• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Transition from prong to flat

bomary

Hot Topics Subscriber
Okay, you guys know I'm a novice. Please don't lambaste me...or maybe do if I am being ignorant....!! Jax is completely rocking out on leash. I've been using a 20 foot lead to train recall, come, come and heel, stay (stand and stay, sit and stay, down and stay, etc.). He is pretty much fail proof. He has never been the type to run after squirrels, other dogs, etc. I am, however, using a prong. I VERY rarely give a correction. There has to be an inordinate number of distractions for him to require one (correction), and even then it is not at all often (He self corrects). I would really love to get his CGC, and would honestly like to train him as a therapy dog. He is amazing with every person (kids, elderly, strangers, etc.) and truly minds his manners around other dogs. At times I just put the prong on, but I don't even attach the leash to that; I attach it to his flat buckle. I am just wondering about where I should go from here. I assume he needs to be perfect on the flat collar in order to get his CGC. I am ready and willing to do that. My personal trainer likes to get everything down on a lead before trying off-leash. (I get that, and of course I am more comfortable with it.) I let go of the lead and walk around him, turn my back to him, stand/sit and hold conversations with others while he is in "stay" (for long periods of time and far away from him.) More often than not, he will lie down near me and let me go about my business. (Today we took my Jeep in for an oil change; he greeted everyone, shook hands, and then just laid down and waited until it was time to load up...about an hour). However, I am concerned about his ability to do all of these things (mostly the pulling concerns me, even though he is much better at that now) on a flat collar.
Again...I know I ask stupid questions, and I apologize. I just truly think he was made for therapy work (I can't say enough about his interactions with kids at school, young kids in the neighborhood, and elderly people...he is just phenomenal), but I guess I need to know whether using the prong is still okay at this age.
Do not worry about offending me...I just know what I want for him and I want to steer him in the right direction.
We met a man a few days ago who owns Dobermans (has two pups who I am begging to babysit), and I am setting up play dates. That's exciting. (The guy is more into personal protection, though, and I am a bit worried about his 6 year old male intimidating Jaxie and perhaps "turning him off" of dogs.) I also thought about maybe asking my trainer about choosing a playmate from the dogs she currently has at her facility (some are hers, some are boarding and training.)
Sorry so long...I'd just love some input. Does this even make sense??!!
 
I'm not sure exactly what you are asking but I'll respond to what I think you are.
If you want to pass the CGC, practice. It's really pretty simple. Where and how do you practice now? Are fimilar with what the test entails? If I remember right, you can download the steps of the test from the AKC website. Print it and take it with you to practice everywhere. I assume you will be taking the test at your training facility? Practice there.
The dog just has to be nonreactive to another dog during to test, not playful. Some dogs, if given lots of playtime with other dogs, see the other dog in the test as a signal it's now playtime.
As far as the collar goes, you have options. The CGC is given on lead, so I'm not sure it's all that important to work with him off lead yet. You can graduate to the e collar for off lead work. Just remember, you can correct with a flat collar.
I would just keep practicing the routine. Find a partner with a dog you trust, maybe someone that is preparing for the test also and just practice, practice, practice.
Run through the test and when he gets it right, mark it with his favorite thing, a toy a game....whatever. I save that favorite thing for reward when the training goes right and only then. Soon the dog learns he gets huge rewards if he does what you want. In our case, it is a tuggy or a kong wubba. Those toys only come out when it's training time so they are considered a special treat. Drake knows it's time to work and get it right so he can be rewarded with the gold.
 
I'm not sure exactly what you are asking but I'll respond to what I think you are.
If you want to pass the CGC, practice. It's really pretty simple. Where and how do you practice now? Are fimilar with what the test entails? If I remember right, you can download the steps of the test from the AKC website. Print it and take it with you to practice everywhere. I assume you will be taking the test at your training facility? Practice there.
The dog just has to be nonreactive to another dog during to test, not playful. Some dogs, if given lots of playtime with other dogs, see the other dog in the test as a signal it's now playtime.
As far as the collar goes, you have options. The CGC is given on lead, so I'm not sure it's all that important to work with him off lead yet. You can graduate to the e collar for off lead work. Just remember, you can correct with a flat collar.
I would just keep practicing the routine. Find a partner with a dog you trust, maybe someone that is preparing for the test also and just practice, practice, practice.
Run through the test and when he gets it right, mark it with his favorite thing, a toy a game....whatever. I save that favorite thing for reward when the training goes right and only then. Soon the dog learns he gets huge rewards if he does what you want. In our case, it is a tuggy or a kong wubba. Those toys only come out when it's training time so they are considered a special treat. Drake knows it's time to work and get it right so he can be rewarded with the gold.
HA!. You did answer all of my questions despite the fact that I asked them in a very round-about way!! Thank you! I think my main worry is that he would need to be able to be really good on a flat collar, and I am still relying on the prong a lot.
 
Transitioning from the prong to flat can be difficult if not done early. I didn't and now I'm still working on it at times with Java in public places to walk nicely on a flat. Given how difficult she can be to work with, with being always Go Go Go!, it will always be an ongoing process for us. One day, we plan to get her CGC and whenever that day is, will be a huge accomplishment for us. I think its awesome that you are wanting to do that now...I would definitely encourage swapping over to the flat collar as much as possible when you can and only using the prong for really new areas, otherwise it becomes like a crutch. And, I'll tell you that man, is it hard to break if you always use it!

Think of it as weaning off of the prong. In situations you would normally use the prong...use the prong to warm him up and get him used to the area and use it to get his attention. When he's performing well and looking to you, halt, have him in a sit next to you and switch the leash to the flat collar. Keep the same confident attitude as before, and continue heeling and doing your other warm up activities. If he begins applying pressure to the collar, coax him back to you in the correct position and praise when he keeps that position for a few steps. I do what Genny does and do a few steps, praise, then game of tuggy. They learn to stop looking at the distractions and start looking to you for that fun game of tug! You can give a simple leash pop on the flat collar for a reminder if he really needs it and if he needs many leash pops in a row, go back to the prong for a bit of a stronger reminder. Back to the flat when you feel he's listening again. Gradually wean off and praise for good performance on the flat. :) Rinse and repeat in as many locations/scenarios as possible!
 
I'm not working toward a title, but I'm thinking about transitioning Hans to a flat collar at the age of 7. I walk him on a narrow road with cars and trucks that disobey the speed limit, but I still want to work up to it just as an exercise and continuing education for both of us ;)
 
I started using a prong collar on Kris when she was about a year old. I gradually switched her over to a leather collar and when she was a year and a half she got her CGN (the Canadian CGC) wearing a leather collar.
 
I started using a prong collar on Kris when she was about a year old. I gradually switched her over to a leather collar and when she was a year and a half she got her CGN (the Canadian CGC) wearing a leather collar.
That makes me feel great!!...I think that is an attainable goal. Thank you so much!
 
Transitioning from the prong to flat can be difficult if not done early. I didn't and now I'm still working on it at times with Java in public places to walk nicely on a flat. Given how difficult she can be to work with, with being always Go Go Go!, it will always be an ongoing process for us.


I still am pretty dependent on the prong depending on the circumstances. Drake will walk nicely with a flat collar but I find myself using the prong when we are around other dogs. Am I right or wrong?, arguments could be made either way. I've been in too many situations where I don't trust the owners so I want to be in control of my dog. Drake will not be the first to react, but he will if pushed. He is fine around controlled dogs, especially females. He is not big on males getting in his face. There is something about him that makes males want to get in his face and his approach is more like, don't start no sh** and there won't be any.
 
I still am pretty dependent on the prong depending on the circumstances. Drake will walk nicely with a flat collar but I find myself using the prong when we are around other dogs. Am I right or wrong?, arguments could be made either way. I've been in too many situations where I don't trust the owners so I want to be in control of my dog. Drake will not be the first to react, but he will if pushed. He is fine around controlled dogs, especially females. He is not big on males getting in his face. There is something about him that makes males want to get in his face and his approach is more like, don't start no sh** and there won't be any.

I certainly agree! I feel it gives you more control...and that's why I've always used it in public. I understand the reasoning for not using the prong in the akc's cgc test but it does make me a tiny bit sad that that's the only thing holding us back. I believe I heard ukc's spot test allows prongs...

Either way she's getting better... yesterday she heeled perfectly on a flat at a public park (pretty much a milestone for us!) and then people walked by with their yappy dogs on a flexi lead. She remained in a heel but needed constant reminders. She was ready to explode lol. In a totally non-aggressive way. Just excited and irritated by their yappy presence. I just wanted to get past them as quickly as possible before the dogs pulled that leash out anymore.
 
She was ready to explode lol.



Boy, do I know about that! Sometimes I think Drake forgets where the off button is. One of his many nicknames is Energizer. like the bunny. LOL!
I'm okay with it, although he can be exhausting, I love his electric look.


Either way she's getting better... yesterday she heeled perfectly on a flat at a public park (pretty much a milestone for us!) and

:yatta::woot::woot::congrats: I completely understand what a milestone that is :rolleyes:
 
You guys, I know this is such an old thread, but I have been having ridiculous medical crap going on and I either read these on pain medication (the good I.V. kind!!), or I never read them! (BTW...the ridiculous medical issues are no big deal at all...just a bunch of tiny crap that all coincided in a few months...all is well.) I just wanted to thank y'all for your responses because I have been completely beating myself up for not having Jax perfectly trained on a flat collar. I'm not even worried about off leash right now. I mean, he minds me in our yard, etc. off leash, but I am not terribly worried about trying to have him off leash in public. I just wondered if I was a failure because I do use a prong in public.
Reading your responses has made me feel better!
I do have a goal of having him do the CGC test, and I hope we can work successfully toward that. (I think I had it in my head that I should already have him able to do it at 8 months, and this surgery bullshit has definitely put a damper on training!)
 
While goals are a good thing sometimes they just put too much pressure on you. That can take the fun out of it for both of you. ;) Just keep putting one foot before the other and you'll get there.
Enjoy the journey....that's what it's really about. :)
 

Back
Top