Dogfight!

RSTweed

Hot Topics Subscriber
My 7.5 month old male dobie pup went after our elderly 13-year-old dog. He has zero history of any sort of aggression and I was completely taken by surprise. No, there was no food or toy or any high value item in the entire yard. My dobie was trying to hump the older one (never did this before) and it escalated in a split second.

It seemed to last forever and I ultimately had to use a chair like a lion tamer to get him off of our old dog, who was flat on his back submitting but our dobie would not let up.

Blood, but no serious injuries that I can see.

Very scary, especially that I could not get the dobie off of him - I yelled and kicked and (stupidly) grabbed but he was unstoppable and ridiculously strong until I ran and grabbed a chair and was able to kind of beat him off with it.

My kids were screaming from the steps. Everyone is traumatized. I don't even know.
 
Awe. I know it is scary when dogs fight. It sounds like he's trying to prove his dominance, the other dog may have given him some resistance on the humping and it set the dobe off? I would watch them closely but it may be that they won't be able to be together. :(
 
Unfortunately older or neutered doesn't matter when it comes to the possibility of same sex aggression. Your Dobe is also going through the doberteens. What type of discipline does he have ? I would certainly not allow humping at all. I would seriously look at who the boss of the house is cuz if your Dobe thinks he is you gotta make it perfectly clear he is not. My boys have never had an issue, but they know whose in charge.
 
Dog fights are scary. Owners wind up getting bit trying to break it up.
They are strong even being a pup. I had to grab Bogie like a wheelbarrow and yank him up to separate my two. No blood was drawn so I think they were more mouthy than out for blood. The female keeps coming back at him. The Ecollar has been a saver for me working with their behavior. I use the tone button if they are getting too amped up and they respond immediately to the tone sound.
Now if there were seriously out for blood I am not sure even the stimulate would work but have never had to venture there.

Perhaps you need to get a trainer to help you and show you how to work with him as you being alpha.
I would not let them be together unsupervised until you get a handle on him.

So sorry this happened. Sure hope your older dog is ok!!
Poor baby. :-(
 
Thank you.

As to the alpha/training issue: he has completed his puppy class and the next class starts next weekend. We work with him every day making him sit or down before he is fed, before he is allowed to exit his crate, have a ball thrown, etc. Before we enter the house he has to sit and allow the rest of us humans to enter first, and we have my kids make him sit, down and stay on a daily basis. He has to wait once his food bowl is on the floor until one of us says "Ok" before he eats it.

He really does seem to know his place when it comes to us humans, but after today I am afraid he's going to kill my other dog or my cat. Do I need to worry about this behavior transferring onto my kids? He is super attentive and obedient to them right now - my youngest is 6.

We do have an e-collar that we've never used but my DH wants to after today. Would we use it at the first sign of humping? Is it strong enough to stop a dogfight before it stops? Because I hesitate to say this here but in all honesty, in my panic to stop him from killing my elderly feeble dog, I landed some solid kicks and it didn't even slow him down. Until I was able to physically separate them with a chair I was utterly helpless to stop it.
 
If I can say this. If you are doing only positive reinforcement training I would look else where. There is a different between tricks and training behavior. Any dog can sit but does that dog respect you.
What you are describing is a dog that is able to go into a red zone where no amount of anything will stop it.
How do they walk together ? How does he walk in general ? I wouldn't let any excited behavior if they are around each other. Excitement, leads to frustration, frustration leads to misplaced aggression, then fights. If he is same sex aggressive, you will either have to seriously consider rehoming one, crate and rotating, or some serious behavior training :/
Like I said my two boys have never had a problem, but that being said I control everything.
 
If I can say this. If you are doing only positive reinforcement training I would look else where. There is a different between tricks and training behavior. Any dog can sit but does that dog respect you.
What you are describing is a dog that is able to go into a red zone where no amount of anything will stop it.
How do they walk together ? How does he walk in general ? I wouldn't let any excited behavior if they are around each other. Excitement, leads to frustration, frustration leads to misplaced aggression, then fights. If he is same sex aggressive, you will either have to seriously consider rehoming one, crate and rotating, or some serious behavior training :/
Like I said my two boys have never had a problem, but that being said I control everything.

Of course you can. Thank you.

I don't know how they walk together because my older dog doesn't have the stamina for long walks and prefers sunbathing and naps. My dobie walks terribly and only is under my physical control with a Gentle Leader head collar. Just bring honest; don't crucify me.

I was pretty committed to positive reinforcement prior to this, but am willing to try whatever will work. Is it a dobie thing to suddenly turn on my other peaceful male dog once they hit doberteens? Will he turn similarly on his humans? Will neutering him help?

I was fully prepared for the high energy but I will admit this has me really shaken.
 
Neutering won't do anything, training will. Yes Dobermans can develope same sex aggression. Gentle leaders aren't suited for Dobermans since they can crank their necks pretty badly. I suggest a prong collar and different trainer. How a dog walks on leash is a huge indicator on what respect a dog holds, if the dog leads you on the walk, he's charge. A prong collar is the most natural correction a dog can have. I think you need to look into different types of training, work on walks, and don't let things escalate in the home with the other dog. It shouldn't transfer onto your children but like anything that doesn't have clear rules, boundaries and limitations anything can happen. Nip it now and make the rules black and white to the dog. Consistency is the key.
 
Neutering won't do anything, training will. Yes Dobermans can develope same sex aggression. Gentle leaders aren't suited for Dobermans since they can crank their necks pretty badly. I suggest a prong collar and different trainer. How a dog walks on leash is a huge indicator on what respect a dog holds, if the dog leads you on the walk, he's charge. A prong collar is the most natural correction a dog can have. I think you need to look into different types of training, work on walks, and don't let things escalate in the home with the other dog. It shouldn't transfer onto your children but like anything that doesn't have clear rules, boundaries and limitations anything can happen. Nip it now and make the rules black and white the dog. Consistency is the key.

Thank you. Any good sites I can check out on how to properly use a prong collar?
 
Thank you. Any good sites I can check out on how to properly use a prong collar?
I recommend Herm Sprenger get the 2.25mm to start with. You'll probably need to get some extra links and once you get it I'm sure we can help you with it :)
 
My trainer showed me how to use a prong collar and it does work. Like Amanda said, positive only training is not good with this breed. They need corrections from you that will get their attention with a prong. Quick correction with verbal command then slack.
They need to understand the consequences for unacceptable behavior. My trainer comes to my home and my neighbor kids ride their bikes and skateboards down the street and others walk their dog by during training and he gives a correction each time they start to focus on the other people and dogs before it gets to a red zone. Sometimes it takes a succession of corrections to get his focus back but now they bothe lay in the driveway in a down stay position while other dogs walk by. He rewards them for the correct behavior but not if they hesitate to follow his commands. Until they are fully trained to your commands I would not use a flat collar and definitely not a gentle lead. Find a trainer that uses positive and corrective training. I guarantee an e collar will stop them in their tracks before they get to the red zone.

Male puppies produce I believe 4xs the level of testosterone than adult dogs and the adult dogs sense this and may try to correct them. Your older dog may have growled during the humping which incited your dog to be more dominant.
Now your pup thinks he is big man on campus and needs to be brought down a peg.
 
My trainer showed me how to use a prong collar and it does work. Like Amanda said, positive only training is not good with this breed. They need corrections from you that will get their attention with a prong. Quick correction with verbal command then slack.
They need to understand the consequences for unacceptable behavior. My trainer comes to my home and my neighbor kids ride their bikes and skateboards down the street and others walk their dog by during training and he gives a correction each time they start to focus on the other people and dogs before it gets to a red zone. Sometimes it takes a succession of corrections to get his focus back but now they bothe lay in the driveway in a down stay position while other dogs walk by. He rewards them for the correct behavior but not if they hesitate to follow his commands. Until they are fully trained to your commands I would not use a flat collar and definitely not a gentle lead. Find a trainer that uses positive and corrective training. I guarantee an e collar will stop them in their tracks before they get to the red zone.

Male puppies produce I believe 4xs the level of testosterone than adult dogs and the adult dogs sense this and may try to correct them. Your older dog may have growled during the humping which incited your dog to be more dominant.
Now your pup thinks he is big man on campus and needs to be brought down a peg.
Agreed. I personally though wouldn't use an e collar till after the dog understands what a correction is. If you have to and I had to when Ares 6 months old and wouldn't stop marking inside is I tethered him to me and gave a correction.
Personally I have seen some dogs ignore the ecollar if they red zone. You'll be able to tell if your dog will by his pain tolerance.
 
Would we use it at the first sign of humping? Is it strong enough to stop a dogfight before it stops?
Like @AresMyDobie said you first need the dog to understand what a correction is before using an ecollar. Otherwise the dog doesn't know why he's getting a vibration/stimulation around his neck. He doesn't know where it came from and he may go into a fight or flight mode which is something you certainly don't want.
Once he understands the ecollar correction, you could use it at the first sign of humping hopefully before he mounts. I can see it in Drogon before he mounts so I assume you can read your pup just as well.
As for dog fights, I've been told not to use an ecollar to attempt to break up a dog fight in progress. If you can preempt the fight then you could give an ecollar correction but you need to exercise good judgement. The reasons not to use it once the fight is in progress is your dog might think the other dog caused the vibration/stimulation and lash out even more at him. Additionally if your dog did respond to the ecollar and turned, it would make him vulnerable to an attack from the other dog. Similarly if you're trying to preempt a fight make sure you don't put your dog in danger.
 
I know I titled this thread "Dogfight" but just to be clear, my old dog was on his back submitting and my dobie was not backing down. Even as I got the chair between them and was able to back my dobie off, he was trying to lunge and dash past it. The other dog was not fighting back or challenging him by any means, and was in fact on his back submissively.
 
I recommend Herm Sprenger get the 2.25mm to start with. You'll probably need to get some extra links and once you get it I'm sure we can help you with it :)

I have been watching videos and reading articles because I know how crucial it is to have a proper fit, and this concerned me:

"It is dangerous to use a prong collar as your primary walking collar. Dogs learn by association. If, in the long term, your dog learns to associate pain with pulling he'll also learn to associate negativity with events that cause him to pull. Most friendly dogs pull in response to seeing other people and animals. If a prong collar is used on every walk, your dog will learn to associate people and animals with pain. With time, he'll become timid and even aggressive in the presence of others and might even begin growling and biting."

I don't want to make the problem worse by making him fearful or people-aggressive...
 
I know I titled this thread "Dogfight" but just to be clear, my old dog was on his back submitting and my dobie was not backing down. Even as I got the chair between them and was able to back my dobie off, he was trying to lunge and dash past it. The other dog was not fighting back or challenging him by any means, and was in fact on his back submissively.
I don't think anyone is saying your old dog was fighting back. That said, animals are great readers of body language, a flip of the ear, a turn in posture, even how they look at each other can be defiance. So while after the fight started the elder dog was submissive, I'm guessing he did something to tell the puppy to stop humping him. (As he has every right to do).

This is where everyone is talking about "who is alpha". If you are alpha they won't quaral because they know it isn't something their leader will put up with.

Working breeds like Dobermans, rotties, Akitas, are not naturally submissive dogs (as a whole). They need that drive tondo what they were bred to do. However, in a house situation, they see you, your family and your other dog as their "pack" and they try to establish their rank. Again, this is where you need to be alpha.

Just following sit/down/stay isn't you being alpha. I second a new trainer who has more experience with working breeds. Your dog is trying to figure out where he fits in the pack and he needs to know that his rank is below all humans and equal with your other dog, and that you will squash him for trying to hurt your other dog.

Once a dog is in that "I see red" zone, they aren't going to stop without major intervention, and even after they will be majorly keyed up. Learning your dog and how to handle your dog and how to establish dominance over your dog is imperative to them all getting along. Everyone here has great advice but every animal is different so a hands on trainer is the way to go. :)
 
I have been watching videos and reading articles because I know how crucial it is to have a proper fit, and this concerned me:

"It is dangerous to use a prong collar as your primary walking collar. Dogs learn by association. If, in the long term, your dog learns to associate pain with pulling he'll also learn to associate negativity with events that cause him to pull. Most friendly dogs pull in response to seeing other people and animals. If a prong collar is used on every walk, your dog will learn to associate people and animals with pain. With time, he'll become timid and even aggressive in the presence of others and might even begin growling and biting."

I don't want to make the problem worse by making him fearful or people-aggressive...
You can't worry about what other people think. What's more important ? Their opinion that is probably an uneducated one or the health of your dog and home life ? and if that were true id have the most aggressive dog ever. The prong saved my sheps life and many here can tell you how great my Doberman is.
 

Back
Top