Dogfight!

I have been watching videos and reading articles because I know how crucial it is to have a proper fit, and this concerned me:

"It is dangerous to use a prong collar as your primary walking collar. Dogs learn by association. If, in the long term, your dog learns to associate pain with pulling he'll also learn to associate negativity with events that cause him to pull. Most friendly dogs pull in response to seeing other people and animals. If a prong collar is used on every walk, your dog will learn to associate people and animals with pain. With time, he'll become timid and even aggressive in the presence of others and might even begin growling and biting."

I don't want to make the problem worse by making him fearful or people-aggressive...
I disagree with this. Any collar can cause pain, even the flat ones. So, if your dog minds his manners when people approach then he won't have to feel the collar. No dog should start pulling the leash when other people approach that is poor behavior. They should sit there calmly and be polite.

I mean picture that in your head: you go to pet smart, your dog walks calmly in heel position beside you, sits when you stop and walks with you when you move again, and because the collar has been used properly he knows what is expected of him and you never even have to engage the collar...

Now picture your in pet smart and your dog is happy to see new people and he pulls at a flat collar in his exuberance, you pull back, he's a wagging ball of excitement, he pulls more, you pull more, dog is choking, stranger is scared of the Doberman lunging at him....

Which scenario is better? I much prefer a well mannered dog, and I think Dobermans have to be even better mannered than a poodle/golden/lab because they can be intimidating and they have a tough reputation.
 
You can't worry about what other people think. What's more important ? Their opinion that is probably an uneducated one or the health of your dog and home life ? and if that were true id have the most aggressive dog ever. The prong saved my sheps life and many here can tell you how great my Doberman is.

?? I'm not at all worried what anyone thinks. I'm worried about the prong collar making my dog become people-aggressive as this article stated.
 
I don't think anyone is saying your old dog was fighting back. That said, animals are great readers of body language, a flip of the ear, a turn in posture, even how they look at each other can be defiance. So while after the fight started the elder dog was submissive, I'm guessing he did something to tell the puppy to stop humping him. (As he has every right to do).

This is where everyone is talking about "who is alpha". If you are alpha they won't quaral because they know it isn't something their leader will put up with.

Working breeds like Dobermans, rotties, Akitas, are not naturally submissive dogs (as a whole). They need that drive tondo what they were bred to do. However, in a house situation, they see you, your family and your other dog as their "pack" and they try to establish their rank. Again, this is where you need to be alpha.

Just following sit/down/stay isn't you being alpha. I second a new trainer who has more experience with working breeds. Your dog is trying to figure out where he fits in the pack and he needs to know that his rank is below all humans and equal with your other dog, and that you will squash him for trying to hurt your other dog.

Once a dog is in that "I see red" zone, they aren't going to stop without major intervention, and even after they will be majorly keyed up. Learning your dog and how to handle your dog and how to establish dominance over your dog is imperative to them all getting along. Everyone here has great advice but every animal is different so a hands on trainer is the way to go. :)

Thank you so much...very informative.
Can you please expand on this for me:

"Again, this is where you need to be alpha. Just following sit/down/stay isn't you being alpha."

We make him wait to eat until we say it's ok, we make him wait to enter or exit a doorway until we have all gone first and tell him ok, we make him wait until we give the ok before we will throw a ball, we do not allow him on the furniture or our beds....what else do we do to establish ourselves as alpha?
 
?? I'm not at all worried what anyone thinks. I'm worried about the prong collar making my dog become people-aggressive as this article stated.
That article is false, as I said if that were true id have the worst Doberman ever. Here is a clear example of how false that article is, and is probably written by an AR nut. I do not know this child or mother, my Dobe clearly has his prong on and was clearly totally fine with both of them, my Doberman has not grown up with children either, this is called a well mannered and respectful dog who can handle any situation. image.webp
 
Thank you so much...very informative.
Can you please expand on this for me:

"Again, this is where you need to be alpha. Just following sit/down/stay isn't you being alpha."

We make him wait to eat until we say it's ok, we make him wait to enter or exit a doorway until we have all gone first and tell him ok, we make him wait until we give the ok before we will throw a ball, we do not allow him on the furniture or our beds....what else do we do to establish ourselves as alpha?
Walking properly is one of the best ways to establish a clear order that's why I asked how he walked. If he's pulling you all over the place and not minding his manners it clearly states that he isn't respecting you. The only time my dogs are in front of me is when tracking or hiking, but I give the go ahead. Structured walks are a huge role establisher. I also think you need to seriously consider a not strictly pos only trainer. Pos only should only be used when they are tiny pups, now you have a dog that's never had a correction so why respect anyone, when he can get away with anything ? Especially during his Doberteens period where he will be testing you and your authority.
 
Walking properly is one of the best ways to establish a clear order that's why I asked how he walked. If he's pulling you all over the place and not minding his manners it clearly states that he isn't respecting you. The only time my dogs are in front of me is when tracking or hiking, but I give the go ahead. Structured walks are a huge role establisher. I also think you need to seriously consider a not strictly pos only trainer. Pos only should only be used when they are tiny pups, now you have a dog that's never had a correction so why respect anyone, when he can get away with anything ? Especially during his Doberteens period where he will be testing you and your authority.

Thank you, this is great info. We started with the no-pull harnesses (the training facility we chose required a harness that hooks at the chest for his last class) and he just yanks so hard on them that he completely frayed one out and it had to be replaced. I just switched to the Gentle Leader head collar as he was so strong and making walks unpleasant with the supposed "no pull" harness, and that helped me to manage him but he still pulls. He puts his head down and barges forward with it anyway.

I know everyone is saying to find a new trainer - I don't know if it's the area of the country I'm in or what but they all seem to stress positive reinforcement only. The class I just paid for at a highly reputable facility about 30 mins from my house starts this weekend and costs $150 which I don't think I can get refunded...they won't let me anywhere near that place with a prong collar. :/ Other options are Petco and Petsmart which I wouldn't do. I don't know of any training facilities in my area that don't use only positive reinforcement.
 
Ive watched a bunch of videos and am eager to start leash training again with some new methods.

The way we were taught to do it in his last class was with treats and clicking so he learned very quickly to snatch his treat and THEN barge ahead, then run back to a perfect heel for the second it takes to get his treat, then lunge forward again. We've never been able to get out of that cycle.

For exercise every day I just load him into my car and take him to a ball field or out in the woods and let him run and play fetch. Leashed walks too but not every day as I've always been more focused on trying to get him physical exercise. So we don't do a lot of leash walking. That's about to change.
 
Thank you, this is great info. We started with the no-pull harnesses (the training facility we chose required a harness that hooks at the chest for his last class) and he just yanks so hard on them that he completely frayed one out and it had to be replaced. I just switched to the Gentle Leader head collar as he was so strong and making walks unpleasant with the supposed "no pull" harness, and that helped me to manage him but he still pulls. He puts his head down and barges forward with it anyway.

I know everyone is saying to find a new trainer - I don't know if it's the area of the country I'm in or what but they all seem to stress positive reinforcement only. The class I just paid for at a highly reputable facility about 30 mins from my house starts this weekend and costs $150 which I don't think I can get refunded...they won't let me anywhere near that place with a prong collar. :/ Other options are Petco and Petsmart which I wouldn't do. I don't know of any training facilities in my area that don't use only positive reinforcement.


I would look into kennel clubs in your area. They might be able to direct you to someone who trains. Around here there are AKC kennel clubs for Median County, Lorain County, Richland County, and I think a Portage County. They probably won't help with this type of issue, but they will be able to direct you to someone locally who can help. And they usually hold weekly meetings where you can work obedience, agility and conformation.
 
. I'm worried about the prong collar making my dog become people-aggressive as this article stated.



IMHO, the only way a prong is going to make a dog aggressive is a prong that is not properly used. A prong used correctly simply tells the dog...hmm, I better knock that crap off. Have you seen dobies play? Put the prong on yourself after you have learned to use and you will see what I am saying is true.

A doberman is a dominate breed. It takes a strong, firm leader to successfully own a dobe. Dobermans are not aggressive, however they are protective and there is a difference. I am currently on my 3rd dobe and my last 2 are/were successful therapy dogs. Properly trained and socialized with a great pack leader, they are amazing dogs.

It is situations like this that caused us to have to deal with BSL. Amazing dogs paying the price for owning that don't step up to be the leader the dog needs.

I would read up on dominate dog behavior. Learn what you need to do to make this dog everything he can be. And by all means absolutely NO e collar until you have learned how and when to use it. I understand you are feeling overwhelmed by what you witnessed. Anybody would be, it's a very scary thing. But it does not mean it has to happen again. Listen to what was said here in this thread and learn from it. After you have had some time to recover and you read the advice given, I'm sure you will be able to see the signs of what went wrong and nip it in the bud before it ever happens. Invest your time and training in this dog (and you) and you will rewarded with the most incredible dog you have ever owned.
 
I am sorry you and your family had to go through this. It can be frightening and it can shatter the trust you had in your dog. You can get past this...the prong collar is an amazing, I am not kidding, amazing tool to help you establish control. You will see a difference immediately. I would continue on with your prepaid class and us the prong collar at home. I am on my 6th dobie, you can get past this.:thumbsup2:
 
Everyone covered everything else well. I personally would not use an ecollar in this case. It could only up the aggression if your boy thinks the stim is coming from the other dog. Find a trainer that knows how to use one. I also would never leave them out together now without having 100% attention on them. You will have to either crate and rotate or put them in separate rooms when you can't watch them.

So sorry this happened. The breed is known for same sex aggression. Is your older dog okay?
 
He really does seem to know his place when it comes to us humans, but after today I am afraid he's going to kill my other dog or my cat. Do I need to worry about this behavior transferring onto my kids?
He is a teenager that is starting at the bottom and trying to work his way up...I think the cat will be fine (that's prey drive not dominance) and as long as you and the kids continue to stay dominant over him that should be fine as well. Now the other dog is another story. I would not leave them alone at all, I would be supervising (like right up in it) when they were together. Any over sniffing, ANYTHING, I would nip it in the bud (from the dobie) I might even suggest leashing him to you when both dogs are out. Just to show him who runs the show. My main concern with the children is getting caught in the middle of a dog fight. Hyper diligence is the key in these situations.
 
The prong collar when used correctly is not cruel. As for an e collar, I use mine for working on recall and excessive barking with verbal commands. I certainly did not mean to imply to use it to break up a fight only as a recall method before he gets in a red zone. A trainer should show you how to use a prong and a e collar before you try one.
Learn to read your dog's body language and that will be key in preventing issues.

As for walking your dog. My trainer told me to be sure to work their minds with the sit, down, stay training in my driveway before ever taking them for a walk .
They see the walk as fun and want to do that and blow off the training. Work, then reward. You don't always have to give treats. Praise works well too.
I know when mine tugged on the lead I would turn and walk in opposite direction, then make them sit, take 7-8 steps, make them sit, then walk in circles one way then walk circles the opposite way. This way their attention has to be on you.
Like everyone has said an e collar is used after the dogs has learned to follow your commands on a prong and flat lead.
Control the head, control the dog.
You can do this, it just takes work where you are the boss.

I think my two least tolerable things with a dog is pulling on lead and excessive barking over nothing.
 
Thank you!
I have more to say but quick question about the prong collar: when walking with it, do the dogs still get pleasure out of their walk when they are glued to your side or is it pretty much a training session the entire time? Do they still get to stop and sniff trees and enjoy, once they understand that the collar means no pulling or lagging?
 
I am sorry you and your family had to go through this. It can be frightening and it can shatter the trust you had in your dog.
He is a teenager that is starting at the bottom and trying to work his way up...I think the cat will be fine (that's prey drive not dominance) and as long as you and the kids continue to stay dominant over him that should be fine as well. Now the other dog is another story. I would not leave them alone at all, I would be supervising (like right up in it) when they were together. Any over sniffing, ANYTHING, I would nip it in the bud (from the dobie) I might even suggest leashing him to you when both dogs are out. Just to show him who runs the show. My main concern with the children is getting caught in the middle of a dog fight. Hyper diligence is the key in these situations.
I, too, am sorry you have gone through this! Dog fights scare the bejebbers outta me! I don't want to experience it personally! Reading through your thread, you are getting some great advice and I agree with everyone. And I must say I am worried about your 'old guy'. I feel for him and agree that he need to be protected. Obviously your younger dog is full of himself now and probably feels he 'won', so that will be an issue. I would be watching him like a hawk around other animals and my children. Like @WiglWerm said, it would shatter my trust a bit. I think its a wake up call.

Have you ever watched the Dog Whisperer? It might help you get a grasp on being a Pack Leader. I think its a 'way of being' that takes time/experience to be able to pull off. I watched that show for a long time before I got what he was getting at. I remember one show where he told a woman to think of herself as Prom Queen. It kind of makes your head go up in pride just thinking of it, doesn't it? :) That's what he was trying to achieve! A tiny bit of 'stuck up'. LOL I know, it sounds funny, but he was trying to get her into a 'mode' of a proud woman in control. Like others have said, just making a dog sit (obey) before dinner isn't everything Pack Leader.

Another way I like to describe it is.......remember when you were a teen and you were caught by your mom coming home too late? The 'look' she gave you? That's Pack Leader! lol You knew by her stance, the look in her eye, her very demeanor that you were in trouble!! :tap: That demeanor needs to ooze out of you to be Pack Leader. Stand tall, put your hand on your hip if need be, BE the leader. You don't need to hit a dog to show dominance.

Thank you!
I have more to say but quick question about the prong collar: when walking with it, do the dogs still get pleasure out of their walk when they are glued to your side or is it pretty much a training session the entire time? Do they still get to stop and sniff trees and enjoy, once they understand that the collar means no pulling or lagging?
If you watch The Dog Whisperer you will see how important the walk is. Just like @AresMyDobie was saying, I believe the walk can be everything in teaching Pack Leader. There are and should be times for letting them sniff and run around. But when you are on a Walk, you should be walking briskly and they should be at your side. Not ahead of you (You are Leader after all! ;) ) not stopping to sniff or bark or engage in another animal. Its for exercise and to teaching respect. They still get a lot of pleasure out of it and the exercise they need! You can use specific times to be 'off'...for sniffing, peeing, playing...etc. But YOU say when.
 
Thank you!
I have more to say but quick question about the prong collar: when walking with it, do the dogs still get pleasure out of their walk when they are glued to your side or is it pretty much a training session the entire time? Do they still get to stop and sniff trees and enjoy, once they understand that the collar means no pulling or lagging?




A dog can absolutely enjoy a walk. In my case, my dogs learn 2 commands, "heel", meaning stay tight to my side, focused on me. I stop, you sit. Then we have "close", meaning stay close to me. No running off and certainly no pulling me down the street. They can sniff around, investigate a bit and just be dogs.
 
Tons of great advice here!!! I was trying to figure out how to put it in words as it isn't beating them (although they do need correction) it is an attitude, a manner, and how you interact with your dog. Body language and small test he gives you that you can pass or fail.

I will give you an example, my ex had a GSD, he left her here with me. She generally respected me as her alpha except when it came to my Min Pin and I could not let them out together for fear GSD would kill the min pin.

Well I met my fiance, and he adored my Min Pin but hated the GSD. He tried to work with her a bit, I didn't always agree with his ways but you know what, he was alpha and those two dogs got on just fine so long as one of us was around. So, it can be done, but it takes work and IMO takes the dogs knowing that damaging a pack member will end badly for them. I don't usually spank my son, but if he does something dangerous that could hurt him or someone else I spank, for everyone's protection. I'm not saying you'll need to beat your dog, but he has to learn whose really in control.

Will he have fun on a structured walk? Absolutely! You're working his mind and body. Plus, your his leader, so long as you've earned that roll nothing makes him happier then "rolling with his leader". That's what pack animals enjoy, being with their pack, they hate being away from them. If the leader says hey we are going this way, they go...
 
Since your guy likes to forge ahead to explore, you can ask him to heel beside you for a decent period of time and reward good heeling with loose leash walking ahead of you. Focus on getting good heels first and increase the distance he must heel beside you each time. Focused heeling can tire the brain but so can sniffing and exploring. Use both to your advantage :)
 

Back
Top