• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Bedtime potty antics

Kaiser2016

Well-Known Member
Kaiser asked to "go potty" around 7:30 pm. He did both.

I asked him to go "bedtime potty" at 8:30 when he was already snoozing. While on the yard, he just walked around sniffing. He had a bit of pee but no poo.

We go inside, I do his bedtime routine. Great end to a great day. He had plenty of play time, plenty of mental work, and some snuggles.

About 10 minutes later, he's whining. I ignore it. He already gave me a false alarm the night prior. He begins howling like there's murder. In my mind, he must need to poo and I cannot ignore that. I pass by the laundry room where he's crated. I walk back and forth waiting for him to be quiet. Once he's quiet I do other little things as I head closer to his area.

I let him out but leash him. Spontaneous potty breaks given FROM me TO him, don't require this, but I had given him an obvious command minutes prior that he was getting his last chance. I don't want him to think that he calls the shots once I put him away. I'm worried about precedent.

We go to the back door leashed and he is already rambunctious. I'm on the deck, open the gate, and he decides he will jump from the deck to the yard instead of taking the stairs (5 steps). I don't expect him to do that because, hello donkey, you are tethered to me! But I also didn't want to get yanked so I released the leash.

He picks up the leash by the handle, does at least a dozen parade laps, not zoomies, but the kind of running that says 'haha, I know I'm not allowed to do this but you can't catch me!', against my better judgement I come on to the yard telling him "off the yard" and "inside". Of course I'll never catch him and I don't try.

I leave him outside. Shut off all the lights. Including the outside lights. I wait a full minute. He is still on the yard. I, at least, expected him to be standing by the door by now. I go outside, tell him "off the yard". He obeys. He's got the leash in his mouth. I grab his muzzle, open it, remove the leash. Tell him "mine". I back him up holding his muzzle shut. I really wanted to smack his snout with the leash. Instead I went through the floor taking his toys away and saying mine to each item. Same for his new cot, his precious sucky blanket, his plastic bottle, all of it.

At this point I did not know for how long I should ignore him. What's appropriate? I want him to weigh the consequences of not listening. I also don't want to put him away in that mood.

It was maybe 3-5-7 minutes that I continued to do random stuff in the kitchen. He's never made me so mad and I was ticked. He came to drink water and I also removed the bowl saying mine. He went and stood by his cot which was vertical now so he couldn't use it. He didn't move.

I passed by him. Opened the laundry room door. He looked that way. I stood in the way. Then I asked him to come. Made him sit, held his collar, and gave him the "you have to listen" lecture. (He watched me intently and it didn't seem like staring.) We used that with the cat with great success minus any physical contact or collars or leashes. But the cat was always brilliant. Sigh. Donkeys, well, they have their days.

Open to all input here. When Kaiser goes "bedtime", there are expectations. No counter-negotiating with me.
 
I can see that I will have a lot of very detailed obedience training in my future. I know dobies are intelligent, but I did not know they will understand things like "mine" and "inside" and the like.

About 10 minutes later, he's whining. I ignore it. He already gave me a false alarm the night prior. He begins howling like there's murder. In my mind, he must need to poo and I cannot ignore that. I pass by the laundry room where he's crated. I walk back and forth waiting for him to be quiet. Once he's quiet I do other little things as I head closer to his area.

I let him out but leash him. Spontaneous potty breaks given FROM me TO him, don't require this, but I had given him an obvious command minutes prior that he was getting his last chance. I don't want him to think that he calls the shots once I put him away. I'm worried about precedent.

Just out of curiosity, did he actually "potty" during this exercise?
 
Open to all input here. When Kaiser goes "bedtime", there are expectations. No counter-negotiating with me.

I liked your style...similar to mine...Grace is my friend, not slave so I'm careful and understanding when correcting, face it she'll be 1yr next week, so there's still some training going on for us...now here's the "however" I don't put up with Dobe Crap...Calmly, assertively when she does "crazy" I simply tell her no more, "you make me sad" or "like you no that's mine" and then they get a time out, if it continues...30 minutes is what I gave my kids back in the day,,,seems right for a Dobe.

Remember I could be wrong...Just kidding!
 
Dog training is all about the moment and as I always say giving a clear picture. Timing of the correction is important that is why I suggest using markers to identify points in time, these are followed by reward or correction/punishment. Although it made you feel better to take Kaiser’s things and say mine, his understanding of what that was about, had nothing to do with his running around outside. We have to remember they are not like us in the way they understand things. You calling him to you then making him sit should have ended with your praise and a reward but instead you basically corrected him for coming to you and sitting. When I get upset or mad during training I just put them up in their kennel until I can get my composure back. If they sense my anger or that I am unhappy it will effect them in training as well because the picture is now different.
 
What a little turd ;) Been there, done that!

You know he peed and pooped at 730...he should have no reason at all to go again. You fell for his trap! :p


Its really really hard but when they play stupid like that, we have to hold our being upset and instead praise them for coming when they do finally come when called. I too have shut the door on one of my dogs if they decide to ignore me or are too slow to come back inside. It gets them coming faster the next time because they don't want to be left out alone! May not work for an independent dog.

With the unusual howling, the rambunctious attitude before going through the door etc, you just KNOW he's gonna pull some stunts! That was your heads-up. I would have made him back up to whatever previous room where he was under control and re-approach the back door with obedience. Either that or be prepared to go fetch him without even bothering calling him because you just knooow he's already acting crazy and is probably going to pull a stunt while outside. Yep, ignored your entire existence on the other end of the leash. Stunt #3 Now you expect him to listen and recall too? :p Teenagers. :rolleyes:
 
I can see that I will have a lot of very detailed obedience training in my future. I know dobies are intelligent, but I did not know they will understand things like "mine" and "inside" and the like.

Just out of curiosity, did he actually "potty" during this exercise?
They are very smart little jerks. "Very detailed" is right. And I still need to name all his toys so he can retrieve them from his crate. I am working on front door and back door locations. Now I clearly need to teach him how to handle the deck stairs while being leashed. End...less.

No, he only did his parade laps. He was pretty dry when he peed at 730. If his pee is less than 12-15 seconds long, he should require no overnight breaks. It was poop that I was worried about.
 
Just my experience....going out the front Grace is a lady and waits until I release her to come....going out into the back yard is a very different story....we have birds, rabbits, squirrels etc all the time inside the fence...I've had more than one Dobe here and 3 Doxies and NOBODY has waited for me! I've tried with them all...I'm the one that failed, but guess what, I'm ok with it as long as all other doors are done right.
 
I liked your style...similar to mine...Grace is my friend, not slave so I'm careful and understanding when correcting, face it she'll be 1yr next week, so there's still some training going on for us...now here's the "however" I don't put up with Dobe Crap...Calmly, assertively when she does "crazy" I simply tell her no more, "you make me sad" or "like you no that's mine" and then they get a time out, if it continues...30 minutes is what I gave my kids back in the day,,,seems right for a Dobe.

Remember I could be wrong...Just kidding!
Thanks! I am trying not to be a slave driver, but it's such a fine line between being too nice to him. We had a great day and so much fun together. Then he rewards me with total chaos at bedtime. It was just the last straw. So, time out, 30 minutes to think about it.
 
So, time out, 30 minutes to think about it.

I tell Grace "you made me sad" then time out....so now when chaos sets in, I correct and if that fails I look at her right in the face and say DON'T MAKE ME SAD....she knows the word sad and sits down now...LOL...Human 1 Dobe 0
 
Dog training is all about the moment and as I always say giving a clear picture. Timing of the correction is important that is why I suggest using markers to identify points in time, these are followed by reward or correction/punishment. Although it made you feel better to take Kaiser’s things and say mine, his understanding of what that was about, had nothing to do with his running around outside. We have to remember they are not like us in the way they understand things. You calling him to you then making him sit should have ended with your praise and a reward but instead you basically corrected him for coming to you and sitting.
I knew I handled this wrong. The whole "mine" tirade was to remind him that I'm the source of everything for him. I took his parading as him making a fool of me which is why I left him on the yard and turned out the lights. He is usually such a superstar of bedtime potty.

You're right. I totally punished him for coming to me :facepalm: So next time he is disobedient, as soon as he does comply, I need to consider the incident to be over and I have to praise him.
 
When I let my dogs out to potty before bed, I just wait till they come back to the door to be let in. If I can’t correct them for not coming to me there is no sense in calling them. But mine usually have ecollar on so I can call then buzz them. They come in and go right in there kennel, I do not say any thing except kennel if they need a reminder of what they are supposed to do. Then it is lights out until morning.
 
I knew I handled this wrong. The whole "mine" tirade was to remind him that I'm the source of everything for him. I took his parading as him making a fool of me which is why I left him on the yard and turned out the lights. He is usually such a superstar of bedtime potty.

You're right. I totally punished him for coming to me :facepalm: So next time he is disobedient, as soon as he does comply, I need to consider the incident to be over and I have to praise him.

Don't beat yourself up; just make a mental note for next time! It's a very odd thing to remind yourself to do... reward them for coming when called, even if they've just done something totally out of line. I have to remind my BF of this - if Rubie is being an asshat but she comes when called, you ALWAYS reward the recall no matter how angry you are with whatever she's just done. That's a separate training exercise to circle back around with.

And I don't blame you... Rubie is usually dead quiet in her crate. If she has to go out because it's an emergency poo, it's less whining and more like moaning? groaning? a warning that it's about to get messy in here? Definitely a unique noise!
 
You know he peed and pooped at 730...he should have no reason at all to go again. You fell for his trap! :p

With the unusual howling, the rambunctious attitude before going through the door etc, you just KNOW he's gonna pull some stunts! That was your heads-up. I would have made him back up to whatever previous room where he was under control and re-approach the back door with obedience.
I have such a fear of him pooping indoors, it makes me a bit excessive with the potty breaks. I know he can hold it but I really hate middle of the night potty breaks. I guess I need to get over it.

You know what, I did know he was going to be crazy! He gave me all the signs and I proceeded anyway:facepalm: I really thought leashing him would keep his crazy under control. If I hadn't dropped the leash this could have turned out differently.

I will definitely back him up to keep his 'enthusiasm' under control.
 
I tell Grace "you made me sad" then time out....so now when chaos sets in, I correct and if that fails I look at her right in the face and say DON'T MAKE ME SAD....she knows the word sad and sits down now...LOL...Human 1 Dobe 0
I say 'thank you' when Kaiser has complied with something important like 'settle' and 'quiet'. I do think verbalizing helps us give off the emotion so the dog can sense that we are pleased. I also say 'sorry' if I accidentally step on him during leashed training of turning 'left' and 'right'.
 
I have such a fear of him pooping indoors, it makes me a bit excessive with the potty breaks. I know he can hold it but I really hate middle of the night potty breaks. I guess I need to get over it.

You know what, I did know he was going to be crazy! He gave me all the signs and I proceeded anyway:facepalm: I really thought leashing him would keep his crazy under control. If I hadn't dropped the leash this could have turned out differently.

I will definitely back him up to keep his 'enthusiasm' under control.

For sure don't beat yourself up over it! A huge chunk of training is us learning how to handle scenarios. You learn as you go. None of us ever started out knowing how to train. It takes time, learning from others, and a lot of it from our own mistakes, and from others mistakes too! That is whats great about a dog forum, obedience classes, competitions etc... is that we can learn from each other. :)
 
Don't beat yourself up; just make a mental note for next time! It's a very odd thing to remind yourself to do... reward them for coming when called, even if they've just done something totally out of line. I have to remind my BF of this - if Rubie is being an asshat but she comes when called, you ALWAYS reward the recall no matter how angry you are with whatever she's just done. That's a separate training exercise to circle back around with.

And I don't blame you... Rubie is usually dead quiet in her crate. If she has to go out because it's an emergency poo, it's less whining and more like moaning? groaning? a warning that it's about to get messy in here? Definitely a unique noise!
I feel like I know the sound he makes if he has to go, but I second guess myself. I should trust him a bit more in that regard.

In hindsight, I mishandled the situation and was clearly upset about it - I wrote a whole book explaining it! :bag:
 
So today's bedtime...

I offer him "bedtime potty" and he goes. Inside, I do the usual routine, his crackers and cucumbers in his crate. I leave thinking this is good. A few minutes later he starts the little boredom yipping. It does not turn into the howling he had the night prior. He goes quiet. I'm upstairs and he yips a few more times. I completely ignore him. I quickly got into the shower just so I wouldn't hear anything more. When I'm done, all is quiet.

Question: if he is downstairs and Im upstairs, just one floor apart, can he sense if I'm a bit nervous? Or would we need to be closer? I am just grateful that the cat didn't start doing her zoomies.
 
He senses your feelings while you're putting him to bed...right after he eats, he reacts...Be Calm, assertive and reassuring...I tell Grace when crating her what's going on... "Ok Grace I'm going to the store now you'll be fine I'll be back later, Love ya" then I cover the crate and turn on the music...I do the same if I'm crating her for a nap & bedtime too...
 
Just like kids when they’re little... I need a drink of water, the night light isn’t on, I’m hot..etc, etc, all to just get your attention and have more time with you. Doesn’t even matter if it’s negative attention.

The best way I deal with this is I do what’s needed and that’s it back to the schedule no extra attention.

When Shadow needs to do a middle of the night potty break I just let her out, no talking no petting, open the door out for a minute, let her do her business and then back in, no extra attention, I don’t even turn on the lights, nothing.
 

Back
Top