• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Same-Sex Aggression & Handling

dobielife

New Member
I'm in a bit of a pickle right now, not with my current dogs, but with a future dog. So, most of you probably already know my story, but I am looking to get a Doberman for the first time. I want to use this dog to get me started in showing in all sorts of events and to just learn and really dive into the breed that I have loved for a long time. The only problem is, I have a four year old male, a four year old female, and a three year old female living in my current home. All are fixed and I will be leaving soon so only the four year old male would be coming with me. He is very sweet and fairly lax. He's never gotten aggressive with our two females and has only shown slight aggression(hair raising and extreme alertness) when an un-itnroduced dog showed up in our back yard(my uncles dog). However, once the two were introduced on neutral grounds, they were very friendly and playful together and he didn't show any signs of aggression after that. He also had a slight incident with a young boy, but it was a monitored situation and the boy just got a little too grabby and tugged his ears a little hard. All he did was give a slight growl before he was reprimanded. After that, he was completely fine and gentle with the boy.
Now, I've never had intact females mostly because I don't want to deal with the heat issue, and I'm not ready to do so now either, really. Hopefully in the future, but not now. I have handled intact males before and that is really what I want, a male.
I just enjoy males a lot more than females and I won't have to deal with the heat issue.
I'm just worried about same-sex aggression. I have done good amount of research on it and it seems like a lost caused. Even having the Doberman as a young puppy and introducing the pair and monitoring social activities and such doesn't seem to help prevent this. So, I wanted to see if anyone has any success stories with same-sex Dobermans and what you did. I really want this to work out because I want to be able to take my boy and the Doberman with me, not leave my boy behind with my parents, but I can't have two dogs hating each other the rest of their lives.
Thanks in advance and I am completely open to any and all suggestions, articles, links, etc!
 
It is a lot to handle if one of the dogs turns same sex aggressive. It is not the case with all dogs but it is a higher risk when a Doberman. If one is same sex aggressive about the best you can do is crate and rotate. Unless you are very experienced in dealing with dominant breeds and strong enough to handle issues it is better to avoid it. Even is not same t sex aggressive they can get get highly excited and turn on each other out of frustration. It usually does not start til the puppy hits about 18 months. At that point I would neuter before issues start to improve your odds for a peaceful home.
 
The problem is that the dog would need to remain intact because I want to compete with it in confrontation and agility and possibly other things. So even having the pup well socialized with my current boy won't help anything? And how bad does it get? I've heard different views but is the 'turning-on-each-other-if-we-so-much-as-see-each-other' thing true?
 
I can say that my friend/roommate and I had two male dogs together in the same household. My Doberman and his German Shepherd. Sometime around the time people have mentioned here, serious fights broke out. Not sure if it could be considered same-sex aggression though, because it was all one-sided – initiated by the GSD who turned out to be quite dog-aggressive – but I do feel it would not have been so bad if they were not the same sex.

We did continue to live in the same place together after the fights started, and most of the time life was good between the dogs. So the problem wasn't constant, but the problem could occur at any moment which was pretty stressful.
 
My male pit and male dobe are best buds. My male pit has no aggression issues and is fixed, so I do believe that played a huge roll in their friendship. I can leave them unattended and have full confidence nothing will happen. My male dobe is not fixed and does have same sex aggression....just not with our male pit. Any other male and its on. I will never bring another male into my house as long as my male dobe is alive. Which I am fine with :) my male dobes same sex aggression didn't start until he was attacked by a male at the dog park. Ever since then he goes on the offensive right away. Although he has same sex aggression we can be in reach of another male without him going ape $#!% so long as I give the command leave it. If a male were to just run up on us though it would not be pretty. He loves all people and the ladies though. I think it depends on your current dog and the training your willing to put in if issues do arise and if you have the patience for a crate and rotate if needed!
86a4320685f5a9d86163f6bbb2f508c9.jpg
 
Have you ever seen a dog sent through meat grinder??? It can mean huge medical bills and/or death. They can loose a leg due to the fight and numerous cuts, torn skin, gaping wounds. It is not something to play with. He does not have to be in tact for agility. Conformation is the only activity he has to be in tact for or the Breed Survey (ZTP). I would never leave them unattended together. It only takes once.

My male dobe is not fixed and does have same sex aggression....just not with our male pit.
I do not think he has same sex aggression, what he had is a trauma when he was attacked so he now does not trust other males. If it was true same sex aggression then he would not tolerate your pit either. That is why it is same sex aggression - and it applies to ALL same sex.
 
I truly think it depends on the temperment of the dog. I had my last dobe and collie for 8 years, both intact. No issues apart from standard dominance stuff. Mostly my dobe would let the collie away with everything until he decided he had to be reined in. I think if your fella is quite relaxed with most dogs you will be fine.
They will have some cracker fights (ours did) until the hierarchy is established. Likewise my friend has two female dobies, they also had a couple of huge barneys until hierarchy was established. Now they are a bonded pair with no issues.
If you have two dogs that are comfortable in their pack roles then they will be fine together.
 
Ah okay. Thank you both! I'm not willing to take the chance if the risk is that big. Unfortunately, I don't think I'll be able to get a Doberman now. I'm just not prepared to handle a female in heat affectively. Thanks for all of your help though! Maybe when I have no dogs again and am looking I can finally get into this.
[DOUBLEPOST=1428671688][/DOUBLEPOST]@MemphisBlue
He is really lax around other dogs, unless, like I said, another dog just shows up in his place. That one incident was the only time I've ever seen him territorial and aggressive, yet after they were introduced he was completely fine. He was perfectly okay with that dog coming into the house and letting me interact with the other male. I am prepared for dominance fights as we've always had more than one dog and I've experienced it quite a bit. In the past, we had two female border collies. While they rarely fought after dominance was established, their scuffles weren't too pretty but I was always able to break it up quickly enough. I'm just concerned because my current boy is small(about the size of a beagle, just a bit thicker maybe) and I don't want him to turn fearful or aggressive and I also don't want that for my Doberman either.
 
Is it heriditary at all? For instance, if you had two parents who weren't same-sex aggressive, would you be more likely to end up with a pup who is not than if one parent was? Or is it purely based on the individual dog? I guess I'm not quite sure how you can't prevent it with a proper upbringing. I never actually heard about this in too much detail until this forum.
 
its always a gamble as you'll never know what they're like until you get to know them.
I agree. I know many people who do it with both males and females but they have to know the possibility is there if you get two of the same gender.
Or is it purely based on the individual dog?
I think in many cases it is. Our male is pretty laid back and he gets along well with his half brother, but of course they don't live in the same household either.
 
I have zero experience with this, but I've been on this board since 2009. I've read many threads and posts about this issue and IMHO it's a gamble. And a gamble I wouldn't want to take. I think you can take every precaution, every lick of training and in the end, still have to crate and rotate. It seems there is no way to foresee what will happen, until it does. Things may be moving along so well......and then they reach an age where things change. By then, you have two dogs that you love and do not want to part with, so you are left with the responsibility of having a constant, watchful eye and crate rotation. And never leaving them alone together. It's just not something I'm willing to chance. That's just me.

When I got my first Doberman (male) my breeder told me back then, if I ever got another one, it should be a female. She said they will be like an old married couple together. :D I understood what she meant, even though some 'old married couples' can be quite aggressive!! LOL! :p
 
Is it heriditary at all? For instance, if you had two parents who weren't same-sex aggressive, would you be more likely to end up with a pup who is not than if one parent was?

Yes it is heriditary - it is called DNA and genetics. Whether we are talking conformation, temperament, color, eyes what ever it is in the gene pool.

It can be dominant, recessive and or a combination of the 100's of thousands of genes laying in the gene pool. That is why you can have a throwback to something you have never seen before. Mother nature does not play by our rules. Mother nature can come right up and slap you in the face.

But if you breed two dogs together who are both same-sex aggressive you will get puppies that are same sex aggressive more than not.

I never actually heard about this in too much detail until this forum.

That is why these forums are so great - they are dedicated to sharing info and helping answer question for new people so they can learn what we have learned only faster and easier than having to make your own mistakes.
 
Ah okay thanks! I won't be taking this risk most likely be chase I don't want both dogs to have to be seperated the rest of their lives. Unfortunately, it's not looking like a Doberman will work out because of this. Thanks for all of your help and directions on everything though!
 
@Dobs4ever will a reputable show breeder even sell another male puppy to someone who already owns a male? I've heard they won't but perhaps I'm wrong? Esp. one where they plan on keeping the male intact and breeding?
 
Have you ever seen a dog sent through meat grinder??? It can mean huge medical bills and/or death. They can loose a leg due to the fight and numerous cuts, torn skin, gaping wounds. It is not something to play with. He does not have to be in tact for agility. Conformation is the only activity he has to be in tact for or the Breed Survey (ZTP). I would never leave them unattended together. It only takes once.


I do not think he has same sex aggression, what he had is a trauma when he was attacked so he now does not trust other males. If it was true same sex aggression then he would not tolerate your pit either. That is why it is same sex aggression - and it applies to ALL same sex.


Hmm that makes sense. Here I thought he was confused about the sex of our pit :)
 
@Gretchen_Red
I don't plan on breeding him. I haven't heard back from any breeders I have contacted but I have told them about my male and such, so we shall see what they come back with, I guess. I would assume not now that I have read more about it and such.
 
@Dobs4ever will a reputable show breeder even sell another male puppy to someone who already owns a male? I've heard they won't but perhaps I'm wrong? Esp. one where they plan on keeping the male intact and breeding?
I know several reputable breeders who will not sell females to homes with other females and males to homes that already have males intact or not. I know of some that will make an exception only for experienced Doberman homes that have proven themselves to be able to handle the situation if it arises
 
I'm sure you'll be getting more insight from some of the people who do have the same sex dogs so you can see both sides of it.
 
I have two neutered males. I have two intact females. I have never had an issue with SSA in any of my dogs. Although having two dogs of the same sex in the house peacefully can be done, I would not recommend it to someone who is inexperienced.

My females are intact because they are shown in conformation. My male Does obedience. If you are truly interested in showing in conformation you should not be worried about the sex of your puppy. You should be worried about quality. The breeder is going to give you a show quality puppy. Puppies are graded up to 8-10 weeks and even nicely bred litters aren't chalked full of show quality puppies. The breeder will assign you with a show quality puppy. There might not be any show quality males in a litter you are waiting on. Sex preference tends to be last on their list, but they do take it into consideration. In the Doberman you should also be worried about health and tempearment. You will be hard pressed to find a conformation show quality dog for what you are looking to pay. If you are really interested in doing dog sports with a Doberman, I suggest you keeping an open mind as to the sex of your first puppy due to the reasons stated above. If it were me starting out again, I would go with a pet quality puppy I could train and grow with as a learning experience. Rally and Obedience are fun to show in. You don't have to have an intact dog for those sports so if you were to get a female there would be no worry about a heat cycle. Just my $0.02 :)
 

Back
Top