• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Raised Bowls - Your Thoughts

Caloni

Active Member
1. Are raised food bowls important?
2. Do they really help to prevent bloat?
3. Are there any studies to back this up?

While I do not instigate play with the pup after he eats he is CRAZY after meal time. I was told not to walk him or exercise him, but even in an X-Pen or crate he tosses around expelling energy then crashes for a nap. Should I be worried?
 
Sounds like a normal pup! :) You could try giving him more exercise before eating to help tire him before he eats. Maybe a controlled modest walk after eating will help regulate his activity level too.

We use bowls to slow any gulping eaters...like our Duke. That's been shown to be a factor in all studies I know of. Foods high in carbs can also play a factor because the carbs can quickly ferment in the stomach and increase the gas and pressure of the bloat.

The latest and biggest study involving bloat and raised dishes (among other things) showed the following-

“Cumulative incidence of GDV during the study was 6% for large breed and giant breed dogs. Factors significantly associated with an increased risk of GDV were increasing age, having a first-degree relative with a history of GDV, having a faster speed of eating, and having a raised feeding bowl. Approximately 20 and 52% of cases of GDV among the large breed and giant breed dogs, respectively, were attributed to having a raised feed bowl.” (J Am Vet Med Assoc 2000;217:1492–1499)

(GDV is bloat.) It is one study, albeit a current large one from a reputable source. Normal walking or mild exercise has never concerned us after they eat. We just don't go straight into lots of running play right after eating.

If he ever has any abdominal surgery, you can see about having them do gastropexy at the same time. It's just a little suture of the stomach to the abdominal wall which prevents it from twisting which makes the torsion bloat.
 
Did I read that right that increased risk of GDV was from raised food bowls? So are they saying NOT to use them?
 
Yep! A 50+% increase with raised bowls. It's a large study out of Purdue Univ.
 
Did I read that right that increased risk of GDV was from raised food bowls? So are they saying NOT to use them?
There have been other studies that show just the opposite, too. From other threads we've had on here it seems that it varies by dog. Some dogs inhale more air if the bowls are on the floor, some if the bowls are raised. You have to pay attention to your dog and see what works best for them. As far as exercise, the general idea is no exercise for at least an hour on either side of feeding. To do this we put them in their crates for an hour or so of down time after eating.
 
We use raised bowls for Godric and have no problems.... our last large breed dog would lay down to eat.. so I think it just varies on the dog..
 
There have been other studies that show just the opposite, too.

True and as stated this is the largest, latest and definitely beyond reputable study thus far in addition to being the only one to show this. I don't easily dismiss a large Purdue study recognized by the AVMA even if I'd like to see more current studies showing the same. That being said, we do feed Duke from a raised bowl as he had bad neck issues an it seems to help him. I wouldn't hesitate to use raised bowls for other issues like that.

Also haven't seen recommendations or studies for no exercise before eating. Common sense not to have them run wild and immediately eat but I wouldn't hesitate to do a good walk before feeding them. It's a combination of factors like everything else. 3 meals a day is way better than one meal a day. Eating slowly better than gulping. Less fermentable food better than not, etc. Genetic predisposition is unfortunately unavoidable unless a breeder tells you others in the line have had bloat.

I can't see caging for 3 hours daily (presuming people go with feeding the slightly less risky 3 times a day) because they've eaten their regular meals. That's the equivalent of caging your dog for >136 8-hr work days every year if you never cage them for anything else! That's a LOT of cage time...
 
Well, i guess there's no real said standard. He doesn't gulp his food either way, but the older dog also because of neck and back issues needs a raised bowl and they eat next to each other. So I will probably stick with a slightly raised bowl for now. Thank you all for the help and it has been interesting to see there are so many studies out there.
 
I have to use a raised bowl with Archer. He is a monster at over 30" tall and has to spread his front legs far apart to try to get down to a bowl at floor level. He is not a food gulper (quite the opposite), so I am not at all worried about bloat. Also, the bowl is not a high rise. I have one that's just high enough that he doesn't have to do the splits to eat. We abide by the no exercise 1hr before and 1 hr after rule. I usually take then on a leash walk about 1.5 hours after eating as Archer has chronic gastroparesis and the walk helps his gut motility. That's a different story, however ;)

If you do go with the bowl elevation, I suggest watching your dog as he eats to make sure he's eating safely. I monitor both of mine as they eat just in case.
 
The studies are pretty inconclusive. I think there's at least some genetic component to bloat. I used to use raised bowls (Simon needed one because of the Wobblers and his age), I don't use them now. I think your best bet is to just know the signs really well and know whether there's a strong history of bloat in your dog's pedigree.
 

Back
Top