• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Curious for feedback....(this is long)...sorry

Vinnie's Mom

Hot Topics Subscriber
So I am taking Vinnie to the only trainer in our area. They are pretty good and it is affiliated with my vet and the playground he goes to once a week. Now, over all the service I (and Vinnie) receive from all of them is above and beyond what I would expect, especially the gals at the playground.
Many many...maaany moons ago I have trained large dogs all from foster settings and I admit I am someone you would call "old school". In basically everything actually, but thats a story for another day. Anyway, so the trainer made it clear that they did not "approve" of old school methods, ie pack mentality, any kind of collar training, ect. They train the "positive reinforcement method" I figured whatever, I would see what this newfangled science training was all about. Plus Vinnie had such bad scars all on his neck from those stupid stupid people he was with the first 8mo...grrrr....I figured he should have some positive reinforcement in his life for a change.
Ok, so I get it, most of it anyway, but Vinnie is now on Trazodone. I understand that it will take a few days to get into his system correctly, and that I should not judge this yet.....but the little voice in the depth of my soul is muttering not nice things about this....
Basically he is too stoned to do much of anything until 4pm. And then, due to not getting his AM excercize (usually a 2-3 mile walk) he is CRAZY. I don't blame him but it just sucks. He wants to go play fetch at 11pm which we cant do. It is not an option where we live atm.
His issue basically boils down to he is an 11 MO Dobe puppy, with less than 4 MO actual life experience, and has an extremely high prey drive, and little to no impulse control. (basically normal Dobe baby) So the trainer explained that if we get him on trazadone, it will calm him to where I can train the wanted behavior of leaving the squirl, truck, golf cart, Bicycle, bug, bunny, bird, child, dog, gopher, wasp, ect alone. This is not possible without the drugs as he goes into such an immediate frenzy I no longer exist in his little world. (neither does liver, chicken or toys)
I am 50 YO with health issues and can't control him when he jumps 5-6 feet in the air, spins mid air and flings slobber in a 7 foot radius on innocent by passers.....yep, that happened.....and not realizing I am the mommy in this frenzy bites my hand to let go of the leash to be able to get the squirl, truck, golf cart, Bicycle, bug, bunny, bird, child, dog, gopher, wasp, ect.
The mutterings of my little voice are yelling get the stupid e collar already, I know how to use one, it is not something you just zap them with and magically expect results. It is 1 tool of many utilized all together, actually, remove trazodone, insert e collar, and continue as I have been doing as he is doing excellent in all other aspects of his training. But the trainer is adamendt that this will make the situation worse. I get the philosophy behind it, if you get static from touching a car, you get mad at the car. Being Irish, I get that;)
So I know several of you guys with experience use them. What I was curious about is what you all think of this new training and the meds......

PS: sorry tons of typos, I just stopped caring days ago...:wtf3:
 
I'm sorry for your & Vinnie's woes. This sounds like the very last kind of dog that would respond to PO (Positive Only) training. I would start with the e-collar and skip the drugs and the PO training. So many people would rather put a dog to sleep - tranquilize with daily drugs or finally euthanize - before training a dog to be a good citizen. This article is long, but worth reading every.single.word. Keep in mind it is not against positive training, it's just a look Positive Only and how it cannot possibly work in the long run. Best to you & Vinnie.

When Did Balance Become A Dirty Word
 
Very interesting article!!!

I use a different training method for different scenarios and my dogs know No. They have to.

Just today, in agility, I yelled NO when my dog was headed toward an incorrect obstacle. She stopped.

I just had to tell my dogs NO because they were playing too rough.

We did train the Dobe on an eCollar because her recall is good but it's non-negotiable. We just bought a bark collar because we live on a corner lot in an active neighborhood and she LOVES to rush the fence and bark herself into hysterics. I can try and throw a ball, I can try and entice her with food but she starts seeing red and to break her focus on that person/dog/bike going by is sometimes impossible. We've had the bark collar for just a few days but already she's learning there are consequences to being crazy. She's actually rushing the fence less and giving up on "the chase" 50% faster. I ALSO praise and tell her that those are the right decisions when she makes them.

I love teaching dog problem solving skills because the equips them (similar to what the articles says) but I am very much a believer that some decisions need consequences.

You can be firm without being cruel which sounds like you know how to do.
 
I'm sorry for your & Vinnie's woes. This sounds like the very last kind of dog that would respond to PO (Positive Only) training. I would start with the e-collar and skip the drugs and the PO training. So many people would rather put a dog to sleep - tranquilize with daily drugs or finally euthanize - before training a dog to be a good citizen. This article is long, but worth reading every.single.word. Keep in mind it is not against positive training, it's just a look Positive Only and how it cannot possibly work in the long run. Best to you & Vinnie.

When Did Balance Become A Dirty Word
Thank you so very much for that, it is a great article. It is pretty much what I have been thinking all along. When there is a pit in my stomach giving him a pill when he is looking up at me trusting me, but absolutely no pit when I think of adding a collar to his training, I know there is a serious problem. I only hope I can get him to trust me again after this...I know I will, I just feel horrible
 
Great article. I’m only part way through it, but boy does it really sum up dog training with good comparisons to kids which I think most people can understand and apply that logic more easily. Goodness, before owning a dog I would never have believed there could be SO MUCH TO KNOW.

I totally agree that PO training for him will create more problems. And wow, giving DRUGS is considered positive? What happened to Just Say No to Drugs!
 
Great article. I’m only part way through it, but boy does it really sum up dog training with good comparisons to kids which I think most people can understand and apply that logic more easily. Goodness, before owning a dog I would never have believed there could be SO MUCH TO KNOW.

I totally agree that PO training for him will create more problems. And wow, giving DRUGS is considered positive? What happened to Just Say No to Drugs!
I know right?? I was shocked when I got attitude for even mentioning the collar but drugs was her first go to!
 
Drugging a young dog who just needs direction and a good way to burn steam? I understand why you are questioning their method. These are serious dogs, and imo need more than these crazy positive only training techniques.

I like e collars and don’t think you will have negative affects if its used correctly. Ill also suggest one activity you can add to his regimen- flirt pole sessions (if you can physically handle it). It helped my previous dog with impulse control so much and it burned energy at the same time. Fun for the human too imo! (My last dog had more prey drive then anything I have ever seen. Killed 9 possums and a couple rabbits in his early days with me)
 
I only hope I can get him to trust me again after this...I know I will, I just feel horrible
Please don't feel guilty. Vinnie probably doesn't associate being drugged with you popping a pill in his mouth, but he will take in your feeling bad and not know what's wrong. Dogs thrive on knowing what's ok and what's not, so if you feel bad and he doesn't know what's causing it, I'm sure it stresses him to a certain degree. Many dogs are stressed because they don't have a strong leader or a clear path to take. I've witnessed so MANY training centers that are PO. There's an agility trainer here that will not let anyone use a prong or choke collar on her property, much less an e-collar, but guess what? She has 2 dogs that are brilliant in agility but are dog aggressive and can't go to ANY shows because she can't control them around other dogs! We live in a crazy mixed up world.
 
Please don't feel guilty. Vinnie probably doesn't associate being drugged with you popping a pill in his mouth, but he will take in your feeling bad and not know what's wrong. Dogs thrive on knowing what's ok and what's not, so if you feel bad and he doesn't know what's causing it, I'm sure it stresses him to a certain degree. Many dogs are stressed because they don't have a strong leader or a clear path to take. I've witnessed so MANY training centers that are PO. There's an agility trainer here that will not let anyone use a prong or choke collar on her property, much less an e-collar, but guess what? She has 2 dogs that are brilliant in agility but are dog aggressive and can't go to ANY shows because she can't control them around other dogs! We live in a crazy mixed up world.
We actually had a 20 min "argument" over the special meatball this AM. The look on his face when I first tried to get him to eat it broke my heart. It's why I sat down and thought about the overall picture and made some decisions today. But yeah, he knows what the meatball did and he knows I made him eat it :( I'm getting a new flavor then waiting a week or so and start to give him them again, just no trippin on these lol
 
It's only my opinion and only from experience with one Dobe mix pup, but drugging seems like the last thing to do to get a good training foundation! Maybe if your dog was overly anxious but it just sounds like normal pup behaviour made worse by the fact that you have to start with a dog who has had no grounding as a youngster. I get the problem of big, strong, excitable dog with high prey drive totally! Such a shame that you aren't able to use a prong collar as after some home schooling with this it made life much easier for both Jazz and I in public situations, but I agree that it would be too distressing for Vinnie after his early experiences.
Positive only training would absolutely NOT have worked with Jazz, she had to learn that there were consequences for deliberate disobedience and misbehaviour. A fine line to walk to be firm enough but also fair and considerate as well! Especially with the Doberteens which you are probably dealing with as well.
An e collar, properly introduced and used intelligently and kindly would work for you well I think. If there is a true aggression issue, maybe not, but if his behaviour stems from high prey drive and teenage excitability then he should respond well, once he understands what the stim means.
You will win in the end! Just do what you are doing and question things as you go. If something isn't working for you and Vinnie, then dream up a new approach. (And I do really mean "dream up". I spend many night hours thinking and rethinking solutions to problems I hit with training Jazz! :banghead:)
Just a thought. Do you have anyone living near you with a very calm older dog who would be willing to go along for walks with you? I didn't, but I think the example of a well trained dog would have been a very helpful influence.
 
Hi in my opinion no to the e collar positive reinforcement is the only way. It's only a suggestion however prior to walking my doberwoman we did 2 sessions of ball chase probably 1_2 hours apart to run the edge of her. I then put on a Canny collar which I am working towards removing in time. She was assessed as a relative dog but not aggressive. She just didn't know how to approach people and other dogs she barked instantly at both which made her look agressive.
I enrolled in a 7 week training course using positive reinforcement. Praise praise and more praise repetition being the key. Us high value treats chicken ham bacon cheese etc.
I suppose what I learned it's not the length of the walk it's the quality of the walk. A half hour focused training walk exhausts the dog opposed to how far you have been. Some days we never left the road I live on. If she pulls I stop when she stands praise and reward. If you dogs rearing it's not learning anything and believe me I have experienced it all. Reward the behaviour you want ignore the behaviour you don't. In time it does get better. What I have learned is to relax no matter how upset I felt with the behaviour. I believe an e collar has the potential to make the situation worse. Hope this helps.
 
First let me say that I personally feel PO training is a Peace Out method that does not produce stable, confident and obedient dogs.

Our first training class was a PO and both my pups were attacked by a 90 lab that had been attending these classes for 9yrs. 9 yrs of training produced a dog that saw fit to terrorize and injure puppies physically and emotionally. I was told this particular dog just lets the puppy know it’s the boss. Bullsh*t is what that statement was. The owner nor the trainer assisted me in removing that dog off my pup. I was enraged and snatched the lab up on his hind legs and was fully prepared to choke it out if necessary. My male shook it off and did not have any lasting issues with being attacked but my confident little female suffered a hairline fx of the pelvis and became a timid, fearful pup. It took a year of working with a behaviorist and trainer to get her over it, not to mention the financial end of it.
This breed is extremely intelligent, strong, boundary pushing and high energy. Positive only does not produce a confident, calm and obedient dog. It produces dogs that work well in controlled environments without everyday distractions that become crazy, looney and reactive in real world settings, with owners not able to control them.

Our society seems to think if a kid has a problem, they need to be medicated to be able to control them. We see how well that worked with so many school shootings and irrational behavior.
Now they want to do it to dogs too? It’s insane to assume the only way to teach a high energy dog or any dog to behave is to dope them up. Just how much do you learn when your faculties are impaired not to mention how an animal might react negatively to a medication.
The dog understands consequences if they are done fairly, calmly and consistently. A dogs mother doesn’t use PO to let her pups know what is and isn’t good behavior.

An E collar or prong when used correctly is a valuable tool. Using a stim most times is not necessary, only a vibrate or tone at the appropriate time is all that is needed to redirect their attention to you.
I haven’t read the article yet but definitely will here shortly as this is a topic of contention with many dog owners. I tend to see PO used in Golden’s, Labs and small dogs a lot down here and when they come in the clinic it becomes a nightmare dealing with them.
They are unruly and some become aggressive when we try to handle or restrain them. Sorry for the looong post but it torques me beyond belief that supposedly intelligent people would find this to be the ONLY training method to be used and berate other methods.
 
And now we can see what is wrong with society today. PO training, whether it is dog training or raising of children, it is definitely not he wrong choice. Just listen to what was written above. “Reward the behavior you want and ignore the behavior you don’t.” Sorry this the biggest joke I have ever heard. So let’s see, your dog is attacking and biting you. Oh yeah, just ignore that and when they stop just toss them a treat. Good boy hear you go.
 
And now we can see what is wrong with society today. PO training, whether it is dog training or raising of children, it is definitely not he wrong choice. Just listen to what was written above. “Reward the behavior you want and ignore the behavior you don’t.” Sorry this the biggest joke I have ever heard. So let’s see, your dog is attacking and biting you. Oh yeah, just ignore that and when they stop just toss them a treat. Good boy hear you go.
I was pressing so hard on my phone for AGREE!! It didn't change anything but it made me feel better. ;)
 
And now we can see what is wrong with society today. PO training, whether it is dog training or raising of children, it is definitely not he wrong choice. Just listen to what was written above. “Reward the behavior you want and ignore the behavior you don’t.” Sorry this the biggest joke I have ever heard. So let’s see, your dog is attacking and biting you. Oh yeah, just ignore that and when they stop just toss them a treat. Good boy hear you go.
Well all I can say is my Doberwoman had a lot of issues significant with a puppy and adolescent. Rearing mouthing counter surfing barging leash pulling reactive to dogs people guess what we have worked through each issue and without the use of an e collar. It's been achieved with love kindness and mutual respect. One could say proof is in the pudding. No she's not perfect but she is reliable in temperament and behaviour. If you can't let your dog off the lead for fear of them running across a busy road then the answer is simple keep them on a lead. If your dog loves and respects you they will come back your the responsible person. If you live in England you can't use them so what would you do then?
 
Well all I can say is my Doberwoman had a lot of issues significant with a puppy and adolescent. Rearing mouthing counter surfing barging leash pulling reactive to dogs people guess what we have worked through each issue and without the use of an e collar. It's been achieved with love kindness and mutual respect. One could say proof is in the pudding. No she's not perfect but she is reliable in temperament and behaviour. If you can't let your dog off the lead for fear of them running across a busy road then the answer is simple keep them on a lead. If your dog loves and respects you they will come back your the responsible person. If you live in England you can't use them so what would you do then?
47C36C3C-2EF2-4D6C-8BB8-D38CAA0FE999.webp
Understanding how to use tools is what makes the trainer. No, not every dog will benefit from the use of sone tools but trainers that understand dog behavior and fairness can teach dogs much quicker and make them more reliable in the long run. I am sorry for people who live in places where rules are enforced by liberal minded bleeding hearts that feel the need to control everything.
Yes ecollar, prong collars, slip leads, flat collars, head halters and even food are abused by many people everywhere. What’s nex? a mandate on how much food and what kind can be feed.
 

Back
Top