Because I'm a fair & open-minded person, I want to post another view on this subject, which after reading it has softened my view considerably on this rule change. What he says is all true. This is long, but worth the read, especially if one is tempted to ditch the sport after this last rule change. We all know it's a sport, not personal protection training, so it makes total sense.
My Two Cents and a Voice of Reason
Over the past few days, I’ve seen FB flooded with comments and hysteria about the FCI’s removal of stick hits from IGP trials.
And while I don’t like the move, don’t agree with it and think it unnecessary, I also do not subscribe to the doomsday meltdowns posted by people.
I have participated in the sport of SchH/IPO/IGP in every aspect for well over 4 decades, many things have changed, most of them not for the better. But I still continue in the sport. Why? Because it is my hobby and I enjoy it in the way that I do it.
The notion that the purpose of the sport is to test the dogs’ character for breeding and that the stick hits are somehow crucial for that is simply not true anymore, and I can say that it hasn’t been for at least 40 years.
The creation of the SchH test and trial was originally to test dogs for suitability for the breeding of POLICE dogs. Once the sport became a sport and it became about points and competition the trials were about something else. Breeding changed accordingly, it became breeding to create the next dog on the podium and not a new generation of police dogs.
If SchH and stick hits are so crucial to the breed worthiness evaluation, what exactly happened with show dogs in every former police dog breed? They have SchH titles, they got stick hits, etc. Why are they not rock star police dogs or for that matter even competitive sport dogs?
Over the years so many things have changed in the SchH sport, many of them much worse for the evaluation of the dogs, but not many people even blinked an eye. SchH is a sport, it’s supposed to be a fun hobby for human and dog together. The breed worthiness aspect of it disappeared a long time ago. And if we talk about breed worthiness, for what exactly? The original purpose was to create police dogs, not more competitive and point capable sport dogs. So which changes do we accept? A slow out with extra commands costs more points than a dog missing the initial bite on a courage test. And the list goes on.
People talk about the dogs needing to be tested; well, do people really want their dogs tested in competition?
Of course they don’t. They want predictability and consistency and most of all they want success. If that wasn’t the case, I assure you that helper selection would be a lot different than what it has become.
The sport tests training and that’s it. The standards of performance have changed in many ways, and many modern-day competitors would be in for a big surprise if they tried to train todays obedience to a dog from 30-40 years ago.
And what breed saving tests are we talking about? Is it really just the stick hits? And who is hitting? A 250# helper or a 170# helper?
Personally, I believe pressure and testing comes from the helper, the person, his presence and ability to make a dog feel pressure. The stick is an object in the helper’s hand, nothing more, nothing less.
As helpers we work at different levels, club level, national level. We administer different levels of pressure and even different intensity in the stick hits. Which level makes it a breed worthiness test? And, the points in a score book are not really reflective of any of it.
I can tell you as a helper at every level, that I have seen more dogs disengage and retreat in exercises which did not involve stick hits.
Why do I say all this, because people losing their minds and giving up on something they love over yet another annoying rule change is a sad overreaction. If you can only enjoy the sport because dogs are being hit with a padded stick maybe you should reflect on that.
Other sports exist, I have participated in most. They all have their pros and cons, their easy parts and their hard parts.
If you want to know who your dog really is, maybe do more than one sport at the same time, if you can accept that you may never reach the best scores in any of them. But if you care more about points that “testing your dog” then why the melt down over removing a couple of slaps with a padded stick?
We all have our own reasons for doing dog sports. If the number #1 reason is not fun and enjoyment, maybe you’re not in it for the right reason.
Sports are NOT real world; they haven’t been as long as I have been doing it no matter what people say.
Videos were posted of a helper chasing off some dogs during long bites. Aside from some technical incorrectness on the part of the helper it certainly showed dogs succumbing to personal pressure, not physical contact with the stick. But is any of that real world? The same helper let go of the sleeve with the same dog twice to avoid falling. The dog while impressively fast and physically powerful happily ran to his handler with the sleeve in his mouth while an unprotected helper was perfectly safe. Because this is a SPORT! And sports should be safe for dog and helper. All sports have rules and referees and all kinds of limiting constraints to keep things safe and fun. Stick hits are not a safety concern, I’m just making the point that MANY things have changed.
Aside from my hobby of dog sports I also work real world dogs at the highest level, police dogs, military dogs and elite special operations dogs all over the world. I train them and sometimes I test them, I test them for the real world work they must be able to do in order to save their own life and the lives of the humans with them and you know what? The padded stick doesn’t even enter the picture. It takes a whole lot more than that.
In the end it is all about perspective.
Enjoy doing something fun and challenging with your dog. If you want to evaluate more about your dog’s character and abilities, try different sports as well, because I can tell you from personal experiences NO one sport checks all the boxes.
Nobody’s life depends on your sport dog, it’s about fun and hobby and maybe a little bit of ego. And that’s it. And if you are a breeder and you want to produce dogs who can go on to save lives, a SchH trial with hits from a padded stick is not enough. It wasn’t last year and it wasn’t 20 years ago.
If you no longer like SchH because it doesn’t have stick hits anymore then that says a lot more about you than the sport. Because the sport is what WE make it for ourselves, our dogs and club members, not politics. And I don’t just mean the official politics which may lead to written rule changes, but all the politics which affect many aspects of our sports that nobody wants to talk about. The reason the European dog sports have all been around for over 100 years is because the majority of people care more about having a fun hobby with their dogs than annoying nuances in a rule book.
Enjoy your dogs, and focus on the great hobby ALL dog sport is.
Armin Winkler