That is actually part of the cause of this. It's too soft. Too easy for him to break it off.It was hard for me to tell from the picture. I breathed a sigh of relief when I read soft plastic!!
The bigger blame would be my own for letting him do it to begin with.
I was just happy to see him showing an interest in playing with anything at that point. Until he ate it.
From now on we stick to nylabone or his favorite, a 16.5 oz water bottle.
He likes to crunch them.

He doesn't try to get the cap off or the label. In fact if the cap is off he doesn't like it as well because there's less resistance when he crunches.
He just likes to crunch the bottle to make noise and annoy us.

I'd rather deal with that than this, so...
is going to be rather loose. 

