Do prong collars cause Bumps on neck?

Alvr728

Novitiate
Hello,

I was wondering if any of you have had past experience with any of your Dobermans getting bumps on their neck due to wearing a prong collar. My Doberman is a year and a half and I noticed lately he has been getting bumps on his neck and losing some hair. I'm not sure if this is due to the prong collar or it may be due to something else. He only wears his prong collar when we go on walks and he wears his leather collar with this dog tag 24/7. Not sure If this may also be an issue. Any recommendations or advice?
 
Photos would be helpful. I only put a collar on my dog if we are going somewhere or training, otherwise she's naked. Some dogs get skin rash from even a soft leather collar rubbing, since the prong sits higher up on the neck, I'm assuming the bumps are in that area, not around the leather collar area?
 
Some dogs have allergic reactions to the metal of prong collars.
HermSpringer has prong collars with different metals and coated metals for allergic response dogs.
I had to switch due to my two reacting to the metals from their first prong collars.
I would recommend HermSpringer instead of other brands.
 
Hello,

I was wondering if any of you have had past experience with any of your Dobermans getting bumps on their neck due to wearing a prong collar. My Doberman is a year and a half and I noticed lately he has been getting bumps on his neck and losing some hair. I'm not sure if this is due to the prong collar or it may be due to something else. He only wears his prong collar when we go on walks and he wears his leather collar with this dog tag 24/7. Not sure If this may also be an issue. Any recommendations or advice?
A flat collar rubs more than a prong. Prong sits high and snug on the neck. Depends where the bumps are. But short answer is no if used correctly.
 
As stated, I only put a prong collar on when necessary, then take it right back off again. We use Herm Sprengers too.
 
One more vote for Herm Springer.
They have a few styles and finishes.
Some look like a flat collar but have a prong under which is good in public. Some folks are a bit vocal about prong collars.

Used correctly they are a game changer.
Anyone with arthritis in their hands or carpel tunnel etc can attest.
 
Hello,

I was wondering if any of you have had past experience with any of your Dobermans getting bumps on their neck due to wearing a prong collar. My Doberman is a year and a half and I noticed lately he has been getting bumps on his neck and losing some hair. I'm not sure if this is due to the prong collar or it may be due to something else. He only wears his prong collar when we go on walks and he wears his leather collar with this dog tag 24/7. Not sure If this may also be an issue. Any recommendations or advice?
And out of curiosity.
Your Dobe a red or other dilute?
They seem to have more sensitive skin than the typical black/rust dogs.
 
Some dogs have allergic reactions to the metal of prong collars.
HermSpringer has prong collars with different metals and coated metals for allergic response dogs.
I had to switch due to my two reacting to the metals from their first prong collars.
I would recommend HermSpringer instead of other brands.
Agreed...that is how I discovered Herm Sprengers Couragan Prong...my girl had a reaction to stainless. You can also buy plastic or rubber tips for the prong.
 
Hello,

I was wondering if any of you have had past experience with any of your Dobermans getting bumps on their neck due to wearing a prong collar. My Doberman is a year and a half and I noticed lately he has been getting bumps on his neck and losing some hair. I'm not sure if this is due to the prong collar or it may be due to something else. He only wears his prong collar when we go on walks and he wears his leather collar with this dog tag 24/7. Not sure If this may also be an issue. Any recommendations or advice?
Did you find a solution to this? My last dobie was fine with a prong and only had a thinning hair reaction to normal collars being left on all day. My new black girl, however, is insanely sensitive and started developing bumps from her prong around 1.5 years old as well. I’ve used the hypoallergenic metal which helped but she was still getting sores and bumps so I added rubber tips. The rubber tips also helped, but she’s still getting bumps. They’re worse when we’re having a bad day or week (if she’s really excited and pulling through the prong). It’s very frustrating. I’m thinking the only way to solve it is to hire a trainer to get her to completely stop pulling and not need the prong anymore, but that’s expensive and I’m honestly not sure she’s ever going to change. It’s her excitement that makes her pull to the point where she’s getting bumps (if she smells the ocean, it’s game over).
 
Did you find a solution to this? My last dobie was fine with a prong and only had a thinning hair reaction to normal collars being left on all day. My new black girl, however, is insanely sensitive and started developing bumps from her prong around 1.5 years old as well. I’ve used the hypoallergenic metal which helped but she was still getting sores and bumps so I added rubber tips. The rubber tips also helped, but she’s still getting bumps. They’re worse when we’re having a bad day or week (if she’s really excited and pulling through the prong). It’s very frustrating. I’m thinking the only way to solve it is to hire a trainer to get her to completely stop pulling and not need the prong anymore, but that’s expensive and I’m honestly not sure she’s ever going to change. It’s her excitement that makes her pull to the point where she’s getting bumps (if she smells the ocean, it’s game over).
Ahh....it sounds like you have fallen into the "always have to use the prong" trap. The prong collar is a tool for training, not an everyday collar. A trainer to teach you is a good idea. However, it you can't afford a trainer your next best option is to watch videos on how to properly use a prong so YOU can train her not to pull.
 
She’s not bad on our morning jogs (she has her days where she’s not so great, but for the most part she understands not to pull). It’s the moments she smells the ocean or park. I’ve had a trainer that insisted on using an ecollar, but her neck reacts to the metal on those as well. She gets sores from any type of metal touching the neck like that (hence the rubber tips I added to the prong). :(
 
Could you put a photo up of the reaction to metal? Did the rubber tips prevent the reaction? It truly sounds like you need to go back to square one with obedience. Corrections need to be swift and enough to stop her in her tracks and then go on with what you are doing. Dragging you to the beach or out-of-control excitement should not be tolerated. You on the other end of the leash not allowing her to go into "game over" mode will be the only way to fix it. Tough love and some come to Jesus moments, but always be fair. No nagging, no dragging it out. Best of luck, you can do this.
 

Back
Top