Countries/States where Docking/Cropping are discouraged/prohibited

DD4MSpock

Hot Topics Subscriber
I was reading the "Ear posting - improved method" and one other thread, and it caused me to question (because I didn't remember). In what countries/states are docking/cropping discouraged or banned outright? I'll be honest... I have some difficulty with an undocked/uncropped dobie. It just doesn't look right. Not that I would love that dog any less, but it just looks like a different breed, to me.

Which Countries/States are real strict about it?

Thanks much.
 
As far as I know there are no US states that it's banned but there has been talk about it in a few.

There are some providences in Canada where it's been banned but some do still allow it, as far as I know.

Quite a few European countries have had a ban on it for quite some time now and with the FCI jumping on the bandwagon it's getting to be more and more. I know quite a few people who have imported pups from Serbia with crops/docks.
Our breeder says "our pups will be cropped and docked before they leave" and that's the way I like it.
 
Complete ban on docking & cropping in the U.K. since 2006. Up until that date all Dobes had tails docked but as ear cropping had been banned by the the Kennel Club of Britain about 80 years before that (& so couldn’t be shown in the U.K) Dobes with cropped ears were just not around (maybe the odd one as breeding stock), so much so that when I got my first one in 1985 it never occurred to me that they came with anything other than “natural“ ears as that was the U.K. breed standard for a Doberman. It was only after an influx of people from Eastern Europe in recent years & relaxation of regulations regarding movement of pets within the European Union that c & d Dobes became easily available & thus somewhat fashionable but even so they have only ever been a tiny minority of Dobes here (Of the hundreds I’ve seen only 2 have been c & d & those with one owner).
I think that there is legislation in the pipeline to even ban the import of c & d dogs into the U.K. in the near future.
Ive had had 4 with docked tails & 2 with natural tails. After nearly 30 years of Dobes without tails the first I had with one took some getting used to, but after 10 years I now like the tail & ones with cropped tails look strange. If I lived in a country where c & d was how the majority of Dobes were, I can imagine that those with natural ears & tails would look odd.
Agree with Jazzies mum….a case of what you get used to.
 
Now I hear in Europe they are also going to Ban the Stick hit in Schutzhund.
Yup, that's a done deal. So far, not in the U.S. This whole SchH. thing started as a test for breeding stellar GSDs: their devout obedience, their fearlessness in protection and their ability to be independent in tracking. In the last 30 years it's done nothing but get softer & easier. Oh well.
 
Are there any EU countries where it is legal?
It seems any country under the British Crown is either all in or getting there(Canada)

I notice many people in Europe get pups from Serbia as they still do C/D
Now, Serbia is in an application status (not sure of the nomenclature there) to join the EU.
If they are accepted in we should expect it will be banned there too.

There a whole wall of words I’d like to type here, but this isn’t the political section and I know someone would complain.
I’m sure many of you can guess where I’d be going with that so I’ll jist bow out now😂
 
Dogs with cropped ears have been ineligible for entry into dog shows associated with the Kennel Club of Britain for decades so any international breeder wishing to show at the biggest (Crufts show) wouldn’t crop their dogs. Simple as that I’d imagine. The EU has so far left it up to individual nation states as to how they legislate about the issue. Switzerland (not an EU member state) I understand has very strict regulation’s against c & d. It’s only become an issue in the U.K. in recent years since quarantine regulations were relaxed & so the reduced cost of importing c & d dogs (though still 3x the price before Covid ) became financially viable. Before then the only Dobes available domestically (& since they’ve been bred here) have had natural ears.
 
A quick Wikipedia search informs that c & d is illegal in virtually all European countries (including Serbia from 2019) In France dogs can be docked but not cropped.
 
Dogs with cropped ears have been ineligible for entry into dog shows associated with the Kennel Club of Britain for decades so any international breeder wishing to show at the biggest (Crufts show) wouldn’t crop their dogs. Simple as that I’d imagine. The EU has so far left it up to individual nation states as to how they legislate about the issue. Switzerland (not an EU member state) I understand has very strict regulation’s against c & d. It’s only become an issue in the U.K. in recent years since quarantine regulations were relaxed & so the reduced cost of importing c & d dogs (though still 3x the price before Covid ) became financially viable. Before then the only Dobes available domestically (& since they’ve been bred here) have had natural ears.

I thought only C/D Working dogs could be imported into the UK?
 
I thought only C/D Working dogs could be imported into the UK?
Any proposed changes to the legislation regarding the import of C/D dogs has yet to be implemented so any C/D dog can be imported providing it has a U.K. “health passport”. Requirements for this are pretty basic. Dog has to be over 15 weeks old, to take into account that a pup must be 12 weeks old before it can have a Rabies jab & 3 more weeks for the Rabies jab to become effective. Also a certificate from a vet from the country of origin saying that the pup is “healthy”.
We have contradictory legislation in this respect….as in, C & D procedures are illegal within the U.K. but OK done in another county & the dogs then imported to the U.K. (even if it’s illegal in that other country, but not policed). :scratch:
 
Last edited:

Back
Top