That Security Instinct

Sophie patrols the perimeter and Dixie is the muscle. As Dixie has gotten older I have realized that she is more, and more dominant and Sophie follows her lead. Sophie is much more apt to bark and sleeps at the head of the bed with us, but Dixie almost never barks unless it is someone or something worth barking at and sleeps at the foot facing the door. The one that would do the damage would be Dixie for sure. Like your Daisy, Gel, when we had stairs up to our porch, that is where Dixie would position herself and stand guard.
 
Sophie patrols the perimeter and Dixie is the muscle. As Dixie has gotten older I have realized that she is more, and more dominant and Sophie follows her lead. Sophie is much more apt to bark and sleeps at the head of the bed with us, but Dixie almost never barks unless it is someone or something worth barking at and sleeps at the foot facing the door. The one that would do the damage would be Dixie for sure. Like your Daisy, Gel, when we had stairs up to our porch, that is where Dixie would position herself and stand guard.
Yep.Rocky is a barker,he barks at everything.We just tell him to stop and redirect him.
If Daisy barks,I'm inclined to go see why.She doesn't bark just to bark,there is always a reason.

We have yet to see how or what Rocky would do in the event of a real threat or intruder.There's no question what Daisy would do..."It's Hammer Time";)
 
So far we have yet to face a real threat, but both girls are very protective of the car, house, and property. If we allow you in the yard or they are on a leash everything is good. But until you are invited in, to Dixie, all bets are off. She is very inquisitive, never afraid around new objects or noises, and all around very steady. Sophie on the other hand has become more nervous and unsure as she gets older. (This is the reason we are returning to advance training classes, I am hoping this will help her be more sure of herself.)
 
Now this would be an interesting test for Daisy.
She tends to high tail it when some things like the garage door opens or my air compressor kicks on.Same with say a rake leaning against an object falls over.
She has not shown fear of any man though,a bit of caution watching their distance maybe but never a retreat.
Exercises like that you show must bolster their confidence.

I once(through dumb luck) tested her with the gate.
It was Sumer time,I pulled into the driveway which she usually hears but this day she was out back at the time I got home.The A/C was running which drowned out the sound of my truck.
I came to the side gate and could see her through the gaps in the boards,she could see a figure through the same gaps.The wind was coming past her to me so she could not smell me either.
She stopped in her tracks and fired off with a 5 bark burst a growl then took a couple if steps forward.
I pulled the cord releasing the latch of the gate.
Another burst of bark and another few steps forward.
She remained cautious but never once backed up,only came forward.
I put my hand through the gate and she lit up again and a few step forward.
At that point I entered the gate.
I could see her ears fold back,her lip curl like a submissive wolf does to the Alpha and she practically folded herself into a C shape to show me her little nub wagging a mile per second.Then she ran to me excited.

Dobs4ever and other experts/experienced handlers overall what's your view here?
Was she too forward?
Not enough?
On her over reactions to objects like mentioned what exercises can we do to tone down her "flight" reaction?
 
Regardless of the breed (doberman) there are dogs that will and dogs that won't. It is why breeders need to pay attention to temperament when breeding. Testing is the best way to learn about the real temperament. I would rate Helio low on the protection side til he showed me what his idea of protection was. He is the most confident dog I have ever seen without any of the craziness and aggressive behavior. You bring the fight and he does not hesitate. He will take it to the end as that is his goal - I can't tell you how many times he has got the whip away from Waine and then spins to get him and finish the fight.

Gel there is no way anyone could judge correctly over a form. You have to see the dog and watch the reactions - every little nuance plays a part. The "tone down her flight reaction" , however, gives an indication - a dog is fight or flight - Lots of dogs can bark and posture - they do it to try to make themselves appear larger in hope the threat will leave but it does not come from a place of confidence and in the end if confronted they are the ones to leave. Not saying at all that this is Daisy just saying it is typical of dogs who want to appear brave until they are not. A confident fearless dog does not bristle or posture. I would rather see a dog who goes straight to the fence - saying I am here and I am ready to defend not leave room for a quick retreat.

I hope that makes sense.
 
Regardless of the breed (doberman) there are dogs that will and dogs that won't. It is why breeders need to pay attention to temperament when breeding. Testing is the best way to learn about the real temperament. I would rate Helio low on the protection side til he showed me what his idea of protection was. He is the most confident dog I have ever seen without any of the craziness and aggressive behavior. You bring the fight and he does not hesitate. He will take it to the end as that is his goal - I can't tell you how many times he has got the whip away from Waine and then spins to get him and finish the fight.

Gel there is no way anyone could judge correctly over a form. You have to see the dog and watch the reactions - every little nuance plays a part. The "tone down her flight reaction" , however, gives an indication - a dog is fight or flight - Lots of dogs can bark and posture - they do it to try to make themselves appear larger in hope the threat will leave but it does not come from a place of confidence and in the end if confronted they are the ones to leave. Not saying at all that this is Daisy just saying it is typical of dogs who want to appear brave until they are not. A confident fearless dog does not bristle or posture. I would rather see a dog who goes straight to the fence - saying I am here and I am ready to defend not leave room for a quick retreat.

I hope that makes sense.
Thank you,that absolutely makes sense.
She was young when that happened,maybe not quite 2 years?
Your last statement comforts me a little.
Upon seeing the gas meter guy at the same gate that's exactly what she did.Straight to it :guns:.
Confidence that has come with maturity?
Like I said,that "flight" is only about things she perceives may fall or land on her.
About the only living creature she kept distance from was Aprils horse...at first.Then she decided to get a real close look and smell.We had to get her out if there a couple of times.She was fascinated by this creature she had never before encountered.
 
a dog is fight or flight - Lots of dogs can bark and posture - they do it to try to make themselves appear larger in hope the threat will leave but it does not come from a place of confidence and in the end if confronted they are the ones to leave.
This is Lord Mars to a capital T... Although ive never (and never will) test the theory to conclusion.. But he certainly does his best to keep strangers away from him.. And of course he does this by acting as billy bad ass as he can and i admit it is a very scary scene.. Actually now that i think about it he did once attempt to bite a kid (a rather large kid) who was just petting him.. I had Mars on a leash and pinch so when he lunged at the boy i was able to react quick enough to prevent some serious damage.. That was the last time Mars was ever allowed around people outside of his pack..
 
I had Daisy at a shop with me once while I worked.It was her and I in a 30,000 square foot building,empty except for two boat trailers.The company was moving so everything was gone except those trailers,the mold I was working bs the spray booth.
I was told before hand by the GM we would be alone.
We had a blast playing ball I that empty building.
There was a company next door going 24 hour shifts,trucks in and out all day.
So,when we heard a truck outside I thought nothing if it.
Once the door about 60-70 feet away from where Daisy was laying opened and a man came through it(the GM) she went into hyper drive at him.She looked like one of "those" Dobermans you see in Hollywood films.
He made it exactly 3 steps into the building,saw and heard the red headed terror teeth ablaze coming at him at Warp 10:eek:
He backed right out that door,shutting it as she slid into it.
I have zero doubt she would have knocked him down and molested him.
It's quite a site to see a 6'4 rather large guy of Mexican descent turn white as a ghost.
 
Like I said,that "flight" is only about things she perceives may fall or land on her.

I have heard that there are really on a couple of "real" fears - fear of falling being one - This brings us back to BALANCE - a dog that shows hesitation in the above situation IMHO is SMART and has a good survival instinct. It is not wise to just rush into everything as some things can kill you. The key is after a small hesitation does the dog move forward to investigate. The dog that can't move forward after investigating is weaker in nerve.

I have often used this example of what I call "good judgement" - German Shepherd and Doberman - both well trained
You start heeling with the German Shepherd and come to a cliff - the GSD will heel right off the cliff - (good foot soldier)

The Doberman stops and says WAIT are you nuts - we can't go off that cliff it is dangerous- They are a thinking breed and all about survival. It is why some do not do well at Schutzhund - the trainers try to train them like a GSD and their approach to any situation is far different than a GSD.
 
I find this thread interesting, especially as Richter just took (and passed) his WAE in June at the age of 23 months. To be honest, I wasn't sure what he would do. He is a very laid back dog. He is extremely well socialized. Every person he meets is his new best friend. I have worked very hard to ensure that he has been exposed to all kinds of people and situations. I intend to someday do therapy work with him when he's a little more grown-up. We had not done any preparation for the WAE as I believe it should test a dog's natural temperament and instincts.

Given his age, especially, I didn't know what to expect out of him. I was fairly confident that he would react well to all of the "startle" exercises and the footing, as we train in agility. I also knew we'd have no trouble with a neutral or friendly stranger. I was correct on all of that. The big question in my mind is what would happen when presented with a "threat."

Richter surprised me quite a bit. Given that he has never had such an experience, and no preparation work, and his young age, his reaction was to move in front of me to the end of the leash. He didn't become highly aggressive, but he definitely showed that the instinct is there, and the evaluator saw enough for him to receive a passing score and his WAC. The instinct is definitely there.
 
Richter surprised me quite a bit. Given that he has never had such an experience, and no preparation work, and his young age, his reaction was to move in front of me to the end of the leash. He didn't become highly aggressive, but he definitely showed that the instinct is there, and the evaluator saw enough for him to receive a passing score and his WAC. The instinct is definitely there.
This is an excellent scenario! Many of us just don't know what's going to happen until they're actually presented with a case where the instinct needs to kick in.
 
Nexus barks at the drop of a hat. and doesnt ever want to stop once she starts, most of the time she is very alert to everything, and the slightest sound or movement makes her go nuts, and she is hard to quiet down too .. Bella wont bark unless she perceives a direct threat, someone passing a window, or if she sees an animal of some sort, be it dog, cat, squirrel or otherwise. She is the one to stand alert and cautious if anyone approaches me though, were Nexus is the more friendly to humans. Neither of them like other dogs, Bella seems to feel the need to protect Nexus, or at times, me, and Nexus just plain doesnt care for them, she will avoid them and back away unless they persist then she gets nasty.
I am pretty sure that if anyone tried to hurt me, Bella would take charge, she would defend me, but Nexus I really dont know, she is hard to predict.
 
My boy Zeus is all play when we are inside unless he hears a car or someone outside than its instant guard dog mode. His ears perk up, his tail stills and his fur stands on end.
He will be mostly silent until someone nocks on the door.
Then the growling starts. His lips peel back to reveal his teeth, and sometimes he even drools a little...
Then the door opens.. He Barks.
And it aunt Cat.... he jumps through the doorway, circling her feet tail wagging.
Once he takes a good look around the yard for any danger all signs of aggression are gone and its play time again..
But when he is outside everything is different.
 
When we are outside together Zeus is always on guard dog mode, especially If my 2yr old daughter is outside. He will find a spot near where she is pplaying often at her feet and just watch everything in our neighborhood. If a car drives by his ears will perk up or someone will walk by he will immediately jump to his feet go to the closest edge of the property near the walker and give a loud swift bark to inform them that this is their property and his girls and he will defend them.

One night I had let him outside to do his buisness. It was dark and we only have one lamp by our front door. I was inside when I heard the barking. And I just brushed it off as Zeus barking at as a car driving by or something. That is until I heard the growling.

I ran to the door to see zeus guarding the front door from a large white pit who was running down my drive way. I grabbed zeus and pulled him inside. He was covered in blood.
He had bitten his tounge and there was blood on his paws.

I later learned the pit was a neighbors "yard dog" that they had "borrowed" from a friend and was very aggressive. They had it chained in their yard to discourage anyone from coming near their house.
The dog had broken the chain and wanted to pick a fight with the only dog around.

This dog also had a reputation of killing smaller dogs

(I had left my gate open as I was expecting company and zeus never left the property)
 
We've only had one dog I know for sure would have absolutely protected me/us. Our GSD/Dal Tia always made me feel very safe. I had control over her behavior but there is no doubt in my mind she would have gone to bat for me if she needed to. There were two times I used that to my advantage.

Once in college a friend was over late and her ex was stalking her (there was a restraining order. In retrospect I have no idea why we didn't call the police) and found her car across the street from my house. He decided to try to let himself into my house. I grabbed Tia's collar cause she was on high alert and barking and I infomed him that if he took one more step I would let her go. She was snarling and pulling and that was all it took to convince him to leave. I am absolutely positive that if I had let her go he would have been in the ER at the very least.

I *think* Panzer would take a stand should it be completely necessary, but I wouldn't count on him to do so. He was my reliable alarm in his younger days when he could hear better.

I believe Maggie would come to my 6 year old's rescue in a heartbeat. Not sure what a 20# Boston Terrier could do, but I believe she would try. :-)

Luther...I have no idea. We've only had him about 12 weeks now. He will bark once or twice at someone if he's outside and they are messing around our fence...and he walks toward the fence confidently so he may be prepared to engage if necessary. I have never seen him do anything other than happily greet a person or dog when he can see them. I'm not sure what he would do should a real threat arise...and I hope I never have to find out. :-)
 
Aggression towards another dog or animal is not the same protective drives to protect humans. That is absolutely no indication of what a dog will do if confronted by a man. Please do not mistake one for the other. They are not related.
Absolutely agree.
 
Most dogs will show confidence when they are behind there fence yard, in there house and a stranger comes to the door or in there car. But for the most part they will not engage if put into a threatened or stressful condition. That is why most all dogs trained in IPO or PP are trained as puppies to build there confidence and learn to deal with stress. There are a select few that have natural confidence. This is something sport dog people are usually looking for when they are purchasing a puppy. Drive is the other thing that is important. So confidence has to be built as the dog grows. Using fences, blinds and tables all can help build there confidence. Most dogs will not protect without some sort of confidence training be done. But for the most part there look and bark is enough to scare off most.
 

Back
Top