• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Herm Sprenger black prong - sharp?

haunani

Member
I recently ordered a black Herm Sprenger collar from Redline K9 for my Kaia. When I received it, I noticed the ends of the prongs weren't as rounded as my stainless steel one. They're more blunt, with a "sharp" edge to them. The way Kaia responded when I briefly tried it on her showed me that she wasn't happy with it either.

Has anyone ever had this same issue with the black ones? Is it the specific model I got?

This is the one I ordered:

 
I have that exact one and they aren't any different from the other HS that I've had and my dog doesn't have any adverse reaction to it. Could you post a photo of the prongs?
 
That's what our trainer has too and I didn't notice any difference aside from the color. The link you posted doesn't work but I'd like to see a photo of the actual collor you got in case there was something defective.
 
Sorry for the delay and photo quality. My phone just did NOT want to focus on the prongs themselves. It was tough to get a picture to really show what I was feeling. In the clearer picture, you can't really see a difference at all, and in the more blurry one, you can kinda see how the black prong has a more blunt end with an edge rather than the smoother, rounded end of the stainless link.

51633225938_5344d7779c_w.jpg


51633225978_9ff780aefd_w.jpg
 
I have black HS for both of my Dobermans.
Love the HS prong.

I don’t think they are dull nor are sharp to a point. I do know that both Dobermans react very quickly to the prong sensation, which is exactly what I need it for.
 
My stainless prong is also an HS and I loved it. I would just use that one for class but I used the links in my keeper collar.

Her reaction to the black one is far more exaggerated than the stainless. Even a light correction had her yelping, which is NOT the type of reaction I'm going for. I want sensitivity, not pain.
 
In the bottom photo it looks like there might be some sort of a small burr on the black prong. I'm sure just a tiny bit of sanding would take it off.
 
They all feel that way, which is why I was wondering if it was just an individual bad collar, or a trend with their black ones. I'm glad to know it's just this collar that seems to have slipped through quality control.
 
I think if you are unhappy with the product there very well may be a poor product or two that comes out and that you should be able to return it for a new one. I had a black hermsprenger (that I've either misplaced or someone took) and it wasn't any different than the stainless. It does look like there is an edge to it on yours. It has the hermsprenger branding and everything?
 
I've never had to return anything to Redline, but I've purchased several things from them and I'm betting an inquiry asking for an exchange would be honored. I'm pretty sure I got my collar like yours from them and it has no sharp edges. Best of luck with the replacement - I love this collar and especially the black finish which just looks good on our dogs.
 

Back
Top