Doberman is blamed for killing a 4 year old girl

Dobie Wan Knobie

Hot Topics Subscriber
$ Forum Donor $
This is really a very sad story, and one that the Doberman will take the fall for. I am surprised that it is not posted on here already, as it is going to be really bad press for the Doberman.

As the story is unfolding it looks like it is a 4 year old Doberman-mix, not sure what it is mixed with, but most of the press is just stating that it was a Donerman. I have already read many comments on news stories about how the Doberman will turn on you, or your kids, and kill. Now they have this story to use as their proof.

This is such a tragic story, and so many things were done wrong by the parties that are involved. But the dog will be the scapegoat for sure, and it is impossible to justify the actions of the dog, but it is not solely to blame. A little girl was killed in a split second, and that is as bad as it can get. Sad, sad, sad, and it hurts me deep inside.

Here is a link to the most info I can find on this right now, but it is all over Google as well.
2016 Dog Bite Fatality: New Dog Kills 4-Year Old Child, Injures Mother in Southwestern Michigan - DogsBite.org
 
No real details have come out yet. It did happen inside the home, and not outside like it was first reported.
 
My heart just breaks. I don't know what to think... until more details come out,(if they do) it's hard to decide. Even being a mom and having young kids, I want to say she must have done something that triggered the dog. Leaned on it, got too close, stepped on a paw, something! Was it a fear bite that the old owner has just dropped the dog off and it was scared? Maybe. Was mom stupid for leaving a 4 year old child unattended with ANY dog, let alone a dog they didn't know, who was probably bigger than the kid? Absolutely. I'm sorry, but even (especially) them having been a prior doberman owner, I can't help but blame the mom. She should have known better. When we got Misty, and old lazy basset hound, who ran right to my kids and licked them all over, my kids were never unatended with her for over 18 months. Poor misty wanted to sleep with them, but the closest she got was at their bedroom door. I don't know. Of course I feel badly for this family, and pray they and their friends will get through this, but God do I also feel for that dog. How often do dogs really bite for absolutely no reason? Like is it really possible there was seriously NO trigger and the dog really is fully to blame here? (Besides mom leaving the little girl unattended)
 
Oh, I saw a headline on my email home page about a four year old girl killed by their dog that they just brought home. I just didn't have time to click on it.
 
Oh man. Yeah, that's the girl I saw in the pic with the headline. Authorities are calling it a Doberman or Doberman mix. You'd think that they'd easily be able to tell.

Tragic. Maulings involving Dobermans are so very rare. We don't know the real breed of this dog, nor do we know the exact circumstances. I don't want to speak ill of those who are hurting beyond belief but, boy, leaving a child alone with a dog – period – is always a risk.
 
I see the commenters are pretty much all suspecting that it was not a Doberman. I know that often if a dog is black with tan markings it is very often called a Doberman, Rottweiler or a mix thereof.

7 comments:

PutMeInCharge41Day | 10/24/2016 1:11 PM | Flag
I expect if we get to see a photo of this initially alleged "Doberman mix" that we are going to see a black and tan pit bull......



PutMeInCharge41Day | 10/24/2016 1:13 PM | Flag
I have a strong suspicion that the "Doberman mix" is going to look like this.

http://mrpitbull.com/PitBull-Pictures-Venus/Blue-Tri-Color-PitBulls.JPG

Your Quiet Neighbor | 10/24/2016 3:44 PM | Flag
But-but-but no one can *possibly* identify a pit bull!

Ka D | 10/24/2016 3:50 PM | Flag
Here's is the big difference: Doberman attacks, particularly FATAL ones, are RARE. Pit bull attacks, and particularly FATAL ones, are ROUTINE.

Where The Sand Pea Grows | 10/24/2016 5:48 PM | Flag
If they thought it was a Doberman mix, it seems likely it was Rottweiler mix of some sort.

Ken Quin | 10/24/2016 11:18 PM | Flag
I'd like to see a photo of the animal.

Dayna Hamilton | 10/25/2016 7:17 PM | Flag
Yes.
 
It makes no difference the breed. The mom failed basic parenting 101. You NEVER leave your child of age 4 unattended especially with a new dog in the house. You wouldn't leave your child unattended in a room with a stranger, why would you do that with a dog who was essentially a '.stranger'.

A friend called me about this who lives in Kalamazoo.

It is unfortunate and my heart breaks for the loss of a child but it will mean certain death for the dog as well.

I just don't understand this!!
 
Such a tragic story!

Don't get me wrong, my heart goes out to the family and friends of this beautiful little girl BUT she should of NEVER been left alone with the dog, not for even the '5 minutes' that was suggested on a different article. I read she had treats in her hand? This is so irresistible of the adults involved. REALLY REALLY bad management on their behalf.
To leave a child alone with ANY breed of dog, especially knowing he'd only been with the family for 1hour, it's just extremely difficult for me to process.

Very saddened by this! :(
 
I agree with what everyone is saying. The introduction of this dog to the family was all wrong. And certainly leaving a child alone with a treat in her hand was too.

The thing I really don't understand is the 'mauling'. The fact that this dog went into an full attack mode and could barely be contained seems so unlike a Doberman. I could better see a 'fear bite' or a 'snap' at the child. But to go into full attack and kill (and right for the throat) seems unbelievable.

I would like to hear from the guy that was giving this dog to the family. Why was he handing it over to them? Did he raise the dog? It's hard to believe that anyone would give a family with a 4 year old child a dog that he knew was unstable.

Tragic, tragic story. But like most stories, there has to be more to this. I know to this family it doesn't matter. Their child is still gone. :( And a scene they will never forget. So very sad. And just minutes from getting the dog. It's just an incredibly sad story.
 
I see the commenters are pretty much all suspecting that it was not a Doberman. I know that often if a dog is black with tan markings it is very often called a Doberman, Rottweiler or a mix thereof.

7 comments:

PutMeInCharge41Day | 10/24/2016 1:11 PM | Flag
I expect if we get to see a photo of this initially alleged "Doberman mix" that we are going to see a black and tan pit bull......



PutMeInCharge41Day | 10/24/2016 1:13 PM | Flag
I have a strong suspicion that the "Doberman mix" is going to look like this.

http://mrpitbull.com/PitBull-Pictures-Venus/Blue-Tri-Color-PitBulls.JPG

Your Quiet Neighbor | 10/24/2016 3:44 PM | Flag
But-but-but no one can *possibly* identify a pit bull!

Ka D | 10/24/2016 3:50 PM | Flag
Here's is the big difference: Doberman attacks, particularly FATAL ones, are RARE. Pit bull attacks, and particularly FATAL ones, are ROUTINE.

Where The Sand Pea Grows | 10/24/2016 5:48 PM | Flag
If they thought it was a Doberman mix, it seems likely it was Rottweiler mix of some sort.

Ken Quin | 10/24/2016 11:18 PM | Flag
I'd like to see a photo of the animal.

Dayna Hamilton | 10/25/2016 7:17 PM | Flag
Yes.

The first headline I read was "Doberman kills 4 year old girl" and had a photo of a male Dobe in full stride. So I started looking it up and found many similar stories as well, with photos of Dobermans. Then as I got deeper into it the story of the "type" or "mix" come into it, but the damage was done for the breed already at that point. I would sure like to know more about the dog and its origins, and see a photo of this particular dog.

I'm thinking that the owner that brought the dog to them could be held liable for delivering a dangerous dog to them or something of the like.
 
The first headline I read was "Doberman kills 4 year old girl" and had a photo of a male Dobe in full stride. So I started looking it up and found many similar stories as well, with photos of Dobermans. Then as I got deeper into it the story of the "type" or "mix" come into it, but the damage was done for the breed already at that point. I would sure like to know more about the dog and its origins, and see a photo of this particular dog.

I'm thinking that the owner that brought the dog to them could be held liable for delivering a dangerous dog to them or something of the like.
Really? So the various article-writers get word that it was a Doberman so they grab pics of Dobermans and use them for their story? Easy to see how misinformation gets spread.

I agree with what @MyBuddy said in a post above: This does not seem like Doberman behavior.

Anything is possible, and every individual animal is different, but I have not seen or heard of this type of attack out of a Dobe.
 
I see the commenters are pretty much all suspecting that it was not a Doberman. I know that often if a dog is black with tan markings it is very often called a Doberman, Rottweiler or a mix thereof.

7 comments:

PutMeInCharge41Day | 10/24/2016 1:11 PM | Flag
I expect if we get to see a photo of this initially alleged "Doberman mix" that we are going to see a black and tan pit bull......



PutMeInCharge41Day | 10/24/2016 1:13 PM | Flag
I have a strong suspicion that the "Doberman mix" is going to look like this.

http://mrpitbull.com/PitBull-Pictures-Venus/Blue-Tri-Color-PitBulls.JPG

Your Quiet Neighbor | 10/24/2016 3:44 PM | Flag
But-but-but no one can *possibly* identify a pit bull!

Ka D | 10/24/2016 3:50 PM | Flag
Here's is the big difference: Doberman attacks, particularly FATAL ones, are RARE. Pit bull attacks, and particularly FATAL ones, are ROUTINE.

Where The Sand Pea Grows | 10/24/2016 5:48 PM | Flag
If they thought it was a Doberman mix, it seems likely it was Rottweiler mix of some sort.

Ken Quin | 10/24/2016 11:18 PM | Flag
I'd like to see a photo of the animal.

Dayna Hamilton | 10/25/2016 7:17 PM | Flag
Yes.
In fairness, I should point out that the site from which I copied these comments appears to be an anti-Pit Bull site, or at least one with that bent.
 
I thought I read the Mom was out there with the kid. No?
Obviously something went very wrong here. How tragic for this family. I just can't imagine...


It bothers me that there is so little information available yet the story has headlines everywhere. I miss the days the media wanted to get the story right, not first.
 
So sad.
Yes to little info to go by. Unsupervised?
This is an armchair quarterback thought. But in the one picture is the little girl and their old dog. Maybe the girl did this to the new dog?
 
O didn't read all the posts but I will give a little story, sometimes it isn't bad parenting.

My mom raised Akitas and as part of her effort to be a "responsible breeder" she took part in rescue. (Yes clear back on the 80s :) my mom is arock star). She got a dog in, neutered male. I was really small, so I don't remember details but what they've told me is the previous owner said they couldn't keep him, not much in other details.

What I remember: I walked up to him while my dad was holding him, he was happy to see me, wagging his tail, had been good with any other tests they put him through. I went to pet him, dog was still wagging tail, he lounged bit my face and I went to hospital for 30-40 stitches and still have faint scars over 30 years later.

My dad shot the dog, that was unavoidable. But later the old owners said the dog hated kids because the neighborho.n
od kids tormented him through the fence. The dog loved adults. IMO a dog like that should be put down because you just never know when a kid will be around. Was it the dogs fault? No. But sometimes that's the way it goes.

Who knows what the old owners said? I agree she shouldn't have left them alone together but maybe she really was right there? I don't know that the article really goes into that much detail and they already have parts of it messed up. Sadly, a mistake like this cost her daughter's life and than is more punishment than anyone should have. I can't begin to imagine how awful it would be.


My puppy can be a dick totje kids. Sometimes I really worry about how he will be when older I work on teach kids respect, but also letting puppy know they are ahead of him and he dies if he hurts them. It would break my heart, but I wouldn't let a dog who can't be trusted around, and to perhaps do even more damage to someone else's child should they be rehomes (even in a home without kids, people have relatives.
 
Also, the mother was attacked trying to save her daughter, so I'm going to go ahead and guess that she was right there. I love animals, my dogs are like kids, but now that I have kids they have been moved a bit, and no dogs life is worth more than a child's. So, I feel for the dog, but I think it needs put down. It sucks, it's sad, but yeah, if Congo, Neegan or MyMy viciously bit my kid they wouldn't even make it to the vets office. (MyMy has been known to do a warning nip but it clearly doesn't hurt because my son laughs, and then he stops laughing because he gets spanked for bothering the dog to the point he made her nip. I know my dog, and I know she tolerates a lot. The kids do whatever they want to Congo and he seems to love it. They ride him for Pete's sake. But I'm always there and always watching his body language. So far the idiot seems to love it as much as they do. But he too knows that his dad would end his life if he hurt them. )
 
Maybe I am just overly cautious but I never allow my pups around the cats or birds unsupervised. Meaning...the birds are secure in their cages when the dogs go into the bird room. I am slowly teaching them respect and what behavior is acceptable and what isn't. With the cats I always make sure they have an escape route and when the cat is in my lap they must sit and behave.

Even as pups, I would never allow my pups around kids without having control of the pups. All it takes is a split second for a tragedy.
My friends tease me about hovering over my animals but I think that is necessary to raise well adjusted dogs.
I don't allow just anyone to come up to them and start petting or touching them, they are in a learning period and a sudden wrong movement could spook them and I don't want them fearful or biting because someone makes an inappropriate move.

They do well around kids but those are the kids that I trust around them to be gentle and respectful. Still I would not leave them unsupervised with anyone.

I can remember when I worked at the clinic and we had a GSD about a year old that had been to the clinic several times over a 6mo period and was a sweet dog. On one occasion he came in with his owner and we had them in an exam room. I got the thermometer and started shaking it down and this dog lunged at me biting me several times before I got control of him.
I think for some reason just the motion of shaking the thermometer set him off and it seemed he was in owner protection mode.
We asked the owner to leave the room and the dog settled down and was fine once the owner wasn't in the room with him.
Needless to say after that we would take the dog to an exam room to do his work up without the owner then allow the owner in the room after the exam was over.
She eventually got training for the dog and we did not have issues with him after the training. The vet said it was a classic case of the owner not being alpha and the dog assumed the alpha role. It certainly made me more aware of every dogs body language when they arrived at the clinic.
 

Back
Top