Sudden Barking

Ingrid H

Hot Topics Subscriber
$ Forum Donor $
My mom's English cocker spaniel has many problems, but the one that gets on my mom's nerves the most is his sudden barking. He will come out of a complete sleep barking for all he's worth at apparently nothing. Needless to say, these sudden outbursts startle my mom and when my mom gets startled, she gets pissed off. They have tried everything they can think of including squirting him in the face with a water bottle (I do not approve...)
Mom could tell that I did not approve of the squirting and yelling at the dog and took a little bit of offence, but she asked if I had any better ideas. I didn't really have any better ideas except for maybe a no-bark electric collar (which I'm really not all that familiar with). At least a collar would be more consistent than they are in disciplining the dog. My dad has a bad habit of scolding the dog even after he has stopped the unwanted behavior- he did it to Hans while I was there too and I told him that he was telling Hans no even after Hans had obeyed and stopped going after a stuffie he would have destroyed. Poor Hans was just standing there like, "What? I stopped, what am I doing wrong now just standing here???"
Any ideas? My folks are 64 and 70 years old and kinda old-school when it comes to dog training- but they are willing to try anything!
 
I'm not familiar with any 'devices', e-collar or bark collar, but I sure know that barking! My moms tiny toy poodle will do that when she hears something like someone at the door. You know how shrill those tiny dogs bark! OMG It's just like your moms dog, sudden and shrill and scares the bajeebers outta ya! My mom is 85 and you wanna see somebody just about fall over in fright! lol

I don't know what to do about her either, although she will quit faster than your moms dog, but I'm sure it's only because she is smaller and almost blind and when yelled at she gets intimidated easier. But mom will stomp her foot sometimes in anger and while I don't blame her, I don't know if it's the answer either. I've given up on any 'Cesar' methods because mom is 85 and the dog is the love of her life and going blind. She spoils her, picks her up when the dog jumps all over her (even though she doesn't want to) and does most of the 'mistakes' that people do with a tiny dog (that they wouldn't let a large dog do! :blink:) But at this stage, :dunno:

In your case, maybe the bark collar would be a good tool. Like you said, it is consistent anyway. Since I have no experience with it, I'll let others give their thoughts. Good Luck!
 
Dogs Bark!!! Maybe ear plugs for the Humans??? If the dog wakes up and barks he's dreaming or just announcing his arrival, or is simply a weak nerved dog making sure attention comes his way. Even negative attention is ATTENTION. When correction Methods aren't in place these little annoyances become nerve racking. I don't believe in e-collars, water bottles or any other substitute for training hands on. Maybe Bark Back, HAHA! Try it! VON.
 
I agree with you for the most part, VonC. but it can be a problem when the correction after he starts barking, doesn't stop him. That's when I would call it an issue. Barking upon waking, yea, maybe he was startled or something, but then quit. :) I don't have a problem with a dog that barks for a reason, but I want them to stop when I say Enough! I will even go look out a window if Buddy is barking, just to show him that, yes, he has alerted me to something. I want him to do that...but...when it's over and done, and there is not 'boogy man', stop when I say stop. I have never used an electrical device either because I think people overuse it and substitute it for training. But perhaps it would work in this case, I don't know.

My moms little dog (as with a lot of little dogs) has such a shrill bark that it goes right through you! I realize that she is also trying to alert us and not being able to see well, she probably barks more...maybe...lol....

And barking back? Um, no. LOL!
 
Ugh, our Sheltie does that too, and as mentioned that high pitch bark is enough to send me through the roof... Not to mention how annoying it is when it gets Boris and Della going too.

I honestly think the bark collar might be a good solution in your parents case if they tend to be impatient and sort of go about the discipline in a different manner than we might. I'm sure they'd have to trim down the hair on the neck in that area for it to be effective though.
The one we have is activated by the throat vibration and on the first bark it's just a little nick, but if they keep barking it will intensify a bit to give them the idea. Usually they figure it out right away though so there isn't a second bark.
 
Ok so I hate to be a negative Nancy or anything but for the dog to wake up out of a sound sleep and start barking when there is nothing to bark at, have your parents taken him to the vet to see about any kind of neurological problems? I mean my dogs dream in their sleep and the only one I wake up is Penny as it can trigger her seizures, but none of them have just woke up barking unless there was a reason, i.e. the doorbell, someone knocking, ya know. I would say to at least have him checked by the vet and if there is nothing wrong with him then go for the no bark collar, I have heard they work and you are right about it being more consitant than the discipline from your parents. :D Hope this helps, lol
 
I wouldn't use an e-no-bark collar in this instance since the dog is coming out of a sound sleep. Who knows what's causing this response to whatever he's been dreaming. Herc does this in his sleep sometimes and I just quietly wake him up with a soothing calm voice and he goes right back to sleep without continuing. Have you parents tried picking him up petting him and talking calmly and soothingly to him? This is just a bad habit that they are reinforcing by their behavior towards this little guy in my opinion. Maybe moving his bed into a small crate to make him feel safer when he goes to sleep might help. The only other thing I'd try as a last resort is one of those ultra sonic no-bark devices. They make a table top model that emits a shrill noise that mostly only dogs can hear when they bark. Burly had success with a collar version of this one with Zulu. But with a little dog with that much fur the table top model would seem more appropriate. Just my opinion.
 
MyBuddy, What is your correction Method? VON.

I don't have probably with excessive barking so I never thought of it as a Method, but here's what I do......my first thing is, like I said before, I want to develop a bit of 'watchdog' in my dog, so when they start to bark at something, I investigate. To show them that this action of hearing a sound or seeing something out the window gets my attention. Of course, mostly, it's a squirrel, bird etc, and not an intruder, so I will look, then tell him its 'ok' and expect him to be quiet. If he doesn't, I'll repeat it "It's ok, quiet"....most times, he does. I have yelled Quiet more than once though but for the most part, it works. If it didn't, I would would redirect him away from the window.

---------- Post added at 10:13 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:09 AM ----------

Have you parents tried picking him up petting him and talking calmly and soothingly to him? This is just a bad habit that they are reinforcing by their behavior towards this little guy in my opinion.

And see in my opinion, this action is reinforcing behavior by 'rewarding'....the dog doesn't understand the human language, only that you are petting him (rewarding) for an unwanted behavior.
 
I don't agree with you MB. This dog is waking up in a startled mode and barking; not doing nuisance barking at the door or window as a rule when awake. In my opinion there's a big difference and this is only reassuring the dog that it's safe.
 
I don't agree with you MB. This dog is waking up in a startled mode and barking; not doing nuisance barking at the door or window as a rule when awake. In my opinion there's a big difference and this is only reassuring the dog that it's safe.

That's ok, you're entitled to your opinion. :)

In the instance of waking and barking my thoughts are that the dog was startled awake by something. It could be anything, just a sound of a pot banging or something, ya know? Something we didn't even realize we did because it's just 'life', but the dog may have been startled awake and was on 'patrol'. Kind of like you being sound asleep and someone shouts and you wake up like, "WHAT, WHAT, Whats happening??" This is over in a few seconds though when you realize it's nothing.

If it's not over in a few seconds with a dog, than he is just not responding to my "quiet'' commands. Because that's the command I would be giving at the time. Again, I've never had a dog who did this, but in the same vein as what I was talking about with Buddy barking at the window, if he is continuing, I am putting a stop to it. And he'd better respond. I wouldn't feel I have to coddle the dog every time he does this. That'd be like me hugging Buddy every time he barks at the window to show him it's alright. My reassurance to him is my, "It's ok" and my demeanor showing him that it's ok, he can be quiet now.

If this dog does it EVERY time he awakens, then maybe there's something deeper going on.
 
Obviously what the parents are doing, similar to what's been described here as a correction, isn't working. Did this dog come from a breeder or perchance a pet store? I've seen some really ingrained neurotic behaviors from dogs who've been housed since puppyhood until they're purchased form pet stores in a cage with no social interaction except at cage cleaning time. Or even where they've been kenneled by a breeder and not given good interaction with humans until it's too late. I'm getting the sence that his might have been the case with this dogs early upbringing, or lack thereof. Sometimes re-parenting is the answer. You have to make the dog feel secure and safe. He might need medication to help with some anxiety issues, too. All that happens with corrections with a dog like this is that you're reinforcing their negative outlook on life and the humans they should be able to trust. I agree with Tye, it would probably be beneficial if this dog was seen by a vet to rule out neurological disorders. This is no different than a dog who obsessively licks himself for no reason until he has bald spots on his coat. You can't command that away in my opinion.
 
Obviously what the parents are doing, similar to what's been described here as a correction, isn't working.

Not everything someone does is the right correction. Or is consistent. That's why it doesn't work. Sometimes to train (or re-train) you have to work on being ready...always watching and waiting for that moment that you can use your 'tactic'. OR you create it. If my horse is afraid of cars, for instance, I'm not gonna ride down the road hoping for a car to past. I'm gonna set him up by having someone drive by him. Same here. I just may sit and do something while I wait for Mr. Cocker to fall asleep...then I will be waiting his wake up call. If you want to fix something, you have to work at it. Not be surprised by it.

I just do not believe coddling a dog when he is doing something you do not want, helps the situation.

Now, if he has some kind of health problems, that's another story. And I said that. If this is happening every time he awakens, yea, that's an issue I would take to a vet. That doesn't seem right. Then again, if he checks out, back to square one and some corrections. I'm not big on medications all the time either. I don't want to medicate my dog. I'd rather train.
 
I agree with Tye and Mary Lou I think this is deeper than a behavior problem. A visit with the vet and maybe medication is needed??
 
  • Like
Reactions: MLR
My mom's English cocker spaniel has many problems, but the one that gets on my mom's nerves the most is his sudden barking. He will come out of a complete sleep barking for all he's worth at apparently nothing. Needless to say, these sudden outbursts startle my mom and when my mom gets startled, she gets pissed off. They have tried everything they can think of including squirting him in the face with a water bottle (I do not approve...)
Mom could tell that I did not approve of the squirting and yelling at the dog and took a little bit of offence, but she asked if I had any better ideas. I didn't really have any better ideas except for maybe a no-bark electric collar (which I'm really not all that familiar with). At least a collar would be more consistent than they are in disciplining the dog. My dad has a bad habit of scolding the dog even after he has stopped the unwanted behavior- he did it to Hans while I was there too and I told him that he was telling Hans no even after Hans had obeyed and stopped going after a stuffie he would have destroyed. Poor Hans was just standing there like, "What? I stopped, what am I doing wrong now just standing here???"
Any ideas? My folks are 64 and 70 years old and kinda old-school when it comes to dog training- but they are willing to try anything!

My first question here is how old is the dog? You also said it has many problems....wut other problems does he have? From wut you've said here about your Mom and Dad both continuing the scolding the dog after it's done something is not helping, he has already forgotten wut he was being yelled and this all could possibly for attention. I agree with Sharon, and they need to go back to the begining with training, once this dog has been given a clean bill of health......JMO but meds are only going to mask a problem especially if there is no medical problems with this dog, sounds to me like a lack of training, the dog has their number;)

Keep us posted on the outcome!
 
It does sound like the parents don't really know how to train the dog and Ingrid did refer to the dog as having alot of problems. I wonder if the dog doesn't have some anxiety issues along with a lack of training. I have never seen a dog continuously wake up barking for all it is worth for no reason. This dog is reacting to something even if it is something in its own mind. I would never use meds in place of training but in some cases meds are needed in order to be able to begin to train if the dog has some anxiety issues.
 
Thanks all for the good suggestions! This is the same dog I've described before as having been a failed show dog that wasn't well socialized because he was just held by his breeder to see how he would develop. He doesn't bark every time he wakes up, and he does have an excessive barking problem when he is already awake.

Most disturbing of all to me is that the dog seems to direct his barking directly at my dad at times and even seems aggressive. I wasn't sure I could believe my eyes, but my mom thought that was what she was seeing as well. He also growls and shows teeth a lot. He shows teeth when he doesn't like something, but he growls even when he's happy. Grooming was a nightmare until my mom dug out the grooming arm and noose I gave her for her last dog. He settles right down when he's groomed like he would be for a show.

I'll suggest a vet visit, but I really think the dog just has a screw loose. Of course he's not exercised well enough either. I think he's 3 years old.
 
Thanks for the info, Ingrid. This sheds more light on the fact, as Sally said, that this dog 'has their number'. Yes, he sounds like he's had a tough beginning and was not socialized properly or enough, but my opinion still stands...coddling him now is not the answer, in my book. Don't feel sorry for him. Work with him. He already has the upper hand and needs a pack leader. As long as there is nothing wrong medically, he needs some new training that your parents are probably not gonna give at this point. They are probably like most older people, a little 'old school' and never heard of dog psychology! lol Get them a DVD of Cesar! :p The dog doesn't need hitting, yelling, electric devices, medications, blah, blah blah,....he needs exercise and discipline, then love! :) From Cesar's site:

Humanizing Your Dog

One of the most important things I want to get across is that dogs are dogs — not humans!

* Find a canine solution. Often, the solution we would use for a human is totally wrong for solving a dog’s issues. For example, when a human sees a scared or nervous dog, s/he will first offer comfort and consolation. This would never happen in the animal world and can make the problem worse instead of better, because it reinforces unstable behavior.
* Speak the animal language. When dogs come into our homes, they meet emotional energy for the first time. We shower them with affection and babble at them in high-pitched baby-talk, so they see us as excited energy. This is why many dogs don’t listen to their human caretakers. Their mothers never acted this way; where did that calm-assertive leadership go?
* Treat your dog like a dog. We often develop a different agenda for our dogs. We want to make puppies our babies. From day one, many humans forget to fulfill and understand their dog's needs and instead project their own needs and desires on the animal.
* Be the pack leader! In the absence of a clear leader, a dog, even a submissive one, will seek to fill what they see as the vacant leadership role. The dog will ignore the owner, act out, and can lead to serious behavior issues.

Imagine if your significant other mistook your needs for the needs of a chimpanzee; where would that leave you? Confused and disoriented. It’s the same for dogs. But their confusion and disorientation manifest in bad behavior such as tearing up the couch or incessant barking. If we don’t fulfill them as a species, our dogs won’t live a balanced, centered life.
 
Good post Sharon....don't you just love Cesar's way's.....I'm so guilty of humanizing Logan when we first got him, now I have to undo all that!!!

I'm sure with a little time and energy, allot of calm and assertive work your parents dog will be on the mend....
 
Good post Sharon....don't you just love Cesar's way's.
Yes, I do!! It takes some time to redirect our own thinking to understand a dogs way, after years of 'humanizing' them. But he has shown me the light and I can't think any other way now. It feels so natural to me now. It actually started with my horses and Pat Parelli and Clinton Anderson (for you horse people!;)) and followed through to my dog and Cesar. :)
 

Back
Top