Behavior questions - growling and nipping

CrisK

Jr Member
Hi, my 6 month-old girl has started doing something really annoying when I take her outside to play. We go out, I throw the ball, she brings it back and within 3 minutes (I timed it) of the play she starts attacking my legs. it starts with a nip, I try to distract her, tell her to sit or go get the ball but it doesn't work. This nipping starts to escalate and in less than a minute she's growling and really going hard on my legs, or hands.

I walk away, as she is still attached to me with her mouth. I leave her outside for a few minutes and try again. This time, she wants to get my legs again but with less intensity. I walk back inside, leave for a few more minutes. And the third time I go out she is up for the game.

I have no idea why she chooses to do that instead of play with the toy. She wasn't like that. We would spend a long time outside playing fetch or keep away without any issues. My trainer doesn't think this is normal behavior, especially because it's pretty much impossible to redirect her attention.

What do you think? What should I do when she starts fixating on biting me?

Thanks!
 

Attachments

  • gypsy.webp
    gypsy.webp
    463.2 KB · Views: 15
Hi, my 6 month-old girl has started doing something really annoying when I take her outside to play. We go out, I throw the ball, she brings it back and within 3 minutes (I timed it) of the play she starts attacking my legs. it starts with a nip, I try to distract her, tell her to sit or go get the ball but it doesn't work. This nipping starts to escalate and in less than a minute she's growling and really going hard on my legs, or hands.

I walk away, as she is still attached to me with her mouth. I leave her outside for a few minutes and try again. This time, she wants to get my legs again but with less intensity. I walk back inside, leave for a few more minutes. And the third time I go out she is up for the game.

I have no idea why she chooses to do that instead of play with the toy. She wasn't like that. We would spend a long time outside playing fetch or keep away without any issues. My trainer doesn't think this is normal behavior, especially because it's pretty much impossible to redirect her attention.

What do you think? What should I do when she starts fixating on biting me?

Thanks!
 
Hi, my 6 month-old girl has started doing something really annoying when I take her outside to play. We go out, I throw the ball, she brings it back and within 3 minutes (I timed it) of the play she starts attacking my legs. it starts with a nip, I try to distract her, tell her to sit or go get the ball but it doesn't work. This nipping starts to escalate and in less than a minute she's growling and really going hard on my legs, or hands.

I walk away, as she is still attached to me with her mouth. I leave her outside for a few minutes and try again. This time, she wants to get my legs again but with less intensity. I walk back inside, leave for a few more minutes. And the third time I go out she is up for the game.

I have no idea why she chooses to do that instead of play with the toy. She wasn't like that. We would spend a long time outside playing fetch or keep away without any issues. My trainer doesn't think this is normal behavior, especially because it's pretty much impossible to redirect her attention.

What do you think? What should I do when she starts fixating on biting me?

Thanks!
She is just amped up in play drive. She has to be taught what play is a acceptable and what isn’t, I would redirect her biting to a tug and play with her. Show her she can interact with you that way and have fun but nipping pants, arms hands ect.. is not allowed. She just needs to be given a clear picture of what you expect from her.
 
I’ve been struggling similarly with this with my 12 week old. Although, not to the same intensity. Redirection helps sometimes, but when he’s really amped up it doesn’t do anything. It’s like he’s testing boundaries, and he only wants what I’m telling him he can’t have (my hand, leg, etc). I asked my trainer and she said if he gets to that level, put him in his crate so he can just chill. And then after he’s calmed down, let him out. It seems to be working so far! Hope this helps.
 
She is just amped up in play drive.
But isn't it a bit too fast for her to get into that amped up mindset? A while back, I got this level of excitement after about 10 minutes. So I would break the game before we got to that level, and restart after a few minutes. I will try your advice and see how it goes. I usually do have a tug toy with me when we are outside, but it's not always she will take that. I think I am struggling with the redirection part. Can't find a way to get her to refocus on something else once she gets my leg - by the way, let me mention that I don't scream, yell at her, or react in any way other than try to offer a redirection. I even tried to not respond and be a statue, but that seems useless. Removing myself and waiting works but it's not ideal. This has happened during walks too, but I know that only happens if I let her run.

Thank you for sharing the video resource!!
 
But isn't it a bit too fast for her to get into that amped up mindset? A while back, I got this level of excitement after about 10 minutes. So I would break the game before we got to that level, and restart after a few minutes. I will try your advice and see how it goes. I usually do have a tug toy with me when we are outside, but it's not always she will take that. I think I am struggling with the redirection part. Can't find a way to get her to refocus on something else once she gets my leg - by the way, let me mention that I don't scream, yell at her, or react in any way other than try to offer a redirection. I even tried to not respond and be a statue, but that seems useless. Removing myself and waiting works but it's not ideal. This has happened during walks too, but I know that only happens if I let her run.

Thank you for sharing the video resource!!
Sounds like it may have become a fun game for her. Bitches can be a handful and very determined. I would train/play with her on a 6 ft leash. Correct with a firm no followed by either grabbing the scruff of the neck and giving a slight shake or leash pressure up and ask for a sit. After the correction present the tug, give your release command then make the tug active by moving it away from her. You can make her miss biting it occasionally to put more drive into her work.
 
Sounds like it may have become a fun game for her. Bitches can be a handful and very determined. I would train/play with her on a 6 ft leash. Correct with a firm no followed by either grabbing the scruff of the neck and giving a slight shake or leash pressure up and ask for a sit. After the correction present the tug, give your release command then make the tug active by moving it away from her. You can make her miss biting it occasionally to put more drive into her work.

That's what it took for me. She wore a leash a LOT just so I could correct her quickly on what was not acceptable. Your girl is entering her teens pretty soon and will be doing a lot of testing on you. Best for you to make sure she learns boundaries now.
 
Sounds maybe like boredom with the repetition of fetch.

Strangely, I'm just now really dealing with that with my 6 1/2 year old Dobe. We haven't done extensive fetch until recently because I didn't want my backyard lawn utterly destroyed. Now, we live near a green space. He has tremendous prey drive, but after just a few throws his unwillingness to return the ball to my hand grows quickly.

Maybe try to mix fetch up by keeping it to 3 or 4 reps, then doing something else. A normal Dobe should be capable of having fetch sessions built up to quite long indeed. My first Dobe would retrieve a frisbee as many times as I would throw it. In fact, he collapsed one time from exhaustion. Scared the crap out of me.

I also wonder if you could go ahead and give the girl what she seems to want by getting yourself a nice tug toy and getting her into directed tug sessions. Not too much obedience involved at the very start, but I definitely see tug as a great opportunity to involve obedience:

Your Dobe waits for command to bite, and eventually she must also release the tug immediately upon your command. I like to take my Dobe out nice and fresh and full of energy and have him heel for a while, demanding good precision. After a bit of that, (and once I stop and he hits an acceptable, crisp sit) I give the command to hit the tug. While I'm heeling, I hold the tug vertically with the top up near my chin. The idea is to keep their gaze on my face as much as possible as they very eagerly await the command to bite the tug.
 
She wore a leash a LOT just so I could correct her quickly on what was not acceptable.
I see a lot of comments about this type of correction. Since I don't currently do that type of correction yet, I imagine I would have to teach her what that means. I will do some research on that. Thank you!!
 
Sounds maybe like boredom with the repetition of fetch.
I wondered that too. Later in the day we went outside again to another play/train session in a different area and she was a lot more receptive - new place, same game. The only time she turned into "attack" mode was when she got too excited because of a Fedex truck going by. The truck was gone, but she was laser focused on the corner it had turned, I called her and she didn't even look. I pulled her leash and she started with the biting/growling/jumping.
 
Since I don't currently do that type of correction yet, I imagine I would have to teach her what that means.

Does she know how to walk on leash, heel, sit, down, come, wait, & stay? If not I highly suggest getting started. Especially if you can attend a class with other dogs on leash, so she has distractions but still has to focus on you. As cute as your dog is now (and your avatar photo is cute!) in another 6 months she will be a powerhouse, and really needs to learn to respect you. Play your games by your rules, not the rules she makes up and offers.
 
@Ravenbird yes, we have been doing the basic commands since we brought her home. She's good with sit, down, wait and stay. Needs to get better at come, heel, and loose leash. We are practicing those skills, but she's not where she needs to be yet. She's pretty big already and can knock me over if she wants. We tried a group class but the trainer said Gypsy was not well suited for it - she barked and looked anxious the entire time we were there. her tongue was stinking out as if she had run a marathon at the end of the class.
 
You can make her miss biting it occasionally to put more drive into her work.
This detail is important! If she doesn't care for the tug toy so much right now, it's because she hasn't figured out the satisfaction it can bring her. My male went crazy for a ball from day 1, but it took time to make him like tugging - this is especially true if you are already teaching her to keep things out of her mouth which was the case for us.

We tried a group class but the trainer said Gypsy was not well suited for it
That's pretty dismissive. We had a similar trainer who seemed to think Kaiser didn't even know his own name and suggested we go back to puppy class. I can laugh about it now, but working with those trainers was a huge waste of time and no one was enjoying it - worse is that they didn't offer any real solutions. Can you find different trainers? Look for something with working/sport dogs, German Shepherd training, police dogs, search IPO/IGP/Schutzhund in your area - that should get you closer to trainers that will know how to get a handle on a Doberman.

My trainer doesn't think this is normal behavior, especially because it's pretty much impossible to redirect her attention.
Yet another indicator that your trainer isn't up to the task.
 
we have been doing the basic commands since we brought her home. She's good with sit, down, wait and stay. Needs to get better at come, heel, and loose leash. We are practicing those skills, but she's not where she needs to be yet. She's pretty big already and can knock me over if she wants. We tried a group class but the trainer said Gypsy was not well suited for it - she barked and looked anxious the entire time we were there. her tongue was stinking out as if she had run a marathon at the end of the class.

Good to know you've been working on basics! As @Kaiser2016 said, it sounds like your initial trainer wasn't a good fit. Your statement about Gypsy barking & looking anxious the entire time suggests to me she is typical Doberman wanting to take care of the chaos and be in charge and maybe even save you (her pack) but didn't know how... so overwhelming for a puppy! No puppy should ever have to feel the weight of being in charge. The biggest thing is that dogs need pack structure and if you are not a strong dominant leader then Gypsy may think she has to take on the role herself. If you are not standing strong she can sense this and thus the anxiety of it all being up to her. At home & relaxed & playing this can bring on an attitude of being in charge and trying to tell you how she wants to play (biting feet etc). Every dog is different - some (ahem, mine for instance) seem to be born to be in charge and challenge for the position constantly. Others don't want the job, but will take it if no one else in the family is assuming control. Gypsys angst at her class suggests that possibility. Hope this makes sense, and helps you understand why that when you take control, rather than her feeling dominated it will give Gypsy more confidence and less anxiety in everything. Basic obedience once they learn will give you a default to fall back on. Biting your feet? Tell her sit, treat for the sit, ask for down & treat, release and go back to your play. With the leash on, if she ignores the commands you can remind her that you said SIT. No leash, no way for you to reinforce. At 16 months my girl still drags a leash around when I suspect she is going to ignore me due to distractions.
 
I take Gypsy to a dog daycare once a week - it's a farm, the owner grew up with dobermans and she has dogs from all walks of life come to her because she fosters and rehabilitates dogs for adoption. She took Gypsy in for the week to observe her. She knows our trainer and respects her a lot but think we should find a new one. Apparently Gypsy behaves like a normal dog when she's there. Even around their house cat!! At home, there is not one time a cat goes by that Gypsy doesn't try to engage with them. She has gotten scratched and still she persists. But look at the picture, she's just looking at this cat. I really wish someone could observe us at our home and say "here! This is what you are doing wrong!" I talked to other trainers who feel she is too young and just needs to learn how to communicate with us. There are so many opinions out there that I don't know who to listen to. Getting all this feedback from this forum has been invaluable! And @Ravenbird I think our dogs have similar temperaments.
 

Attachments

  • 137218212_1379756335704036_6476040526356486230_n.webp
    137218212_1379756335704036_6476040526356486230_n.webp
    105.2 KB · Views: 10
I take Gypsy to a dog daycare once a week - it's a farm, the owner grew up with dobermans and she has dogs from all walks of life come to her because she fosters and rehabilitates dogs for adoption. She took Gypsy in for the week to observe her. She knows our trainer and respects her a lot but think we should find a new one. Apparently Gypsy behaves like a normal dog when she's there. Even around their house cat!! At home, there is not one time a cat goes by that Gypsy doesn't try to engage with them. She has gotten scratched and still she persists. But look at the picture, she's just looking at this cat. I really wish someone could observe us at our home and say "here! This is what you are doing wrong!" I talked to other trainers who feel she is too young and just needs to learn how to communicate with us. There are so many opinions out there that I don't know who to listen to. Getting all this feedback from this forum has been invaluable! And @Ravenbird I think our dogs have similar temperaments.
I found that my girl, who was also a little devil as a pup, behaved much better away from home. Which led me to believe that a lot of the crazy nipping and back chatting was from BOREDOM! Even with plenty of exercise and games my girl would still try to engage me in her idea of fun...........which was rough play! Very persistent about it too. :sour: She knew all her basic commands but this would go out the window when she got into her "Tassie Devil Mode"! Like you I found that most of the usual disincentives just didn't work well but what did work was to take her into as many different situations as possible. Car rides and different walks. The breakthrough happened when she was 8 months old and I took her on a road trip with camping and a visit to my friend who lives in an urban environment. All this new input and she was still an excitable handful at times, but she totally stopped all that nipping.
I am not an expert by any means and am just giving you my own experience in case any of it helps. A few things I did wrong in the beginning and the main one was giving too much freedom off leash! This meant she thought she could choose when to take notice of me. Doing it again I would have her attached to me all the time! Doesn't stop the crazy pup stuff but you can do something about it. And I had never, ever seen a dog throw a major tantrum in my life..........it's sure something to behold, and a shock the first time they throw themselves down and start thrashing and catterwauling! :rofl:

In the end though, it is all so worth it. A great companion and never a problem. She still invites me to play, and sometimes I respond and we have a lovely time ducking and diving and dancing around...........but no teeth or claws, ever!
 
@jazzies mum I think you are one of the few who identified with my puppy tantrums video! Asha was so wicked! @ChrisK you have a nice pup, reread what Jazz said, it's 100%. Also, not being on their home ground puts a little intimidation on her, so she is not likely to act like she does at home where she knows the rules and how to break them. As a 12 year old kid I was kind of wild at home, but I set standards like Miss Manners if I was in public, with or without my parents. The more outings the better and things are ingrained so much better at this age!
 
Also, not being on their home ground puts a little intimidation on her, so she is not likely to act like she does at home where she knows the rules and how to break them.
:spit: My parents were always astounded how well behaved my brother and I became when we were staying with our Grandparents! I know, I know. :ot::facepalm:
 
I found that my girl, who was also a little devil as a pup, behaved much better away from home. Which led me to believe that a lot of the crazy nipping and back chatting was from BOREDOM! Even with plenty of exercise and games my girl would still try to engage me in her idea of fun...........which was rough play! Very persistent about it too. :sour: She knew all her basic commands but this would go out the window when she got into her "Tassie Devil Mode"! Like you I found that most of the usual disincentives just didn't work well but what did work was to take her into as many different situations as possible. Car rides and different walks. The breakthrough happened when she was 8 months old and I took her on a road trip with camping and a visit to my friend who lives in an urban environment. All this new input and she was still an excitable handful at times, but she totally stopped all that nipping.
I am not an expert by any means and am just giving you my own experience in case any of it helps. A few things I did wrong in the beginning and the main one was giving too much freedom off leash! This meant she thought she could choose when to take notice of me. Doing it again I would have her attached to me all the time! Doesn't stop the crazy pup stuff but you can do something about it. And I had never, ever seen a dog throw a major tantrum in my life..........it's sure something to behold, and a shock the first time they throw themselves down and start thrashing and catterwauling! :rofl:

In the end though, it is all so worth it. A great companion and never a problem. She still invites me to play, and sometimes I respond and we have a lovely time ducking and diving and dancing around...........but no teeth or claws, ever!


I think lack of new experiences might just be the thing here. When I decided to get her, my idea was to visit all my friends with her, take her to gatherings and parties, go to public events etc. Covid hit, and all that became impossible. We have plenty of parks around here, when I get her back I will be taking her out more to new places. If only she would stop with the nipping! I have holes in almost everything I wear! :D Oh the tantrums!! I get bruises and scratches from those.
 

Back
Top