• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Keeping the proper weight on your puppy or dog

Katja
I would also like to point out that they in Europe are discussing the trend towards the very heavy Dobies we see in Eastern Europe and Russia. That is not what the Dobie is supposed to look like and we need to be careful they don't end up becoming to heavy but stay elegant and athletic like it was intended.

clearly you prefer the finer boned, finer structured, slender dogs who are lithe and gazelle like, and who also interestingly example the exact Phenotype that is simply NOT BEING bred for in Europe anymore by any breeders who are considered TOP breeders in that world, and who are demonstrating the Judges view of what TOP "Phenotype" is by winning everywhere in the the show circuit...
your dobies are finer boned and because of this difference of their bone structure they are lighter than say Ozzy who is also from your same branch of lineage of Dobermans from Europe, but he has the same bone structure of Baba and Lilly and Buddy....
which of these puppies has a 'big belly' as you say? and what has a belly got to do with 'fat'...
"fat" as is defined by the dictionary: is adipose tissue deposited on the muscle or in the muscle tissue...

Dogs have intra muscular fat and human beings have subquetaneous fat...
older mature obese dogs can also build up some sub Q fat,
but puppies? fat? they have not been alive long enough to develop fat on their torso.. so a belly that is distended and bloated? Is that a fat puppy?
Because a fat and bloated belly is indicative of a serious case of worms and malnutrition not a chubby puppy...
fat above the tail, on the shoulders, masking the rib cage or distending the width of the dog and you cannot FEEL the ribs is the definition of 'fat' dog....
so I am curious how you go about determining which puppies in here are fat and which ones are 'lean, trim and HEALTHY".... so are you healthier than me because you are thin? so you mean to suggest that because I am overweight or anyone else in here who is overweight is UNHEALTHY and in dire health risk?
or are you simply mouthing and parroting 'archaic' views/myths about health and wellness based on your myopic view of what that is?
or were you referring to the Phenotype of these puppies as being 'too much' or 'too heavy' or "too fat"?
but typically I hear these kinds of opinions from those like you who have finer boned dogs and are used to looking at that and are kennel blinded to anything but your 'standard' of dog...

None of the top Euro kennels want that Phenotype of the dogs that are being bred in the USA and in Norway or Sweden or the Netherlands... the top Kennels who win consistently in Europe are the breeders who prefer the Phenotype of Ozzy, Buddy, and Baba... hence we see the puppies coming out looking this way...
interestingly... Judith's Buddy is from the UK and so is Ozzy.... Baba is from Poland and German lineage.....

It's true that I take pleasure in correcting you so often, but the biggest dogs out on the top winning circuit right now are the Italian dogs also with Serbian, Croatian, and Russian dogs.... another interesting fact is:
The top Italian Kennel (Del Diamante Nero aka Massimo Santini, Author of the most comprehensive book on Dobermann's in the 21 century) with the most winning-est Dobermans IN all of Europe, just bred his top winning Italian male to the Kennel out of which My Gemma came from... because they like so many others so prize that Phenotype that you continually say is 'TOO heavy" too something or other...
but their puppies are being sold even before the litters are born... there are waiting lines for these 'too big boned dogs' all day long and these same dogs are winning the IDC, Sch Titles, IPO titles, Korung Titles, AIAD titles and regional country titles day in and day out....

so these puppies in question, are what a Dobermann is SUPPOSED to look like whether you like it and agree with it, or not... we are all entitled to our own opinions, no matter how myopic they may be... they are ours and it is what it is... :martini:
 
Well all i know is dogs are all different , Bella would never ever look like some of the slim dogs i have seen here she just is not built that way, she never ever overeats she never gets scraps or tit bits she is usually walked and run approx five mile a day , i say usually as she has not been getting this with having her puppies but we are on track again, i put her on Obesity food earlier this year 300grms a day weighed it every morning and in two months she had lost 1lb, even the vets laughed , but she is very very fit never pants and feels as solid as a rock so i am hoping she is very healthy , the puppies or pup now is fed four good healthy meals a day he is only 11 weeks tomorrow and growing like a weed ,and already PurlFrog said her vet would put mum and pups on a diet , exact words were
"those are some CHUNKY MONKEY babies and mama! My vet would be all over me with "diet, diet, diet" if I showed up with dogs like that:eekwtf:"
this comment has really got to me :mad:i never tell anyone their dog is too thin , you know if i wanted a dog that looks like a Greyhound i would buy a Greyhound :tap:
 
Sorry, I just have to chime in again. I don't have a lot of time so it may seem choppy or short, I certainly mean no disrespect to anyone, but had to put in my 2 cents.

ok a couple clarifications- first there was no insinuation of anyone being overweight.

second- You CAN overfeed a puppy, just because a puppy thinks he is still hungry doesn't mean that is what is best for them. When feeding a puppy dry food (as I think a lot of us do), they will keep eating until they "Feel full", unfortunately when the food hits the stomach and starts to swell (picture dropping a kibble in water and watch how much it swells), they end up just poopong it out the back door-this equals wasted food, un needed calories deposited as fat, puppies may start eating their poop because it comes out undigested, more poop to clean and it CAN affect their growth rates which will affect Panosteitis. Puppies will reach a certain size based on their genetics, The more protein they get (also correlation between vit D/ phos ratios), the faster they get there, the more chance they have of developing pano. And when I say I am watching out for their hips in the long run ( I am not talking about Pano)- It is a proven fact in veterinary science that puppies that are allowed to gain too much weight too fast are at a greater risk of developing Hip Dysplasia when they are older. The added weight during puppy hood causes unnecessary concussion on the joints during normal activity.

Again, I never meant to insinuate that anyone was overweight, over feeding, or not doing what they think was best for their dog. I know that everyone on this forum LOVES their dog or why would any of us spend our free time talking about them!! LOL

Thats like my Axl. ...he was always starving. But if I tried to feed him more it did end up in the yard.
I tried a couple of times to let him eat what he wanted way back as a little guy and oh my god did we both pay for that..He was so sick once the food started to swell, I imagine, he was standing frozen, then trying to 'bum up' as he must of had the worst stomach ache. To this day Axl still gets 5 cups of kibble but I have to re-hydrate.
Never had to worry about pano here!
 
Katja


clearly you prefer the finer boned, finer structured, slender dogs who are lithe and gazelle like, and who also interestingly example the exact Phenotype that is simply NOT BEING bred for in Europe anymore by any breeders who are considered TOP breeders in that world, and who are demonstrating the Judges view of what TOP "Phenotype" is by winning everywhere in the the show circuit...
your dobies are finer boned and because of this difference of their bone structure they are lighter than say Ozzy who is also from your same branch of lineage of Dobermans from Europe, but he has the same bone structure of Baba and Lilly and Buddy....
which of these puppies has a 'big belly' as you say? and what has a belly got to do with 'fat'...
"fat" as is defined by the dictionary: is adipose tissue deposited on the muscle or in the muscle tissue...

Dogs have intra muscular fat and human beings have subquetaneous fat...
older mature obese dogs can also build up some sub Q fat,
but puppies? fat? they have not been alive long enough to develop fat on their torso.. so a belly that is distended and bloated? Is that a fat puppy?
Because a fat and bloated belly is indicative of a serious case of worms and malnutrition not a chubby puppy...
fat above the tail, on the shoulders, masking the rib cage or distending the width of the dog and you cannot FEEL the ribs is the definition of 'fat' dog....
so I am curious how you go about determining which puppies in here are fat and which ones are 'lean, trim and HEALTHY".... so are you healthier than me because you are thin? so you mean to suggest that because I am overweight or anyone else in here who is overweight is UNHEALTHY and in dire health risk?
or are you simply mouthing and parroting 'archaic' views/myths about health and wellness based on your myopic view of what that is?
or were you referring to the Phenotype of these puppies as being 'too much' or 'too heavy' or "too fat"?
but typically I hear these kinds of opinions from those like you who have finer boned dogs and are used to looking at that and are kennel blinded to anything but your 'standard' of dog...

None of the top Euro kennels want that Phenotype of the dogs that are being bred in the USA and in Norway or Sweden or the Netherlands... the top Kennels who win consistently in Europe are the breeders who prefer the Phenotype of Ozzy, Buddy, and Baba... hence we see the puppies coming out looking this way...
interestingly... Judith's Buddy is from the UK and so is Ozzy.... Baba is from Poland and German lineage.....

It's true that I take pleasure in correcting you so often, but the biggest dogs out on the top winning circuit right now are the Italian dogs also with Serbian, Croatian, and Russian dogs.... another interesting fact is:
The top Italian Kennel (Del Diamante Nero aka Massimo Santini, Author of the most comprehensive book on Dobermann's in the 21 century) with the most winning-est Dobermans IN all of Europe, just bred his top winning Italian male to the Kennel out of which My Gemma came from... because they like so many others so prize that Phenotype that you continually say is 'TOO heavy" too something or other...
but their puppies are being sold even before the litters are born... there are waiting lines for these 'too big boned dogs' all day long and these same dogs are winning the IDC, Sch Titles, IPO titles, Korung Titles, AIAD titles and regional country titles day in and day out....

so these puppies in question, are what a Dobermann is SUPPOSED to look like whether you like it and agree with it, or not... we are all entitled to our own opinions, no matter how myopic they may be... they are ours and it is what it is... :martini:

Ok Im not getting in the middle of this one...BUT...all I want to say is 'YAAAYYYY ITALIANS' :dance:
 
Yes, they are all different. Queen is 69 sm tall at 8 months, and the max standard for females is 68 sm.
She is a Euro, but so far she is tall and lean, about 60 pounds, and her breeder expects her to fill out and to be more than 90. We shall see...
 
Diva if you compare Dobermans to Great Danes they look like medium dogs.
It's very confusing as a Doberman is between tallest of medium or shortest of large :)
There are many oversized dogs these days and many breeders prefer KING Dobermans what is out of the standard.

From FCI standard :
SIZE AND WEIGHT: SIZE Height at the highest point of withers: Males: 68cm (26.8") to 72cm (28.4"). Bitches: 63cm (24.8") to 68cm (26.8"). Medium size desirable.
WEIGHT Males ca. 40kg (88lbs) to 45kg (99.2lbs). Bitches ca. 32kg (70.5lbs) to 35kg(77.2lbs).

From ACK standard:
Height at the withers: Dogs 26 to 28 inches, ideal about 27½ inches; Bitches 24 to 26 inches, ideal about 25½ inches.
They don't specify the weight. You may find on other pages the approx. weight for NA Dobermans are 66 – 88 pounds.

My girl is 27" what is 1" off the NA standard... too bad. She is a beautiful girl and I wanted to show her. She fits into FCI standard. Should I move to Europe? LOL
 
I agree. You can tell in the pictures the difference in the body structure of the Dobes from different places in the world. I think the problem that is happening with the Dobes in NA is that people are breeding them just for money. There are too many breeders that don't do health testing and sell a puppy for $200 - $300 USD. They also breed any color and size. Lately I have seen several adults standing near 30 inches at the shoulder, more like a great dane's size. And the breeders that do care about size don't care about temperament and I am seeing a LOT of Dobies from rescues that are adopted or fostered and brought to our dog training center. Every one of them has aggression issues towards people and or other dogs. It really is sad!

I also agree that they should not be heavy and keep their elegant appearance. I just received flack in another forum post for saying that someone's dogs and her puppies looked to be quite plump. I have no apologies for saying so. If your dog is fat then your dog is fat! I don't think puppies or parents should look like piggies or be without a waste line. It really leads to health problems down the line.
 
Thank you April, Katja and Jess - I guess if you are used to seeing mastiffs everything else looks anemic to you. Doctors agree that there is a way to measure body fat and for dogs or people they recommend the ribs - you should be able to see a hint of rib - if you clearly see ribs they are too thin and if you can't see a hint of rib it is excessive body fat.

That is what they were referring too. Not thin or malnourished puppies. But whether too fat or too thin neither is correct and can cause damage. Usually a puppy that is fed puppy food or a high protein count tends to have more problems with pano - Pano is growing pains where one part grows fast than another part and it causes the pain til it all catches up usually about 18 months. You do not want to accelerate this growth.

There is less than one inch difference in the Euro and the American standard. Katja you are so correct in that too many of the Euro breeders today are breeding dogs that are way overdone and over standard while the Americans have gone the other way and are breeding too refied and elegant for a working breed but I guarantee you that neither is good for working long term. Maybe the Euros have spent too much time with mastiffs and so think that is correct -

I am going to upload a picture of Dictator - One of the early Dobermans sent to America to preserve the breed.
Which side do you think he more resembles??? Doberman's are a medium sized breed. If you want a 150 lb dog then stick with the mastiffs.
Dictator.webp

Now I will psot some great Euro dogs of the past Byron v Forell.webp to compare This dog is Byron v Forell

View attachment 8285
The above dog is Alfa alphaledobry.webp LeDobry

Now for some great American dogs
BondGirl.webp
Marienburgs Bond Girl - one of my favorites

Bruda Teller of Talkes.webp
Bruda's Teller of Tales

This is just a few - but it makes a point - We are not breeding mastiffs or are not suppose to be on either side of the continent. It scares me when I see what Euros have gone to and some here like it and promote the "biggness" of their dogs not the correctness - I don't like what I see here, because we are promoting too refined and elegant. According to the standard on both sides FCI and AKC this is wrong. You must be able to evaluate and recognize over weight which is just as big a problem as underweight - both are wrong.

We do need to keep heavy bone as that is what the standard calls for but you can over do or under do. The hard part is to get it right but you will not get it right if you just want or have fallen into the BIgger is Better train of thought.
 
From FCI standard :
SIZE AND WEIGHT: SIZE Height at the highest point of withers: Males: 68cm (26.8") to 72cm (28.4"). Bitches: 63cm (24.8") to 68cm (26.8"). Medium size desirable.
WEIGHT Males ca. 40kg (88lbs) to 45kg (99.2lbs). Bitches ca. 32kg (70.5lbs) to 35kg(77.2lbs).
Thank you for posting this. I couldn't find it last night.

It scares me when I see what Euros have gone to and some here like it and promote the "biggness" of their dogs not the correctness - I don't like what I see here, because we are promoting too refined and elegant. According to the standard on both sides FCI and AKC this is wrong. You must be able to evaluate and recognize over weight which is just as big a problem as underweight - both are wrong.

We do need to keep heavy bone as that is what the standard calls for but you can over do or under do. The hard part is to get it right but you will not get it right if you just want or have fallen into the BIgger is Better train of thought.
You whole post was perfectly said Suzan but I wanted to pull this out because I feel it really sums up the whole issue very well.
 
Thank you for putting those photos up Suzan - perfect examples. I agree - very well said!

I also think that Iceman's dogs, who are of course both 100% Euro are great examples of the perfect balance and have shown it with their performance in the ring.
I hope you don't mind my borrowing a couple of your pics Iceman. :)

5746686698_548a7545f3_z.jpg


5743421670_88ed4455bf_z.jpg


5746136225_d9554af557_z.jpg
 
It scares me when I see what Euros have gone to and some here like it and promote the "biggness" of their dogs not the correctness - I don't like what I see here, because we are promoting too refined and elegant. According to the standard on both sides FCI and AKC this is wrong. You must be able to evaluate and recognize over weight which is just as big a problem as underweight - both are wrong.

We do need to keep heavy bone as that is what the standard calls for but you can over do or under do. The hard part is to get it right but you will not get it right if you just want or have fallen into the BIgger is Better train of thought.

I believe many people here do not know the difference between a fat dog and a dog with good substance/strong bone..The breed standards define dobermann as a well built, muscular dog and it clearly defines the size in height...
As long as the dog is within the breed standards in height,proportional substance & bone is rewarded..
So,no one can say, in Europe "biggness" is promoted!!!

I copy pasted some parts of the breed standards below...take notice the emphasis put on muscles and bones..(bold highligting mine)


Dobermann Standard FCI n.143 1994-02-19
General Appearence,
The Dobermann is a medium sized, powerful and muscularly built dog. Thanks to the elegant lines of its body and its proud expression of determination, this dog conforms to the ideal figure of a dog.

Neck
The neck is of a good length proportioned with the head and the rest of the body. It is muscular, the skin is relatively tight and firm and the superior outline gently curved. The posture is erect as a sign of noble distinction.​

Body
WithersWell pronounced especially in males. The height and length are determinant for the dorsal top line that is lightly ascending starting from the croup.​
​
Back (dorsal region)​
The back is firm, strong and of proportionate length covered with well developed muscles.​
LoinsOf good length and well covered with muscles. In the females the loins can be a little longer to allow room for the breast.​
CroupA hardly perceptible inclination, starting from the sacrum to the tail root. The croup appears well rounded with a good width and covered with strong muscles. From a top line view it should not be either perfectly straight or noticeably inclined.​
Chest and ThoraxThe height and the depth of the thorax must be well proportionated to the withers' height and to the length of the body. The ribs are lightly curved so that the thorax height is almost equal to half of the withers' height. The chest is of a good width with an especially developed fore chest.​
UnderlineStarting from the sternum's posterior edge and arriving to the pelvis the ventral line of the abdomen is well tacked in.​
TailThe tail is highly set and docked short so that 2 caudal vertebrae are still visible. In those countries wheredocking is illegal the tail may remain intact.​

Limbs
ForelimbFrom every side of view the front legs appear strongly developed, almost straight and vertical to the ground.​
ShoulderThe shoulder lies tight to the thorax. The scapula is covered with strong muscles from both sides of its spine and reach over the spinus process of the thoracic vertebras. The shoulder blade iswell set back and has an approximately 50 degree angle to the horizontal line.​
Upper ArmThe upper arm is of a good length and well muscled. The angle between the scapula and the humerus is of 105/110 degrees.​
ElbowThe elbows are well tied to the thorax and not turning out.​
Lower ArmThe lower arm is strong, straight and covered with muscles. Its length is in proportion with the rest of the body.​
Carpal RegionThe carpal joint is strong and firm.​
Metacarpal RegionWith a solid bone structure that follow the lower arm's vertical line. From the frontal view the metacarpus appear straight, from a side view it shows a flexion of a 10 degree maximum.​
Front FootThe front feet are short. The toes are tied together and arched toward the top (cat paw). The nails are short and black.​
HindlimbAs a whole, seen from behind, the Dobermann looks wide and rounded thanks to the strong musculature of the pelvis and the croup. The muscles that leave from the pelvis running down the thigh and those that reach the knee and the lower thigh, give a substantial width to the whole hindlimb that appear to be very powerful. The hindlimbs are strong parallel and perpendicular to the ground.​
ThighThe thighs are of a good length, wide and well covered with muscles. The coxale (pelvis bone) must have a good inclination. The thigh rest at approximately 80 degrees from the horizontal line.​

http://www.dobermann-review.com/info_library/Dobermann_Standard/FCI_Dobermann_Standard.php
 
Yes Jan they are more "normal" - of course I don't mind - You put all your heart and love into them and then have to wait two years to know for sure you stayed in standard. It is hard to breed for correct bone without suddenly ending up with oversized dogs and you have to watch like a hawk to not loose that bone.

The key with the doberman is balance. No loose flappy skin, flews straight topline and nice tie at the neck. The front end should match the rear end. I would like to see a straighter topline and a little more rear to be balanced.
 
You put all your heart and love into them and then have to wait two years to know for sure you stayed in standard. .

very true statement...they change for better & for worse till they finish..
My Nika is NOT finished yet...OK..for an experienced eye, she can give a good idea on what she will look like in the end, but still room for some change.

this is at 18 months..
6420358773_34c4897d06_z.jpg




Going back to topic "Keeping the proper weight on your puppy or dog"
It is a very fine line to keep a dog in top condition all year round..It not just the quantity or quality of their diet..
You have to take into consideration the climate conditions and the dogs activity level..
When we are in show season i weigh my dogs every few weeks to make sure they are in shape..so easy to go over or under weight.

My advice to people with puppies or young dogs is not to be afraid to feed them well.... BUT,give them as much exercise as possible (preferably off leash)
a chubby puppy is better than a lean puppy...they need all they can get in growing stages..
 
I agree. You can tell in the pictures the difference in the body structure of the Dobes from different places in the world. I think the problem that is happening with the Dobes in NA is that people are breeding them just for money. There are too many breeders that don't do health testing and sell a puppy for $200 - $300 USD. They also breed any color and size. Lately I have seen several adults standing near 30 inches at the shoulder, more like a great dane's size. And the breeders that do care about size don't care about temperament and I am seeing a LOT of Dobies from rescues that are adopted or fostered and brought to our dog training center. Every one of them has aggression issues towards people and or other dogs. It really is sad!

I also agree that they should not be heavy and keep their elegant appearance. I just received flack in another forum post for saying that someone's dogs and her puppies looked to be quite plump. I have no apologies for saying so. If your dog is fat then your dog is fat! I don't think puppies or parents should look like piggies or be without a waste line. It really leads to health problems down the line.


I'm not sure I want popular opinion on my side -- I've noticed those with the most opinions often have the fewest facts. :moon:
 
My advice to people with puppies or young dogs is not to be afraid to feed them well.... BUT,give them as much exercise as possible (preferably off leash)
a chubby puppy is better than a lean puppy...they need all they can get in growing stages..

That's so much true. I have never seen a chubby puppy. They grow like a weed and look skinny and all legs.
I never overfeed my puppies either... they get as much raw food as an adult dog.
 

Back
Top