Quee
Hot Topics Subscriber
Pippi and I are sending Christmas blessings, and hoping that you have a and a happy and more healthful new year. My condolences on the loss of your Aunt - I am so sorry.
Your situation with Axl sounds sort of similar to mine when I first got Pippi, but she's doing much better than when I first adopted her back in July of this year. When I first got Pippi, who is also petite and was IMO underweight when I adopted her (65#) I had to go through a few foods to find one that she did well on. She ate a lot of grass when I first got her, and I immediately tried weaning her off of the Costco-brand dog food that she was on while she was fostered. The foster and the head of the Doberman rescue said that lots of Dobermans do very well on the Costco brand. Since I wasn't a Costco member (and there's none anywhere near me) I had researched dog foods extensively and decided to go with Natural Balance, and had also planned to eventually get her on a raw diet. Well, she started eating more grass not less as I transitioned her to the Natural Balance, and also started throwing up periodically and her stools progressively got looser, to the point where she had watery stools and was drinking a ton of water.
I immediately called Natural Balance to ask them about their kibble and to tell them about our experience. They were very nice and sent us free coupons to try different versions of their foods, which I donated to the Doberman rescue. I went to my 2nd choice of foods which was Blue Buffalo Blue Wilderness formula dry kibble (chicken). She took to that like a fish to water, and in a couple of days her tummy straightened out with no more grass eating, throwing up or diarrhea.
About a month later I thought I'd give raw food a try - not a good idea. I started with raw chicken - from Whole Foods no less, and made sure that I cleaned it thoroughly before giving it to her. She did very poorly - she ate some of it but not all of it, went back to eating grass then eventually not eating for a whole day, and whining and becoming lethargic. I took her to the vet thinking she had some kind of blockage, they did x-rays, and she had really terrible gas building up and causing her stomach pains. The vet warned me to get ready for an explosion, gave her an antibiotic to fight against any mischief going on in her stomach, and suggested I fast her for another day before starting to feed her again, and no more raw. He was right - we both almost died of asphyxiation from her terrible gas and then she had diarrhea for a day and a half. After that it was back to the Blue Wilderness again, and she's been fine on that ever since. I give her vitamins (fish oil and a multivitamin) to make sure she's getting complete nutrition. My vet says she really is sensitive to different foods and has grain allergies, so keeping her on an almost grain-free diet is critical. I say 'almost' because I mix in some soft food that isn't certified as grain-free (Blue Family Recipies or Blue's Stew) because she gets tired of the same old food and will go a half-day to a day or more without eating. I also occasionally give her a meaty bone (Pork), and she tolerates Bully Sticks very well too. Meaty bones we have to be careful with because she can eat them in a few minutes, and her poop can be rock-hard cand cause her constipation after eating.
Pippi has also filled out more and generally has a lot of energy and her coat looks great too. I plan to keep her consistent on this diet with no more food experiments since she's doing so well. I hope you and Axl can get to the point where he thrives on his diet too!
Your situation with Axl sounds sort of similar to mine when I first got Pippi, but she's doing much better than when I first adopted her back in July of this year. When I first got Pippi, who is also petite and was IMO underweight when I adopted her (65#) I had to go through a few foods to find one that she did well on. She ate a lot of grass when I first got her, and I immediately tried weaning her off of the Costco-brand dog food that she was on while she was fostered. The foster and the head of the Doberman rescue said that lots of Dobermans do very well on the Costco brand. Since I wasn't a Costco member (and there's none anywhere near me) I had researched dog foods extensively and decided to go with Natural Balance, and had also planned to eventually get her on a raw diet. Well, she started eating more grass not less as I transitioned her to the Natural Balance, and also started throwing up periodically and her stools progressively got looser, to the point where she had watery stools and was drinking a ton of water.
I immediately called Natural Balance to ask them about their kibble and to tell them about our experience. They were very nice and sent us free coupons to try different versions of their foods, which I donated to the Doberman rescue. I went to my 2nd choice of foods which was Blue Buffalo Blue Wilderness formula dry kibble (chicken). She took to that like a fish to water, and in a couple of days her tummy straightened out with no more grass eating, throwing up or diarrhea.
About a month later I thought I'd give raw food a try - not a good idea. I started with raw chicken - from Whole Foods no less, and made sure that I cleaned it thoroughly before giving it to her. She did very poorly - she ate some of it but not all of it, went back to eating grass then eventually not eating for a whole day, and whining and becoming lethargic. I took her to the vet thinking she had some kind of blockage, they did x-rays, and she had really terrible gas building up and causing her stomach pains. The vet warned me to get ready for an explosion, gave her an antibiotic to fight against any mischief going on in her stomach, and suggested I fast her for another day before starting to feed her again, and no more raw. He was right - we both almost died of asphyxiation from her terrible gas and then she had diarrhea for a day and a half. After that it was back to the Blue Wilderness again, and she's been fine on that ever since. I give her vitamins (fish oil and a multivitamin) to make sure she's getting complete nutrition. My vet says she really is sensitive to different foods and has grain allergies, so keeping her on an almost grain-free diet is critical. I say 'almost' because I mix in some soft food that isn't certified as grain-free (Blue Family Recipies or Blue's Stew) because she gets tired of the same old food and will go a half-day to a day or more without eating. I also occasionally give her a meaty bone (Pork), and she tolerates Bully Sticks very well too. Meaty bones we have to be careful with because she can eat them in a few minutes, and her poop can be rock-hard cand cause her constipation after eating.
Pippi has also filled out more and generally has a lot of energy and her coat looks great too. I plan to keep her consistent on this diet with no more food experiments since she's doing so well. I hope you and Axl can get to the point where he thrives on his diet too!

buying 2 foods and mixing ALL the time.

He's doing well and starting to round out his ribs and butt...looking more muscular.!! 
