have followed with giving him a command. That helps to remind him that I am in charge, and his compliance is a sign that he is accepting this. It also gives me a chance to give him the "good" words for obeying.

Perfectly said. I do this with Maze...( including the alpha roll- didnt know what that was until I bing'd it. ) It helps me establish that she knows she messed up BUT I still care and love her and she still obeys; establishing that- im in charge relationship.

@bbarbie2u good hopefully the dog knows it messed up. I would tell the granddaughter to keep her distance while closely monitoring the dog next time. Maybe keeping the dog close to you, and see that sign of a snap. Some people can tell by reading body language of a dog. Hair stands up. Position of tail. Position of ears. The "lips" position. The eyes of the dog.

Seems farfetched but the way we humans observe other humans, dogs too can be observed and predict behaviors.

Bottom line, you can NEVER be too safe around kids with any dog.
 
My opinion is to not let a dog on the couch because it seems to eventually cause problems down the road as far as possession. Also if my dog ever attempted to bite my grandchild the dog is going to lose. I love dogs but kids far out rank any dog and my dog would be locked up from then on when the kids were over. I do like a protective dog when it comes to strangers since that is what the doberman was bread for. Protect our kids first.
 
I have a 7 year Old female spayed Doberman, 90 lbs. She’s very intimidating but has never really showed aggression until recently. My 6 year old granddaughter was sitting next to him on the couch and doing great. My granddaughter repositioned herself, and Cindy, my dog, turned around and growled and snapped at her only an inch from her face. I have eight grandkids who visit. She loves to be petted by them, but because of this one incident, I am scared to death because she was unprovoked. Should I lock her up when they visit, try a muzzle? I have to admit I’m not sure if she would even be good with so,some new in my house. She has no aggression towards me at all. Any suggestions please???


Please keep us posted!
 

Back
Top