• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Lawsuit filed against Champion Pet Food – Acana and Orijen

strykerdobe

Hot Topics Subscriber
WOW!

Lawsuit filed against Champion Pet Food – Acana and Orijen

By Susan Thixton
- March 19, 2018

Consumers in Minnesota, California and Florida are suing Champion Pet Food for “False Advertising”, violations of “feed law”, and numerous other charges. The lawsuit includes results of heavy metal testing and includes results that this dry dog food contains BPA – a chemical typically not associated with dry/kibble pet foods.

This is a Class Action lawsuit – currently representing consumers in Minnesota, California and Florida. The consumers are suing Champion Pet Food “for their negligent, reckless, and/or intentional practice of misrepresenting and failing to fully disclose the presence of heavy metals and toxins in their pet food sold throughout the United States. Plaintiffs seek both injunctive and monetary relief on behalf of the proposed Classes (defined below), including requiring full disclosure of all such substances in its marketing, advertising, and labeling and restoring monies to the members of the proposed Classes.”

The lawsuit claims Champion pet foods (Acana and Orijen) “contain levels of arsenic, mercury, lead, cadmium” “known to pose health risks to humans and animals, including dogs” and interestingly for a kibble pet food…the lawsuit claims the dry pet food contained “BISPHENOL A (“BPA”)”.

The lawsuit provided this chart of lab result findings in Acana and Orijen pet foods:

A19BFAFF-66E0-49FE-92D1-E02E138583F0.webp



With the heavy metal results provided, the levels found in the Champion Pet Food appear be be below that what authorities recognize as a ‘Maximum Tolerable Level of Minerals in Feed’.

As example: the National Research Council (NRC) publication Mineral Tolerances for Animals 2005 are the guidelines that FDA enforces. Within this publication (which is a pay for publication, not free public access) the NRC provides a chart listing the maximum tolerable level for multiple species. Dogs and cats are not listed within the NRC chart. The closest species provided in the NRC publication is rodents.

For rodents, the maximum tolerable level of arsenic is: 30 mg/kg.

The highest level of arsenic found in the Acana and Orijen dog foods was 3256.40 mcg/kg (microgram per kilogram). Converting micrograms to milligrams, the highest level or arsenic found in Acana and Orijen dog foods was 3.2564 mg. Well below the NRC maximum tolerable level for rodents and we can assume dogs and cats.

That said, much of the NRC consulted science their maximum tolerable levels are established on were based on short term research. There was/is little consideration to cats and dogs that consume pet food with higher levels of heavy metals over a lifetime. The NRC Mineral Tolerances 2005 publication found that dogs fed “2.3 and 4.6 mg per day per kilogram of body weight” for only “183 days“ experienced “decreased weight gain and food intake”; 183 days is not a fair consideration to base pet health on when exposure could be years.

Lawyers will have to argue out the heavy metal content health risks cited in the lawsuit.

But what about the BPA found in the Champion pet foods…kibble pet foods? Most pet food consumers understand that canned pet foods could contain BPA…but not dry/kibble pet foods.

The lawsuit states “Defendants market the Contaminated Dog Foods as “Biologically Appropriate,” using “Fresh Regional Ingredients” comprised of 100 percent meat, poultry, fish, and/or vegetables, both on the products’ packaging and on Defendants’ websites. Moreover, Defendants devote significant web and packaging space to the marketing of their DogStar® Kitchens, which they tell consumers “are the most advanced pet food kitchens on earth, with standards that rival the human food processing industry.”

Where did the BPA come from if ‘fresh regional ingredients’ are used and processed in ‘the most advanced pet food kitchens on earth’?

How much BPA was found in Champion Pet Foods as compared to canned pet food?

In 2002 a study – Determination of bisphenol A in canned pet foods – found BPA levels in dog foods tested from “11 to 206 ng/g”.

Nanogram per gram (ng/g) results stated in this study is the same as microgram to kilogram (ug/kg) stated in the lawsuit.

The lawsuit cites testing of Orijen and Acana BPA levels from zero to 102.70 ug/kg. Not quite as high as results of canned pet food, but significantly high for what a kibble pet food would be expected to contain.

It will be very interesting to follow this lawsuit, to learn of future updates/arguments from both sides. As more is learned, it will be shared.

To read the full lawsuit, Click Here.

To contact the law firm, Click Here.



Wishing you and your pet(s) the best,

Susan Thixton
Pet Food Safety Advocate
Author Buyer Beware, Co-Author Dinner PAWsible
TruthaboutPetFood.com
Association for Truth in Pet Food

atpfbannersmall.jpg

Become a member of our pet food consumer Association. Association for Truth in Pet Food is a a stakeholder organization representing the voice of pet food consumers at AAFCO and with FDA. Your membership helps representatives attend meetings and voice consumer concerns with regulatory authorities. Click Here to learn more.

What’s in Your Pet’s Food?
Is your dog or cat eating risk ingredients? Chinese imports? Petsumer Report tells the ‘rest of the story’ on over 5,000 cat foods, dog foods, and pet treats. 30 Day Satisfaction Guarantee. Click Here to preview Petsumer Report. www.PetsumerReport.com

2018listseal_B-small.png




The 2018 List
Susan’s List of trusted pet foods. Click Here to learn more.



Have you read Buyer Beware? Click Here

Cooking pet food made easy, Dinner PAWsible

Find Healthy Pet Foods in Your Area Click Here
 
I’m feeding orijen large puppy it’s not on that list, should I change my dudes food? Or stay on it.
 
the highest level or arsenic found in Acana and Orijen dog foods was 3.2564 mg. Well below the NRC maximum tolerable level for rodents and we can assume dogs and cats.

Don't freak out people...make sure to read the article. Either way it will be interesting to learn what comes of this.

I hate to say it but can we really guarantee our raw food doesn't have "safe" levels of BPA in it too? We don't test it. Nothing is pure anymore.
 
I’m riding it out everything they stated was almost nit picky imo. It’s levels of bpa was lower then what’s acceptable in another type of food,(so it clearly is acceptable at some level, regardless how it enters the system it’s in the system)they lied, ok so what’s hid in other foods that haven’t been dissected in a lab yet, it’s main lawsuit is false adv. ok guess I got lied too. Lawsuit doesn’t make em guilty just yet either, I’ll wait for the whole deal to be sorted out before I panic. It’s 2018 at this point breathing air isn’t safe again just my thoughts
 
Don't freak out people...make sure to read the article. Either way it will be interesting to learn what comes of this.

I hate to say it but can we really guarantee our raw food doesn't have "safe" levels of BPA in it too? We don't test it. Nothing is pure anymore.

Oh, yes. Not freaking out but been toying with the idea of looking at a new food anyway (we're feeding the last food on that list, Acana heritage freshwater fish). Worries me because these are the things that build up in your system over time. You can get mercury poisoning from eating too much sushi and this is the food Dingo gets everyday. We've been talking about doing more raw when the new puppy comes but to your point, who's to say it's any "safer." Haw jeeze... Guess we do the best we can with the info we have, right?
 
Interesting, sorta.

I haven’t read much on this. Who is the attorney or law group representing the people that filed this suit?

Any Purina ties? ;)
 
Interesting, sorta.

I haven’t read much on this. Who is the attorney or law group representing the people that filed this suit?

Any Purina ties? ;)

I haven't read the Lawsuit so I don't know about that. I would bet No ties with Purina. They Champion Foods are a very tight company and would not have any ties with crap companies.

Towards the bottom of article are two links

One for the Lawsuit which is like 70 some pages so I could not post it. To read the full lawsuit, Click Here.
Second is a link for Contact Law Firm To contact the law firm, Click Here.
 
WOW! Now a Cat Food Lawsuit


mail

upload_2018-7-18_12-47-0.webp
Another Champion Pet Food Lawsuit, Now it is Cat Food
upload_2018-7-18_12-47-0.webp
Champion Pet Food is facing another class action lawsuit, this time regarding Orijen and Acana Cat Food.
http://truthaboutpetfood.com/another-champion-pet-food-lawsuit-now-it-is-cat-food/
upload_2018-7-18_12-47-0.webp
Wishing you and your pet(s) the best,
Susan Thixton
Pet Food Safety Advocate
Author Buyer Beware, Co-Author Dinner PAWsible
TruthaboutPetFood.com
Association for Truth in Pet Food

Become a member of our pet food consumer Association. Association for Truth in Pet Food is a a stakeholder organization representing the voice of pet food consumers at AAFCO and with FDA. Your membership helps representatives attend meetings and voice consumer concerns with regulatory authorities. Click Here to learn more.
What’s in Your Pet’s Food?
Is your dog or cat eating risk ingredients? Chinese imports? Petsumer Report tells the ‘rest of the story’ on over 5,000 cat foods, dog foods, and pet treats. 30 Day Satisfaction Guarantee. Click Here to preview Petsumer Report. www.PetsumerReport.com


Another Champion Pet Food Lawsuit, Now it is Cat Food
By Susan Thixton
- July 18, 2018

Champion Pet Food is facing another class action lawsuit, this time regarding Orijen and Acana Cat Food.

Filed in Illinois on June 22, 2018 – is another class action lawsuit against Champion Pet Food “for their negligent, reckless, and/or intentional practice of misrepresenting and failing to fully disclose the presence of heavy metals and toxins in their pet food sold throughout the United States.” This particular lawsuit is specific to Orijen and Acana Cat Food. The foundation of this Champion Cat Food lawsuit is similar to the previous dog food lawsuit, the pet food company is accused of selling cat food that “contain levels of arsenic, mercury, lead, cadmium, and/or bisphenol A (“BPA”) — all known to pose health risks to humans and animals, including cats.”

The lawsuit provides the following lab results:

Championcatfoodlawsuitresults1.png


Championcatfoodlawsuitresults2.png


Excerpts from the lawsuit:

Arsenic is deadly to cats in doses of just one to twelve milligrams per pound of body weight.

The Contaminated Cat Foods contain arsenic, which can affect the gastrointestinal and cardiovascular systems, as well as lead to circulatory collapse.

Additionally, the Contaminated Cat Foods contain mercury, which can cause damage to the kidneys and to the cardiovascular, nervous, and neurological systems in cats.

Side note: Both the dog food lawsuit and this cat food lawsuit quotes Champion Pet Foods trademarked claim of “Biologically Appropriate”. It appears someone else has challenged Champion with this trademark and won. Champion Pet Food cancelled their trademark in June 2018.

Championlawsuittrademark.png


You can read the full lawsuit Here.

You can contact the law firm Here.



Wishing you and your pet(s) the best,

Susan Thixton
Pet Food Safety Advocate
Author Buyer Beware, Co-Author Dinner PAWsible
TruthaboutPetFood.com
Association for Truth in Pet Food

atpfbannersmall.jpg

Become a member of our pet food consumer Association. Association for Truth in Pet Food is a a stakeholder organization representing the voice of pet food consumers at AAFCO and with FDA. Your membership helps representatives attend meetings and voice consumer concerns with regulatory authorities. Click Here to learn more.

What’s in Your Pet’s Food?
Is your dog or cat eating risk ingredients? Chinese imports? Petsumer Report tells the ‘rest of the story’ on over 5,000 cat foods, dog foods, and pet treats. 30 Day Satisfaction Guarantee. Click Here to preview Petsumer Report. www.PetsumerReport.com

2018listseal_B-small.png




The 2018 List
Susan’s List of trusted pet foods. Click Here to learn more.

Have you read Buyer Beware? Click Here

Cooking pet food made easy, Dinner PAWsible

Find Healthy Pet Foods in Your Area Click Here
 
Well Champion Foods WTF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


mail


Champion Pet Food Lawsuit Amended – ‘risk of inclusion of Pentobarbital’
By Susan Thixton
- November 12, 2018

ChampionLawsuitamended.jpg


The class action lawsuit against Champion Pet Food (manufacturer of Orijen and Acana) has been amended in a concerning way. The lawsuit now includes “risk of inclusion in their pet food of pentobarbital…”

Filed in Colorado today (11/12/18) was an amended lawsuit (complaint) against Champion Pet Food. The initial lawsuit against Champion was based on “negligent, reckless, and/or intentional practice of misrepresenting and failing to fully disclose the presence of heavy metals and toxins in their pet food sold throughout the United States.” Now the lawsuit states this:

“…bring this Class Action Complaint against Defendants Champion Petfoods USA, Inc. and Champion Petfoods LP (“Defendants”), for their negligent, reckless, and/or intentional practice of misrepresenting, failing to test for, and failing to fully disclose the presence and/or risk of inclusion in their pet food of heavy metals, pentobarbital, toxins and/or unnatural or other ingredients that do not conform to the labels, packaging, advertising and statements sold throughout the United States.”

The clue to this concerning change in the Champion Pet Food lawsuit was this statement:

“It was recently revealed on information and belief that Defendants were knowingly, recklessly and/or negligently selling certain of the Contaminated Dog Foods from the DogStar Kitchens containing pentobarbital, a substance largely used to euthanize animals.”

“DogStar Kitchens” mentioned in the lawsuit is the newer Champion plant located in Auburn, Kentucky. The Champion website states this about the Kentucky plant: “Located on 85 acres of lush farmland in Auburn, Kentucky and custom-built from the ground up to advance our Biologically Appropriate and Fresh Regional Ingredient mission, our DogStar kitchens have won significant awards in the pet food industry.”

The lawsuit does not disclose if someone has tested a Champion Pet Food and found pentobarbital, but it reads as if that is the case. As for the possibility that this is a false claim added to the lawsuit, a friend that is an attorney stated “all lawsuits have to be based on a good faith basis”.

If any information is provided to us about the pentobarbital in Kentucky Champion pet food plant, it will be shared.

To read the full amended lawsuit against Champion Pet Food, click here.

To contact law firm, click here.



Fact: Champion Pet Food is a feed grade pet food. The FDA openly allows ANY feed grade pet food manufacturer to utilize “material from diseased animals or animals which have died otherwise than by slaughter” in their products with no disclosure to the pet owner. Pet food ingredients sourced from “diseased animals or animals which have died otherwise than by slaughter” are a direct violation of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act. But…FDA ignores the very laws they are required to enforce.

In other words, any feed grade pet food could be utilizing euthanized animal meat just like many others have in the recent past BECAUSE the FDA lets them. As well, every single AAFCO meat ingredient definition allows the use of diseased or non-slaughtered animal material too. No consumer is warned or alerted, in fact the pet food ingredient definitions that allow the waste are hidden from public view.

If this is true – this is one more sad example of the waste allowed by FDA that pet food manufacturers are making billions on. This is the illegal cooperation between FDA and feed grade pet food manufacturers to cheat and deceive pet owners. It’s collusion.

The only type of pet food that would be guaranteed by law not to utilize euthanized animal meat would be a pet food that states “Human Grade” on the label. Human grade pet foods are manufactured in a licensed human food facility that by law can only utilize USDA inspected and passed meat. Raw pet foods manufactured under “constant USDA inspection” would as well by law not be allowed to utilized diseased or non-slaughtered animal meat. Consumers cannot trust a human grade claim on a website – regulatory authorities never scrutinize pet food websites for truthful or false claims. Only trust a Human Grade claim on a pet food label or with raw pet food, ask the manufacturer to provide you their USDA plant ID number (and call the USDA plant to confirm it is made under inspection).



Wishing you and your pet(s) the best,

Susan Thixton
Pet Food Safety Advocate
Author Buyer Beware, Co-Author Dinner PAWsible
TruthaboutPetFood.com
Association for Truth in Pet Food

atpfbannersmall-295x120.jpg

Become a member of our pet food consumer Association. Association for Truth in Pet Food is a a stakeholder organization representing the voice of pet food consumers at AAFCO and with FDA. Your membership helps representatives attend meetings and voice consumer concerns with regulatory authorities. Click Here to learn more.

What’s in Your Pet’s Food?
Is your dog or cat eating risk ingredients? Chinese imports? Petsumer Report tells the ‘rest of the story’ on over 5,000 cat foods, dog foods, and pet treats. 30 Day Satisfaction Guarantee. Click Here to preview Petsumer Report. www.PetsumerReport.com

2018listseal_B-small.png




The 2018 List
Susan’s List of trusted pet foods. Click Here to learn more.



Have you read Buyer Beware? Click Here

Cooking pet food made easy, Dinner PAWsible

Find Healthy Pet Foods in Your Area Click Here
 
HOLY :poop::censored::censored::censored::censored:

mail


Did Champion Pet Food use the same ingredient supplier as Gravy Train?
By Susan Thixton
- December 3, 2018
170Casey.png

A Freedom of Information Act request provided by FDA seems to disclose Gravy Train Pet Food and Champion Pet Food used the same ingredient supplier.

When the lawsuit against Champion Pet Food was updated to include the risk of pentobarbital in Orijen and/or Acana pet foods, a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request was sent to FDA. The FOIA request was just provided, and although it was heavily redacted – it seems to indicate that Champion Pet Food and Gravy Train Pet Food used the same ingredient supplier.

And as it turned out, even though both pet foods contained pentobarbital – FDA forced Gravy Train to recall yet allowed Champion to silently pull products from store shelves.

A little background information:

  • Gravy Train Pet Food initiated a pet food withdrawal on February 14, 2018 after television station WJLA of Washington, D.C. found pentobarbital in 9 of 15 cans of Gravy Train dog food.
  • On February 23, 2018, Smucker’s Gravy Train releases a statement that the source of the pentobarbital was “animal fat” ingredient in the pet foods.
  • About two weeks later, FDA reclassified Smucker’s Gravy Train withdrawal into an official recall.
Gravy Train did not disclose the name of the pentobarbital “animal fat” supplier, but a lawsuit against the company did. Quoting the updated lawsuit complaint against Smucker’s Gravy Train (bold added for emphasis):

“Defendant claims that the source of contaminated tallow comes from one supplier—JBS USA Holdings, Inc. (a subsidiary of JBS S.A.) and its rendering facility MOPAC located in eastern Pennsylvania (collectively, “JBS”).”

Quoting the FDA Establishment Inspection Report of Champion Pet Food (bold added for emphasis):

“A for-cause inspection of this pet food manufacturer was initiated per the request of CVM in reference to adulterated beef tallow containing pentobarbital that was distributed by [redacted], received by the firm.”

“On 5/16/2018, Investigator Caitlin L. Almonrode and I arrived at Champion Petfoods USA, Inc.“

“I (FDA) informed management their firm was identified as a recipient of at least two contaminated shipments of beef tallow containing pentobarbital that was purchased from [redacted]. Ms. Flowers (Champion Pet Food) explained they received notification in person from [redacted] on Tuesday, May 8th, 2018 that three lots of beef tallow were contaminated.”

“Ms. Flowers (Champion Pet Food) provided copies of shipping documents including COA (Certificate of Analysis), Tank Cleaning Verification, and Bills of Lading for Beef Tallow lots 20, 21, and 22 (Exhibit 1). Per Ms. Flowers [redacted] included Lot 22 in their notification because laboratory results were still pending and it was top loaded on lot 21 when received at the firm. [redacted] also provided a list of beef tallow shipments received at the firm from [redacted] since January 2017-present (Exhibit 2). The firm did not receive the notification letter from Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture per Ms. Flowers (Attachment 1). I provided a copy of the letter to her for their purposes.”

There is the connection…“notification letter from Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture”. JBS USA Holdings, Inc. rendering facility that sold pentobarbital contaminated “animal fat” to Smucker’s Gravy Train was located in “eastern Pennsylvania.” When that pentobarbital contaminated pet food issue was investigated, regulatory authorities required JBS USA to disclose all companies that received the illegal fat ingredient. We can assume – from that investigation, Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture notified Champion Pet Food they too received pentobarbital contaminated “beef tallow”.

Note the above quote from the FOIA Champion Pet Food inspection report states the contaminated fat ingredient was “top loaded” at the Kentucky Champion Pet Food facility. This means the contaminated fat was unloaded onto the “top” of the container of existing fat. Thus, the known pentobarbital contaminated fat contaminated the existing fat in the storage bin.

Also note the above quote from the FOIA states Champion Pet Food had been purchasing fat from this supplier – the same supplier that sold to Gravy Train – “since January 2017.”

Quote from FOIA:

“Per Ms. Flowers, the firm received its tallow solely from [redacted]. She provided an Ingredient Specification Form-Fats and Oils for Beef Fat that outlines specifications for the beef tallow (Exhibit 3). Ms. Flowers explained the beef tallow obtained from [redacted] is received on a COA and is supposed to be sourced from [redacted] and therefore, pentobarbital was not identified as a potential hazard. Ms. Flowers admitted that while [redacted] is fully aware of this requirement there is no written agreement. She stated this is something they have overlooked and will be a requirement for future shipments of beef tallow.”

Surprisingly, Champion Pet Food admitted to FDA they had no “written agreement” with the fat supplier to assure quality of the ingredient.

Quote from FOIA:

“I (FDA) asked corporate management if a Reportable Food Registry (RFR) had been filed and in response [redacted] explained that one had not been filed because the firm didn’t feel the reported levels of pentobarbital was high enough to cause a health risk and based on previous FDA cases and reports.”

Champion pet food did NOT report the pentobarbital contaminated fat to FDA.

Quote from FOIA:

“On 5/23/2018, a close-out meeting was held with firm management. Mr. Wagner reported [redacted] pounds of affected dog food was further distributed to the store/consumer level.”

Shockingly – pentobarbital contaminated Champion Pet Food was distributed to “consumer level” – but no recall was issued.

To read the full FDA FOIA request, Click Here. Note – the Exhibits and Attachments mentioned on page 5 were not provided by FDA.

FYI: An email was sent to Champion Pet Food 12/2/2018 asking about their supplier. As of publishing this post – Champion Pet Food has not responded.



Significant.

The pentobarbital contaminated fat sold to Gravy Train Pet Food and Champion Pet Food was a rendered ingredient. This means the fat was obtained by grinding and cooking euthanized animals. The fat that rises to the top of the rendered euthanized animal mix becomes “animal fat” (when there is a mix of species) or “beef fat” (when only cattle). When the rat is removed, the remains becomes meat and bone meal or beef meal pet food ingredients. The meat and bone meal and the beef meal produced at the VERY SAME time the contaminated fat was produced would be just as contaminated with pentobarbital.

But there have been no recalls or notifications from FDA or Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture about pentobarbital contaminated meat and bone meal or beef meal ingredients?

Quoting the JBS USA “rendering” webpage (confirmed supplier to Gravy Train and suspect supplier to Champion Pet Food): “JBS USA also has a full rendering facility, MOPAC®, located in eastern Pennsylvania. MOPAC is one of the largest renderers on the East Coast, with more than 125 years of industry experience.” How many pet foods have been contaminated with pentobarbital in meal ingredients with NO WARNING to pet owners?


Why?

Why did FDA force Gravy Train Pet Food to recall of their pentobarbital contaminated pet foods – when they did not force Champion Pet Food to recall? Champion pet food admitted to FDA “affected dog food was further distributed to the store/consumer level.” Why would there be such a double standard for pentobarbital contaminated pet food?

Why didn’t Champion Pet Food alert consumers to the potential risk when they learned of it in May of 2018? Champion only admitted to the pentobarbital contaminated pet food AFTER an updated lawsuit was filed in November 2018 citing the pentobarbital contamination. Wouldn’t it have been better for Champion to come clean with consumers about the pentobarbital contaminated fat right when they learned it?

What other pet foods purchased fat or rendered meat meal ingredients from JBS USA Holdings, Inc?

Is the FDA ever going to stop this? A pentobarbital euthanized animal in pet food (any food) is a direct violation of federal law? When will law be enforced?

How many pets have to die from contaminated illegal ingredient pet food?



AssociationforTruthinPetFood.com – our pet owner stakeholder organization – is still waiting for response from FDA to a Citizen Petition submitted in October of 2016 asking FDA to finally enforce law in pet food. Click Here to view our documents sent to FDA. FDA has never responded.

AssociationforTruthinPetFood.com asked FDA on October 18, 2018 for a public meeting with pet owners. We want to give pet owners the opportunity to speak with FDA directly. But…FDA has never responded.

Something has to change. The insanity of dangerous illegal pet food ingredients – the insanity of the system of illegal pet food ingredient definitions and law making (pet owners denied public access) – has to stop.

Wishing you and your pet(s) the best,

Susan Thixton
Pet Food Safety Advocate
Author Buyer Beware, Co-Author Dinner PAWsible
TruthaboutPetFood.com
Association for Truth in Pet Food

atpfbannersmall-295x120.jpg

Become a member of our pet food consumer Association. Association for Truth in Pet Food is a a stakeholder organization representing the voice of pet food consumers at AAFCO and with FDA. Your membership helps representatives attend meetings and voice consumer concerns with regulatory authorities. Click Here to learn more.

What’s in Your Pet’s Food?
Is your dog or cat eating risk ingredients? Chinese imports? Petsumer Report tells the ‘rest of the story’ on over 5,000 cat foods, dog foods, and pet treats. 30 Day Satisfaction Guarantee. Click Here to preview Petsumer Report. www.PetsumerReport.com

List_Logo-Copy-300x291.png




The 2019 List
Susan’s List of trusted pet foods. Click Here to learn more.





Have you read Buyer Beware? Click Here

Cooking pet food made easy, Dinner PAWsible

Find Healthy Pet Foods in Your Area Click Here
 
Hrm... very interesting... it is amazing where the paper trail takes you.

I WILL say (not in defense of anyone or anything that has been done here) that often times, suppliers will provide ingredients/materials to all levels of manufacturing and labels. The generic Mac and Cheese you buy is often times with very similar or the same ingredients and from the same manufacturing facility as your fancy, brand name Mac and Cheese, for instance.

We've actually been reviewing FDA warning letters to companies that supply our company with ingredients and looking for red flags. When we find one, we call them out on it. A lot of places aren't doing this, yet, and probably not pet food.

I actually don't see the Gravy Train recall notice on the FDA's website so not sure what they're referencing in the article. There is an article that says the FDA is alerting people to the possible presence of pentobarbital in Gravy Train, but I don't believe they issued an actual RECALL for it (in 2018, anyway - Milos' Kitchen owned by Smuckers had one for elevated levels of beef thyroid hormone but no mention of pentobarbital). So the part about them NOT issuing a recall with Champion while they had with another company does not seem true. A VOLUNTARY recall is not issued or handled by the FDA.

This article, from a few days ago, says that Champion ceased using the material once they were aware of it, tested their retains and products that had been shipped for the presence of pentobarbital and received negative results. If that were the case and they could prove it, the FDA would have no reason to alert consumers about Champion pet food as they did with Gravy Train. In fact, I believe they would react the same way with a human food manufacturing facility. If one of our facilities was known to have received in materials from a supplier that caused a recall with another company, they would absolutely show up and do an investigation and determine if it had been handled properly or if more action needed to be taken. Should Champion had been more up-front about it? Probably.

Again, I'm only going based of what the FDA site shows me and recalls they've initiated are all in the system for anyone with the internet to see.

All the VIT D recalls are in there, though (again, probably one supplier that sells to multiple companies that make several labels).

VIT D.webp

I'm not trying to take a side or prove or disprove anything. I just get curious and go on a fact finding spree!
 
Its strange that Champion did not have any contract with this supplier. They have contracts with all of their farmers and fisherman that supply all of their ingredients. I thing someone :censored: up!

Also the FDA does not enforce some of their laws like allowing road kill and euthanized animals in pet foods.

FDA Recall of Gravy Train and others February 16, 2018 link below

FDA Alerts Pet Owners About Potential Pentobarbital Contamination in Canned Dog Food Manufactured by The J.M. Smucker Company, Including Certain Gravy Train, Kibbles ‘N Bits, Ol’ Roy, and Skippy Products

https://www.petful.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/fda_gov-ucm597135.pdf
 
Its strange that Champion did not have any contract with this supplier. They have contracts with all of their farmers and fisherman that supply all of their ingredients. I thing someone :censored: up!

Also the FDA does not enforce some of their laws like allowing road kill and euthanized animals in pet foods.

FDA Recall of Gravy Train and others February 16, 2018 link below

FDA Alerts Pet Owners About Potential Pentobarbital Contamination in Canned Dog Food Manufactured by The J.M. Smucker Company, Including Certain Gravy Train, Kibbles ‘N Bits, Ol’ Roy, and Skippy Products

https://www.petful.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/fda_gov-ucm597135.pdf

And... Sometimes we don't have "contracts' with suppliers too. *Sometimes* it's done on a PO bases but certainly not ideal and leaves the door open for sloppiness, yes. Also harder to get the supplier to pay up when they f*ck up!

I'm gonna look up that gravy train thing more tomorrow. Figure out why it's not listed on the actual recall site.
 
Well, I stand corrected! I really have no explanation for why that recall/document for Gravy Train isn't showing up on the list of recalls, though... I have more issue with that than anything else because that's where people go to get information on unsafe food and to see if the food in their house is part of the affected lots.

Reading thought the document of the FDA For Cause Inspection of Champion pet foods (again, not an unusual circumstance for the FDA to show up), it sounds like they did all the 'right' things when they discovered there was an issue. It's exactly what human food companies would do. The FDA visit required no further action and no 483s were issued so as far as the FDA was concerned, there was no reason to withdraw product.

I would even venture a guess that their lot tracking, receiving protocols, and sanitation programs were all very strong if they were able to confidently identify, track down, and test product AND show a clean break in between production runs to prevent cross contamination. Even without a contract with the supplier, they were receiving CoAs to ensure the product was within specification of whatever analysis they'd agreed on (and contract or not, you do NOT accept material in if a CoA is wanky). It's all redacted but if it's anything like normal bulk deliveries, they verify the BOL, check the CoAs and wash tickets, perhaps pull a sample and do their own in-house testing, and then inspect all the unloading pipes and magnets before and after unloading. They probably have an outdoor, jacketed silo where the new stuff gets pumped on top of the current stuff and, if they know what's good for them, have done analysis on how the liquids mix in the silo so have expanded their trace program to accommodate for that.

I see Ms Amanda Flowers worked at Blue Buffalo for a brief period in 2013. Perhaps she didn't like what she saw and got the heck out. I've been saying it for years that no way could anyone pay me enough to be a QA manager in any plant, these days.

Again, should Champion have been more up-front with their customers? Just a "Hey, we received this same ingredient but we've identified product with the potential to be contaminated, we tested it, it all came back negative, but we're going to pull it anyway just for warm, feel-good, fuzzies."? Probably. Have companies knowingly lied about test results and purposely sent harmful product to the market? Absolutely (anyone remember Peanut Corporation of America and their bird sh*t peanut butter? Those guys are rotting in jail). Is there an issue with them making unsafe food and the FDA turning a blind eye and letting it go to market and playing favorites with companies? I don't think so.

Looking through the FDA wesbite, I can't find any 483s issued to MOPAC in Souderton, PA (part of the JBS brand) but I do see that JBS also owns Pilgrim Pride Chicken which has had their fair share of recalls. I also can't find any inspection reports for Big Heart or Smuckers in regards to their Bloomsburg plant. Shucks!

I quite enjoy internet sleuthing FDA files :thumbsup:
 
It seems there are quite a few of them with the Vitamin D issue these days. I doubt it's really new but people are just finding or digging up more things these days.
 
Well, I stand corrected! I really have no explanation for why that recall/document for Gravy Train isn't showing up on the list of recalls, though... I have more issue with that than anything else because that's where people go to get information on unsafe food and to see if the food in their house is part of the affected lots.

Reading thought the document of the FDA For Cause Inspection of Champion pet foods (again, not an unusual circumstance for the FDA to show up), it sounds like they did all the 'right' things when they discovered there was an issue. It's exactly what human food companies would do. The FDA visit required no further action and no 483s were issued so as far as the FDA was concerned, there was no reason to withdraw product.

I would even venture a guess that their lot tracking, receiving protocols, and sanitation programs were all very strong if they were able to confidently identify, track down, and test product AND show a clean break in between production runs to prevent cross contamination. Even without a contract with the supplier, they were receiving CoAs to ensure the product was within specification of whatever analysis they'd agreed on (and contract or not, you do NOT accept material in if a CoA is wanky). It's all redacted but if it's anything like normal bulk deliveries, they verify the BOL, check the CoAs and wash tickets, perhaps pull a sample and do their own in-house testing, and then inspect all the unloading pipes and magnets before and after unloading. They probably have an outdoor, jacketed silo where the new stuff gets pumped on top of the current stuff and, if they know what's good for them, have done analysis on how the liquids mix in the silo so have expanded their trace program to accommodate for that.

I see Ms Amanda Flowers worked at Blue Buffalo for a brief period in 2013. Perhaps she didn't like what she saw and got the heck out. I've been saying it for years that no way could anyone pay me enough to be a QA manager in any plant, these days.

Again, should Champion have been more up-front with their customers? Just a "Hey, we received this same ingredient but we've identified product with the potential to be contaminated, we tested it, it all came back negative, but we're going to pull it anyway just for warm, feel-good, fuzzies."? Probably. Have companies knowingly lied about test results and purposely sent harmful product to the market? Absolutely (anyone remember Peanut Corporation of America and their bird sh*t peanut butter? Those guys are rotting in jail). Is there an issue with them making unsafe food and the FDA turning a blind eye and letting it go to market and playing favorites with companies? I don't think so.

Looking through the FDA wesbite, I can't find any 483s issued to MOPAC in Souderton, PA (part of the JBS brand) but I do see that JBS also owns Pilgrim Pride Chicken which has had their fair share of recalls. I also can't find any inspection reports for Big Heart or Smuckers in regards to their Bloomsburg plant. Shucks!

I quite enjoy internet sleuthing FDA files :thumbsup:


This is also why I sign up for recalls on a couple of other sites. Truth About Pet Food (Susan Thixton) is an awesome pet food advocate and she would go to AFFCO meetings. Also signed up for recalls on the Dog Food Advisor site. Both will have FDA links about the recall.
 
This is also why I sign up for recalls on a couple of other sites. Truth About Pet Food (Susan Thixton) is an awesome pet food advocate and she would go to AFFCO meetings. Also signed up for recalls on the Dog Food Advisor site. Both will have FDA links about the recall.

You can even sign up on the FDA and USDA sites directly! I get all the human and dog food recalls.

I actually just saw JBS is in the middle of a 12 MILLION pound beef recall :facepalm:

It seems there are quite a few of them with the Vitamin D issue these days. I doubt it's really new but people are just finding or digging up more things these days.

Unfortunately it's the same with a lot of human food. People weren't worried about E. coli O157:H7 in beef until Jack in the Box in the 90s; people assumed raw sprouts, spinach, and romaine lettuce were safe until children were in the hospital with failing kidneys and going septic; people didn't consider infant formula a target until a Chinese ingredient supplier started cutting the milk powder with fillers to falsely increase the protein content and make a few extra bucks; people weren't looking at listeria in nuts until one of the largest suppliers of sunflower seeds recalled a years worth of product that had been distributed to dozens of customers and used in possibly hundreds of finished products.

It seems it takes an incident to make change or to start looking at ingredients differently. This time, it's pentobarbital in beef tallow. Even the FDA document states that Champion assumed, with assurance from the supplier I'm sure, that the beef was from viable sources so pentobarbital wasn't taken into consideration in their ingredient risk assessment. One of the biggest changes with FSMA is the Supplier Approval process and making sure your ingredients are safe and wholesome throughout the supply chain. Unfortunately, there are bad people who do bad things and willingly put people and pets lives in danger. Luckily, I've worked with far more people who care than who don't.

If I go into a facility and would not eat anything out of that facility or if management seems clueless, I do everything in my pion power to make sure we do not do business with them and make sure I document it.

I get to talking about my love/hate relationship with the food industry and apparently can't stop! :pullhair:
 

Back
Top