Dogfight!

I have been watching videos and reading articles because I know how crucial it is to have a proper fit, and this concerned me:

"It is dangerous to use a prong collar as your primary walking collar. Dogs learn by association. If, in the long term, your dog learns to associate pain with pulling he'll also learn to associate negativity with events that cause him to pull. Most friendly dogs pull in response to seeing other people and animals. If a prong collar is used on every walk, your dog will learn to associate people and animals with pain. With time, he'll become timid and even aggressive in the presence of others and might even begin growling and biting."

I don't want to make the problem worse by making him fearful or people-aggressive...
Sorry you're dealing with this. :(
Most things have been covered as far as I can see but wanted to add a couple of things.
First on this, I'm not sure I buy this?
I've used a prong for both of mine, Daisy is gone now but she never developed any of these things described.
Rocky just pulls hard. Pay attention here;) I believe he pulls like that because of my lack of training skills. I think a pro trainer could have him in a perfect slack leash heel on a flat collar.

I have just enough arthritis in my hands the prong saves me from "feeling" it all day. As an anecdotal experience from last week, we happened past a guy who lives way down the street washing his car. We stopped and talked for about 5-7 minutes. Rocky was as polite as could be. Loose leash, smelled the guy then just sat while we gabbed.

Now, about a previous post regarding the 6 year old human and where he stands in the hierarchy of the pack.
This is what I would do. That child gets a new responsibility, feeding the dog. Under your direct super vision of course.

The person holding the food is higher on the chain. Future goals will be to get the child giving the sit, presenting the food and the verbal release.
In time that creates a bond, and the child is in control and respect is in order.

It's also a great life lesson for the child. Animals are a responsibility. The earlier its engrained into the human brain the better.

Please don't be afraid of the prong as a short term solution but the best choice is some pro help. Not only to train the dog but to train you on how to properly train the dog.
 
?? I'm not at all worried what anyone thinks. I'm worried about the prong collar making my dog become people-aggressive as this article stated.
So far I've not seen this in mine. In fact Rocky is maybe more friendly than I would care for him to be, lol. But I think that's just who he is, he knows not a stranger.
 
I am sorry you and your family had to go through this. It can be frightening and it can shatter the trust you had in your dog. You can get past this...the prong collar is an amazing, I am not kidding, amazing tool to help you establish control. You will see a difference immediately. I would continue on with your prepaid class and us the prong collar at home. I am on my 6th dobie, you can get past this.:thumbsup2:

Thank you! I have purchased a prong collar and watched a bunch of videos on how to properly fit it. Now I just need to know where to start so he can get a feel for it. Walking indoors with no distractions? Standing still outside so he can learn to stay by me and not pull away? Do I treat when he's doing it correctly?

As to the article I read about prong collars making dogs aggressive and how they shouldn't be used more than an hour at a time, that was Wiki-How. The link is here: How to Use a Prong Collar on Dogs

I was looking at prong collars at Petco and the girl who works there said she highly recommends we DON'T use them because it will damage our dog's trachea.
 
Everyone covered everything else well. I personally would not use an ecollar in this case. It could only up the aggression if your boy thinks the stim is coming from the other dog. Find a trainer that knows how to use one. I also would never leave them out together now without having 100% attention on them. You will have to either crate and rotate or put them in separate rooms when you can't watch them.

So sorry this happened. The breed is known for same sex aggression. Is your older dog okay?

Thank you. Yes my older dog is ok. We are not letting them out together anymore but just putting around the house when I'm right there with them, my dobie is his usual play-bowing, tail-wagging self and my older dog is his usual plodding slow self.
 

Very eye opening. We thought we had a good handle on establishing ourselves as alphas (he's not allowed on furniture, we hold the food and he can't eat it until we give the ok, he isn't allowed through doorways until we say ok, etc) but some of these behaviors are so subtle that I never would have pegged them as dominance. Like standing/sitting on my feet - he does that all the time.
 

Thank you! It feels so tight to me when I set it so it stays right behind his ears. But any looser than that and it slides down.

The correction is not being made when it's tight to his neck, right? Seems I wouldn't want a constant squeeze on his neck with these prongs.
 
I was looking at prong collars at Petco and the girl who works there said she highly recommends we DON'T use them because it will damage our dog's trachea.


Ah the PetCo/Petsmart experts!!...I've had my own experience with that!!...I have since "seen the light!"
I trust them now (at my local stores...I'm sure there are great and experienced employees/trainers at other) only to show me where I can find something I want to purchase, search for coupons for me to help save money, and to go crazy with happiness when my boy walks in the door.
The trainer there....well...after she demeaned me for using a prong, I've seen her several times pull a dog's front feet out from under him/her with a flat collar....or her very favorite, a halti.
Love my prong, and love my trainer even more!!
 
I have the Herm Sprenger 2.25. You may need to add a link to make it not be digging in but snug enough to stay put.
 
Thank you! I have purchased a prong collar and watched a bunch of videos on how to properly fit it. Now I just need to know where to start so he can get a feel for it. Walking indoors with no distractions? Standing still outside so he can learn to stay by me and not pull away? Do I treat when he's doing it correctly?

As to the article I read about prong collars making dogs aggressive and how they shouldn't be used more than an hour at a time, that was Wiki-How. The link is here: How to Use a Prong Collar on Dogs

I was looking at prong collars at Petco and the girl who works there said she highly recommends we DON'T use them because it will damage our dog's trachea.

People who don't understand HOW to use prong collars are very against them, sadly. I would say a flat collar damages trachea's, prongs don't. I was told that a dog never forgets a mother dogs 'correction' nip on the neck. A prong collar simulates that. We started by just going very short distances and you will make a LOT of turns. We started walking and when Rubie got too far ahead, we did an abrupt 180 with a firm "NO." It gave her a little tug and taught her that pulling wouldn't get her to where she wanted to go. We still use this method when we're going to, say, the dog park or somewhere exciting. "Pulling means we either stop or walk the opposite direction. We'll get there when you walk nice." We didn't treat, just a "good heel/easy" when she's walking nice (her "easy" is the equivalent to another posters "close"). Any horror pictures you see online of prong collars is typically when a collar is put on a puppy and never taken off or made larger as they grow. Rubie gets excited when she hears her collar because she knows we're going somewhere fun, as it should be! When you start training, you won't go far, like I said. Keep training sessions short so your pup doesn't get too overwhelmed! Also, it should never be left on during play or around the house. Good luck and be consistent!!
 
oh! someone also mentioned grabbing their dog like a 'wheelbarrow.' This is actually the BEST method for physically removing the aggressor dog from an altercation. I've actually practiced it on my dogs (they look at you like, "what... are you doing?") and have used it on strangers dogs when they were too far away to get involved. You wrap your arms around their waist, lift up, and pull them backward. Dogs can't get to you with their teeth parts and they can't scramble away. Worth trying out!
 
Also, it should never be left on during play or around the house.
I'm gonna have to disagree with the 2nd half of this. I think you should have your prong on when you are supervising him along with a leash tab. Especially when you are having same sex aggression. A quick flick of the wrist if given BEFORE will redirect your dog from attacking.
 
I'm gonna have to disagree with the 2nd half of this. I think you should have your prong on when you are supervising him along with a leash tab. Especially when you are having same sex aggression. A quick flick of the wrist if given BEFORE will redirect your dog from attacking.
Yes, thank you for clarifying! "never left on around the house UNSUPERVISED!"
 
I can't upload photos right now because photobucket.com is down, but I bought the Medium sized prongs and I think I'm going to return it for the smallest ones. A few people mentioned the 2.25 mm I believe. I thought the Medium would work but when I have it fitted tight enough to stay put just under the ears, I've removed all but 5 of the prongs and I don't think it's at all evenly dispersed.
 
Thank you to all who posted vids! I've watched them all. I get the training method, its just the proper fit I'm really concerned about.
 
I have the 2.25 and it works great for both of my dobies. I think that will be the best size for you as well.Depending on what kind of puller you have will dictate if you need to clip one or both of the rings. My pair once they tried the prong do not pull so I hook to both rings, they don't need the added correction of a single. Good luck I think you will be amazed at the results!
 

Back
Top