• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Don't Know What to Do

Cranekc35

Notable member
I need help. I have an 18 mo. old Euro/American. I do a lot of physical and mental stimulation with him. He's great in obedience training and picks up new tricks easy. Eager to learn. When he was 8 months I had him trained on the ecollar mainly because he kept coming at me with the nipping and jumping. I couldn't get him to stop. With that being said, he has the collar on any time he is out of the crate as a communication tool, not punishment. He has been great on it, but has become collar savvy. Last night, I left the remote inside because I really haven't had to use it for the past couple of months. He's being doing his commands without it and no more issues. He waits until I release him for food, through thresholds before loading up in the car, etc. I do all of the things I'm supposed to. Anyway, I left the remote inside and went to bring him outside for a bath. We use the hose and he loves the hose, so I always let him play for a few minutes then I place the leash on him to tie him to a pole on the deck so I can bathe him. Well, he wasn't having any part of this. He started growling at me, nipping at me, circling and barking me like he has done in the past knowing that I didn't have the remote with me. (Also, note that he had been up all day with family at our house. He had plenty of exercise and training throughout the day)

My question is: is this still because he is young and that light bulb goes off when he matures between 3 and 4 years as I keep reading and this behavior stops? Or maybe having a tantrum like a toddler because he was way too tired? Because he is AMAZING in public. He's the best dog when we are out. Or do I have a real problem on my hands?

The other question I have: is there something that I need to do differently to show him that I am in control and getting him to respect me without relying on the collar? I have some trainers coming in this week to help me, but looking for help here too. I have been very upset since this happened last night and don't know what to do.
 
Were they play growls? It kinda sounds like it with the other behaviors described. It sounds like you've done a great job with him! They love and need structure. I just think you may be ready to start fading out the ecollar in low distraction areas (inside the house) and with time work your way up. A great tip @Doberman Gang mentioned on here that he does with his boy (and I've done this with fading the prong collar for my girl) is to put the ecollar in your pocket. If they start acting up, the ecollar comes out and goes on. Rinse and repeat. They'll learn that at any time the ecollar can come out due to their behavior and that they are in control of it. Dogs learn so well when they think they are in control of a situation!
 
When I am bathing my dogs they have either their ecollar on or a prong collar with a tab to get hold off. My dogs are not allowed to test me. Does your dog have a capped position? (Sit or Down) these need to be taught for when they get over stimulated or are being disobedient. What you described above sounds kind of like rough play to me. Do you do any tug play with your dog for exercise? This can also help to teach capping behavior.
 
Were they play growls? It kinda sounds like it with the other behaviors described. It sounds like you've done a great job with him! They love and need structure. I just think you may be ready to start fading out the ecollar in low distraction areas (inside the house) and with time work your way up. A great tip @Doberman Gang mentioned on here that he does with his boy (and I've done this with fading the prong collar for my girl) is to put the ecollar in your pocket. If they start acting up, the ecollar comes out and goes on. Rinse and repeat. They'll learn that at any time the ecollar can come out due to their behavior and that they are in control of it. Dogs learn so well when they think they are in control of a situation!
True, that is how I fade training collars for competition. When at home especially for things I know my dog isn’t a big fan of, baths nail trimming ect…, I will give a sharp correction for bad behavior, Blaze pretty much always wears an ecollar. Most people have not seen true aggressive behavior. Lunging or snapping at a toy is more of mean game the dog plus because it hasn’t learned how to properly play yet. A dog that is barking and spinning is not being aggressive. An aggressive dog will not turn its back on you and will only be lunging forward to attack. An aggressive dog won’t just snap at you it will climb a leash and try to eat you. Most of the time I read posts like this it is just a need for training and the dog not understanding rules for the particular situation. Dogs will definitely push you to see where the boundaries are, this can then become a problem later if it is let go for too long. I get angry at times when I get dogs brought to me that have not been shown proper training or as I say humanized or babies to the point that now the owner can’t control them. It is not fair to put the dog into a situation where now it may have to learn some really hard lessons to understand things. It is not fair the dog has to go thru that when if train properly when it was young it would be more confident and happy knowing it’s place.
 
I'd simply say perhaps don't have the collar on him as often. I only put it on mine when the situations warrants. He sure does sound collar savvy, and I'd also say that it'd be helpful to work with him sans collar.

As mentioned, the type of growling makes a difference; but I'd say it just sounds like something my Dobes have never done. I guess I am rather stern and don't ever entertain foolishness.
 
Great advice so far!

I'd be curious and to Rit's point, was he 'playing?' Any sort of play bow or tail wagging, excitement that the hose was coming out? Or was it more the bark and hold, with a stiff body?

My girl doesn't get 'silly' too often but when she does, I really try to embrace it because it is so rare. She's pretty 'business' all the time (when she's not sleeping) because that's just her personality. She's definitely a barker when when she gets in this mood (it's a quick, high pitched bark, not her deep, booming "we're under attack" bark) but really only growls if she's playing tug with my other dog, never at me.

Or, as you stated, he could've been just REALLY tired; sounds like he had quite a day!

Don't be too hard on yourself as it sounds like you do a lot of work with and spend a lot of time with him.
 
Were they play growls? It kinda sounds like it with the other behaviors described. It sounds like you've done a great job with him! They love and need structure. I just think you may be ready to start fading out the ecollar in low distraction areas (inside the house) and with time work your way up. A great tip @Doberman Gang mentioned on here that he does with his boy (and I've done this with fading the prong collar for my girl) is to put the ecollar in your pocket. If they start acting up, the ecollar comes out and goes on. Rinse and repeat. They'll learn that at any time the ecollar can come out due to their behavior and that they are in control of it. Dogs learn so well when they think they are in control of a situation!
I'm pretty sure it was play with him running around, etc.
 
When I am bathing my dogs they have either their ecollar on or a prong collar with a tab to get hold off. My dogs are not allowed to test me. Does your dog have a capped position? (Sit or Down) these need to be taught for when they get over stimulated or are being disobedient. What you described above sounds kind of like rough play to me. Do you do any tug play with your dog for exercise? This can also help to teach capping behavior.
I'm assuming "capped" position means that they listen to the sit or down command while overstimulated or disobedient? if that is the case, no. Not sure how to do that. Could you please elaborate because when he gets like that, I am staying calm and tell him to sit or down and he just continues his antics. Yes, tug is one of his favorite things to do. I do play this with him quite a bit.
 
Great advice so far!

I'd be curious and to Rit's point, was he 'playing?' Any sort of play bow or tail wagging, excitement that the hose was coming out? Or was it more the bark and hold, with a stiff body?

My girl doesn't get 'silly' too often but when she does, I really try to embrace it because it is so rare. She's pretty 'business' all the time (when she's not sleeping) because that's just her personality. She's definitely a barker when when she gets in this mood (it's a quick, high pitched bark, not her deep, booming "we're under attack" bark) but really only growls if she's playing tug with my other dog, never at me.

Or, as you stated, he could've been just REALLY tired; sounds like he had quite a day!

Don't be too hard on yourself as it sounds like you do a lot of work with and spend a lot of time with him.
Thank you. He was excited and playing, but the nipping, I can't control. There has been times where he will listen when I tell him to sit or down when he is like that, but that is only sometimes. I do a lot of work and spending time with him every day. That is what is so frustrating for me. I want to do right by him, just struggling with this part. Everything else, he's been right on point with.
 
He was excited and playing, but the nipping, I can't control. There has been times where he will listen when I tell him to sit or down when he is like that, but that is only sometimes.
There's a great conversation on this training thread titled "Managing the Defensive Doberman..." It's just a few titles past this one. DG gave some advise about getting the dog to a "10" in excitement and THEN make them down. I have a video on the last page where I get my dog as excited as possible then cap that into a down. So yes, the big take away for me was when DG said to get the dog amped up on purpose so you can cap at that level. It doesn't help that they can sit & down when they are at a level 3 of excitement. They have to learn to sit & down at a level 10. The lightbulb in my head just about exploded with that tidbit of information.
 
I'm assuming "capped" position means that they listen to the sit or down command while overstimulated or disobedient? if that is the case, no. Not sure how to do that. Could you please elaborate because when he gets like that, I am staying calm and tell him to sit or down and he just continues his antics. Yes, tug is one of his favorite things to do. I do play this with him quite a bit.
Playing tug will help with capping.
1-You play for a short time
2- out the tug
3- release the dog but make him miss by pulling the toy away from his grip.
4- I will usually make two or three missed them ask for a sit or down. As soon as they give you a calm sit or down you release them then let them bite the tug and play again. The misses and capping must be done randomly, do not follow a pattern or they will catch on to it.
 
There's a great conversation on this training thread titled "Managing the Defensive Doberman..." It's just a few titles past this one. DG gave some advise about getting the dog to a "10" in excitement and THEN make them down. I have a video on the last page where I get my dog as excited as possible then cap that into a down. So yes, the big take away for me was when DG said to get the dog amped up on purpose so you can cap at that level. It doesn't help that they can sit & down when they are at a level 3 of excitement. They have to learn to sit & down at a level 10. The lightbulb in my head just about exploded with that tidbit of information.
wow! thanks for this!
 
Playing tug will help with capping.
1-You play for a short time
2- out the tug
3- release the dog but make him miss by pulling the toy away from his grip.
4- I will usually make two or three missed them ask for a sit or down. As soon as they give you a calm sit or down you release them then let them bite the tug and play again. The misses and capping must be done randomly, do not follow a pattern or they will catch on to it.
thank you so much! I will let you know how it goes.
 
When I am bathing my dogs they have either their ecollar on or a prong collar with a tab to get hold off.
Same, although they like to bath, they sometimes get too playful. I specifically ordered waterproof ecollars for bathing.
Tbh, it seems like he is still testing the boundaries, so maybe it is too early to take off the e collar.
 

Back
Top