Breeder With Active Facebook Page and Good Online Reviews: Trust?

Oh Little Oji

Hot Topics Subscriber
$ Forum Donor $
Of course I don't mean automatically and inherently trust a breeder based on this, but:

Today's online world is such that some breeders do not go to the time, trouble and expense of creating a website. Instead, Facebook fills the bill. This is also the case for other businesses these days.

There is a major upside to this in that most of the time the Facebook page is much more likely to receive updates and current information.

I've been looking at a breeder for a while now. They don't have a website (it's been allowed to lapse due to the breeder suffering a car crash), but they do have an active Facebook page and their reviews there are basically all glowing.

Yes, I know there are the very important questions of health testing and working/titling the dogs; but how would you feel about a breeder like this, provided you liked the appearance of their dogs?

I mean, it's so different from the traditional way. Traditionally, you have a breeder who has a phone number and you call it and leave a message and they probably will not return your call. Or they may have a website with an email address and you email them and they probably will not reply to your email. Or, maybe they will after several weeks. Maybe you fill out an online puppy application where you pour out your heart and you get no reply or some quick one-liner reply.

The breeder to which I am referring has responded to my private messages on Facebook fairly promptly and has thus been communicative. They have pointed me to their Youtube channel where they have a good number of videos posted. They say they like to do this, as it really shows how their dogs look and move and what they are like.

Yes, I asked about health testing. Their response via Facebook private message was a not very reassuring sort of "they have all their health clearances."

But I guess the main thrust of my question is what is your opinion on the phenomenon of breeders who maintain a public presence exclusively via Facebook?

The breeder I am talking about does list a phone number on Facebook, in addition to an email address and an actual physical address. I have not called them on the phone, but then again I am researching my next pup very early what with Oji only being about 4 1/3 years old.
 
Last edited:
I would be concerned with this answer "they have all their health clearances" Well lets see all the test results and OFA Certifications?
Next would be Longevity questions??
There are lots of Dobes I like but Longevity in the line is #1 for me.
 
But I guess the main thrust of my question is what is your opinion on the phenomenon of breeders who maintain a public presence exclusively via Facebook?


The thing with facebook is it's cheap and easy. Maintaining a website can be expensive and time consuming and a downright PITA. I can understand not wanting to deal with that.


but they do have an active Facebook page and their reviews there are basically all glowing.

Glowing reviews don't mean a whole lot to me. Unless I know or have talked to the person giving the review. Who's going to allow a bad review of their page?

I prefer a breeder that is going to be upfront and honest. Willing to provide proof of health testing and pedigrees with COD listed. Someone that can speak confidently about why they put 2 dogs together. While it's not important for everyone, I like a breeder that shows and works their dogs. NOTHING teaches you about conformation and temperament like getting in the ring and doing it.
 
I think just having a Facebook and not a real site is lazy. Not everyone (including me) has Facebook, everyone can go onto a web site. Sites are also tailored to properly disclose the necessary information where you expect to find it, Facebook I’ve found myself in the past meandering around trying to find out details and eventually giving up.

In today’s world I would expect to have both.
 
I would be concerned with this answer "they have all their health clearances" Well lets see all the test results and OFA Certifications?
Next would be Longevity questions??
There are lots of Dobes I like but Longevity in the line is #1 for me.
Yes. I'm totally not happy with their "...have all their health certifications" answer, and it sounds BYB to me. I did reply that maybe I could inquire further with them in the future – which I would do if I were to keep considering this breeder.
 
The thing with facebook is it's cheap and easy. Maintaining a website can be expensive and time consuming and a downright PITA. I can understand not wanting to deal with that.




Glowing reviews don't mean a whole lot to me. Unless I know or have talked to the person giving the review. Who's going to allow a bad review of their page?

I prefer a breeder that is going to be upfront and honest. Willing to provide proof of health testing and pedigrees with COD listed. Someone that can speak confidently about why they put 2 dogs together. While it's not important for everyone, I like a breeder that shows and works their dogs. NOTHING teaches you about conformation and temperament like getting in the ring and doing it.
Yes, they appear to have had a website but have let it lapse (he explained, due to a car crash and being disabled now).

I was not aware that people were able to disallow or remove negative reviews. But then, I don't keep up on all the features and capabilities of the different applications out there. It would be a shame if there were any setup where someone could only allow positive reviews to appear. That, of course, totally negates the whole concept.

This breeder does in fact show in conformation, but it doesn't appear to be at a high/respected level. There is really no prevalence of working-lines existing in this breed that I'm aware of. (Yes, it's a not a Doberman breeder! :eek:) If I were to go with this breed, I would be relying on the breed's size and appearance to provide sufficient deterrent for my family and home. I would just need the dog to not be a wimp, but to stand its ground which would provide most bad guys a hard time.
 
Not trying to be cryptic here. The breed I am talking about is Bullmastiff.

I would ultimately prefer the South African Boerboel, but I got to thinking: I have a little almost 8 year old daughter and another daughter on the way. The Boerboel, in addition to getting somewhat larger than a Bullmastiff, is known to have more in the way of drives. I think the Bullmastiff has been watered down to a pretty ineffective creature in terms of actually following through on guarding duties.

So I was thinking: Would I be a fool to bring a 150 lb. + animal into my home if I didn't totally trust that that dog did not have the propensity to be a danger, or to be unpredictably aggressive? Sorry, Bully breed lovers (I am admirer!) but it's my belief that many of the bully breeds, and some of the Molosser types have what I call "dangerous potential."

Would I be able to neutralize a switched-on 150 - 180 pound dog?

So, my considerations turned to the (it seems to me) more creampuffy Bullmastiff.

By the way, the Boerboel breeder I was excited about does have a nice slick website. It would not, however, successfully accept my puppy application. So I contacted the breeder by email. Their response was very brief and rather off-putting. In response, I provided them my contact information like they requested and they did not get back to me.

Contrast this with the Bullmastiff breeder who got back to me promptly via Facebook and had an actual conversation with me.
 
As a Doberman “pet” owner who has bought from both a BYB and a reputable breeder my observations are that the BYB is more of a marketer because they’re in it to sell dogs so they need to advertise themselves. Whereas finding a reputable breeder is much more difficult. I think their efforts are put into showing/working the dogs and producing dogs to better the breed. They’re getting their buyers from shows/competitions, groups such as this. So I’m not sure how much effort is put into a flashy website. Sure I think in today’s world you need to have some kind of a presence so that people can find you/contact you but I wouldn’t rule out a breeder because their website isn’t all that great or if they only had a FB page.
 
I have been to breeder websites and just because they have an amazing website doesn't mean they are great breeders. Times are changing and whether we like it or not, we will all have to adjust. I have found great things through websites but on the other hand I also have found great things through social media. I own a small business and we have had to change our approach on marketing, as well as how we actually handle our clients. It was not easy for me as I was resistant to social media, but without the change I would have had my business suffer. I like old school ways much better, it has been a real challenge and I am sure every generation has gone through it as the world changes around us. I would do a ton of investigating before considering a breeder on facebook, but I would do that any way, so I guess it is just an adjustment and who knows in 20yrs how we will be finding breeders! Hope it's not smoke signals!
 
If you are considering a non Doberman for your next dog, why not think about a shepherd? I might be (slightly) biased but i have been thoroughly impressed by my little guy. And there’s not a person alive that sees a GSD and doesn’t think “bad ass cop dog”! Whether they actually are of course is completely besides the point, you’d get your deterrent via image though. Incredibly intelligent like Dobes, very trainable, and solid family companions. They are hairy but personal presence id rather deal with hair versus drool! Not saying anything bad about mastiffs and the like, I think they are beautiful dogs. That being said you will get a different type of shepherd considering the lines, American show lines are rather problematic because titling is not necessary to breed via AKC and they are bred on looks rather than temperament and function. European show dogs still must be titled in ring sport and pass their health tests in order to breed, creating generally medium drive, fully functional, stable dogs. Then you have Czech/DDR and East German lines that are working. Mostly sable, bicolor and blacks, smaller with high drives and extreme athletes!
 
If you are considering a non Doberman for your next dog, why not think about a shepherd? I might be (slightly) biased but i have been thoroughly impressed by my little guy. And there’s not a person alive that sees a GSD and doesn’t think “bad ass cop dog”! Whether they actually are of course is completely besides the point, you’d get your deterrent via image though. Incredibly intelligent like Dobes, very trainable, and solid family companions. They are hairy but personal presence id rather deal with hair versus drool! Not saying anything bad about mastiffs and the like, I think they are beautiful dogs. That being said you will get a different type of shepherd considering the lines, American show lines are rather problematic because titling is not necessary to breed via AKC and they are bred on looks rather than temperament and function. European show dogs still must be titled in ring sport and pass their health tests in order to breed, creating generally medium drive, fully functional, stable dogs. Then you have Czech/DDR and East German lines that are working. Mostly sable, bicolor and blacks, smaller with high drives and extreme athletes!
Yeah, your GSD pup is awesome looking. Is he from those Czech/DDR and East German working lines? The color just suggests that to me – especially based on what you wrote.

Hmm. My initial reasons for not considering a GSD are, yes, the hair; also (no offense) but I don't like to have a breed that is very popular. A couple of reasons for my considering a different breed are: Whininess, high exercise/stimulation demand. I think both of those would still be present in a GSD – only in a dog that brings far more requirement to sweep the floors and is more common.

Boy, you do have a good point on the drool v hair thing though. That's a tough one! Either one would have my awesome wife complaining at me very often.

I saw a video online where the guy claims the Bullmastiff is gassy. :nono:

Really, I always just come back to the Doberman.
 
Thank you! His sire is a European show line and his dam is a Czech/DDR. He is FAR less vocal than Brinks, but he does need a regular energy outlet. I’m used to it because of Brinks, but understand wanting to get a little bit of a break in that department. Shepherds are a popular breed, for a good reason! All else aside, it doesn’t bother me. And actually when you have one of the more uncommon colors people aren’t really sure that they are a shepherd.

In the end though we’re all a little nuts, dealing with Dobermans LOL as wonderful as they are :D
 
I guess not. Lol
Ha! No, actually I don't dislike Rottweilers. I do think that the breed was, overall kind of hijacked by types of people I don't so much care to be associated with. They also are, in my mind, one of the breeds you hear about mauling people. They are also a rather coarse physical specimen; but then again guess what? So are Bullmastiffs and Boerboels.

Good thoughts and fun to think about anyway!
 
Friends I knew many years ago had a situation where they absolutely had to have a good guard dog patrolling their yard. (Sadly their daughter was murdered by her boyfriend leaving two small sons for these grandparents to raise. The boyfriend was threatening to abduct/harm the children, even from a jail cell) They chose a Bullmastiff female. She was huge, laid back, loved the kids and everyone who was welcomed into the house, and slobbery! They put serious 12' fences around their house yard and this is where this dog spent her time, sleeping, eating and getting pats, until anyone or anything out of the ordinary happened along. Then she turned into the Hound of the Baskervilles! :machinegun: No one was going to climb over that fence without losing fingers and toes on the way!

Yes, she did the job brilliantly, was next to no trouble at all, but to my mind she lacked a bit of brain power. That could have been because she didn't receive much training, or was just dozier than I was used to, not sure. One thing I am sure of is that Oji will run rings around this breed! :biggrin:
 
Friends I knew many years ago had a situation where they absolutely had to have a good guard dog patrolling their yard. (Sadly their daughter was murdered by her boyfriend leaving two small sons for these grandparents to raise. The boyfriend was threatening to abduct/harm the children, even from a jail cell) They chose a Bullmastiff female. She was huge, laid back, loved the kids and everyone who was welcomed into the house, and slobbery! They put serious 12' fences around their house yard and this is where this dog spent her time, sleeping, eating and getting pats, until anyone or anything out of the ordinary happened along. Then she turned into the Hound of the Baskervilles! :machinegun: No one was going to climb over that fence without losing fingers and toes on the way!

Yes, she did the job brilliantly, was next to no trouble at all, but to my mind she lacked a bit of brain power. That could have been because she didn't receive much training, or was just dozier than I was used to, not sure. One thing I am sure of is that Oji will run rings around this breed! :biggrin:
I read in a book years ago a tale of homeowners who came home and discovered a human hand laying on their floor. Story goes, someone had tried to break in by reaching in through a partially open window or door. This family had a Bullmastiff.

Well, the "Gamekeeper's Night Dog" seemed to really take to her job for your friends in their yard years ago, @jazzies mum !

You are correct too: All 70-75 lbs. of Oji could literally run circles around a mature Bullmastiff. He bites fast as well. @Brioddy , the description you give of the Czeck/DDR and East German working-line German Shepherds fits Oji very closely.

Incidentally, the Boerboel is said to be the most athletic of the Mastiffs. You can pretty much see it when you see them move.
 

Back
Top