• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Preventing whining?

Thanks for clarifying @Doberman Gang. I think - especially the high drive dogs - are going to have issues to manage. I wouldn't trade my puppy for anything, it just took a few come-to-Jesus moments of realizing exactly what I signed up for. LOL. I do have the whining about 95% stopped, wish I hadn't bothered with the "just ignore it" the first couple of weeks, that was brutal. Whining is way easier to manage than some other poor genetic traits.
@Rits - yeah, the excitement/anticipation whine when the brain goes out the window... I don't mind if it's just the few seconds before we go do something, but if you were at a show and it went on & on & on, that would be hard. Definitely the more active we are, the less there is to whine about.
 
Thinking out loud...
I wonder if the emergence and increase of "whining" in all breeds coincides with the rise of "Pure Positive Training methods"?
Where the model is to ignore bad behavior & reward good behavior....Hummm
MR
 
Seems to me the more drivey a dog is, the more whiny the dog is.

Funny: Oji sometimes, when he is running free and is doing his sort of goofy run where he is tearing around crazily, I will hear a slight whine here and there in the midst of the action.

Anyway, I've thought of working-line dogs like thoroughbred horses (or please give me a better breed to use as an example, as I am horse ignorant). Possessed of capabilities you can't get in other dogs, but it comes at a price. They are a lot to handle and a pain.

I often think of an episode of Dirty Jobs where Mike joined with a crew in the woods who cut down trees and dragged them out of the woods using horses. Eventually in the episode they showed this particular horse that is the one they used when none other could do the job. He was not just the strong one, but the most intense. The guy mentioned how he was hard to handle and you could see it – sort of explosive and unruly. Remind you of anyone, Oji?
 
Thanks for clarifying @Doberman Gang. I think - especially the high drive dogs - are going to have issues to manage. I wouldn't trade my puppy for anything, it just took a few come-to-Jesus moments of realizing exactly what I signed up for. LOL. I do have the whining about 95% stopped, wish I hadn't bothered with the "just ignore it" the first couple of weeks, that was brutal. Whining is way easier to manage than some other poor genetic traits.
@Rits - yeah, the excitement/anticipation whine when the brain goes out the window... I don't mind if it's just the few seconds before we go do something, but if you were at a show and it went on & on & on, that would be hard. Definitely the more active we are, the less there is to whine about.
I do want to add that a puppy whining because it needs to go potty or even adult dog whining because it needs to go out are not the same as the dogs that constantly whine. I believe some dogs that are not taught to cap and be calm can have it become a learn behavior to where they don’t even realize they are doing it or do it to self soothe.
 
I do want to add that a puppy whining because it needs to go potty or even adult dog whining because it needs to go out are not the same as the dogs that constantly whine. I believe some dogs that are not taught to cap and be calm can have it become a learn behavior to where they don’t even realize they are doing it or do it to self soothe.
I appreciated your input here. How do you teach them to cap themselves? When they only do it out of frustration that they aren't working. Do you expect quietness for long periods? Or just before release? Do you expect total calmness or is muscle twitching acceptable? I know the mind isn't calm when even shaking is happening but it seemed silly to discipline that. Maybe I'm wrong. Trying to prepare myself and learn for the future :D
 
I appreciated your input here. How do you teach them to cap themselves? When they only do it out of frustration that they aren't working. Do you expect quietness for long periods? Or just before release? Do you expect total calmness or is muscle twitching acceptable? I know the mind isn't calm when even shaking is happening but it seemed silly to discipline that. Maybe I'm wrong. Trying to prepare myself and learn for the future :D
I'm almost sure you're not talking to me, but I wanted to make sure.
 
I appreciated your input here. How do you teach them to cap themselves? When they only do it out of frustration that they aren't working. Do you expect quietness for long periods? Or just before release? Do you expect total calmness or is muscle twitching acceptable? I know the mind isn't calm when even shaking is happening but it seemed silly to discipline that. Maybe I'm wrong. Trying to prepare myself and learn for the future :D
Discipline can be as simple as removal of something they want. You have to first reward moments of silence just as you would to build the duration for a stay. As simple as asking them to sit before putting down there food bowl. Sit quietly or the discipline will be I won’t set your food down. It is matter of fact with no emotion from me. These are the rules you must learn them to eat. Once I set the dish down I say OK and release them, I don’t tease them and make them do a long sit stay while the food dish is sitting there, to me that is unnecessary.
 
Discipline can be as simple as removal of something they want. You have to first reward moments of silence just as you would to build the duration for a stay. As simple as asking them to sit before putting down there food bowl. Sit quietly or the discipline will be I won’t set your food down. It is matter of fact with no emotion from me. These are the rules you must learn them to eat. Once I set the dish down I say OK and release them, I don’t tease them and make them do a long sit stay while the food dish is sitting there, to me that is unnecessary.
Ok great that is what I thought and what we always expected at feeding time. When she realized whining didn't get her food, she would eventually lay her head down and wait. That's when we would release her with a command. I had a hard time translating this behavior to a kennel in a trial situation. I'm guessing with time it would have gotten better but we only went to maybe 6 trials or so a year. Hard to practice in that situation when you're up, you're up. Im realizing now I could have practiced in between runs and rewarded her with play after periods of quiet. She just took so long to calm herself with everyone around her doing fun things she wanted to do. I guess this is where having access to some kind of club would have been beneficial to practice more!
 
I think I may have some answers on how to prevent whining. At least help anyway. Been trying to post it here for the last hour or so. :confused-alt: I'm in the hospital and not being left alone long enough to get this done. I may be home by Sunday so someone remind me to post my tips.
 
I think I may have some answers on how to prevent whining. At least help anyway. Been trying to post it here for the last hour or so. :confused-alt: I'm in the hospital and not being left alone long enough to get this done. I may be home by Sunday so someone remind me to post my tips.
LOL, you might get a reminder a day until you post your new tips! Mine is down to just a few "special" moments, so I'm pretty pleased, but new tips to prevent whining would be welcomed by all!
 
And to answer your question.....YES, IT'S BEEN A NIGHTMARE! Thankfully my family is wonderful and my cousin is staying here to help.
 
That looks so uncomfortable! At least it sounds like you can be at home instead of in hospital. You will have Rue there with you. Maybe she can learn some new helpful things, like bringing you items you need. Always look on the bright side of life, as in Life of Brian, but sometimes I think it's REALLY hard to find that bright side through the :poop:.
 
Oh wow. @GennyB I had no idea. My best to you & wishes for super fast recovery. Is there anything we can do for you from cyberspace??? It appears from the illustration that you can't bend at the waist, like sitting up? Seriously, if there is any way we can make your 6 month recovery faster or easier, just name it.
 

Back
Top