• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Does anyone know Immortal Dobermans?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Don't feel bad - it is one of the hardest things for people to sort out when reading the websites especially of new breeders who are greatly overcharging for their dogs when they have no track record.

There were several red flags a couple years ago we pointed out which only people who really know what they are doing would recognize but to those not well versed it all appears very impressive. In the guise of being nice it all fell on deaf ears.
 
Don't feel bad - it is one of the hardest things for people to sort out when reading the websites especially of new breeders who are greatly overcharging for their dogs when they have no track record.

There were several red flags a couple years ago we pointed out which only people who really know what they are doing would recognize but to those not well versed it all appears very impressive. In the guise of being nice it all fell on deaf ears.

I was taught to live and learn :D and I'm doing both til the day I die ;)
Thanks for responding :)
 
I do have a concern - why would you import dogs from Europe where health would be unknown to some extent???? I wonder if she is going to stand behind those dogs if things go wrong or say - I didn't breed them??? I think that would be scary - i would not want to put my name of dogs that I was not very familiar with up close and personal. Enough can go wrong when you know.
 
I'm sorry things are not working out, but she is a member here, I think she deserves the benefit of a doubt to explain herself before we start discrediting her breeding program.

immortaldobes
I agree. Hopefully she will respond. I hope this gets worked out for you agift4me, as I'm sure it's subtracting from your excitement of getting a puppy. IMHO she owes you your deposit back, or a puppy. If it were me I would go elsewhere due to lack of explanation alone.
 
I don't think explaining things that went on before and why we had concerns then is trying to discredit. Pointing out things that could be misleading is trying to help educate those that don't know. The OP said communication has stopped we pointed out some of our concerns earlier and she was a member then. Came on here to first advertise her litter from 2 dogs that were very young and no health testing or OFA. Now importing puppies from Europe and I am sure you will agree that puppy brokers are not the best for the breed.
 
I don't think explaining things that went on before and why we had concerns then is trying to discredit. Pointing out things that could be misleading is trying to help educate those that don't know. The OP said communication has stopped we pointed out some of our concerns earlier and she was a member then. Came on here to first advertise her litter from 2 dogs that were very young and no health testing or OFA. Now importing puppies from Europe and I am sure you will agree that puppy brokers are not the best for the breed.

That's fine, but my comment still applies. She deserves the same respect both you and I receive on this forum. Lets keep it about why the thread was originally created.
 
Evidently not well. She is a vet tech and I have found and it was so they think they know it all. Somedays it does pay to listen and I do understand new people wanting to quickly establish that they know something but usually it is all blow. She got quite upset here because she got the same advise here as elsewhere but we were nicer about it.
Ow I was hoping it wasn't that April. I hear from her occasionally, I was her secret santa this year and she is just a sweet girl, something must be wrong I will see if I can get hold of her. I know she has a super sweet personality and she has great integrity and character I would suspect something has happened. I will IM you if I get hold of her.

I am worried about her now :(
 
TBM - hopefully you can get hold of her and Agift4me gets her money back or gets a puppy. i know many of you were not around for the original discussions. No one tried to discredit anyone but we did point out some problems that existed as most breeders want a level of health testing done before jumping into breeding especially when both dogs are under two, from a puppy broker and that is usually frowned on. When things are posted on a web site that are misleading then that kind a puts it out there for anyone to read and comment on.

There is no test that guarantees cardio clear not even the PDK4 DNA test. It just says that you don't have one of the contributing factors but that you can still get DCM and die. To those that know it does seem that there is a pattern or string of things that throw up red flags. You always hope that they don't go the other way but experience has taught us some things and sadly it often proves true.
 
That's fine, but my comment still applies. She deserves the same respect both you and I receive on this forum. Lets keep it about why the thread was originally created.

Agreed.
 
I NEVER take a deposit from any puppy person until there are puppies on the ground and I know I have what they are looking for!! I think she should return the money to you and I would contact the AKC which I'm hoping she is a member.

I would not breed a bitch with so many health tests pending! All health tests are done prior to even choosing a stud dog. I hope she contacts you and does the honorable thing and returns your deposit. Good luck
 
TBM - hopefully you can get hold of her and Agift4me gets her money back or gets a puppy. i know many of you were not around for the original discussions. No one tried to discredit anyone but we did point out some problems that existed as most breeders want a level of health testing done before jumping into breeding especially when both dogs are under two, from a puppy broker and that is usually frowned on. When things are posted on a web site that are misleading then that kind a puts it out there for anyone to read and comment on.

There is no test that guarantees cardio clear not even the PDK4 DNA test. It just says that you don't have one of the contributing factors but that you can still get DCM and die. To those that know it does seem that there is a pattern or string of things that throw up red flags. You always hope that they don't go the other way but experience has taught us some things and sadly it often proves true.
I will let ya'll know if I get hold of her. Susan why is the age for males 2 years? I understand with the female because her body is not developed enough to reproduce but what is the reasoning behind males? I always intended to get Boris neutered at two because ya'll said so but I never asked why that is the age?
 
I will let ya'll know if I get hold of her. Susan why is the age for males 2 years? I understand with the female because her body is not developed enough to reproduce but what is the reasoning behind males? I always intended to get Boris neutered at two because ya'll said so but I never asked why that is the age?

The joints seal around that age so any x-rays of hips, and I believe elbows, are not accurate until 2 years old.
 
One of the reasons Mel is both breeding Males and females have to have hips cleared by the OFA. This test can't be performed until they are two years old
 
TBM mainly because they have not be OFA'd as well as other health testing. They are not considered mature so that means you don't know if they will prove out. While males can be bred at 1 year that is usually the BYB that do that because they are in a rush to make all that money!!!

While it is done occassionaly by good breeders to preserve a bloodline, etc but it is very risky for a new breeder and both dog being under two. Most health issues don't show up til after two so why rush it?
 
As long as everyone is throwing in their 2 cents (I seem to have a lot of 2 cents lately :D) I am a clinical therapist. I specialize in substance abuse, having some very distinct opinions of alcohol and drugs and so on but I have to separate my professional life from my personal life and realize though I always think I am right there are places and times my opinion is not solicited nor welcome (shocking I know :eek:) I had to realize that not everyone believes as I do. All that to say this, DC is a family/friends type of gathering place and I really think business and causal relationship should be separated so no one feels like they are being singled out over a situation that does not apply to DC or that may even be innocent and a misunderstanding. If I had a business relationship with someone and discovered they were discussing that business transaction with people I consider my friends I would be terribly embarrassed and my feelings would be hurt that my friends would engage in that conversation. April is my friend and she certainly doesn't owe me any explanation. I apologize April if your reading this for participating :oops:
 
TBM you are too funny and we don't always need your resume to know where you stand. But let me ask you this - in your therapy work do you encourage enabling????? You can't discredit anyone they can only do that to themselves. Hopefully a little peer pressure will get agift4me's refund. When things like this go wrong we all get blamed and God knows we get blamed for enough. But if I had a friend that did wrong i would tell them to get their act together and make it right. I won't enable them in their misbehavior. I would tell my own children the same thing - if you need to clear something up then do it don't avoid it. If they had circumstances beyond their control then at least contact the person and set up arrangement. Anyone can get into trouble and it is why we are so cautious of new breeders. We see stories like this way too often.
 
I know from life experience sometimes life serves up something unexpected,or personal that makes just about everything else just lower on the totum pole.
I hope she can come on here and clear the air,but I refuse to pass any kind of judgement until then.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top