What's your opinion on this (Pit Bulls)

I looked at her fb page. It doesn't show that she owned these dogs for any long period of time. The earliest pic was Jan this year. Makes me wonder what kind of life they had before her, if they were rescues, what kind of life they had with her etc...
 
Horrific. I have mixed feelings myself about the "pit bull", having been attacked by 2 for no reason in Detroit. I have known some great ones, but due to my personal experience I have trust issues. May be wrong, but it is what it is. I DO know that when in a "pack" setting (more than one dog) things can get dicey quick. I don't know what could have provoked the attack, maybe nothing. In my case the owner let the dogs out the front door and they came at me from across the street as I was exciting my vehicle. Luckily they were not able to get me to the ground (although they did tag team me, one in front barking and lunging and the other behind me bit me in the back of the leg) I don't want to think what would have happened if they had.
 
I too almost wonder if they got in a fight with each other and she tried to break them up and in the moment, they turned the fight on her.

Either way, they were NOT acting like any bully breeds bred with correct temperament. Attacking humans is 100% against bully breeds makeup. They needed to be handled by their humans when in the thick of the fight. Whether baiting a bull or fighting another dog. Due to their popularity, you have every joe schmoe with no care or idea about breeding, breeding a powerful breed...and you end up with dogs like hers (if they even were "pitbulls" to begin with, which isn't even a breed...its a description for a "type" of dog).

Any breed of dog not bred with a stable temperament can be "bad" dogs and possibly a time bomb ticking.
 
All good points. Rits I think it says a " Brendal " breed ? Isn't that color though ? I know there are many that define a dog a pitbull when in fact they are not. Look I'll say this, I cannot even shoot a squirrel so I love all animals. However I've just had my fair share of bad experiences that makes me not want to be near one. I don't even allow my two Dobermans around them. I have a truck driver that delivers machinery/vehicles from around the country. He has one. It was not long ago this summer he showed up and it takes an hour or so to unload, so his dog China was in the truck watching my two play around. So unwillingly I said " ok let her out to play and run for a while. Geez it wasn't more than a few minutes that damn thing went right after Justice. And for the record Justice LOVES all other dogs. They just don't seem to like him so much. Anyways that was only the recent experience. I've been attacked once myself, and Justice got teamed up on by two of them. I even had a good friend that owned a doberman that didn't want his pitbull out to join in the fun. Appears he knew better. At least he was responsible unlike so, so many.

Anyways thanks for the input everyone.
 
I looked at her fb page. It doesn't show that she owned these dogs for any long period of time. The earliest pic was Jan this year. Makes me wonder what kind of life they had before her, if they were rescues, what kind of life they had with her etc...


Of course no one does any research as to past history, at least if they are doing such a thing they aren't saying anything about it. The fact that they were guarding the kill when police showed up doesn't make me feel any better about it.
 
I heard this story on the news. No matter what really happened, it's incredibly sad for the girl, her family and the dogs.
When I saw this thread I decided to do a quick search for updates on the story. Pretty disappointed to see so many different accounts of what happened. What happened to the days when the media had to have the facts straight before releasing a story? Getting the story out first should never be as important as getting it right.

We'll probably never know what really happened. In the eyes of law enforcement, it's an open and shut case.







Wow! Some of the comments from readers of the story. :shock:
 
Agree with @WiglWerm and @Liberty & Justice that once trust is broken with this type of dog, it's impossible to get it back.

When I was learning about Dobermans, it seemed that we were being held in the same "dangerous breed" category as pits and rotts. I thought ok I won't judge the pits any more. But one bad experience is all it takes.

The first dog to ever bite Kaiser was a pitbull. He was completely unprovoked, gave no warning, just grabbed K at the neck and wouldn't let go until a stranger used a stick to open his mouth. The owner was completely unable to call the dog off. Thank god that horrible creature did not shake his head for the kill. It seemed he had bit over K's leather collar and K pulled himself out of the collar.

It was a frightening experience with K being spooked and collarless in a parking lot. He stood off by my car and my hb opened the hatch. K got in on his own with his neck covered in slobber and we had no idea whether it was blood. Worst was that we were in an area with no cell coverage. Once I had a connection I called the vet and asked them to wait for us as it was almost their closing time.

He turned out to be fine. Two punctures that did not warrant stitches. And now he has white hairs marking the spots. I didn't want to expose him to more dogs that evening with our Doberman play date but my hb insisted we go. He was right. K was able to play and be happy with familiar dogs and that had to have helped him shake off the experience.

But I would still cross the street with an approaching pitbull. That dog needs very good and very responsible owners. Many of them just aren't. They rescue these dogs thinking that all they need is love and no judgement and all will be fine. I would still trust a Golden Retreiver over a pit!
 
So I've had my two bad run in's with the pitbull breed. I'm honestly not a fan, not a fan at all. So I'm a bit racist ( not the best of terms I know ) towards the breed. I know there are some on here that have had exceptional success, so if offended I'll apologize in advance. I just saw this on the news. Give your honest opinion.


Virginia woman killed in 'grisly mauling' by her dogs, cops say
I have an opinion.
I wasn't there so I don't know what happened. But that isn't my opinion, that's a fact.
My opinion is, I don't trust one damn thing reported by mainstream news outlets anymore. Not even Fox. :)
 
I would still trust a Golden Retreiver over a pit!
I went to the people park at Higgs Beach to meet with the trainer and work my pups.
There were many dogs there, a GR came after my dogs and my trainer was yelling to the owners to control their dog. Owners got pissed because they were told to control their off leash dog. My trainer took care of the GR by grabbing his collar and then putting a slip lead on him and hauled him back to the owners with the advice they need to learn how to control their dog because next time he wasn’t going to be so nice. During that 2 hr park training class it was the labs and GRs that tried to provoke fights. There were quite a few pit types there that day that totally ignored my pups. The dogs I have been bitten by the most are GSDs and Chihuahuas. There is a pit in my neighborhood that gets loose every couple weeks and roams the neighborhood. It has come up to my gate on numerous occasions when I had the pups downstairs. It has never once acted aggressive towards my pups or me but I don’t want to be out walking and have him run up to us either. Loose dogs scare me including the little ones that are the biggest troublemakers. I don’t believe any of these dogs are true Pit Bulls, I think they are a blend of many dogs that unfortunately carry some visual traits of a pit bull. I have a strong dislike and mistrust of Chows.
I have a healthy respect for any dog because they are all capable of inflicting bites.
If you own a strong bully breed it is your responsibility to make sure they are trained and never in a position to harm another dog or person. Inexperienced owners with these breeds is the largest cause of incidents with them.
As hard as I try, I don’t know all the triggers that will set a dog off, but I do know how to read body language of the dog. I always watch their body language so I can circumvent further escalation.
We get boarding dogs that are aggressive, mostly GSDs, Pits and Chihuahuas. I hate having to deal with them but you learn how quickly to avoid getting bit. Even though two pits come in together and owner wants them boarded together we can’t do that. For our safety they have to be handled one at a time. I refuse to be in the exercise yard with two bully dogs off leash. At least with the leash I have some form of control with them. Off leash I have none, it’s the same with the aggressive chihuahuas. The difference between the two is the power and size of the mouth.
 
Ya I wouldn't want to be alone with two bully types either. @WiglWerm mentioned pack settings. They must be predisposed to that. Dobes don't seem to have those issues in a pack setting.

I'm still working on reading dog body language. Not easy!
All dogs are predisposed to pack setting/structure.
The pack leader makes the rules.
That is why no matter what breed(s) a human chooses the human must be a strong leader.
It's why people who know suggest some breeds be left to experienced dog owners.
That's true of Bully breeds, Rottweiler, our own breed, and a host of others. Their capability is much greater than say a Cocker or a Pug. No offense to Cockers or Pugs.
 
All dogs are predisposed to pack setting/structure




A few years ago in North St. Louis, (N STL is the bad part of town. Drugs, gangs, murders almost nightly). Gangs members just had to have a pit. Turned out they couldn't handle them and were being attacked by their dogs. They just turned them out in the street, intact of course. Wasn't long until their were packs of them every where. The leaders were more than happy to protect their pack and were attacking people to do so. Even children at bus stops. Of course the dogs were blamed and be shot on the spot by people that were afraid to leave their house.




member: 2703"]That's true of Bully breeds, Rottweiler, our own breed,




It was not long ago that many people would say some of these thing about the doberman that they are saying about pit bulls now. Remove every single pit bull from the face of the earth and it would be replaced by another breed. Rotts, GSD's, Dobies have all had their turn. Now it's the pit bull.
 
That breed has me a bit concerned. I've never had one but have seen what other's ownership has produced including an attack by one upon another pit. Also an incident where the pit grabbed their little grandchild. That's when they got rid of it. I told my neighbor, whose pit constantly charged the wooden fence when my son was little and practicing soccer in the yard, that I'd kill him if he ever broke thru that fence. She said she understood. Having said that, if I were to ever know I'd be "in the company" of a pit bull, or especially walking two of them, I'd have a handgun on me that'd be superbly "up to the task" of putting them down quickly.
 
It was not long ago that many people would say some of these thing about the doberman that they are saying about pit bulls now. Remove every single pit bull from the face of the earth and it would be replaced by another breed. Rotts, GSD's, Dobies have all had their turn. Now it's the pit bull.
I had someone tell me this when we were at a dog park in CT with Princess. My question is.. were the Dobermans during that time all over shelters and Doberman mixes. Around here it just seems that at least half of the dogs in shelters are filled with some bully type breed. Was that the case with Dobermans or were they just getting a bad wrap.
 
It takes a special owner to have "power house" dogs. Rule #1 never assume anything...even your own pet can bite you.

My buddy Bob M. 25yrs ago was sitting on the floor eating chips & drinking a beer, watching TV...His Rott pops into the room and charges him...bites him in the face, causing MAJOR injury. The Rott had been with him since a pup and was about 4-5 years old...Never assume, always lead!
:usa::dobe::cool:
 
Unpopular opinion for sure, but I agree with you. I think Pitbulls are a challenging breed that is prone to aggressive/dominant behavior. In the right hands this can be nothing to worry about, but with a normal pet owner I feel like these situations are far too common. You look at bite statistics and it overwhelmingly damns pitbulls. Im sure there are a lot of great pitbulls out there that do not fit into this mold, but I would never put one around a child or myself.
Hope you are doing well buddy.
 

Back
Top