Collar Use While Indoors

Does Your Dog Wear Their Collar Indoors?

  • Yes

    Votes: 15 51.7%
  • No

    Votes: 8 27.6%
  • Sometimes

    Votes: 6 20.7%

  • Total voters
    29
I keep my dogs collar loose and on all the time. Unfortunately when the wife takes Daisy out to the beach or to play with another dog she almost always comes home without a collar on. After losing 3-4 collars you'd think she'd start to understand that this can get expensive. Maybe she's losing them on purpose just to get back at me for something and they're all in the glove box of her car. ;-)
 
I voted no. Pretty much the same reasons as Archer. We are gone for 8 hours a day and I would be devastated if something were to happen while we were gone. The only time my girls wear their collars is when we leave our property.
 
I have had it save far more accidents than I have ever had it be a problem because my collars are very loose so if they did get caught then they would slip right off. I have put a dog back in the crate at training and had it get caught (prong - forgot to take it off) but I am right there and catch it right away. A leather collar can't really get caught in a crate but even though I train mine not to bolt out of the crate it could happen and I want to catch them.

I also teach my dogs that catching the collar is always a good things so they are not shy of me grabbing for them. I have a friend that does not collar her dogs and they are far more prone to panic if they should get caught while mine are taught that resistance means hold still so I can get you loose. I don't let my dogs run loose anywhere so they don't loose their collars.

Guess it comes from my horse training days - A horse must learn to give to the pressure and not freak out - otherwise they could kill themselves very easily when tied. A horse or dog who panics can quickly kill themselves. Even if you are trying to get them loose So I want them to understand that if they are still or quiet I can get them loose.
 
I guess I have to say sometimes. But my real answer would be most of the time. I do take them off for baths and forget to put them back on once in a while. I have taken them off for pictures because I like the no collar look.
I ordered Drake a waterproof collar because his leather collars are looking kind of sad. I can't keep the brat out of the water and it's taking it's toll on the leather.
 
Dixie has undone Sophie's more than a few times when they wore them. This is one of the reasons I removed them. Seems as though they always made a grab for the collars during playtime. I was scared that one twist of the head and it would get caught on their bottom jaw.
 
Kris usually has a collar on when she is outside but I take it off in the house. No particular reason as she does not play with anyone in the house and probably more likely to get it hooked on something outside. She does wear it in her crate in the Van but really no way she can get it hooked on anything. She has it off at night in her crate but that is because it is off already.
 
I personally would caution to be careful with hanging dog tags on the collars when leaving them on in a crate/kennel. That's usually what gets caught when the dog lays down, the tag dangles and falls through the bars and then the dog gets up, either the tag or the ring holding the tag is stuck. A breakaway collar for a kennel is a good idea, I haven't thought of having one of those but may be a good idea if I ever need to kennel them again!

For those that don't wear collars a good idea for emergencies is to have a slip leash nearby or quickly make one using the handle of a leash. That way you don't have to fuss with a collar and then trying to clip the leash on, just slip the noose part over their heads. The dogs at the clinic never had their collars on so that they wouldn't get caught in something and since we walked them with these, we always had a dozen slip leashes nearby.
 
I personally would caution to be careful with hanging dog tags on the collars when leaving them on in a crate/kennel. That's usually what gets caught when the dog lays down, the tag dangles and falls through the bars and then the dog gets up, either the tag or the ring holding the tag is stuck.
This is a very good point, but the rings we use for the tags are nearly like a breakaway collar and would let go under a little pulling just as fast as the collar, I think. I can see where you wouldn't want a super heavy duty one though for the reasons you listed. This is another reason I'd rather have the plastic crates than the all wire ones since there's a lot less of the wire they could get caught on.
 
Mine don't wear collars at home. The back yard is enclosed by a 5 foot fence. I watched Cooper walk under a tree once and a branch got between his neck and collar. When he tried to get out, the collar twisted and trapped him. None of the dogs are diggers or can escape unless the fence gate is left open. I had a sign on the gate to keep closed. It cracked from the UV and I intend to replace it. I should put another one on the car gates. If there was no fence, I'm think that I would put on collars all the time.

I've never had a situation around the house where I needed to grab a collar. Obedience training helps because when I speak, they listen no matter what they're doing.
 
I personally would caution to be careful with hanging dog tags on the collars when leaving them on in a crate/kennel. That's usually what gets caught when the dog lays down, the tag dangles and falls through the bars and then the dog gets up, either the tag or the ring holding the tag is stuck.

Excellent point Rits and might be why I never put tags on my collars, but never thought about them being more prone to getting hung up.
 
My Dobermans do not wear their collars at home for the following reasons
They play bite at collars
Worried they will get stuck on something when left unattended
Aria is crated when we're not home and to me a collar while in the crate is a disaster waiting to happen
They scratch us at night when they sleep in the bed
The annoying sound they make when they shake
Chronic wear around neck
They don't ever think about escaping the back yard. I'm always out with them when they are in the yard
They are microchipped

A fine job backing your responses, Archer! Situations here with Crutch are somewhat similar in many ways, and vice versa. I'll give mine for comparison:
1. I only have one big monster-sized love bug, so play biting is non applicable. Although, our JRT has not been privy to yard freedom because I'm afraid the big guy might develop a taste for those $100 invisible fence collars. Maybe someday, tho.
2. Crutch has gotten stuck in his crate by his collar one time when he was little. Since it was necessary to take him out to pee a lot back then, I bought him a special night collar that he still wears at bed that will not get caught on anything.
3. Agreed. Never a collar on a crated dog. Not if your leaving. Ever.
4. Mama's toenails are a bigger threat for me in bed...besides, since day 1, we've slept in our night crate all night and probably always will.
5. Do collars make a sound? (damn artillery fire)
6. To offset "collar fur", Crutch gets a collar change at least daily. He has several nice collars, and I have only a slight collar-buying addiction.
7. Crutch respects his boundaries in the yard. I will have one of several leashable collars on him while outside. I am always with him so as to be able to call him to me and leash him while for example when the young mother with her stroller and her Labrador walk by us on the sidewalk.
8. I told the Vet to put a microchip in him when he was under for his neutering, but he forgot...and after seeing the needle used to insert those chips, I didn't want him to be hurt while awake for the insertion. Again, this boy never leaves my side, and most of his collars have proper ID. :2cents
 
You guys must use the wire crates - I only use them for traveling and in the car because they are dangerous IMHO. I have the plastic Vari- kennels at home and have never had a dog get caught. Knowing me I would loose the collars if I was always taking them off and putting them back on or find them eaten by some alien. Mine are very very loose so I have never had them wear the hair off the neck. But if I fit them properly (two fingers loose) I think that would wear hair off. I can put my whole hand and arm through my collars. It is interesting to read all the differences of experiences.
 
You guys must use the wire crates - I only use them for traveling and in the car because they are dangerous IMHO. I have the plastic Vari- kennels at home and have never had a dog get caught.
This is one of the big reasons I don't use wire crates either. They have about 10 times more wire for something to get caught on and I don't like the risk. We have a soft side crate for shows, but Della hates it.
 
I just got two new soft sides for the Intl show. We ONLY put the puppies in them however- Pretty sure Sniper would have been out in about 5 seconds. Hopefully by acclimating the girls to them they will always be good. Now there an optimistic outlook for a Doberman!!!

The only crates mine have ever gotten out of were wire and thank goodness no major damage to the dog.
 
You guys must use the wire crates

Yes indeed, D4E! I did sort of go the cheap route with the wire crate(s). It has paid off well, tho..as I am a doberman greenhorn who was/is unsure just how big a Euro male might get (I hope every day that he grows up as awesome as Rach's dog, Godric). I've got my eye on a 42" square steel tubing/steel rod design crate (something called a Level III?) that I'm going to have to buy before too much more time passes here as Crutch is now just under 80# and is looking a little bottled-up in the 36" version he has now. I have a 48" wire in the den that he uses just for a "time-out" playpen thing. The new 42" will be in the bedroom,..and darn it, I just like the looks of that Level III,..although I think most of them sell for their escape "resistance" than their looks.
 
All of our pets have flat collars on all the time. I agree with everyone who has said Dobermans are stunning without collars and I've tried leaving them off before but I'm always paranoid they (the dogs) will get out or get lost some how and the collars go back on pretty quickly.
 
Dixie has undone Sophie's more than a few times when they wore them. This is one of the reasons I removed them. Seems as though they always made a grab for the collars during playtime. I was scared that one twist of the head and it would get caught on their bottom jaw.
my dogs did this very thing. they had rolled leather collars, with a standard buckle, and Nexus grabbed Bella's collar, twisted somehow and got her jas twisted in the collar, Bella was choking, Nexus was panicking and in pain and it took FOREVER (or seemed like it) to get them undone. Now I prefer snap buckles, but have used martingales also
 

Back
Top