• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Article about the use of vitamin C in dogs , quite long but worth reading

Judith

Hot Topics Subscriber
You should not feed your dog a food product containing vitamin C. Your dog can manufacture all of the vitamin C its own body needs. The dog's glandular system is different than the glandular system of a human. The dog is able to synthesize (manufacture its own) vitamin C by its liver using trace minerals in its diet. The human's glandular system can not manufacture the vitamin C its body requires and therefore needs to have a supplemental dietary source.

Vitamins C & D work together in a dog to make collagen (a substance that effects the tendons and ligaments) and all dogs need vitamin C, just not from a dietary source. Today, there are a number of pet food products on the market that contain vitamin C. All of the endorsements for using vitamin C has many pet owners confused on this issue. The pet food companies who are making the claim that it is in their food as a "natural" preservative should remember that their product is going to consumed by a dog and vitamin C is not "natural" for a dog's dietary intake - it may be "natural" for a human but even with humans there are differences in the type of vitamin C that can be assimilated "naturally." Many breeders and veterinarians are also advocating mega doses of supplemental vitamin C so a puppy's ears will stand up faster or to change the elasticity of a dog's tendons and ligaments if they are worried about arthritis or hip displasia. Those who promote feeding a dog with mega doses of vitamin C can be compared to the coach who wants what steroids will do for his athlete. In some cases that coach may not be aware of the problems his athlete will be facing in the future and is so happy with the immediate results he sees that he sells others on the idea that steroids are good. We know they are not. Supplemental vitamin C can do a "quick fix" for dogs, the type that the people advocating supplemental dietary vitamin C want. It will have an immediate affect on arthritis, displasia or getting the ears You should not feed your dog a food product containing vitamin C. Your dog can manufacture all of the vitamin C its own body needs. The dog's glandular system is different than the glandular system of a human. The dog is able to synthesize (manufacture its own) vitamin C by its liver using trace minerals in its diet. The human's glandular system can not manufacture the vitamin C its body requires and therefore needs to have a supplemental dietary source.
Vitamins C & D work together in a dog to make collagen (a substance that effects the tendons and ligaments) and all dogs need vitamin C, just not from a dietary source. Today, there are a number of pet food products on the market that contain vitamin C. All of the endorsements for using vitamin C has many pet owners confused on this issue. The pet food companies who are making the claim that it is in their food as a "natural" preservative should remember that their product is going to consumed by a dog and vitamin C is not "natural" for a dog's dietary intake - it may be "natural" for a human but even with humans there are differences in the type of vitamin C that can be assimilated "naturally." Many breeders and veterinarians are also advocating mega doses of supplemental vitamin C so a puppy's ears will stand up faster or to change the elasticity of a dog's tendons and ligaments if they are worried about arthritis or hip displasia. Those who promote feeding a dog with mega doses of vitamin C can be compared to the coach who wants what steroids will do for his athlete. In some cases that coach may not be aware of the problems his athlete will be facing in the future and is so happy with the immediate results he sees that he sells others on the idea that steroids are good. We know they are not. Supplemental vitamin C can do a "quick fix" for dogs, the type that the people advocating supplemental dietary vitamin C want. It will have an immediate affect on arthritis, displasia or getting the ears to stand up. Unfortunately, just like steroids in humans, it has some long term negative effects as well.

Supplemental vitamin C has been clinically tested and proven to cause problems. One test conducted in 1980, by Teare et al., showed that supplemental vitamin C can aggravate skeletal disease induced by overfeeding protein, energy, and calcium to Labrador Retriever puppies. The test by Teare et al. is shown on page 38 in the US Government National Research Council's publication, Nutrient Requirements of Dogs - Revised 1985. That single NRC publication cites 24 test done with vitamin C and dogs. The 24 test were done to find out if dog food should contain any vitamin C. The conclusion the members of the National Research Council drew from all of those test was that dog food should not contain any vitamin C.

Feeding a dog vitamin C may have a negative affect on both the dog's liver and kidneys. Feeding vitamin C to a healthy dog can affect that dog's liver the same as feeding thyroid medication would affect the healthy dog's thyroid gland. It could shut the gland down. Any time we take over the function of a healthy gland with dietary supplements or medication, the gland slowly atrophies. The effect it has on the dog's kidneys is because most forms of vitamin C that are found in dog foods or supplements are not the same as the molecular form the dog is able to produce naturally. The different dietary forms of vitamin C like: Ascorbic Acid (in an "L" form), Sodium Ascorbate or Calcium Ascorbate are all synthetic water soluble forms. They end up in the dogs kidneys where they change the uric pH while waiting to be discharged from the dogs body. This change in the natural pH within the kidneys puts additional stress on them and can cause many problems.

The Morris Animal Foundation has released the findings of a survey determining the main causes of death for dogs in the United States. The second and sixth leading causes cited in that report were kidney disorders and liver failure. Supplemental vitamin C may not cause a dog to die as fast as a bullet from a gun or accidents (the #1 reason) but all indicators point to the fact that it does cause glandular problems which can lead to a dog's death. It works very slowly and can rob years from a pet's normal life span.

Today we know that the average life span of dogs has decreased and people are accepting their shorter life span as being "normal." Advocates for including supplemental C in a dogs diet are quick to point out that there are a number of reasons for the shorter life span. They claim that today our air is full of pollutants that can cause medical problems and vitamin C is needed to combat those pollutants. For a human that can not produce their own vitamin C supplemental vitamin C is needed to combat those pollutants. For a dog supplemental vitamin C is not needed since their glands are capable of producing any amount they need. Test cited in the 1985 NRC publication illustrates this. Test show how a lactating bitch's milk supply contains approximately 4 times that of the blood. This test illustrates how the bitch's glandular system not only increased the amount of vitamin C she normally produces but put it where it was needed (her pup is not able to produce its own vitamin C until it is eating solid foods). The human glandular system does NOT produce vitamin C but a dog's glandular system does. There are other animals that have glandular systems that can produce ALL the vitamin C they need, just like a dog. i.e. An adult goat will manufacture more than 13,000 mg of vitamin C per day in normal health and as much as 100,000 mg daily when faced with life-threatening disease, trauma or stress.

With all the proof we have that supplemental vitamin C can cause a dog problems, the question arises: why do we have vitamin C in dog food products? Vitamin C is found in dog food products because it is an antioxidant (a preservative). Vitamin C can keep fats from going rancid or keep colors bright. It is there with AAFCO's approval. In 1994 AAFCO ("the governing body for the pet food industry") met and agreed with the pet food companies that they would no longer recognize the findings of the National Research Council (NRC) which were listed as the NRC's "Minimum Nutrient Requirements of Dogs" for being a standard to make a dog food eligible to claim it was "Complete & Balanced." This ruling was brought about because the pet food companies wanted to use vitamin C in dog food, as a preservative, and still make the claim that their food was "Complete & Balanced." Under the old definition (before the 1994 AAFCO ruling) for a dog food manufacturer to claim their food was "Complete & Balanced" it could not contain any vitamin C since the NRC showed how it was not required by dogs AND HOW IT COULD DO HARM - TO A DOG. When AAFCO agreed not to recognize the NRC's standards because they were "not current" the pet food companies were then allowed to use this cheap preservative (vitamin C) in a pet food and still make the claim that their food was "Complete & Balanced."

The test cited by the NRC should not be ignored. The NRC's book is still a good source of to stand up. Unfortunately, just like steroids in humans, it has some long term negative effects as well.

Supplemental vitamin C has been clinically tested and proven to cause problems. One test conducted in 1980, by Teare et al., showed that supplemental vitamin C can aggravate skeletal disease induced by overfeeding protein, energy, and calcium to Labrador Retriever puppies. The test by Teare et al. is shown on page 38 in the US Government National Research Council's publication, Nutrient Requirements of Dogs - Revised 1985. That single NRC publication cites 24 test done with vitamin C and dogs. The 24 test were done to find out if dog food should contain any vitamin C. The conclusion the members of the National Research Council drew from all of those test was that dog food should not contain any vitamin C.

Feeding a dog vitamin C may have a negative affect on both the dog's liver and kidneys. Feeding vitamin C to a healthy dog can affect that dog's liver the same as feeding thyroid medication would affect the healthy dog's thyroid gland. It could shut the gland down. Any time we take over the function of a healthy gland with dietary supplements or medication, the gland slowly atrophies. The effect it has on the dog's kidneys is because most forms of vitamin C that are found in dog foods or supplements are not the same as the molecular form the dog is able to produce naturally. The different dietary forms of vitamin C like: Ascorbic Acid (in an "L" form), Sodium Ascorbate or Calcium Ascorbate are all synthetic water soluble forms. They end up in the dogs kidneys where they change the uric pH while waiting to be discharged from the dogs body. This change in the natural pH within the kidneys puts additional stress on them and can cause many problems.

The Morris Animal Foundation has released the findings of a survey determining the main causes of death for dogs in the United States. The second and sixth leading causes cited in that report were kidney disorders and liver failure. Supplemental vitamin C may not cause a dog to die as fast as a bullet from a gun or accidents (the #1 reason) but all indicators point to the fact that it does cause glandular problems which can lead to a dog's death. It works very slowly and can rob years from a pet's normal life span.

Today we know that the average life span of dogs has decreased and people are accepting their shorter life span as being "normal." Advocates for including supplemental C in a dogs diet are quick to point out that there are a number of reasons for the shorter life span. They claim that today our air is full of pollutants that can cause medical problems and vitamin C is needed to combat those pollutants. For a human that can not produce their own vitamin C supplemental vitamin C is needed to combat those pollutants. For a dog supplemental vitamin C is not needed since their glands are capable of producing any amount they need. Test cited in the 1985 NRC publication illustrates this. Test show how a lactating bitch's milk supply contains approximately 4 times that of the blood. This test illustrates how the bitch's glandular system not only increased the amount of vitamin C she normally produces but put it where it was needed (her pup is not able to produce its own vitamin C until it is eating solid foods). The human glandular system does NOT produce vitamin C but a dog's glandular system does. There are other animals that have glandular systems that can produce ALL the vitamin C they need, just like a dog. i.e. An adult goat will manufacture more than 13,000 mg of vitamin C per day in normal health and as much as 100,000 mg daily when faced with life-threatening disease, trauma or stress.

With all the proof we have that supplemental vitamin C can cause a dog problems, the question arises: why do we have vitamin C in dog food products? Vitamin C is found in dog food products because it is an antioxidant (a preservative). Vitamin C can keep fats from going rancid or keep colors bright. It is there with AAFCO's approval. In 1994 AAFCO ("the governing body for the pet food industry") met and agreed with the pet food companies that they would no longer recognize the findings of the National Research Council (NRC) which were listed as the NRC's "Minimum Nutrient Requirements of Dogs" for being a standard to make a dog food eligible to claim it was "Complete & Balanced." This ruling was brought about because the pet food companies wanted to use vitamin C in dog food, as a preservative, and still make the claim that their food was "Complete & Balanced." Under the old definition (before the 1994 AAFCO ruling) for a dog food manufacturer to claim their food was "Complete & Balanced" it could not contain any vitamin C since the NRC showed how it was not required by dogs AND HOW IT COULD DO HARM - TO A DOG. When AAFCO agreed not to recognize the NRC's standards because they were "not current" the pet food companies were then allowed to use this cheap preservative (vitamin C) in a pet food and still make the claim that their food was "Complete & Balanced."

The test cited by the NRC should not be ignored. The NRC's book is still a good source of
 
studies and arguments that disagree with this theory:
How Vitamin C Kept Doggies from Death Row
Canine hip dysplasia occurs when a dog’s femur no longer rests in the ball-and-socket joint of the hip. This genetic and degenerative disease common to many breeds of hunting dogs was traditionally treated in one of two ways: expensive hip replacement surgery or pet euthanasia. Since the malady was inherited more often than not, breeding a dog with CHD was out of the question. Until Wendell Bellfield, a veterinarian in San Jose, California, experimented with vitamin C supplementation.
According to Larry Mueller, the Hunting Dogs Editor of Outdoor Life, Bellfield gave bitches who had CHD, had mates with CHD, and who had previously whelped pups with the disease vitamin C throughout pregnancy and lactation. None of the pups in the eight litters developed the disease.
After this experiment, numerous vets and breeders began giving vitamin C to dogs who already had CHD. The success rate - and the ease in which the disease was rendered powerless - astounded them while the precise way in which the vitamin C worked baffled them. Even though the cured dogs ran pain free, X-rays still revealed hip dysplasia and the severe arthritis that it produced.
Despite the evidence, the medical community was not impressed until a double-blind crossover study performed by veterinarian L. Phillips Brown proved what many dog lovers already knew: crush a 1000 mg tablet of vitamin C in with Lucky’s lunch and he loses his limp. Brown’s research also revealed an additional fact: a specific type of vitamin C, Ester-C, was more effective than traditional ascorbic acid.
What the Canine Cure Means to You
The implications of vitamin C supplementation curing CHD are staggering. Dogs — along with every other animal besides apes, bats, guinea pigs, and humans — produce vitamin C naturally at a far greater rate than we can ingest it. In fact, a 154-pound human needs 10 grams of vitamin C per day to keep pace with the natural production of larger animals. Furthermore, animals produce additional amounts of C in times of stress. Yet dogs benefited from an additional vitamin C supplement. Could you benefit from the same? The answer becomes apparent when you consider that the FDA’s Recommended Daily Allowance is six hundredths of a gram, 167 times less than what a large animal naturally produces on an uneventful day!
Naturally Treating Epilepsy
and Seizure Disorders

by Darleen Rudnick, Pet Nutritionist

Supplement

Purely Pets does not recommend discontinuing traditional medications cold turkey or discontinuing them at all. This is YOUR decision based on how the following program works. We highly recommend you work closely with your veterinarian.

Super C 2000
Vitamin C is known as the king of vitamins and absolutely essential to the living process. Dogs do produce Vitamin C, but stress, separation from the mother, relocation to a new home, neutering, immunizations, sickness, skin problems, ear crops, de-worming, heartworm pills, teething, weather changes, seizures and other ailments quickly deplete the little amount they produce. Medical science has described Vitamin C as one of the least toxic substances known. It is the single most important thing you can do for the health of your pet.



http://www.organic-pet-digest.com/vitamin-c-for-dogs.html
ALL other animals' bodies, including dogs, make Vitamin C, so it is not typically provided in dog food. The problem comes when your dog does not have a healthy immune system.
Not all dogs produce enough Vitamin C due to things like stress, surgery,over-vaccination and genetics. In the wild, these animals would be eating a raw diet to compensate.
And guess what raw meat contains... vitamin C! When meat is cooked or heated the Vitamin C is destroyed. As a result, there is no Vitamin C in a cooked dog food diet.

Vitamin C:
Vitamin C works with vitamin E and helps regenerate vitamin E, potentiating its antioxidant effect. Vitamin C supplementation does no harm, since the excess is excreted through the kidney. While dogs produce vitamin C in their bodies (unlike human beings and guinea pigs who must have it in their diet), under stress or disease, they may need vitamin C in excess of their manufacturing capacity. In excessive dose, vitamin C can cause flatulence and diarrhea. This intestinal tolerance level varies among dogs, but is generally around 3000 mg per day in an adult German Shepherd. I recommend this be given to all dogs. For dogs under 2 years of age, give 250 mg vitamin C twice a day. For dogs over 2 years of age, give 500 mg of vitamin C twice a day.
R.M. Clemmons, DVM, PhDAssociate Professor of Neurology & NeurosurgeryDepartment of Small Animal Clinical Sciences




Your dog need sufficient vitamin C to break down the animal protein in his diet, strengthen his immune system, speed wound healing, help the function of his musculoskeletal system, and whether he gets wormed, is given drugs of any kind or put under any kind of stress.
A lack of vitamin C in the diet commonly result in urinary track infections, cystitis and limping in the front or rear legs. A fairy common misconception is that dogs don’t need extra vitamin C because they produce their own.
Since not enough of either vitamin B complex or C is contained in any processed dog food to meet our criteria for raising a puppy, you have to add both of these to his diet.
The same hold true with vitamin B complex. A fragile, water-soluble vitamin, B is needed for energy, breaking down protein and promoting biochemical reactions in the body which work with enzymes to change the carbohydrates into glucose.
VITAMIN C-DIFFERENT KINDS
CALIUM ASCORBATE
The ascorbic forms are thought to be the most gentle (buffered) and cause the fewest side effects, such as diarrhea or indigestion. Calcium ascorbic is necessary for the breakdown of protein and seems to be accepted and utilized well by most dogs. A water-soluble vitamin, it is flushed through the body in a matter of hours, and cannot be stored. It must be fed to your dog with each meal and is easily absorbed anywhere in the intestinal track. Many health practitioners are of the opinion that recent studies have shown that it helps in stress reduction. Calcium ascorbic is a pH-neutral, slightly bitter powder.
ASCORBIC ACID
Ascorbic Acid a naturally occurring vitamin C, it is tart tasting , and most commonly used in human vitamin C pills. When given in high dosage, it is not efficiently absorbed by dogs and can cause diarrhea. Most find powdered forms of ascorbic acid to be unpalatable due to its tartness.
ESTER-C
Being a time release product, the question has come up a to its effectiveness for dogs, who, when fed properly, process their food in 8 hours. Is the Ester-C actually utilized or passed straight through the intestinal tract? Like the pure forms of calcium and sodium ascorbic, Ester-C is non acidic with a neutral ph, and does not cause gastrointestinal upset One way to find out if your dog needs this expensive form of vitamin C is to kinesiology .
SODIUM ASCORBIC
. Being a time release product, the question has come up a to its effectiveness for dogs, who, when fed properly, process their food in 8 hours. Is the Ester-C actually utilized or passed straight through the intestinal tract? Sodium ascorbic is another readily available and easily absorbed source of vitamin C, Ph-neutral powder, with a slightly saline taste. Shown to stay in the system twice as long as ascorbic acid, this form of vitamin C can be used in low doses in your dog’s diet, especially if Addison’s disease is suspected.



Back to Index
 

Back
Top