• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

A really good explain about Your Dog & other dogs/people

See, I like this, overall; and I think I will probably start to do things differently with my next dog.

A couple thoughts though:

If one is to commit to this, they had better be prepared to have thick skin and would do well to naturally have antisocial tendencies themselves or to just not care what anyone thinks of them. (Incidentally, this might be good fit for yours truly). When you have your dog out in public, JQP tends to feel that it IS your obligation to let your dog meet them, and to varying degrees, to let your dog meet their dog. I also think that one would not want to take their dog to places like the patio of restaurants. I have enjoyed doing that, but to do it and to tell several people over the course of your visit that, no, you cannot pet my dog would be awkward. I suppose an effective weapon would be "my dog is in training."

One reason I have felt the need to take my dog around other dogs (in the case of Oji, to the dog park for zero $ socializing) is: What would happen if your dog, who has not been exposed to meeting other dogs or being in contact with other dogs since it was a couple months old, has a dog come up to it? This could take the form of an off-leash dog coming up to your dog, or just an on-leash dog and yours having to share sidewalk space. I would be concerned that my dog would be scared by such an unfamiliar experience and would either cower or be quite aggressive.

So, doesn't a dog need some experience with rubbing shoulders and sniffing butts with other dogs – preferably in as safe and controlled an environment as possible?
 
This us what I teach and believe also. Our dogs need to be confident and ok being in public when other people and dogs are present. They don’t need dog friends or play dates, they are not human children. I do teach my dogs to be tolerant of strangers since people will occasionally come up to great us. They need to sit or lay down politely. This is basics that taught even for the CGC test. Meet and greet a neutral stranger, a friendly stranger and one with a dog. The dogs are never allowed to interact and must be calm and in control. The biggest mistake most people make when they get a puppy is thinking that socializing is about introducing the puppy to people and other dogs thru interaction, when it is exposure to those things while interacting and building the bond with you. This teaches them your leadership and that they can always feel safe when out with you. Dogs pulling, barking, whining are all full of anxiety an are unsure of there situation but have been taught this behavior thru improper socialization skills.
 
@Oh Little Oji - it's not talking about isolation, it's talking about teaching the dog to be neutral in the presence of strange dogs/people and to look to its handler for direction on how to handle the situation. @Doberman Gang explained it well.

Rubbing shoulders & sniffing butts doesn't teach anything about remaining neutral, that's allowing the dogs to introduce themselves to each other then to commence dominance, because that's the next step. Sometimes it's through play but sometimes it's with a fight, but either way it leads to dominance by one dog or the other. That first line about wolves: Two packs might pass close enough to see and observe each other but then they keep going. A meet & greet & butt sniff is going to become a fight, same with lions & horses.

And yes, it takes some will power to say "no" to people wanting to pet your dog. And there's nothing wrong with saying its in training. Dogs are in training for life, so it's never a lie. ;) Asha is overly suspicious of strangers and started growling at people when she was 3 months old. I was horrified that she didn't look to me for guidance. So when she was a puppy I did let some strangers pet her and offer her one of my treats as I was trying to get her to accept that every human was not a threat. I have since acknowledged that this is some deep genetics as she is growly to everyone she meets until she has some time with them. This is a disaster for showing, and like the CGC test with allowing someone to touch them. I still don't have it mastered, but she is better. I manage Asha & don't allow it & correct it when it happens, but I've totally quit letting strangers come up and pet her and frankly they've pretty much quit asking because of her attitude. Patio diners, a down stay by your feet and anyone who asks, just say no, the dog is not allowed to socialize. And that's not a lie either.
 
@Oh Little Oji - it's not talking about isolation, it's talking about teaching the dog to be neutral in the presence of strange dogs/people and to look to its handler for direction on how to handle the situation. @Doberman Gang explained it well.

Rubbing shoulders & sniffing butts doesn't teach anything about remaining neutral, that's allowing the dogs to introduce themselves to each other then to commence dominance, because that's the next step. Sometimes it's through play but sometimes it's with a fight, but either way it leads to dominance by one dog or the other. That first line about wolves: Two packs might pass close enough to see and observe each other but then they keep going. A meet & greet & butt sniff is going to become a fight, same with lions & horses.

And yes, it takes some will power to say "no" to people wanting to pet your dog. And there's nothing wrong with saying its in training. Dogs are in training for life, so it's never a lie. ;) Asha is overly suspicious of strangers and started growling at people when she was 3 months old. I was horrified that she didn't look to me for guidance. So when she was a puppy I did let some strangers pet her and offer her one of my treats as I was trying to get her to accept that every human was not a threat. I have since acknowledged that this is some deep genetics as she is growly to everyone she meets until she has some time with them. This is a disaster for showing, and like the CGC test with allowing someone to touch them. I still don't have it mastered, but she is better. I manage Asha & don't allow it & correct it when it happens, but I've totally quit letting strangers come up and pet her and frankly they've pretty much quit asking because of her attitude. Patio diners, a down stay by your feet and anyone who asks, just say no, the dog is not allowed to socialize. And that's not a lie either.
Good stuff, Ravenbird, thanks. I totally agree that a dog is in training pretty much for life – maybe until it is quite elderly. People are so presumptuous about dogs though. I know many people would follow up with "Oh. Training for what?" So one would do well to have an answer for that, and another answer for whatever question comes next. Else, just be prepared to at some point to be uncomfortably firm with the person.

Or, when they ask your dog's name (which is almost inevitable) you could answer as I have a few times: "Snapper Head."

The meeting / not meeting of other dogs thing: Here is one of the many areas where I believe that country life with a dog is so different from city life with a dog. I have the sense that more people on here live lives closer to what could be described as country life.

Actually, I think the pandemic has brought about a condition that is applicable to this conversation: I just took a run with Oji on the sidewalks in our residential neighborhood. I was going to take him for a walk in the nearby wooded area because I know on a "nice" Saturday, the sidewalk space is at a premium and for a year now I have had to negotiate with people on distancing as we share sidewalk space. This morning, however, was in the 30s so I thought the sidewalks would be sparsely populated. I was mostly correct. Still, on a handful of occasions, I had to find a space – someone's driveway, a lawn, or whatever – to pull over and wait until other dog walkers passed by.

I imagine this system advocated in this socialization thread might be similar in my geographic environment: When another dog walker is oncoming to you, you (while, yes, trying to get your dog to focus on you, or as I have been able to accomplish, I "take control of the situation" by issuing the command to not bark at the other dog) you would have to give a wide berth to the other dog walker because of the chance that while your dog is faithfully paying attention to you, the other dog who may come close enough to touch your dog might actually wind up biting your dog. That would be terribly unfair to your dog.

So my policy has always been that if a dog is either loose or it appears the other dog owner is going to let it reach my dog, I let my dog stand and defend itself – at least until the other dog owner physically gets their dog out of range. It reminds me of the time I had Oji running next to my bicycle off leash as I do. An off leash dog ran up behind behind Oji, who was faithfully heeling alongside the bike, and bit him on the leg.
 
I trained the Sinsiters to ignore other people and dogs, unless I say otherwise! I do agree with what Ravenbird posted. My girls are not reactive to strange people and dogs. Certainly, if another persons dog is not behaving, I keep the girls at a distance and under my control. I also carry protection in case of an attack which, thankfully, has never happened to us. I train so that my girls are not stressed when around others. I think by deciding when and who I want them to meet has kept them on a very even keel when out and about. For me it is about socialization through ignoring everything until I decide I want them to meet another person or dog. I have no problem refusing to let strangers pet them. I do not care what question they ask as to the reason, my answer is no "my dog is not allowed to be petted due to training in obedience". If they don't like the answer or continue to ask questions I just repeat "no"! I do live in the city, so I run into this on a regular basis.
 
Good stuff, Ravenbird, thanks. I totally agree that a dog is in training pretty much for life – maybe until it is quite elderly. People are so presumptuous about dogs though. I know many people would follow up with "Oh. Training for what?" So one would do well to have an answer for that, and another answer for whatever question comes next. Else, just be prepared to at some point to be uncomfortably firm with the person.

Or, when they ask your dog's name (which is almost inevitable) you could answer as I have a few times: "Snapper Head."

The meeting / not meeting of other dogs thing: Here is one of the many areas where I believe that country life with a dog is so different from city life with a dog. I have the sense that more people on here live lives closer to what could be described as country life.

Actually, I think the pandemic has brought about a condition that is applicable to this conversation: I just took a run with Oji on the sidewalks in our residential neighborhood. I was going to take him for a walk in the nearby wooded area because I know on a "nice" Saturday, the sidewalk space is at a premium and for a year now I have had to negotiate with people on distancing as we share sidewalk space. This morning, however, was in the 30s so I thought the sidewalks would be sparsely populated. I was mostly correct. Still, on a handful of occasions, I had to find a space – someone's driveway, a lawn, or whatever – to pull over and wait until other dog walkers passed by.

I imagine this system advocated in this socialization thread might be similar in my geographic environment: When another dog walker is oncoming to you, you (while, yes, trying to get your dog to focus on you, or as I have been able to accomplish, I "take control of the situation" by issuing the command to not bark at the other dog) you would have to give a wide berth to the other dog walker because of the chance that while your dog is faithfully paying attention to you, the other dog who may come close enough to touch your dog might actually wind up biting your dog. That would be terribly unfair to your dog.

So my policy has always been that if a dog is either loose or it appears the other dog owner is going to let it reach my dog, I let my dog stand and defend itself – at least until the other dog owner physically gets their dog out of range. It reminds me of the time I had Oji running next to my bicycle off leash as I do. An off leash dog ran up behind behind Oji, who was faithfully heeling alongside the bike, and bit him on the leg.

Good stuff, Ravenbird, thanks. I totally agree that a dog is in training pretty much for life – maybe until it is quite elderly. People are so presumptuous about dogs though. I know many people would follow up with "Oh. Training for what?" So one would do well to have an answer for that, and another answer for whatever question comes next. Else, just be prepared to at some point to be uncomfortably firm with the person.

Or, when they ask your dog's name (which is almost inevitable) you could answer as I have a few times: "Snapper Head."

The meeting / not meeting of other dogs thing: Here is one of the many areas where I believe that country life with a dog is so different from city life with a dog. I have the sense that more people on here live lives closer to what could be described as country life.

Actually, I think the pandemic has brought about a condition that is applicable to this conversation: I just took a run with Oji on the sidewalks in our residential neighborhood. I was going to take him for a walk in the nearby wooded area because I know on a "nice" Saturday, the sidewalk space is at a premium and for a year now I have had to negotiate with people on distancing as we share sidewalk space. This morning, however, was in the 30s so I thought the sidewalks would be sparsely populated. I was mostly correct. Still, on a handful of occasions, I had to find a space – someone's driveway, a lawn, or whatever – to pull over and wait until other dog walkers passed by.

I imagine this system advocated in this socialization thread might be similar in my geographic environment: When another dog walker is oncoming to you, you (while, yes, trying to get your dog to focus on you, or as I have been able to accomplish, I "take control of the situation" by issuing the command to not bark at the other dog) you would have to give a wide berth to the other dog walker because of the chance that while your dog is faithfully paying attention to you, the other dog who may come close enough to touch your dog might actually wind up biting your dog. That would be terribly unfair to your dog.

So my policy has always been that if a dog is either loose or it appears the other dog owner is going to let it reach my dog, I let my dog stand and defend itself – at least until the other dog owner physically gets their dog out of range. It reminds me of the time I had Oji running next to my bicycle off leash as I do. An off leash dog ran up behind behind Oji, who was faithfully heeling alongside the bike, and bit him on the leg.
I have wondered about this also. If an unleashed dog aggressively approaches your leashed dog what is the best action? My boyfriend always says to let your dog off the leash so they can defend themselves. I have never been sure of what would be best in this situation
 
I have wondered about this also. If an unleashed dog aggressively approaches your leashed dog what is the best action? My boyfriend always says to let your dog off the leash so they can defend themselves. I have never been sure of what would be best in this situation
Your boyfriend is correct in that your leashed dog would be at a physical disadvantage; however in terms of blame, and if it should go to court or at least be hashed out by a law enforcement officer, you gave up your legal advantage if you took off the leash. On the other hand, you don't want your dog to get hurt because you are trying to follow the law. So it's a tough call.

I don't think I've ever dropped the leash in this situation. If you chose to let your dog loose, I would do it that way – dropping the leash, instead of unhooking it. This way, you can claim you dropped it accidentally. Just don't accidentally step on your dog's leash in the chaos. Also, don't let the other dog's owner grab your dog's leash.

A lot to think about, I know.

I know I said I let my dog stand and defend himself, but I didn't mention that if I determine that the dog coming at him is too much a threat, I actually put myself between them and am ready to let the soles of my shoes do the talking. A lot of dogs are scared or at least put off by this. If the dog kept coming for my dog, then I'd drop the leash and I'd go for the hips or tail of the aggressor dog and pull it back. If it takes damage from my dog while I've got a hold of it, oh well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Skb
If an unleashed dog aggressively approaches your leashed dog what is the best action?
This has only happened to me twice and both times my dog was game but I stood between her and the offending dog, holding the leash about 3" off the collar forcing her behind my legs while I threatened the offending dog. Both times the owner was there & caught them up, both times the dog had slipped it's collar and both times they were yelling "he's friendly!". And both times I yelled back, SHES NOT! And they believed me because she was trying really hard to get by me to the loose dog and it made them move a lot faster to capture their dog. I would never ever turn my dog loose in a situation like that. You have no idea what they're going to be dealing with or if the loose dog turned tail and ran for his life into traffic and your dog chased blindly? No f'ing way. I'm my dogs life long protector and I'll fight kicking & screaming to keep her from being attacked by someones loose dog. And it works because, like Oji said:
I actually put myself between them and am ready to let the soles of my shoes do the talking. A lot of dogs are scared or at least put off by this.
Probably 99% of them will back off. They want to whip your dog, not you.
 
This has only happened to me twice and both times my dog was game but I stood between her and the offending dog, holding the leash about 3" off the collar forcing her behind my legs while I threatened the offending dog. Both times the owner was there & caught them up, both times the dog had slipped it's collar and both times they were yelling "he's friendly!". And both times I yelled back, SHES NOT! And they believed me because she was trying really hard to get by me to the loose dog and it made them move a lot faster to capture their dog. I would never ever turn my dog loose in a situation like that. You have no idea what they're going to be dealing with or if the loose dog turned tail and ran for his life into traffic and your dog chased blindly? No f'ing way. I'm my dogs life long protector and I'll fight kicking & screaming to keep her from being attacked by someones loose dog. And it works because, like Oji said:

Probably 99% of them will back off. They want to whip your dog, not you.
Yes, i believe that would be my first reaction to get my dog close to the collar and try to kick the other dog away. I cant imagine just letting my dog go. I hope I never have to find out. Dog fights are scary to me.
 
This has only happened to me twice and both times my dog was game but I stood between her and the offending dog, holding the leash about 3" off the collar forcing her behind my legs while I threatened the offending dog. Both times the owner was there & caught them up, both times the dog had slipped it's collar and both times they were yelling "he's friendly!". And both times I yelled back, SHES NOT! And they believed me because she was trying really hard to get by me to the loose dog and it made them move a lot faster to capture their dog. I would never ever turn my dog loose in a situation like that. You have no idea what they're going to be dealing with or if the loose dog turned tail and ran for his life into traffic and your dog chased blindly? No f'ing way. I'm my dogs life long protector and I'll fight kicking & screaming to keep her from being attacked by someones loose dog. And it works because, like Oji said:

Probably 99% of them will back off. They want to whip your dog, not you.

I do all the above AND yell NOOOO in my most firm, don't f*ck with me voice possible. I would say most dogs understand the word NO. The couple of times we've come across off leash dogs (they're even dogs we know 75% of the time who's owners just don't bother leashing them in a busy suburb????), I put Rubie behind me, get into an intimidating stance and yell NO at the approaching dog.

We also have Moo who is a wonderful interceptor of 'friendly dogs' :facepalm:
 
Just to 'vent'... Yesterday, dogs leashed, we saw this man again and his dog about 45 lb size walking on the sidewalk on the opposite side of the street from where I was walking Bedja. This man's dog has acted out before and is always the one who starts misbehaving - if other dogs are cool mine doesn't take notice. Anyway, me knowing that our dogs don't like each other from several previous encounters!, instead of turning around adding 3/4 mile to our destination in order to avoid them, I put Bedja in a down stay, hoping the man would settle for just passing by.
But, won't you believe it, despite me having turned my back to them and not responding, the man keeps calling out 'Hello!'...Hello!' and approaching us and crossing the street, until he showed up right behind me, and there wasn't enough time to tell him to keep distance and move on, but his dog exploded at Bedja and Bedja sprang up from his 'down' stay and at it they went loud and noisy :facepalm::facepalm::facepalm:
Good thing whatever Bedja is saying it makes the other dog shut up:whistle:
Next time I see them from my car without Bedja in it, I guess I shall have to ask the man directly to stay away???

I also do the counter conditioning my dog with treats, but with these kind of people:weird::groan:
 
Last edited:
Just to 'vent'... Yesterday, dogs leashed, we saw this man again and his dog about 45 lb size walking on the sidewalk on the opposite side of the street from where I was walking Bedja. This man's dog has acted out before and is always the one who starts misbehaving - if other dogs are cool mine doesn't take notice. Anyway, me knowing that our dogs don't like each other from several previous encounters!, instead of turning around adding 3/4 mile to our destination in order to avoid them, I put Bedja in a down stay, hoping the man would settle for just passing by.
But, won't you believe it, despite me having turned my back to them and not responding, the man keeps calling out 'Hello!'...Hello!' and approaching us and crossing the street, until he showed up right behind me, and there wasn't enough time to tell him to keep distance and move on, but his dog exploded at Bedja and Bedja sprang up from his 'down' stay and at it they went loud and noisy :facepalm::facepalm::facepalm:
Good thing whatever Bedja is saying it makes the other dog shut up:whistle:
Next time I see them from my car without Bedja in it, I guess I shall have to ask the man directly to stay away???

I also do the counter conditioning my dog with treats, but with these kind of people:weird::groan:

First of all that guy is an :censored: Hole!

But when we are walking, we never put them in a sit or a down. We just keep moving talking to them to get their attention. Especially putting them in a down this is a very vulnerable position for a dog.
 
Just to 'vent'... Yesterday, dogs leashed, we saw this man again and his dog about 45 lb size walking on the sidewalk on the opposite side of the street from where I was walking Bedja. This man's dog has acted out before and is always the one who starts misbehaving - if other dogs are cool mine doesn't take notice. Anyway, me knowing that our dogs don't like each other from several previous encounters!, instead of turning around adding 3/4 mile to our destination in order to avoid them, I put Bedja in a down stay, hoping the man would settle for just passing by.
But, won't you believe it, despite me having turned my back to them and not responding, the man keeps calling out 'Hello!'...Hello!' and approaching us and crossing the street, until he showed up right behind me, and there wasn't enough time to tell him to keep distance and move on, but his dog exploded at Bedja and Bedja sprang up from his 'down' stay and at it they went loud and noisy :facepalm::facepalm::facepalm:
Good thing whatever Bedja is saying it makes the other dog shut up:whistle:
Next time I see them from my car without Bedja in it, I guess I shall have to ask the man directly to stay away???

I also do the counter conditioning my dog with treats, but with these kind of people:weird::groan:
How irritating!

I'm not giving the guy a pass, but is it plausible that he needed to use the side of the street that you were on? I'd hope so. If he crossed the street just to get over by you and Bedja, that is kind of messed up.
 
But when we are walking, we never put them in a sit or a down. We just keep moving talking to them to get their attention. Especially putting them in a down this is a very vulnerable position for a dog.
I totally see your point. Bedja is normally good at giving me attention, but with this particular dog in sight I'm not able to make him look at me since that first time that dog acted out. As long as the other dog is quiet Bedja is also, although on alert. My Dobe is also quite confident so I thought we could have a few moments of focus training under distraction there, which might have been possible if they hadn't crossed the street.
How irritating!

I'm not giving the guy a pass, but is it plausible that he needed to use the side of the street that you were on? I'd hope so. If he crossed the street just to get over by you and Bedja, that is kind of messed up.
No he didn't have to cross the street, I think he just wants to strike up a conversation, feels like the lonely needy type.
Because Bedja is well behaved, the guy still seems to think we are approachable, despite our dogs' previous loud (though short) vocal arguments. As mentioned in some other thread mine is not reactive in general, but when this dog starts Bedja comes unglued as well and if I haven't parked my bike, he can be a piece of work to hold back. That's the reason I had him in a 'down', as he is more prone to break a 'sit'.

However I may reconsider putting him in a command, since I don't necessarily want to have to correct him for breaking it in this type of situation.

Edit to add: The man already asked in the past if our dogs could 'say hello' and I declined.
 
Last edited:
Agree with getting your dogs attention & keeping on walking. Mine will react to other reactive dogs
so always have a few “rewards” on me to reinforce the vocal distraction & or as a reward for not reacting when provoked.
 
Wow, @AnnV, just wow. I honestly can't comprehend how some people think! or don't think! You handled it the best you could and it turned out alright, so that's good.

If I think Asha is about to explode on something I put her in a down at heel position. @strykerdobe my thought on this would depend on the scenario, but the reason I do it is to assert my position to my dog that I'm in control and she needs to stay out of it. Because she's a very dominant dog and thinks she needs to control every little thing, putting her in the down gives me more control. In this situation if she were standing facing the dog & man walking purposely toward us, the aggressive dog staring at her and the man in a hurried step calling out - she would have gone nuts. So if Bedja has a similar mindset, I think a down would be OK. They can get to their feet in a split second, but the idea is to prevent any fights, not to get at the ready for one.

@AnnV if this man & dog is a regular on your walks, I'd just ask him to please not approach, that your dog is not always friendly. You've already told him once, so it may fall on deaf ears. I don't know what's wrong with people like that. :(
 
Good to hear differing points of view. I agree that there are many variables and scenarios and the best approach for the time depends on the confidence level and nature of one's own dog, the distance from the distraction, the level/intensity of the distraction and timing and so many more things.

Funny how some scenarios are comical in retrospect, like the one I described, as if from a cartoon strip lol, if it wasn't so annoying in the moment.
 
Funny how some scenarios are comical in retrospect, like the one I described, as if from a cartoon strip lol, if it wasn't so annoying in the moment.
I've had that same thought several times! Being really cross at the time for whatever antics the dog pulls, but then the next day wishing I could have a video or a cartoon of it because it would be so funny.
 

Back
Top