Herm Sprenger Neck Tech

DoubleDogDare

Hot Topics Subscriber
Hi. I looked these collars up on the forum, and saw a couple of threads about them, and even a good picture. But they were somewhat older threads. So I thought I'd launch the same question, and see if anyone has new opinions on, or new experience with, the Herm Sprenger Neck Tech collars.

Dylan is super sensitive, and I have yet to make a true correction with his prong collar. Usually just a twitch of the lead does the job. So if the Neck Tech is a bit less effective for corrections, that's not a problem for us. He's very attentive, but not always completely focused. But for some reason, on the flat collar, he's an idiot. He goes from obedient to iditarod in three seconds flat. So I do need some sort of training collar. But I wanted something smaller and less than the regular prong. Plus, I like the idea that the appearance isn't so stereotypical "bad dog".

So if anyone has opinions and/or comments, I would love to hear it. Also, I would LOVE more photos, if anyone has one! Thanks!!
 
Hi. I looked these collars up on the forum, and saw a couple of threads about them, and even a good picture. But they were somewhat older threads. So I thought I'd launch the same question, and see if anyone has new opinions on, or new experience with, the Herm Sprenger Neck Tech collars.

Dylan is super sensitive, and I have yet to make a true correction with his prong collar. Usually just a twitch of the lead does the job. So if the Neck Tech is a bit less effective for corrections, that's not a problem for us. He's very attentive, but not always completely focused. But for some reason, on the flat collar, he's an idiot. He goes from obedient to iditarod in three seconds flat. So I do need some sort of training collar. But I wanted something smaller and less than the regular prong. Plus, I like the idea that the appearance isn't so stereotypical "bad dog".

So if anyone has opinions and/or comments, I would love to hear it. Also, I would LOVE more photos, if anyone has one! Thanks!!
I knew it.....there had to be that Iditarod gene imbedded deep in their brain. Callie does the same thing with a flat collar. Callie's neck doesn't seem as sensetive as what you describe of Dylan's neck but I too would like to hear of anyone who has used one.

Cya
 
Each dog is different and if he is super sensitive to you then it might be workable. You can always move up if you need more control but it is much harder to back up if you over corrected and created an issue.
 
ive got the neck tech and a prong collar the neck tech is not half as affective but it still does the job i just brought it as a sort of in-between collar as it works better than just a flat collar but not as good as a prong collar
 
I personally will only use prongs. You can always adjust how hard you make the correction. I just bought an all black sprenger prong, and man do I love it. Blends in with the coat, no quick release so I don't have to worry about that silly clamp popping loose.
 
I have the stainless steel version, and it looks nice on the dog. I prefer the prong collar over the Neck Tech though, because the correction is more adjustable (IMHO). I also have the black HS, but in the larger link size. I prefer the smaller prong as it lays on the dog so that it is barely noticeable and provides correction with just a wrist flick.

I order my prongs from this site, and Shannon adds the side release buckle to the HS collar.I have the Ultra Plus. (Just order a few more links for a larger neck)

Small stainless steel prong collar - $37.00Herm Sprenger
Ultra-Plus style: 9 links (6 removable), plus side release buckle - fits a 15" neck (approx.) before extra links are needed.Traditional style: 8 links (5 removable), plus side release buckle - fits a 14" neck (approx.) before extra links are needed

Herm Sprenger prong collars with side release, quick release buckle|Leashes by Design
 
P.S.
I also used this small prong HS on my previous dog. An 85 lb German Shepherd and it worked great, just added more prongs. I have arthritic hands and can not get the regular prongs apart, and the clip type of "quick release" HS occasionally released by accident. The buckle one I have been using has never released by accident.
 
You could try putting a bandanna over the prong collar so most people walking by would just see that.
 
HS also has a prong collar that we use that is flat on the top. It looks more like a watch band in stainless steel. It is great. No quick release.
 
I haven't tried a full prong so cannot comment on Neck Tech vs full prong but I can tell you that it does command respect from Ozzy when he's wearing it much more so that a choke chain (which I don't like using) or flat collar. Ozzy is not a sensitive dog however a flick of the wrist usually gets his attention and pulls him into line. The only time it has no impact is if he's going hell for leather for some dog he's taken a dislike to.

Here's a pic of him wearing his metal necklace. For some reason he's wearing it low when it should be much higher like in the lower photo

DSC_0389-XL.jpg


P1010799%20copy-X2.jpg
 
I meant to add that if you do go for the Neck Tech martingale, I'd advise you to go for the version with the carabinar hook like below. Cant comment on the type with a snap hook as I've not tried one

Neck_tech_release_new_11__33763_zoom.jpg


Do NOT buy this type, I've had one and it unexpectedly came apart very easily so not safe.

Neck%20Tech%20Sport%20Martingale.jpg
 
I am guessing for a more sensitive dog you won't have to worry about the neck tech being less effective. I'm not comfortable with giving hard corrections so often, as Ashra doesn't self-correct or even take notice of pops with a normal prong. (I now use a thick flat buckle collar with a handle for her, with an extra key chain on the D-ring to make a noise to get her attention when I jingle the leash)
 
I personally will only use prongs. You can always adjust how hard you make the correction. I just bought an all black sprenger prong, and man do I love it. Blends in with the coat, no quick release so I don't have to worry about that silly clamp popping loose.

Where did you buy a black prong? I would love to have it... How durable it is? Is it black metal or paint?
 
Where did you buy a black prong? I would love to have it... How durable it is? Is it black metal or paint?

Here is the link.

Black Sprenger Stainless Steel Prong Collar, Dog Training Collar, prong Collar : DogSport Gear

It is a sprenger so very very durable. I don't believe it is black metal, I think it is anodized black paint. I have vigorously used it since I bought it, and so far no wear marks. The anodized stuff tends to last a long long time.

This company had excellent prices, and shipping was very fast. I'd highly recommend them over the other places I have bought from.
 
It is a sprenger so very very durable. I don't believe it is black metal, I think it is anodized black paint. I have vigorously used it since I bought it, and so far no wear marks. The anodized stuff tends to last a long long time.

This company had excellent prices, and shipping was very fast. I'd highly recommend them over the other places I have bought from.


I also have a black HS prong and it has held up equally well!
 
OK, I've been meaning to get back to this thread now that I've had to use of a couple of HS prong collars for some time now. Compared to a neck tech, a full blown prong of either 4mm or 3.2mm works a lot better with my dog, he has way more respect for the prong, I have retired the neck tech.
 

Back
Top