• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Can I Feed Healthy For Less?

StarlightDobe

Hot Topics Subscriber
I ue Natural Balance right now, Limited Ingredient, current formula is lamb and brown rice, but the flavor changes occasionally. I think its around $58 or so a bag (28 lb bag).
I am curious how Purina Pro Plan compares, is it as good for the dogs? And Nexus needs a limited ingredient food because she is missing a considerable amount of intestine, so would it be ok to switch or should I stick with the NB food?
 
Honestly, I would not switch if it is doing well for her. What you feed is a good food. I'll refrain from sharing my opinion on Purina Pro Plan and try to keep said opinion out of my advice. Some dogs do well on it, and my breeder swears by it. If you choose to switch, I would try their SELECT line and stay with the same protein/carb blend you are currently using.

Personally, I think you could find a better food to switch to
 
Last edited:
We feed Canidae (also switched from pro plan) and get twice the amount for the same price then your currently paying. It's my first choice but not always easy to come by.
 
Not big on Purina Pro Plan. Some ingredients I don't like. Corn gluten meal, whole grain wheat, animal fat (from what animal),
animal digest (from where), menadione sodium bisulfite complex (source of Vitamin K activity)
  • Causes toxic reactions in liver cells
  • Weakens the immune system
  • Induces allergic reactions
  • Causes abnormal break-down of red blood cells
  • The FDA has banned the use of menadione from over-the-counter supplements because large doses have been shown to cause dangerous biological effects.

The best diet would be Raw. This is if you did it yourself and not bought pre made (Bravo, Primal and others). We buy from My Pet Carnivore. We buy for a hole month. Depending on what meats you buy, the prices are different. We switch meats up (Turkey, Beef, Mutton, Lamb, Rabbit, Chicken, Duck, Get extra organs, Chicken Necks) everyday. We get 2# containers.

The best would be is to join a co-ops. Find a farmer. Join some Raw chat groups. Look for Grass Fed meats.

If we were to go back to kibble. Right now the best ones out there are Orijen and Acana (which we fed before switching to Raw). But are like $30 more than what you are paying for NB.

Look on
www.dogfoodadvisor.com
www.dogaware.com
www.dogfoodanalysis.com
www.truthaboutpetfood.com
www.dogfoodproject.com


I would stick with a 4 or 5 rated food, Grain Free, NO Corn, Wheat, Soy of any kind. Which most is GMO. No Canola Oil (GMO). Once you find them you can check out the prices. Also believe in rotational (changing meat protiens) diet being Kibble or Raw.
The thinking is if you feed better you will not be making trips to the Vet more often. So you can spend more on food.
The number one reason for Vet visits is Skin issues and allergies. Get off the Grains!

Also besides feeding better and for good health is Not to over vaccinate your pets.
 
Pro plan is a good food and is more reasonably priced than what you are using. I would also recommend the sensitive formula as it is easier to digest. A dog food should be affordable. If you think about it those who spends the most in advertising bucks on TV means a large portion of the money is going to pay for adds not improve the dog food.

Pro Plan is Purina's higher end dog food so don't think it has corn etc. in it. As far as raw some do well on it and some do not. If you read the menus for people it clearly states that raw food contains bacteria and several on this list have had problems feeding it to their dogs. But I am not a fan of raw myself - I prefer the convenience of kibble when traveling to dog shows etc. Just the thought of Contamination from raw just makes me want to gag. Not to mention that the FDA is considering restricting it and that should say something.

As far as all the dog food blogs - if you read them most of them are written by people like you and me - no degree in nutrition and they do get money for the promotion from the dog food companies. So I have just never been convinced that they are any smart at reading labels then you or me.
 
Pro plan is a good food and is more reasonably priced than what you are using. I would also recommend the sensitive formula as it is easier to digest. A dog food should be affordable. If you think about it those who spends the most in advertising bucks on TV means a large portion of the money is going to pay for adds not improve the dog food.

Pro Plan is Purina's higher end dog food so don't think it has corn etc. in it. As far as raw some do well on it and some do not. If you read the menus for people it clearly states that raw food contains bacteria and several on this list have had problems feeding it to their dogs. But I am not a fan of raw myself - I prefer the convenience of kibble when traveling to dog shows etc. Just the thought of Contamination from raw just makes me want to gag. Not to mention that the FDA is considering restricting it and that should say something.

As far as all the dog food blogs - if you read them most of them are written by people like you and me - no degree in nutrition and they do get money for the promotion from the dog food companies. So I have just never been convinced that they are any smart at reading labels then you or me.
It doesn't say "corn" but...
Purina Pro Plan Sport Advanced 28/18 Formula
Dry Dog Food

Estimated Dry Matter Nutrient Content

Protein010032
Fat010021
Carbs010040
Ingredients: Chicken, brewers rice,poultry by-product meal (natural source of glucosamine), corn gluten meal, whole grain wheat, animal fat preserved with mixed-tocopherols (form of vitamin E),whole grain corn, corn germ meal,brewers dried yeast, fish meal (natural source of glucosamine), animal digest, fish oil, dried egg product, wheat bran, calcium phosphate, salt, potassium chloride, vitamin E supplement, choline chloride, l-ascorbyl-2-polyphosphate (source of vitamin C), zinc sulfate, ferrous sulfate, l-lysine monohydrochloride, manganese sulfate, niacin, calcium carbonate, vitamin A supplement, calcium pantothenate, thiamine mononitrate, copper sulfate, riboflavin supplement, vitamin B12 supplement, pyridoxine hydrochloride, garlic oil, folic acid, vitamin D3 supplement, calcium iodate, biotin, menadione sodium bisulfite complex (source of vitamin Kactivity), sodium selenite

Fiber (estimated dry matter content) = 3.4%

Red items when present indicate controversial ingredients

Estimated Nutrient Content
MethodProteinFatCarbs
Guaranteed Analysis28%18%NA
Dry Matter Basis32%21%40%
Calorie Weighted Basis26%41%33%







If your dog has corn allergies this food will set them off,ask me how I know;)
It's definitely affordable,and it does deliver "performance" and the energy and stamina they claim.
I was already considering getting him off of it and was also turned off by their BS with Blue.
Daisy was on Blue,Blue was firing back with their own bs.I really dislike the tactic of attacking your competition as a sales gimmick.Sell your product on the merits of your product,not tearing down others.
So I said screw them both because while they were bickering back and forth there were some great threads going here on other food options.
Now their both on the same food,fair price,they seem to be doing well on it,so happy happy happy!
 
Thanks for all the adivce! Fred, the store we now shop at does carry Canidae brand, I will have to double check the formulas and see which might be best, and what size bags they carry.
I thought about a raw diet before, but call me lazy lol I prefer the ease of kibble as I dont have to make sure they get the nutrition they need because its already in the food, and plus Im not big on cooking for my human family! haha not sure I would be good with feeding raw to the dogs.
I will check into the Canidae and do a price comparison. That and find out if they have a comparable formula.
 
I thought about a raw diet before, but call me lazy lol I prefer the ease of kibble as I dont have to make sure they get the nutrition they need because its already in the food, and plus Im not big on cooking for my human family! haha not sure I would be good with feeding raw to the dogs.
That's me exactally. :D
 
We feed the ALS variety. Been happy with it for years then they switched up the formula and we moved away from it for several years until it was announced that they were making a return to the original formula.. I didn't think twice about it and have had nothing but success.

Lol There was a lot of they's in there.. They being Canidae.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Pro plan is a good food and is more reasonably priced than what you are using. I would also recommend the sensitive formula as it is easier to digest. A dog food should be affordable. If you think about it those who spends the most in advertising bucks on TV means a large portion of the money is going to pay for adds not improve the dog food.

Pro Plan is Purina's higher end dog food so don't think it has corn etc. in it. As far as raw some do well on it and some do not. If you read the menus for people it clearly states that raw food contains bacteria and several on this list have had problems feeding it to their dogs. But I am not a fan of raw myself - I prefer the convenience of kibble when traveling to dog shows etc. Just the thought of Contamination from raw just makes me want to gag. Not to mention that the FDA is considering restricting it and that should say something.

As far as all the dog food blogs - if you read them most of them are written by people like you and me - no degree in nutrition and they do get money for the promotion from the dog food companies. So I have just never been convinced that they are any smart at reading labels then you or me.


Pro Plan is Purina's higher end dog food so don't think it has corn etc. in it. Yes it does. For sure some dogs might not like Raw or do well on Raw. That for sure is the same with kibbles. A domesticated dogs digestive system has not changed in 100,000 years. Kibble has only been around for a 100 yrs. A dogs stomach acid is a 1. Which can dissolve bone and kill bacteria. Has a short digestive tract. Will digest Raw in about 4-6 hours. Another reason dogs do not get sick from eating Raw. Kibble takes any where from 10-12 hours to digest. Dogs do not get salmonella. Unless their immune system is compromised. Also 99% of the recalls have been for kibble and not Raw. This is for the pet owners protection who handle kibble and not wash their hands. And this is for pre made Raw. Its not hard to look up ingredients on the back of the bag of food or call the manufacturer and ask questions to really do your own research.

The very first ingredient in pro plan is chicken. This is great. But after that most of the protein is from grains. I would look for a food which in the first 5 ingredients are mostly from a named meat. Any meat proteins you want named as to what they are.

Would you feed your dog Old Roy??? Purina spends millions on advertising. And then maybe less on good ingredients?

Call up Purina and ask what kind of fish they use in their un-named fish meal? Then ask if they guarantee from their sources that they get the fish meal from, that they do not use Ethoxyquin (you can search this one) as a preservative? Which they do not allow in people food. Do they use GMO Corn? If they will not tell you then I would question well why not?
 
Would you feed your dog Old Roy???
Old Roy is recalled every Tuesday at 8am. ;)

Lots of corn in pro plan. I'm guessing it was the single ingredient that had Mars so sick.
image.webp
I still recommend PP and besides Mars' allergies my dogs did well on it. But admittedly left some room for improvement. No doubt it's incredibly overpriced for what it is.
 
I am frustrated with pet stores, argh! I think I need to find someplace that will deliver and that always has what I want. Before we moved, we had an amazing store that was somewhat like a warehouse, they had great prices and had pretty much all flavor varieties of Natural balance that we use, now we have moved and that store is half an hour drive away, so we found a pet store here, it is really an amazing place, they have a pet store (no, not the kind that sells pets, the kind that sells pet supplies lol) they also have a vet, a groomer, a rescue and training there, its just that they only carry like, 2 flavor varieties of the food and they are more expensive than our old store. I really need mail order lol
 
I am frustrated with pet stores, argh! I think I need to find someplace that will deliver and that always has what I want. Before we moved, we had an amazing store that was somewhat like a warehouse, they had great prices and had pretty much all flavor varieties of Natural balance that we use, now we have moved and that store is half an hour drive away, so we found a pet store here, it is really an amazing place, they have a pet store (no, not the kind that sells pets, the kind that sells pet supplies lol) they also have a vet, a groomer, a rescue and training there, its just that they only carry like, 2 flavor varieties of the food and they are more expensive than our old store. I really need mail order lol
www.chewy.com
www.wag.com
www.petfooddirect.com

All places I have known people to buy dog food with success. I have bought toys off of wag.com and I love them!!
 
Boy can I relate.. I used to get our Purina Pro Plan from tractor supply and even they were out from time to time.. Fortunately Purina has other retailers but if that happened to the Canidae I'd be screwed since only one place sells it in the entire county.

I actually tried an online pet food retailer but never really got in the swing of it and either had to much pilling up or would run out before the next auto ship. I know it's convenient but I just couldn't make it work for me.
 
We feed the ALS variety.
Canidae's Adult Life Stages is exactly what I'm feeding Crutch. He loves the food, and the vet even told me that it was a good food, but now I have to take him off of it due to some stomach issue.
When he was a small pup, I started him on Pro Plan, but moved over to the Canidae when his stools became too loose to deal with in the now melting snow. The Large Breed Puppy with duck meal & lentils is what I switched to.
Now I'm no "poop-scientist", but the stools on this variety of Canidae (bear with me) looked good out of the mill, but hit with a splat like the center was all pudding. And the smell! Good Lord, Jackie across the street knew when the big one dropped a bomb!
I then figured it was time for an inter-brand switch, so I went to the ALS like Von did...well...way less smell, but still the "splat-factor" was too high.
When he got sick here recently, the vet had me put him on some vet-specific prescription food that only cost me $45 for the 15# bag! He told me to switch to a lamb/rice formula if he perked-up and his stools went firm with this high grade stuff. Well they did finally become firm enough to maintain shape "after impact", but the bag will be empty today. This is a first with the stools, but now which food to switch to?
Research has me to want to try the Merric Lamb/Brown Rice/Apple variety because the numbers on the analysis closely jive to the one on the script food, but it isn't a puppy food. Will that be OK since Crutch turns 9 mo here soon? I figure if he has a good stool and maintains his current "figure", maybe this adult food would be OK with a vitamin or other supplement? (I have salmon oil still)
If an adult variety is not the best thing for a near 9 mo old dobie, which puppy variety do ya'all think would be best? Puppy or not, that Merric was real close in numbers??
:feedback:
 
Hmm possibly a parasite

We finally discovered it was those little brown toadstool mushrooms that popped up in the side yard that was the probable culprit (shy of labratory-like analysis, we'll never know for sure). Crutch is nortotious for grazing in the yard (dandelions are his fav) and I'm sure he had been in them, but, in further vet direction, he told me to switch out his food for the stool firming factor we all love. He is albeit cured for now, but he has only one meal left of that Rx food, so today's shopping day.
I bet that supplement and a sensitive stomach food will set him straight. Thank You for your input, Sir...
 

Back
Top