Dobs4ever
Hot Topics Subscriber
San Diego Ordinance To Stop Pet Stores From The Sale of Puppies
From: Dr. Kay A. Henderson <[email protected]>
Date: Sunday, July 7, 2013 9:27 PM
To: [email protected],
[email protected], [email protected],
[email protected], [email protected], [email protected],
[email protected], [email protected], [email protected],
[email protected]
Subject: Please Do Not Support the
Propose Ban on Pet Sales From Pet Stores in the Current Form
Size: 8 MB
Attachments: Copy of California 990's (1).xlsx (23.8 KB) 2008-800191770 Animal Rescurers Without Borders.pdf (1126.9
KB) 2011 Laboradors and Friends Dog Rescue Group-2.pdf (672.1
KB) 810646390 Laborador Rescuers-1.pdf (1111.7 KB) 2012-951661688 San Diego Humane Society-2.pdf (2141.1
KB) 2011-237228287-Helen Woodward Animal Center-1.pdf (1937.3
KB) 2009 San Diego Animal Advocates-1.pdf (697.5 KB) 2011 Friends of Humane Societh de Tijuana.pdf (455.1
KB)
Dear
Mayor Filner & San Diego City Council Members,
The proposed ban on
pet sales from pet stores may be well-intentioned, but it violates the federal
laws on restraint of trade. It creates a monopoly for shelters and rescues
which are big business in San Diego and the business is selling pets. Make no
mistake, most shelters and rescue groups do noble and laudatory work, but not
all do. In the same way that San Diegans do not want to see pets imported to
San Diego from unscrupulous breeders, we also don't want unscrupulous rescue
groups bringing in strays from out of the area and foreign countries.
Shelters and Rescue groups adopt or sell puppies. We can get an idea of
the enormity of the Private Shelters from the 2011 990 forms. San Diego Humane
Society brought in Helen Woodward brought in almost $18 million, Helen Woodward
brought in over $6.5 million, Escondido Humane brought in over $3 million and
Rancho Coastal brought in over $1.5 million. San Diego Humane and Helen
Woodward generated $403,000 and $534,000 respectively from pet adoptions (sales)
and these non-profits pay salaries of $965,000 and $490,000. The President/CEO
of Helen Woodward earns over $265,000 and two other Vice Presidents earn more
than the Mayor of San Diego. At San Diego Humane Society there are 7 people who
have salaries higher than the San Diego Mayor. These non-profit shelters are
indeed very big business. Much bigger business that the store that sells
purebred puppies.
Rescue groups sell pets, like the shelters, and are not
regulated in any way, while Pet Stores and local breeders are regulated.
Polanco-Lockyear- Farr is excellent cutting edge legislation that regulates
California pet stores. Polanco-Lockyear Pet Breeder Warranty Act is the puppy
lemon law that regulates all breeders, large and small in CA. These laws govern
the sale of dogs and cats in the state of California. The Lockyear-Polanco-Farr
Pet Protection Act creates rules for the sale of dogs and cats by pet dealers,
defined as persons engaged in selling dogs or cats at retail who are not
breeders. The Polanco-Lockyear Pet Breeder Warranty Act applies to dog breeders
that have sold or given away puppies from three or more litters in the past 12
months. The acts contain similar basic content regarding pet purchases. The
California pet lemon laws provide recourse for buyers if their pets become ill
within 15 days of sale from a condition that existed at the time of sale and if
their pets, within one year of sale, develop a congenital or hereditary disease
that will affect their health or likely require hospitalization or surgery.
A Veterinarian must provide a written statement confirming any of these
conditions. The buyer has three options if their dog becomes ill within the
limits of the acts: Return the dog for a refund of the purchase price, plus
reimbursement for veterinary fees up to the purchase price; exchange the dog for
another of similar value and receive reimbursement for veterinary fees up to the
purchase price; or keep the dog and receive reimbursement for veterinary fees up
to 150 percent of the purchase price. There is no lemon law for pets adopted
from a Rescue Group or Shelter although both of these groups deal in the sale of
pets. These Groups are entirely unregulated. The only requirement for an
individual wanting to become a Rescue Group is to fill out IRS paperwork. An
unscrupulous individual can become a Rescue Group, traffic in pets from Mexico
and other countries obtained for free or low cost and be unregulated in CA. The
proposed ban on pet sells would give this type of individual carte blanche to
sell/adopt pets without having to make any guarantees to the adopter/buyer.
There have been documented incidences where Rescue Groups sold diseased
puppies.
To give an idea of the financial impact of these rescue groups,
I offer three examples. In 2011 Labrador Rescuers brought in over $157,000 in
application fees, training fees, and adoption fees. A second rescue group,
Labradors and Friends Dog Rescue Group of San Diego adopt purebred puppies for
$400, part-labs for $300, show income in excess of $175,000 but don't list any
separate income from adoptions.
The FOCAS (Friends of County Animals Shelters)
website states that there are "approximately 160 animal rescue groups in San
Diego County". A pet peeve of the Members of Del Sur Kennel Club of San Diego
is that many of the rescue Groups and Shelters import dogs from Mexico, China,
Columbia, and yes, Helen Woodward Center adopted out Romanian dogs in two
different years. (10News - Orphaned Puppies From Romania Up For Adoption - 10News.com - News)( Puppies get passport to U.S. | The San Diego Union-Tribune ) San Diego shelters accept hundreds of dogs from out-of-state, all
unregulated and without protections for consumers. The arguments that we make
against pet store pets purchased from the worst commercial breeders are that the
pets have not received prenatal care, they may have inferior genetics, they have
not had proper socialization, and they have not had proper veterinary care. The
very same arguments can be made against the shelter dogs and cats, particularly
the ones that come from Mexico and other countries were dog to dog rabies
transmission is prevalent.
A third rescue example is Animal Rescuers
Without Borders. This San Diego Rescue Group actively participates in the much
touted Petco Adoption Events. Currently they have 33 dogs for adoption at the
next Petco event. The A.R.W.O.B. group is based in San Diego, CA and operates
primarily in Mexico but also in Southern California. Oddly, their last taxes
were filed in 2008 and they did not list any income from sale/adoption of pets
although they have adopted/sold pets regularly throughout the years. Some of
their animals come out of the Tijuana pound. If these dogs do not work out in
their new homes, they will most likely end up as a tax burden in the County
Shelter as importers of Rescue animals are not obligated to take them back. The
Border Patrol estimates that 10,000 puppies per year enter San Diego and they do
nothing to screen the dogs. The Border Patrol says that the Center for Disease
Control is responsible for checking immunization records. CDC is not present at
the San Diego border.
Rather than enacting this ordinance and taking away the
livelihood of those working at a regulated business selling a regulated
commodity, this ordinance could easily be amended to require that all animals
sold in San Diego Pet Stores be purchased from sources with no direct (animal
care) violations. USDA violations and inspection records are a matter of public
record. This would make certain that pets were not purchased from bad
commercial breeders. A second needed amendment would be that shelters and
rescue groups operating in San Diego be required to meet the regulations of
Polanco-Lockyear-Farr. A third needed amendment would be to discourage the
importation of strays from foreign countries by requiring that these animals be
vaccinated for rabies and quarantined before bringing them in to San Diego for
sale or adoption. This is particularly important because California is free of
dog to dog rabies, but Mexico and much of Asia and the mid-East are not. (Dog imports raise fears of a resurgence of disease - USATODAY.com
Please
do not pass this ordinance in it's current form. We urge you to amend it so
that it protects all animals sold or adopted in San
Diego.
Sincerely,
Kay A Henderson, PhD
Legislative Liaison
Del
Sur Kennel Club of San Diego
327 Galloway Valley Road
Alpine, CA
91901-2826
Open Attachment Copy of
California 990's (1).xlsx Open Attachment 2008-800191770
Animal Rescurers Without Borders.pdf Open Attachment 2011
Laboradors and Friends Dog Rescue Group-2.pdf Open Attachment 810646390
Laborador Rescuers-1.pdf Open Attachment 2012-951661688
San Diego Humane Society-2.pdf Open Attachment 2011-237228287-Helen
Woodward Animal Center-1.pdf Open Attachment 2009 San Diego
Animal Advocates-1.pdf Open Attachment 2011 Friends
of Humane Societh de Tijuana.pdf
From: Dr. Kay A. Henderson <[email protected]>
Date: Sunday, July 7, 2013 9:27 PM
To: [email protected],
[email protected], [email protected],
[email protected], [email protected], [email protected],
[email protected], [email protected], [email protected],
[email protected]
Subject: Please Do Not Support the
Propose Ban on Pet Sales From Pet Stores in the Current Form
Size: 8 MB
Attachments: Copy of California 990's (1).xlsx (23.8 KB) 2008-800191770 Animal Rescurers Without Borders.pdf (1126.9
KB) 2011 Laboradors and Friends Dog Rescue Group-2.pdf (672.1
KB) 810646390 Laborador Rescuers-1.pdf (1111.7 KB) 2012-951661688 San Diego Humane Society-2.pdf (2141.1
KB) 2011-237228287-Helen Woodward Animal Center-1.pdf (1937.3
KB) 2009 San Diego Animal Advocates-1.pdf (697.5 KB) 2011 Friends of Humane Societh de Tijuana.pdf (455.1
KB)
Dear
Mayor Filner & San Diego City Council Members,
The proposed ban on
pet sales from pet stores may be well-intentioned, but it violates the federal
laws on restraint of trade. It creates a monopoly for shelters and rescues
which are big business in San Diego and the business is selling pets. Make no
mistake, most shelters and rescue groups do noble and laudatory work, but not
all do. In the same way that San Diegans do not want to see pets imported to
San Diego from unscrupulous breeders, we also don't want unscrupulous rescue
groups bringing in strays from out of the area and foreign countries.
Shelters and Rescue groups adopt or sell puppies. We can get an idea of
the enormity of the Private Shelters from the 2011 990 forms. San Diego Humane
Society brought in Helen Woodward brought in almost $18 million, Helen Woodward
brought in over $6.5 million, Escondido Humane brought in over $3 million and
Rancho Coastal brought in over $1.5 million. San Diego Humane and Helen
Woodward generated $403,000 and $534,000 respectively from pet adoptions (sales)
and these non-profits pay salaries of $965,000 and $490,000. The President/CEO
of Helen Woodward earns over $265,000 and two other Vice Presidents earn more
than the Mayor of San Diego. At San Diego Humane Society there are 7 people who
have salaries higher than the San Diego Mayor. These non-profit shelters are
indeed very big business. Much bigger business that the store that sells
purebred puppies.
Rescue groups sell pets, like the shelters, and are not
regulated in any way, while Pet Stores and local breeders are regulated.
Polanco-Lockyear- Farr is excellent cutting edge legislation that regulates
California pet stores. Polanco-Lockyear Pet Breeder Warranty Act is the puppy
lemon law that regulates all breeders, large and small in CA. These laws govern
the sale of dogs and cats in the state of California. The Lockyear-Polanco-Farr
Pet Protection Act creates rules for the sale of dogs and cats by pet dealers,
defined as persons engaged in selling dogs or cats at retail who are not
breeders. The Polanco-Lockyear Pet Breeder Warranty Act applies to dog breeders
that have sold or given away puppies from three or more litters in the past 12
months. The acts contain similar basic content regarding pet purchases. The
California pet lemon laws provide recourse for buyers if their pets become ill
within 15 days of sale from a condition that existed at the time of sale and if
their pets, within one year of sale, develop a congenital or hereditary disease
that will affect their health or likely require hospitalization or surgery.
A Veterinarian must provide a written statement confirming any of these
conditions. The buyer has three options if their dog becomes ill within the
limits of the acts: Return the dog for a refund of the purchase price, plus
reimbursement for veterinary fees up to the purchase price; exchange the dog for
another of similar value and receive reimbursement for veterinary fees up to the
purchase price; or keep the dog and receive reimbursement for veterinary fees up
to 150 percent of the purchase price. There is no lemon law for pets adopted
from a Rescue Group or Shelter although both of these groups deal in the sale of
pets. These Groups are entirely unregulated. The only requirement for an
individual wanting to become a Rescue Group is to fill out IRS paperwork. An
unscrupulous individual can become a Rescue Group, traffic in pets from Mexico
and other countries obtained for free or low cost and be unregulated in CA. The
proposed ban on pet sells would give this type of individual carte blanche to
sell/adopt pets without having to make any guarantees to the adopter/buyer.
There have been documented incidences where Rescue Groups sold diseased
puppies.
To give an idea of the financial impact of these rescue groups,
I offer three examples. In 2011 Labrador Rescuers brought in over $157,000 in
application fees, training fees, and adoption fees. A second rescue group,
Labradors and Friends Dog Rescue Group of San Diego adopt purebred puppies for
$400, part-labs for $300, show income in excess of $175,000 but don't list any
separate income from adoptions.
The FOCAS (Friends of County Animals Shelters)
website states that there are "approximately 160 animal rescue groups in San
Diego County". A pet peeve of the Members of Del Sur Kennel Club of San Diego
is that many of the rescue Groups and Shelters import dogs from Mexico, China,
Columbia, and yes, Helen Woodward Center adopted out Romanian dogs in two
different years. (10News - Orphaned Puppies From Romania Up For Adoption - 10News.com - News)( Puppies get passport to U.S. | The San Diego Union-Tribune ) San Diego shelters accept hundreds of dogs from out-of-state, all
unregulated and without protections for consumers. The arguments that we make
against pet store pets purchased from the worst commercial breeders are that the
pets have not received prenatal care, they may have inferior genetics, they have
not had proper socialization, and they have not had proper veterinary care. The
very same arguments can be made against the shelter dogs and cats, particularly
the ones that come from Mexico and other countries were dog to dog rabies
transmission is prevalent.
A third rescue example is Animal Rescuers
Without Borders. This San Diego Rescue Group actively participates in the much
touted Petco Adoption Events. Currently they have 33 dogs for adoption at the
next Petco event. The A.R.W.O.B. group is based in San Diego, CA and operates
primarily in Mexico but also in Southern California. Oddly, their last taxes
were filed in 2008 and they did not list any income from sale/adoption of pets
although they have adopted/sold pets regularly throughout the years. Some of
their animals come out of the Tijuana pound. If these dogs do not work out in
their new homes, they will most likely end up as a tax burden in the County
Shelter as importers of Rescue animals are not obligated to take them back. The
Border Patrol estimates that 10,000 puppies per year enter San Diego and they do
nothing to screen the dogs. The Border Patrol says that the Center for Disease
Control is responsible for checking immunization records. CDC is not present at
the San Diego border.
Rather than enacting this ordinance and taking away the
livelihood of those working at a regulated business selling a regulated
commodity, this ordinance could easily be amended to require that all animals
sold in San Diego Pet Stores be purchased from sources with no direct (animal
care) violations. USDA violations and inspection records are a matter of public
record. This would make certain that pets were not purchased from bad
commercial breeders. A second needed amendment would be that shelters and
rescue groups operating in San Diego be required to meet the regulations of
Polanco-Lockyear-Farr. A third needed amendment would be to discourage the
importation of strays from foreign countries by requiring that these animals be
vaccinated for rabies and quarantined before bringing them in to San Diego for
sale or adoption. This is particularly important because California is free of
dog to dog rabies, but Mexico and much of Asia and the mid-East are not. (Dog imports raise fears of a resurgence of disease - USATODAY.com
Please
do not pass this ordinance in it's current form. We urge you to amend it so
that it protects all animals sold or adopted in San
Diego.
Sincerely,
Kay A Henderson, PhD
Legislative Liaison
Del
Sur Kennel Club of San Diego
327 Galloway Valley Road
Alpine, CA
91901-2826
Open Attachment Copy of
California 990's (1).xlsx Open Attachment 2008-800191770
Animal Rescurers Without Borders.pdf Open Attachment 2011
Laboradors and Friends Dog Rescue Group-2.pdf Open Attachment 810646390
Laborador Rescuers-1.pdf Open Attachment 2012-951661688
San Diego Humane Society-2.pdf Open Attachment 2011-237228287-Helen
Woodward Animal Center-1.pdf Open Attachment 2009 San Diego
Animal Advocates-1.pdf Open Attachment 2011 Friends
of Humane Societh de Tijuana.pdf
