• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Ekg

jennmay25

New Member
T is 5 months. Our vet is pushing us to get a EKG, he said she sounds fine but to get one. I've read a few varying things, some saying 2 years if you aren't showing, some say each year, and I read one site who said your vet should be able to tell the difference simply by listening to the heart as they go through their puppy shots and the main differences from 4 months on. Any opinions or personal experiences? I love the assistants in our vet office but am not sure on the vet. He's answered all my questions but h e told us all the puppy shots need to be done by 16 weeks, which didn't sem right to me, but then when we went in for our last shots he said Bo both our dogs would need another set; easy $80 for him. Angain any help would be appreciated
 
An EKG? Holy smokes that sounds excessive for a dog that isn't showing any signs of a problem. I can't really comment on the puppy shots because I don't know what I'm talking about and because I think requirements vary from state to state and even for dogs that live in military housing.

If you are not sure about the vet, why not get a second opinion? Ask friends and co-workers for references and try out another vet.

An EKG... Did the medical malpractice lawyers get to this vet or what? Or maybe he just needs help paying off the fancy new machine in his office...
 
Here in FL, puppy shots are usually completed at 16 wks which is when they get their first Rabies shot also.

I'm not so sure about the EKG. If he says things sound fine, pushing an EKG makes no sense at all. If you plan to show or breed, I would recommend having a cardio check at about 1 yr of age and annually after that. At 5 mo, you can get away with an ultrasound to easy your mind to make sure everything is in good working order and less expensive.
Did he give you a reason for recommending an EKG?
 
16 weeks for the shots seem ok, but my vet suggested one more shot for my dobe because the breed is more susceptible to parvo etc. ( he is not one for excessive testing etc so I believe him). As far as EKG, I can not really say....but seems excessive for a dog not sowing problems.
 
$80 for two sets of shots?
i tink thats very expensive in the first place, about the EKG, if you thing it isn't nessasary, don't do it ;)
 
As far as the shots go the clinic where I work gives puppy vaccines at 8, 12, and 16 weeks (ideally) and for some breeds (Dobes and Rotts recommends an additional parvo vaccine at 20 weeks (Dobes and Rotts and a couple of other breeds don't always get good immunity from parvo vaccines--that's been well documented).

But the EKG is a little mystifying. The cardiologist I use for echo's and to read holters says that you'll give yourself coronaries doing a lot of cardiac testing on very young dogs. Immature hearts evidently will do things that would be very bad news in an adult dog but mean nothing in a puppy. His recommendation (other than the situation of a dog who is exhibiting symptoms of a cardiac condition) is that it would be good to do an EKG at 18 months in the form of a holter (a 24 hour EKG) and an echo at 2 years. This would generally give you a reliable base line for all future testing of the dog.

He also has recommended that dogs be echo'd every two years between 2 and 6 and yearly after that--if and when any abnormal readings occur he recommends echos every six months. Holters will give much more information than the usual 1 minute or 3 minute EKG's that are done in clinics. The recommendation is that holter be done on a yearly basis even in young dogs--this will give a heads up for treatment in a dog who is having arrhythmias. Arrhythmias are the main cause of sudden death in young Dobes.

If they are very bad they'll show up in a short EKG but you get a lot more information out of a holter. The local Dobe club here has two holter monitors which they rent at a very low price to club members. One is digital and a local vet has the software to read results for that one. The other in analog and you send the tape to Alba (the manufacturer of the monitor) to be read and they send a report which your vet or your cardiologist can look at.

But in the absence of symptoms I'd want an explanation from the vet about just WHY he wanted to do an EKG on the puppy. If he can't give an good understandable explanation I'd maybe think about finding a vet who was more informative or at least more in tune with what you need to know about exactly what is being done to and for your puppy.

Good luck.
 
Did he give you a reason for recommending an EKG?

When the vet suggested it, he said it was due to the breed having problems. They've sent us two mailings and called my husband multiple times. I just find it strange. We have to get a shot as we have to get borded next weekend and I think I may find another vet and see what they say.
Thanks for all the advise and comments!!
 

Back
Top