• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Very aggressive doberman on my hands and it's time I accept that I have a big problem. Please help.

When Apollo is amped up and lunging (Red zone!!) ....NEVER, I REPEAT NEVER touch the back of the neck. He will turn on your hand, not intentionally. From him it's an immediate 'GET OFF!' Plus, it can happen so quickly.


I would definitely seek expert advice.
I am trying to. It's just that everyone is saying different things. The trainer is telling me that he is acting this way because he doesn't see me as the alpha so he took on the role and feels the need to react aggressively to everything to protect himself because he doesnt trust me or his environment enough so i need to establish the alpha role with him to show him i call the shots. the dog behavioralist told me it has nothing to do with who is alpha and that it has nothing to do with trust and respect either but more to do with the fact that he just doesnt like other people and dogs and i should fix it by showing him dogs and people from afar and feed him his favorite foods so he can associate them with good things over time. I don't know who to listen to.
 
I was in a hurry when I wrote this a.m., and I realize now that I didn't say anything positive, and that was crappy of me! You ARE doing things right, and you clearly love this boy. When I first read (just now) about the trainer saying your dog needs for YOU to get him prepared to even be in the class that sounded kind of silly, but now I see that they do at least offer one-on-one, but that is a pretty steep price (I think??...I live in the sticks, so prices are different here!!)
Sorry I sounded so negative in my earlier post! You will get this figured out.
Thank you! It's okay. Don't worry, I was not offended and I agreed with what you said. I just want to make sure that nobody gets hurt in the end, including him....because if he hurts someone, he will get put down and I would never want that to happen to him. I need to protect him, myself, and everyone else.
 
I notice in some of your pictures, he's on a harness. Is he always on a harness when you take him out? They certainly would not help if he starts pulling toward someone and getting them to get their focus off whatever is driving them bonkers is pretty important, I think.

I had a pooch who would snap at other dogs, occasionally, when he was on a leash. *UNDER THE SUPERVISION of a trainer,* they gave me a bottle of the bitter apple spray and told me to spray him in mouth the second he opened his mouth to bark at a dog passing by *IN A SUPERVISED OBEDIENCE CLASS.* We were also training with prong collars which certainly help deter lunging. A couple of sprays of that stuff and he decided worrying about other dogs while passing on a leash wasn't that big of a deal.

Again, not very similar to your situation. I'm sure it's frustrating have different trainers tell you different things. It might be worth finding a group who's familiar with these types of dogs and their training requirements. We worked with German Shepard group for a little while. They realize that these dogs are thinkers. They're assessing situations all the time. And that comes with some challenges.
 
Have you check out Leerburg.com? The guy who started the website trained police dogs and Cindy who answers the Q&A section used to breed Dobermans. She usually has good free advice and will refer you to some of the videos they sell. There's a whole category on aggression.
 
I had a dog reactive dog, she wasn't dog aggressive. It took her over a year to finally get the concept we can walk calmly by other dogs and have them walk by us as well. I am a very strict owner in my home because I have to be to keep my pack safe. I own 4 dogs, one is a pup, a tiny 8 pound chihuahua, a German shepherd mix and my Doberman. When I see for instance Boo my shep getting to interested in anything it gets shut down immediately ( such as: intense staring, stalking, slowing up.) This is the same for when we go outside the home, none of them are allowed to call any of the shots.
With Ares my male Doberman he rarely needs a prong collar, Boo still needs one but it's not for pulling, it's to give her a reminder pop when I see her thinking about going back to her old ways. I don't even let her get to that point. This being said I have never alpha rolled any of my dogs. I don't let my dogs walk all Willy nilly on leash either they are to remain by my side walking calmly at all times till released for rewarded sniffing. In my opinion walks set the tone of the house, and my dogs are to follow not lead.
When Ares went through his doberteen phase he learned not to challenge me. Like I said I'm strict, consistent and can out stubborn a mule lol ask my fiancé ;)
I think asserting yourself more, correcting right before the behavior happens and reward for when he gives you eye contact would be a good place to start. Also and I have had to do this, tether him to you so you can continue to enforce the rules in and out of the home. Dogs need a clear and consistent person and rules should be black and white, if you set a rule have him follow it every time. You'll find giving a corrective pop will be one much more clear to the dog because a correction can only happen in the first couple of the seconds of when the dog messes up or they don't know what or why you did that. Also you'll find much easier and rewarding then the alpha roll.
I also don't believe in only using positive reinforcement, I think it causes more problems then good. I use pos only when they are puppies and just learning the basics but at 6 months old they are introduced to the prong and once they learn that, they learn what an e-collar is. I don't abuse my tools and know how and when to use them :)
 
Sorry you're going through this!

I will see if I have anything useful to offer later this evening.
 
I am curious if there was any escalation in these situations. For instance, did Apollo display any cues that he was uncomfortable with a situation or growing anxious or did he suddenly go from chillin' and relaxin' to raging bat-guano crazy? What is his exercise regimen?
 
Harnesses tend to make a dog more pulling aggressive. Restraint will amp them up an a halter whereas a prong collar for quick corrections before it gets to level 2 of the zone. Read body language because that will let you know when an immediate correction is needed before it goes too far. Then proceed on after rewarding him for bringing his attention back to you and keep moving forward and give quick corrections as necessary and reward positive behavior.
 
I am curious if there was any escalation in these situations. For instance, did Apollo display any cues that he was uncomfortable with a situation or growing anxious or did he suddenly go from chillin' and relaxin' to raging bat-guano crazy? What is his exercise regimen?
He literally goes from chillin in the grass and doin' his business to bat shit crazy pyscho....literally from a 1 to a 20 within the span of 3 seconds. The SECOND his eyes land on another person or dog (especially dog), it's game over and I have a flailing dog at the end of the leash. I honestly feel like if he were on a prong collar, he would seriously hurt himself by the way he swings himself out towards them full force.
 
It was so sad because when he was young (3 months) and still a shy little sweet pup, there's this girl that lives in my building with a dog named Sorsi that loved playing with Apollo when he was little. They got along very well...well, the past couple of months, I haven't seen them outside at all until today. So literally the last time I saw Sorsi and her owner was 5 months ago when he was still sweet and innocent. Well Sorsi and her owner happened to come outside today and when her owner saw Apollo, she was like "oh my gosh! he got so big!" with a big smile on her face and Sorsi was so excited to see Apollo too. Too bad Apollo had forgotten all the great times he had with Sorsi in the past and lunged at both of them trying to kill them both, showing all his teeth, then turned around at me and growled at me when I told him to stop. They immediately walked away and didn't speak to me after that. I apologized and was so embarrassed. They really liked Apollo and now they think he's crazy :(
 
Has he been checked by a vet? This doesn't seem normal at all. Until you can get some help, I would avoid any places he would run into other dogs as much as possible before someone gets hurt. I'm only thinking for the best of you guys and I don't want you to get hurt! The interactions sound like they are getting worse. He needs to see a professional asap.

Resources for veterinary behaviorists:
For The Public « ACVB
Member Directory « ACVB
 
Does he get much vigorous exercise? Has he been to a vet to be checked over (blood work especially)? As others have mentioned, I would also reach out to the breeder to let her know your situation and see if she has any suggestions or people she can put you in touch with.

If it's worth anything (I am by no means an expert), it doesn't sound like this is being driven by fear or his need to be dominant. It sounds like a 'learned' behavior. When he was younger and there was signs of escalation, nothing was curbed until he reached that "stress point" (where he growled or reacted adversely to something) so the behavior continued escalating until it has reached this point. Totally not your fault because it's not something you expect to have to combat with a puppy. Try googling 'redirection training dogs' -- there's tons of good info there and it might be helpful while you try and find other solutions. Whatever you do decide to do, it's crucial that you don't put him in a position where he has to submit or become fearful of you. It's been my experience that it will only reinforce his bad behavior.

I would continue with basic obedience like you have been... making him sit/stay before eating, entering a room, leaving, etc. I'm the type that has always let my dog sleep with me (I think it helps with the bonding) so I don't kennel my dog at night. Granted, he flips out when I put him in a kennel when I have to leave, but that's a problem I'm slowly trying to resolve!

Have faith and keep at it. He's not a bad dog and you're not a bad owner. His behavior is his way of telling you something is wrong... you just need to figure out what he's trying to say.
 
Trainers and people keep saying it is fear aggression but I don't think it's fear. When he barks and growls at people, he isn't doing it from behind me but lunging forward towards them. he doesn't like to back down or to be held back. He wants to get to them. He doesn't seem like he is doing it because he is scared
A fear biter, or fear-aggressive dog does not have to display signs that look like fearfulness. They can look like a ferocious, assertive dog when they lash out, but it can still be driven by fear. Fear-aggression was in the forefront of my mind on this. I could be wrong of course.

It is confusing that you are doing all these correct things and Apollo is still exhibiting these problematic behaviors. I would like to see Apollo in the hands of a different person for a few minutes – just to see how he acts. Seems there is something in the dynamic between you two that is allowing the problems.

You're a first time Doberman owner. Do you have other dog experience? I just wonder if you're seeing these problems as more dramatic and serious than they are. You say he is trying to kill other dogs and people. I bet there would not be any killing going on, and that Apollo would likely be put in his place by a lot of dogs, no offense. It may seem to you that he is going from total chill to attack mode in an instant, but dogs move fast and there are subtle cues and body language you can pick up.

I don't like to just tell people to go buy the services of a trainer or behaviorist. I like to spend money wisely. But if you have the availability of funds, it might be a good idea. I know you shared that the one trainer rejected him. There has to be someone who could take him on on a one-on-one basis. But that's going to be expensive! What I would do in the absence of spending money on a trainer would be to immerse myself in knowledge on dogs and these matters.

The other things I can think of are: Is there something going on health-wise? Is this just an unusual example of a Dobe and he is truly very aggressive and unstable? I would certainly be talking with the breeder.
 
Didn't you just board him for 10 days?
Could something have happened during boarding?
@Oh Little Oji is right, sometimes you don't recognize the signs of a fear biter because you probably haven't seen a dog with that issue before. It does sound more like fear aggression than just pure aggression especially at this age.
 

Back
Top